4.2 Review

Evidence for Targeted and Universal Secondary School-Based Programs for Anxiety and Depression: An Overview of Systematic Reviews

Journal

ADOLESCENT RESEARCH REVIEW
Volume -, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

SPRINGER INT PUBL AG
DOI: 10.1007/s40894-023-00211-1

Keywords

Schools; Students; Adolescent; Humans; Mental Health

Ask authors/readers for more resources

There is heterogeneity in the overall findings and conclusions of school-based mental health programs, possibly due to combining evidence from primary and high school programs. A systematic review of systematic reviews was conducted to investigate the effectiveness of targeted and universal mental health programs delivered in secondary schools. Findings were generally positive but heterogeneous in terms of quality and long-term outcomes.
While there are a number of systematic reviews on school-based mental health programs, there appears to be heterogeneity in their overall findings and conclusions, possibly due to the tendency to combine evidence from primary school and high school programs. To investigate the evidence for the effectiveness of targeted (for specific groups) and universal (for all students) mental health programs delivered in secondary schools, a systematic review of systematic reviews was conducted. A systematic search for reviews published from 2015 included outcomes for depression and anxiety-the most common mental health conditions-and quality appraisal of original studies in majority secondary school settings. A total of 395 references were screened and 14 systematic reviews were included. Of reviews that were assessed in full, most were excluded for not clearly separating studies in secondary school settings from primary school settings. Findings were generally positive but heterogenous in terms of quality and long-term outcomes. Interventions were mainly based on cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT), with results showing that targeted interventions are generally effective in the short-term for both anxiety and depression, while universal programs may be effective in some situations, typically in the short term and when programs were CBT-based; where reviews focused on universal resilience programs there were no significant effects. The overview shows a need for systematic reviews focused on secondary school settings, which consider contextual and individual factors that can influence the implementation and effectiveness of programs.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.2
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Medicine, General & Internal

Suicide prevention for international students: a scoping review protocol

Sam McKay, Angela Yuen Chun Li, Eleanor Bailey, Michelle Lamblin, Jo Robinson

Summary: This document provides a scoping review protocol aiming to systematically review the available literature on the prevention strategies for suicide in international students. The study will use a six-stage methodological framework and cover published, unpublished, and grey literature. It will conduct electronic searches and grey literature searches to identify relevant materials, and the findings will be disseminated through peer-reviewed journals, conference presentations, and consultations with relevant stakeholders.

BMJ OPEN (2022)

Article Psychology, Educational

Shaping the self through education: exploring the links between educational identity statuses, appraisals of control and value, and achievement emotions

Samuel McKay, Earl Freeman, Jason L. Skues, Lisa Wise

Summary: The study explored the relationships between educational identity, control value theory constructs, and achievement emotions in emerging adults enrolled in higher education. Findings suggest that different identity statuses are related to varying levels of adaptive appraisals and achievement emotions, influencing academic achievement and identity development.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PSYCHOLOGY OF EDUCATION (2022)

Article Psychiatry

Risk Factors for Suicide Attempt During Outpatient Care in Adolescents With Severe and Complex Depression

Laura S. van Velzen, Yara J. Toenders, Akhil Kottaram, Belinsha Youzchalveen, Vita Pilkington, Sue M. Cotton, Abi Brooker, Ben McKechnie, Simon Rice, Lianne Schmaal

Summary: Prediction of suicide attempts during mental health care for young people is moderately accurate, and individual risk factors for suicidal behavior during care can be identified.

CRISIS-THE JOURNAL OF CRISIS INTERVENTION AND SUICIDE PREVENTION (2023)

Review Psychiatry

Empirical evidence for climate concerns, negative emotions and climate-related mental ill-health in young people: A scoping review

Reem Ramadan, Alicia Randell, Suzie Lavoie, Caroline X. X. Gao, Paula Cruz Manrique, Rebekah Anderson, Caitlin McDowell, Isabel Zbukvic

Summary: Climate change poses a serious threat to human health, including mental health, due to extreme climate events and concerns about climate change. This scoping review aims to explore the research on mental health and climate-related negative emotions in young people. The findings highlight the need for further research and support in addressing the mental health impact of climate change on youth.

