3.9 Review

Application of the precautionary principle under article 7 of Regulation (EC) No 178/2002: general principles and evaluation of cannabidiol in food

Journal

Publisher

SPRINGER INT PUBL AG
DOI: 10.1007/s00003-023-01457-6

Keywords

Food Law; Precautionary Principle; Risk Assessment; Cannabidiol; Hemp Extract; CBD; Novel Food

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The precautionary principle is an important concept in EU law, particularly in relation to food control. However, it has not received enough attention in practice. This article examines the application of the precautionary principle in the context of products containing CBD, and concludes that authorities can take additional protective measures based on this principle.
The precautionary principle is deeply rooted in the case law and legislation of the European Union (EU). In food law, the precautionary principle was introduced by Article 7 of the Basic Food Regulation (EC) No. 178/2002 (Basic Regulation). Nevertheless, the precautionary principle does not receive the attention it deserves in food control practice and national jurisprudence. In addition to the historical development and its application in national and EU case law, the possibilities and limitations of the application of the precautionary principle according to Art. 7 of the Basic Regulation are examined in this article using the example of products containing cannabidiol (CBD). The authors conclude that authorities may take priority protective measures beyond those required by the Novel Food Regulation, based on the precautionary principle.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

3.9
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Food Science & Technology

Coffee Leaf Tea from El Salvador: On-Site Production Considering Influences of Processing on Chemical Composition

Marc C. Steger, Marina Rigling, Patrik Blumenthal, Valerie Segatz, Andres Quintanilla-Belucci, Julia M. Beisel, Jorg Rieke-Zapp, Steffen Schwarz, Dirk W. Lachenmeier, Yanyan Zhang

Summary: This study investigated the production of coffee leaf tea in El Salvador and the effects of processing steps on non-volatile compounds and volatile aroma-active compounds. The findings can help coffee farmers adjust the processing parameters according to consumer preferences and generate additional income from this by-product.

FOODS (2022)

Review Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Risk Assessment of Coffee Cherry (Cascara) Fruit Products for Flour Replacement and Other Alternative Food Uses

Sara Eckhardt, Heike Franke, Steffen Schwarz, Dirk W. Lachenmeier

Summary: This article reviews the exposure and risk assessment of various products made from coffee cherry pulp and husk, as well as the use of dried and powdered coffee cherry as a flour substitute in bakery products. The research shows that even adolescents can safely consume coffee cherry products without adverse health effects. Additionally, using coffee cherry by-products as a partial flour substitute can help mitigate issues such as rising grain prices and disrupted supply chains.

MOLECULES (2022)

Review Food Science & Technology

Evaluation of the genotoxic potential of acrylamide: Arguments for the derivation of a tolerable daily intake (TDI value)

Sabine Guth, Matthias Baum, Alexander T. Cartus, Patrick Diel, Karl-Heinz Engel, Barbara Engeli, Bernd Epe, Tilman Grune, Dirk Haller, Volker Heinz, Michael Hellwig, Jan G. Hengstler, Thomas Henle, Hans-Ulrich Humpf, Henry Jaeger, Hans-Georg Joost, Sabine E. Kulling, Dirk W. Lachenmeier, Alfonso Lampen, Marcel Leist, Angela Mally, Doris Marko, Ute Noethlings, Elke Roehrdanz, Angelika Roth, Joachim Spranger, Richard Stadler, Pablo Steinberg, Stefan Vieths, Wim Waetjen, Gerhard Eisenbrand

Summary: This opinion from the SKLM presents arguments for an updated risk assessment of acrylamide (AA) exposure in diet, based on a critical review of relevant scientific evidence. The SKLM concludes that as long as exposure limits for AA are not exceeded, genotoxic effects leading to carcinogenicity are unlikely to occur. Considering the totality of evidence, the SKLM deems it scientifically justified to establish a tolerable daily intake (TDI) as a health-based guidance value.

