4.7 Article

Series and Parallel Elastic Actuation: Impact of natural dynamics on power and energy consumption

Journal

MECHANISM AND MACHINE THEORY
Volume 102, Issue -, Pages 232-246

Publisher

PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.mechmachtheory.2016.04.004

Keywords

Compliant actuators; Energy efficiency; Dynamics; Series Elastic Actuators; Parallel Elastic Actuators

Funding

  1. Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) [BE 5729/2-1]
  2. European Commission starting grant SPEAR [337596]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This paper provides a detailed analysis of the power and mechanical/electrical energy consumption of Series Elastic Actuators (SEAs) and Parallel Elastic Actuators (PEAs). The study is done by imposing a sinusoidal motion to a pendulum load, such that the natural dynamics automatically present itself in the power and energy consumption. This allows to link the actuators' dynamics to their loss mechanisms, revealing interesting characteristics of series and parallel elastic elements in actuator designs. Simulations demonstrate that the SEA and PEA allow to decrease both peak power and energy consumption, provided that the stiffness of their elastic element is tuned properly. For the SEA, both are minimized by tuning the elastic element to the antiresonance frequency of the actuator. For the PEA, peak power is minimal at the link's resonance frequency, but the optimal stiffness for minimal electrical energy consumption cannot be determined by a theoretical resonance and needs to be calculated using a complete system model. If these guidelines are followed, both types of elastic actuators can provide significant energetic benefits at high frequencies. This was confirmed by experiments, which demonstrated energy reductions of up to 78% (SEA) and 20% (PEA) compared to rigid actuators. (C) 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Engineering, Industrial

Passive shoulder exoskeleton support partially mitigates fatigue-induced effects in overhead work

Sander De Bock, Toon Ampe, Marco Rossini, Bruno Tassignon, Dirk Lefeber, Carlos Rodriguez-Guerrero, Bart Roelands, Joost Geeroms, Romain Meeusen, Kevin De Pauw

Summary: Physical fatigue affects task performance during overhead work, but the support provided by the occupational passive shoulder exoskeleton (PSE) can mitigate changes in shoulder joint kinematics and muscle activity, reducing the negative effects of fatigue.

APPLIED ERGONOMICS (2023)

Article Automation & Control Systems

A low-cost framework for the recognition of human motion gait phases and patterns based on multi-source perception fusion

Dianbiao Dong, Chi Ma, Miao Wang, Huong Thi Vu, Bram Vanderborght, Yuanxi Sun

Summary: This paper proposes a recognition system framework based on multi-source information fusion for the recognition of human gait patterns and phases. The framework utilizes multi-channel low-cost sensors to obtain human motion information and processes the raw signals into a valid recognition vector. The experimental results show that the proposed framework achieves high recognition accuracy for gait phases and patterns, proving its effectiveness.

ENGINEERING APPLICATIONS OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE (2023)

Article Engineering, Electrical & Electronic

Easy Integrability and Data Processing of a Soft Tactile Array Sensor Through Reconfiguration

Julie Legrand, Ellen Roels, Bram Vanderborght

Summary: To simplify the integration of soft tactile sensors, a new type of soft tactile array sensor is proposed, featuring sensitive keys made of different self-healing Diels-Alder (DA) conductive polymers. The optimization of key positions in the sensor array maximizes accuracy in detecting pressed key positions while minimizing the number of required wires. The use of reversible covalent bonds in the DA polymers allows for reconfiguration of the keys, enabling tailored tactile sensors for different applications.

IEEE SENSORS JOURNAL (2023)

Article Polymer Science

Soft dielectric actuator produced by multi-material fused filament fabrication 3D printing

Ivan Raguz, Michael Berer, Mathias Fleisch, Clemens Holzer, Joost Brancart, Bram Vanderborght, Sandra Schloegl

Summary: This paper presents a soft dielectric actuator fully produced by fused filament fabrication, which offers the potential for the production of personalized dielectric actuators. The 3D printed prototypes are characterized in terms of the maximum displacement depending on the electrode printing direction. A soft dielectric gripper made of two 3D printed actuators, achieving a maximum displacement of 42%, is developed as a showcase example.

POLYMERS FOR ADVANCED TECHNOLOGIES (2023)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Self-Healing, Recyclable, and Degradable Castor Oil-Based Elastomers for Sustainable Soft Robotics

Aleix Costa Cornella, Seyedreza Kashef Tabrizian, Pasquale Ferrentino, Ellen Roels, Bram Vanderborght, Seppe Terryn, Guy Van Assche, Joost Brancart

Summary: Self-healing polymers improve sustainability by recovering their properties, and can be recycled. However, there are still sustainability issues, including the use of fossil-derived materials and hazardous chemicals.