EARLY INTERVENTION IN PSYCHIATRY (2023)

Review Environmental Sciences

Suicide Prevention for International Students: A Scoping Review

Samuel McKay, Maria Veresova, Eleanor Bailey, Michelle Lamblin, Jo Robinson

Summary: International students are at risk of suicide, and there is a lack of comprehensive review on effective suicide prevention approaches for them. This scoping review aimed to identify the extent and nature of evidence on prevention strategies for international students. The review found recommendations in four categories: cultural competency training, improved risk screening, proactive interventions, and collaborative approaches. Evaluating the effectiveness of these recommendations will inform the development of evidence-based policies and interventions.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH AND PUBLIC HEALTH (2023)

Article Psychiatry

The use of implementation science to close the research-to-treatment gap for cognitive impairment in psychosis

Isabel Zbukvic, Shayden Bryce, Joanna Moullin, Kelly Allott

Summary: For individuals with psychosis, cognitive impairment is common and affects both treatment engagement and quality of life. Cognitive remediation is an effective treatment, but engagement with treatment is often challenging. Implementation science is crucial for integrating cognition-focused treatments into routine care and improving patient outcomes. This paper provides an overview of implementation science and offers practical guidance for clinical research.

AUSTRALIAN AND NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF PSYCHIATRY (2023)

Editorial Material Sport Sciences

Starting young to protect elite athletes' mental health

Rosemary Purcell, Joanna Henderson, Katherine A. Tamminen, Joshua Frost, Kate Gwyther, Gretchen Kerr, Jeemin Kim, Vita Pilkington, Simon M. Rice, Courtney C. Walton

BRITISH JOURNAL OF SPORTS MEDICINE (2023)

Article Pediatrics

Implementing a Digital Depression Prevention Program in Australian Secondary Schools: Cross-Sectional Qualitative Study

Joanne R. Beames, Aliza Werner-Seidler, Michael Hodgins, Lyndsay Brown, Hiroko Fujimoto, Alexandra Bartholomew, Kate Maston, Kit Huckvale, Isabel Zbukvic, Michelle Torok, Helen Christensen, Philip J. Batterham, Alison L. Calear, Raghu Lingam, Katherine M. Boydell

Summary: This study aimed to explore the contextual factors that influence the implementation of the Future Proofing Program (FPP) from the perspectives of school staff. The findings revealed that active leadership and involvement, teamwork, communication, and staff capacity were critical for the successful implementation of FPP. Moreover, low student engagement and staffing availability were identified as barriers for future adoption and implementation by schools.

JMIR PEDIATRICS AND PARENTING (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

#chatsafe 2.0. updated guidelines to support young people to communicate safely online about self-harm and suicide: A Delphi expert consensus study

Jo Robinson, Pinar Thorn, Samuel McKay, Laura Hemming, Rikki Battersby-Coulter, Charlie Cooper, Maria Veresova, Angela Li, Nicola Reavley, Simon Rice, Michelle Lamblin, Jane Pirkis, Dan Reidenberg, Vicki Harrison, Jaelea Skehan, Louise La Sala

Summary: This study aimed to update the #chatsafe guidelines to reflect new evidence and current social media affordances, and to include guidance on self-harm. A total of 191 items were included in the new guidelines, which cover eight themes. The guidelines will be disseminated via a national social media campaign and supported by a series of adult-facing resources.

PLOS ONE (2023)

Article Sport Sciences

Psychological Safety for Mental Health in Elite Sport: A Theoretically Informed Model

Courtney C. Walton, Rosemary Purcell, Vita Pilkington, Kate Hall, Goran Kentta, Stewart Vella, Simon M. Rice

Summary: This paper proposes a model that explores how the level of psychological safety in the environment can affect the mental health outcomes of athletes. In an environment where individuals feel safe to be their authentic selves, better mental health outcomes are likely.

SPORTS MEDICINE (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Examining the Feasibility of Implementing Digital Mental Health Innovations Into Hospitals to Support Youth in Suicide Crisis: Interview Study With Young People and Health Professionals

Demee Rheinberger, Rachel Baffsky, Lauren McGillivray, Isabel Zbukvic, Ann Dadich, Mark Erik Larsen, Ping- Lin, Daniel Z. Q. Gan, Catherine Kaplun, Holly C. Wilcox, Valsamma Eapen, Paul M. Middleton, Michelle Torok

Summary: This qualitative study explored the potential benefits, barriers, and collective action required for integrating digital therapeutics for the management of suicidal distress in youth into routine hospital practice. The results showed that digital innovations were seen as a beneficial complement to in-person clinical services, but there were existing resource, logistical, and technical barriers to integration. Staff training, improving access to technological devices and internet connectivity, increasing staff motivation, and allowing patients autonomy over the use of digital therapeutics were identified as critical factors to integration.

JMIR FORMATIVE RESEARCH (2023)

Article Family Studies

Identity Development During Student Exchange: A Qualitative Study of Students' Perspectives on the Processes of Change

Samuel McKay, Lyda Lannegrand, Jason Skues, Lisa Wise

Summary: The aim of this qualitative study was to explore how exchange students conceptualize the processes of change and development during exchange within an identity framework. The findings suggest that students' experiences and identity development play a crucial role in the changes that occur during exchange.

EMERGING ADULTHOOD (2022)

No Data Available