FOOD AND CHEMICAL TOXICOLOGY (2023)

Review Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Risk Assessment of Trigonelline in Coffee and Coffee By-Products

Nick Konstantinidis, Heike Franke, Steffen Schwarz, Dirk W. Lachenmeier

Summary: Trigonelline is a bioactive pyridine alkaloid found in high concentrations in coffee and coffee by-products. The use of coffee by-products as food has gained interest due to their economic and nutritional value and environmental benefits. This review aimed to assess the risk of acute and chronic exposure to trigonelline from coffee and coffee by-products on human health. Limited toxicological knowledge and a lack of human data make it difficult to draw conclusions. However, trigonelline ingested as part of coffee and coffee by-products appears to be safe based on their traditional use.

MOLECULES (2023)

Article Food Science & Technology

Assessment of Aspartame (E951) Occurrence in Selected Foods and Beverages on the German Market 2000-2022

Sydney Schorb, Katharina Gleiss, Roland Wedekind, Eero Suonio, Ann-Kathrin Kull, Marcel Kuntz, Stephan G. Walch, Dirk W. Lachenmeier

Summary: This study analyzes the presence of the artificial sweetener aspartame (E951) in German foods and beverages from 2000 to 2022. Among 53,116 samples, aspartame was detected in 14% and further evaluated in nine major food groups. Aspartame was most commonly found in powdered drink bases, flavored milk drinks, chewing gum, and diet soft drinks. The levels of aspartame detected generally comply with the legal limits set by the European Union.

FOODS (2023)

News Item Oncology

Carcinogenicity of aspartame, methyleugenol, and isoeugenol

Elio Riboli, Frederick A. Beland, Dirk W. Lachenmeier, M. Matilde Marques, David H. Phillips, Eva Schernhammer, Abdul Afghan, Ricardo Assuncao, Giovanna Caderni, J. Christopher Corton, Gisela de Aragao Umbuzeiro, Daphne de Jong, Melanie Deschasaux- Tanguy, Allison Hodge, Junko Ishihara, Dan D. Levy, Daniele Mandrioli, Marjorie L. Mccullough, Sarah A. Mcnaughton, Takeshi Morita, Anne P. Nugent, Kumiko Ogawa, Arun R. Pandiri, Consolato M. Sergi, Mathilde Touvier, Luoping Zhang, Lamia Benbrahim- Tallaa, Shirisha Chittiboyina, Danila Cuomo, Nathan L. Debono, Charlotte Debras, Aline de Conti, Fatiha El Ghissassi, Emma Fontvieille, Rhea Harewood, John Kaldor, Heidi Mattock, Elisa Pasqual, Gabrielle Rigutto, Hannah Simba, Eero Suonio, Susana Viegas, Roland Wedekind, Mary K. Schubauer-Berigan, Federica Madia

LANCET ONCOLOGY (2023)

Review Food Science & Technology

Acetaldehyde as a Food Flavoring Substance: Aspects of Risk Assessment

Alexander Cartus, Dirk Lachenmeier, Sabine Guth, Angelika Roth, Matthias Baum, Patrick Diel, Gerhard Eisenbrand, Barbara Engeli, Michael Hellwig, Hans-Ulrich Humpf, Hans-Georg Joost, Sabine Kulling, Alfonso Lampen, Doris Marko, Pablo Steinberg, Wim Waetjen, Jan Hengstler, Angela Mally

Summary: The Senate Commission on Food Safety has found that the use of acetaldehyde as a flavoring substance in foods may pose health risks due to its genotoxic potential. However, there is a lack of sufficient data to determine its genotoxic effects in vivo after oral exposure. Therefore, the commission recommends reassessing the safety of using acetaldehyde as a food flavoring.