ACS SUSTAINABLE CHEMISTRY & ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Improving Postural Ergonomics during Human-Robot Collaboration Using Particle Swarm Optimization: A Study in Virtual Environment

Mohsen Omidi, Greet van de Perre, Roshan Kumar Hota, Hoang-Long Cao, Jelle Saldien, Bram Vanderborght, Ilias El Makrini

Summary: In this work, a method using the Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) algorithm is proposed to optimize human posture during human-robot collaboration. The robot's end-effector is positioned to minimize the distance between the optimized human posture and their current posture. A user study in a virtual reality environment validates the effectiveness of the proposed method, showing a 66% improvement in ergonomics.

APPLIED SCIENCES-BASEL (2023)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Optimal Sensor Set for Decoding Motor Imagery from EEG

Arnau Dillen, Fakhreddine Ghaffari, Olivier Romain, Bram Vanderborght, Uros Marusic, Sidney Grospretre, Ann Nowe, Romain Meeusen, Kevin De Pauw

Summary: Brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) can enable individuals to interact with devices based on their brain activity. However, the high costs associated with research-grade electroencephalogram (EEG) acquisition devices make them impractical for everyday use. This study demonstrates that decoding movement intention from a limited number of sensors is feasible, opening up the possibility of using commercial sensor devices for BCI control.

APPLIED SCIENCES-BASEL (2023)

Review Energy & Fuels

Selecting Suitable Battery Technologies for Untethered Robot

Tom Verstraten, Md Sazzad Hosen, Maitane Berecibar, Bram Vanderborght

Summary: Untethered robots rely on battery packs for power supply, and this paper proposes criteria to evaluate the suitability of different battery technologies for robotic applications. It evaluates and compares the capabilities of relevant battery technologies, discusses current limitations and new technological developments, and highlights opportunities for interdisciplinary research between battery technology and robotics.

ENERGIES (2023)

Article Engineering, Electrical & Electronic

A Novel Physical HumanRobot Interface With Pressure Distribution Measurement Based on Electrical Impedance Tomography

Huaijin Chen, Kevin Langlois, Joost Brancart, Ellen Roels, Tom Verstraten, Bram Vanderborght

Summary: A sensorized physical human-robot interface was proposed based on electrical impedance tomography (EIT), allowing continuous pressure measurement over a large area for wearable robots. The reconstruction method using convolutional neural network-enhanced Tikhonov regularization achieved accurate localization and size estimation of compressed areas, as well as distinguishing multiple compressed areas. The experimental results validated the suitability of the EIT pressure sensor for physical interfaces.

IEEE SENSORS JOURNAL (2023)

Article Computer Science, Cybernetics

Design and Implementation Requirements for Increased Acceptance of Occupational Exoskeletons in an Industrial Context: A Qualitative Study

Shirley A. Elprama, Sander De Bock, Romain Meeusen, Kevin De Pauw, Bram Vanderborght, An Jacobs

Summary: Occupational exoskeletons are not widely used at work, and previous research has identified several factors that contribute to this lack of adoption. However, there is a lack of specific requirements for improving exoskeletons. This research aimed to formulate concrete requirements for the design and implementation of exoskeletons, based on input from multiple stakeholders. The findings indicate that potential future users of exoskeletons believe that improvements should be made to enhance comfort and flexibility. The study has formulated 49 requirements and validated and extended an existing framework for occupational exoskeletons, with the aim of encouraging improved design.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HUMAN-COMPUTER INTERACTION (2023)

Article Polymer Science

Fast Self-Healing at Room Temperature in Diels-Alder Elastomers

Ali Safaei, Joost Brancart, Zhanwei Wang, Sogol Yazdani, Bram Vanderborght, Guy Van Assche, Seppe Terryn

Summary: By adjusting the off-stoichiometric ratio of maleimide-to-furan in the polymer network, we demonstrate the ability of Diels-Alder polymers to heal macroscopic damages at room temperature and restore their mechanical properties within a few hours. Immediate partial recovery is observed mere minutes after reuniting the fractured surfaces. The influence of crosslink density on self-healing and material performance was investigated through an extensive study of seven different Diels-Alder polymers.

POLYMERS (2023)

Article Automation & Control Systems

Self-Regulated Self-Healing Robotic Gripper for Resilient and Adaptive Grasping

Huijiang Wang, Seppe Terryn, Zhanwei Wang, Guy Van Assche, Fumiya Iida, Bram Vanderborght

Summary: Flexible, soft materials are increasingly used for the fabrication of soft robots, as the inherent compliance and shock-absorbance protect the robot from mechanical impact. Soft universal grippers take full advantage of this adaptability, facilitating effective and safe grasping of various objects. However, due to their predominantly soft material composition, these grippers have limited lifetimes, especially when operating in unstructured and unfamiliar environments. The self-healing universal gripper (SHUG) is proposed, which can grasp various objects and recover from substantial realistic damages autonomously.