MOLECULAR NUTRITION & FOOD RESEARCH (2023)

Review Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Risk Assessment of Chlorogenic and Isochlorogenic Acids in Coffee By-Products

Sascha Behne, Heike Franke, Steffen Schwarz, Dirk W. Lachenmeier

Summary: Chlorogenic and isochlorogenic acids, found in plants, fruits, vegetables, coffee, and coffee by-products, are natural antioxidant compounds. This review aimed to assess the potential health risks of consuming coffee by-products containing these acids. Literature research revealed the major chlorogenic acids in coffee by-products. Studies on animals and humans indicated no significant toxic effects following acute exposure, suggesting long-term consumption of chlorogenic and isochlorogenic acids from coffee by-products is not a health risk.

MOLECULES (2023)

Review Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Occurrence and Regulatory Evaluation of Contaminants in Tattoo Inks

Patricia Fels, Dirk W. Lachenmeier, Pascal Hindelang, Stephan G. Walch, Birgit Gutsche

Summary: This literature review focuses on the analysis of organic and inorganic contaminants in tattoo inks prior to the implementation of the REACH regulation in 2022. Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and primary aromatic amines (PAAs) were found to be the most common contaminants, with the presence of heavy metals such as lead and chromium(VI) detected in almost all tattoo inks. However, the limited quantitative data on contaminants in tattoo inks and the potential changes in ink composition due to the implementation of REACH pose limitations to the results of this review.

COSMETICS (2023)

Review Chemistry, Analytical

Liquid Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) Spectroscopy in Transition-From Structure Elucidation to Multi-Analysis Method

Thomas Kuballa, Katja H. Kaltenbach, Jan Teipel, Dirk W. Lachenmeier

Summary: This review assesses the current state of implementing liquid NMR in the food, cosmetics, and pharmaceutical industries, highlighting its transformation from a structural elucidation tool to a widely recognized multi-analytical method that incorporates multivariate techniques.

SEPARATIONS (2023)

Article Chemistry, Applied

1H NMR-based approach to determine the geographical origin and cultivation method of roasted coffee

Vera Gottstein, Dirk W. Lachenmeier, Thomas Kuballa, Mirko Bunzel

Summary: A comprehensive study utilizing NMR fingerprinting and multivariate data analysis was conducted on 603 roasted arabica coffee samples. The results showed that the coffee samples could be differentiated based on their geographical origin, but differentiation between organically and conventionally produced coffee samples was not achieved.

FOOD CHEMISTRY (2024)

Meeting Abstract Toxicology

Biomonitoring of heat-induced food contaminants: Quantitative analysis of urinary furan metabolites as putative biomarkers of exposure in rats and humans

C. Kalisch, M. Reiter, M. Krieger, L. Wuest, B. Saenger, R. Dekant, D. W. Lachenmeier, O. Scherf-Clavel, A. Mally

TOXICOLOGY LETTERS (2023)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Using the BMD Approach to Derive Acceptable Daily Intakes of Cannabidiol (CBD) and Tetrahydrocannabinol (THC) Relevant to Electronic Cigarette Liquids

Pascal Hindelang, Andreas Scharinger, Elke Richling, Stephan G. Walch, Dirk W. Lachenmeier

Summary: This study presents a toxicological risk assessment of CBD and Delta(9)-THC relevant to e-liquids using the benchmark dose (BMD) approach. Due to limited dose-response data, the estimated reference doses (RfD) may have considerable uncertainties. Therefore, further research is recommended.

FRONTIERS IN BIOSCIENCE-LANDMARK (2022)

Article Pharmacology & Pharmacy

Absence of Relevant Thermal Conversion of Cannabidiol to Tetrahydrocannabinol in E-Cigarette Vapor and Low-Tetrahydrocannabinol Cannabis Smoke

Pascal Hindelang, Andreas Scharinger, Patricia Golombek, Miriam Laible, Sandra Tamosaite, Stephan G. Walch, Dirk W. Lachenmeier

Summary: This study aims to validate a recent claim that CBD in commercial e-cigarette liquids can be converted into Delta(9)-THC. The results show that under realistic smoking conditions, such conversion does not occur.

CANNABIS AND CANNABINOID RESEARCH (2022)

No Data Available