ADVANCED INTELLIGENT SYSTEMS (2023)

Article Automation & Control Systems

Self-Closing and Self-Healing Multi-Material Suction Cups for Energy-Efficient Vacuum Grippers

Zhanwei Wang, Seppe Terryn, Huijiang Wang, Julie Legrand, Ali Safaei, Joost Brancart, Guy Van Assche, Bram Vanderborght

Summary: In this article, a comprehensive approach to address the environmental impact of energy waste in vacuum grippers is presented. The approach involves the development of a self-closing, multi-material, and self-healing system based on reversible elastomers. The system effectively prevents energy waste, achieves versatility and stability, and enables self-repair within a short period of time.

ADVANCED INTELLIGENT SYSTEMS (2023)

Article Computer Science, Information Systems

Investigating the Potential of Flexible Links for Increased Payload to Mass Ratios for Collaborative Robotics

Greet van de Perre, Thierry Hubert, Tom Verstraten, Bram Vanderborght

Summary: One of the main restrictions of commercial cobots is their limited payload to mass ratios. This paper investigates the potential benefits of using flexible links in collaborative robotics. The study explores the theoretical potential of flexible links to increase the payload to mass ratio and proposes a control strategy based on strain measurements to counteract the undesired side effects of flexible designs.

IEEE ACCESS (2023)

Article Engineering, Electrical & Electronic

Comparison of Drivetrain Topologies for an Ankle Gait Cycle

Yentl Joos, Peter Sergeant, Hendrik Vansompel, Tom Verstraten

Summary: Powered prosthesis actuation is a challenging field that requires high energy efficiency and low mass. Combining high torque at low speed and low torque at high speed in a single electric motor is difficult. One possible solution is to use an oversized direct-drive motor, but this results in a heavy and inefficient system. A common practice is to combine a smaller electric motor with a gear reduction system. In this study, we compare multiple electrical actuation systems with different motor-gearbox combinations, and a double-stator, single-rotor electric motor with a gearbox shows the most promising overall performance.

MACHINES (2023)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Model predictive control for multimode power-split hybrid electric vehicles: Parametric internal model with integrated mode switch and variable meshing losses

Antonella Castellano, Pietro Stano, Umberto Montanaro, Marco Cammalleri, Aldo Sorniotti

Summary: This paper proposes a new control strategy for hybrid electric vehicles, called Model Predictive Control (MPC), and considers the losses in transmission gears. Through a case study on Chevrolet Volt, the results show that the simplified internal model has a minor impact on fuel consumption performance.

MECHANISM AND MACHINE THEORY (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Morphable thick-panel origami

Rui Peng, Gregory S. Chirikjian

Summary: This article introduces a method of designing morphable thick-panel origami structures using reconfigurable linkages, which improves the potential of origami techniques for different tasks and solves the limitations of one-DOF and multiple-DOF folding structures.

MECHANISM AND MACHINE THEORY (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Extension of transmission performance evaluation for planar higher pair mechanisms

Gaohan Zhu, Weizhong Guo, Yinghui Li, Youcheng Han

Summary: Comprehensive and accurate performance evaluation is crucial for profile synthesis and analysis of higher pair mechanisms. This paper proposes evaluation indices and methods for the transmission performance of planar higher pair mechanisms from different perspectives. It subdivides the transmission performance into element-based performance and joint-based performance and develops novel indices specific to higher pair mechanisms. A graphical mapping method based on element-based performance is also proposed for intuitive analysis. Practical examples validate the effectiveness of the proposed indices and methods for evaluating the performance of higher pair mechanisms.

MECHANISM AND MACHINE THEORY (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

A Body-frame Beam Constraint Model

Ke Wu, Gang Zheng, Guimin Chen, Shorya Awtar

Summary: Researchers proposed a new modeling method, namely Body-frame Beam Constraint Model (BBCM), to predict and optimize the design of high-precision compliant mechanisms (CMs).

MECHANISM AND MACHINE THEORY (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Updating structural synthesis methodology of mechanisms: from kinematic geometry to kinematic geometry accompanied with statics

Youcheng Han, Weizhong Guo, Changjie Zhao, Ziyue Li, Ze Fu, Yinghui Li

Summary: This study proposes a structural synthesis methodology that considers motion, force, and energy characteristics simultaneously to design efficient mechanisms.

MECHANISM AND MACHINE THEORY (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

A parametric flexible multibody formulation with an explicit dependency on material properties

Cristian Enrico Capalbo, Daniel De Gregoriis, Tommaso Tamarozzi, Giuseppe Carbone, Domenico Mundo

Summary: This study proposes a novel flexible multibody formulation that enables efficient updating of models while maintaining small size and high accuracy. Numerical validation demonstrates its wide applicability across various materials and mechanisms, showing promising results in terms of accuracy.

MECHANISM AND MACHINE THEORY (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

A novel design of series elastic actuator using tensile springs array

Weihao Zhao, Junbei Liao, Wei Qian, Haoyong Yu, Zhao Guo

Summary: This paper presents a newly designed compliant actuator using a tensile springs array to address the challenges in achieving linear and consistent elastic properties, low friction, minor hysteresis, and good compliance in series elastic actuators (SEA). The unique geometry of the spring array enables the SEA to have consistent rotary stiffness with minimal friction and hysteresis. The device's performance is evaluated using PID and sliding mode control, demonstrating its constant low rotary stiffness and torque tracking bandwidth, making it suitable for human-robot interaction requirements.

MECHANISM AND MACHINE THEORY (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Normal contact stress analysis of large-deflection compliant mechanisms using a CPRBM-based method

Mohui Jin, Yukang Luo, Xing Xu, Bowei Xie, Weisheng Wang, Zewei Li, Zhou Yang

Summary: This paper presents a method for evaluating the contact interaction between compliant mechanisms and external objects. By establishing a numerical model and introducing contact springs to describe the contact forces, the deformation and normal contact force/stress can be accurately calculated. The static equilibrium configuration and contact force/stress can be obtained by minimizing the total potential energy function of the system.

MECHANISM AND MACHINE THEORY (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Synthesis of parallel flexure stages with decoupled actuators using sum, intersection, and difference of screw systems

Alejandro G. Gallardo, Martin A. Pucheta

Summary: This paper presents a method for the synthesis of parallel flexure systems using Screw Theory and Linear Algebra. The method is validated through three case studies and offers a simple and precise design with decoupled actuators.

MECHANISM AND MACHINE THEORY (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

A two-step solution for robot-world calibration made intelligible by implementing Chasles' motion decomposition in Ad(SE(3))

Xiao Wang, Chenglin Liu, Haoxiang Sun, Hanwen Song

Summary: This paper presents a new decomposition mode for robot-world calibration, which decomposes the Ad(SE(3)) equation using Chasles' motion. A two-step method based on point set matching is proposed. The superiority of this method is verified through simulations and experiments.

MECHANISM AND MACHINE THEORY (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Error modeling and analysis of a spherical parallel mechanism with a multiloop circuit incremental method

Yanlin Chen, Xianmin Zhang, Yanjiang Huang, Yanbin Wu, Jun Ota

Summary: This study establishes an error model for a 3-RRR+UR spherical parallel mechanism and analyzes the sensitivity of error parameters. A design structure is proposed to reduce input errors based on the analysis. Experimental results show that the multiloop circuit incremental method provides more accurate results.

MECHANISM AND MACHINE THEORY (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Performance analysis of gravity-balanced serial robotic manipulators under dynamic loads

Vu Linh Nguyen, Chin-Hsing Kuo, Po Ting Lin

Summary: This paper presents a method for analyzing the performance of gravity-balanced serial robotic manipulators under dynamic loads and uses a three-degree-of-freedom planar serial manipulator as a case study. The significance of this method is demonstrated by evaluating the impact of dynamic loads on gravity-balanced performance and proposing a step-by-step design procedure to improve it.

MECHANISM AND MACHINE THEORY (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Sustainability-oriented dry cutting tool collaborative optimization model for face-hobbing hypoid gears

Shifeng Rong, Jiange Zhang, Xing Zhang, Keliang Li, Kaibin Rong, Zhenyu Zhou, Han Ding

Summary: This article proposes a data-driven dry cutting tool collaborative optimization model to improve the economic and environmental attributes of facehobbing hypoid gears. An innovative ease-off tooth contact analysis method is introduced to establish accurate relations between ease-off flank and loaded contact performance evaluations. The proposed model significantly improves sustainability in terms of economic and environmental assessments.

MECHANISM AND MACHINE THEORY (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Instantaneous kinematics of a planar two-link open chain in complex plane

Kemal Eren, Soley Ersoy, Ettore Pennestri

Summary: This research investigates the instantaneous kinematics of the terminal link of a planar two-link open chain using the complex-number technique and higher-order instantaneous invariants.

MECHANISM AND MACHINE THEORY (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Design and analysis of modular deployable antenna mechanism based on a class of self-limiting position units

Bo Han, Zhantu Yuan, Jiachuan Zhang, Yundou Xu, Jiantao Yao, Yongsheng Zhao

Summary: This paper proposes novel deployable mechanism units with self-limiting position function, and constructs ring truss deployable mechanisms. The degrees of freedom (DOF) of deployable units are analyzed and it is proved that the constructed ring truss deployable mechanisms have only one DOF. The dynamic model of the deployable mechanism unit with passive actuation is established and verified by simulation. The deployable mechanism units proposed in this paper have the advantages of good scalability and stability, and have broad application prospects.

MECHANISM AND MACHINE THEORY (2024)