4.0 Article

Source credibility and plausibility are considered in the validation of textual information: evidence from a social media context

Journal

JOURNAL OF COGNITIVE PSYCHOLOGY
Volume 35, Issue 2, Pages 183-204

Publisher

ROUTLEDGE JOURNALS, TAYLOR & FRANCIS LTD
DOI: 10.1080/20445911.2022.2149757

Keywords

Validation; text comprehension; text-belief consistency; source information; source credibility

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study examined the influence of message plausibility and trustworthiness in the validation of tweet-like messages. Results showed that participants considered both the plausibility of the messages and the credibility of the sources in the validation process, but the exact relationship depended on contextual factors.
We examined the interplay of message plausibility and trustworthiness in the validation of tweet-like messages. Reading times served as implicit indicator for validation and participants rated the tweets' plausibility and source credibility. In Experiment 1, plausibility was varied via text-belief consistency and trustworthiness via the message's fit with the source's typical argumentative position. Participants read belief-inconsistent (vs. belief-consistent) messages longer and judged these as less plausible. Similarly, participants read messages from untrustworthy (vs. trustworthy) sources longer and judged these as less plausible. Belief-consistent messages by a trustworthy (vs. untrustworthy) source were judged as more plausible. In Experiment 2, plausibility was varied via world-knowledge consistency and trustworthiness via the reputation of media organizations. Participants read plausible messages from untrustworthy (vs. trustworthy) sources more slowly. Plausibility and trustworthiness seem to be considered in the validation of tweet-like messages, but their exact relationship seems to depend on contextual factors.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.0
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Psychology, Multidisciplinary

Here I sit, making men in my own image: how learning disorder labels affect teacher student's expectancies

David J. Franz, Wolfgang Lenhard, Peter Marx, Tobias Richter

Summary: This study examines the negative effects of diagnostic labels on teacher evaluations of students and finds that different labels have different impacts on academic expectations. Additionally, the study explores the cognitive mechanisms driving label effects and implements a short intervention to counteract the negative effects of labels.

CURRENT PSYCHOLOGY (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

The Testing Effect in University Teaching: Using Multiple-Choice Testing to Promote Retention of Highly Retrievable Information

Sven Greving, Wolfgang Lenhard, Tobias Richter

Summary: Retrieval practice through multiple-choice testing has a positive effect on students' ability to retrieve easily accessible information from memory in a university psychology course, even without feedback.

TEACHING OF PSYCHOLOGY (2023)

Article Communication

The Experience of Emotional Shifts in Narrative Persuasion

Julia R. Winkler, Markus Appel, Marie-Luise C. R. Schmidt, Tobias Richter

Summary: Recent theory suggests that emotional shifts are characteristic of immersed story processing and precursors of narrative impact. Two experiments and a pilot study found a positive association between transportation and the number and intensity of emotional shifts, particularly with affective-level attitudes.

MEDIA PSYCHOLOGY (2023)

Article Psychology, Developmental

Using Accuracy and Response Times to Assess Inhibitory Control in Kindergarten Children: An Analysis with Explanatory Item Response Models

Daniel Schulz, Tobias Richter, Julia Schindler, Wolfgang Lenhard, Madlen Mangold

Summary: This study examined the diagnostic value of using response accuracy and latency in a simple inhibitory control test for kindergarten children. The results showed that response accuracy and latency were reliable predictors of item difficulties and time intensities, and they enhanced the prediction of fluid intelligence.

JOURNAL OF COGNITION AND DEVELOPMENT (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

Does speed-reading training work, and if so, why? Effects of speed-reading training and metacognitive training on reading speed, comprehension and eye movements

Marina Klimovich, Simon P. Tiffin-Richards, Tobias Richter

Summary: This study examined the effects of a commercial speed-reading training app on reading performance in German-speaking undergraduates. The results showed an increase in reading speed, although not to the extent claimed by the app, and there were no significant changes in comprehension.

JOURNAL OF RESEARCH IN READING (2023)

Article Psychology, Multidisciplinary

The Testing Effect in the Lecture Hall: Does it Depend on Learner Prerequisites?

Julia Glaser, Tobias Richter

Summary: The benefits of practice testing for long-term learning have been established, but little is known about the learner characteristics that might moderate its effectiveness. This study explored whether the effects of practice testing in a university lecture would depend on cognitive, motivational, or emotional dispositions. The results showed that practice testing improved retention of learning contents, regardless of individual learning prerequisites.

PSYCHOLOGY LEARNING AND TEACHING-PLAT (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

General knowledge norms: Updated and expanded for German

Andreas G. Wertgen, Tobias Richter

Summary: The study introduces a valuable set of general knowledge questions that can be used as a research tool in various areas of cognitive research. The authors translated, updated, and expanded the questions for German, and present data on recall probability, metacognitive measures, response latencies, correlations, and common errors. These questions can be used in studies with German speaking participants in memory, illusory truth, misinformation, and metacognitive research.

PLOS ONE (2023)

Article Psychology, Experimental

Distinguishing between struggling and skilled readers based on their prosodic speech patterns in oral reading: An exploratory study in grades 2 and 4

Panagiotis Karageorgos, Sebastian Wallot, Bettina Mueller, Julia Schindler, Tobias Richter

Summary: This study aimed to differentiate struggling and skilled German readers in Grades 2 and 4 by examining prosodic patterns in oral reading using Recurrence Quan-tification Analysis (RQA). The findings indicated that struggling second graders showed slower reading rate, longer intervals between pauses, and more repetitions of recurrent amplitudes and pauses. Struggling fourth graders, on the other hand, exhibited less stable pause patterns over time, more pitch repetitions, more similar amplitude patterns over time, and more repetitions of pauses. Additionally, models with prosodic patterns outperformed models with prosodic features.

ACTA PSYCHOLOGICA (2023)

Article Psychology, Educational

Text Generation Benefits Learning: a Meta-Analytic Review

Julia Schindler, Tobias Richter

Summary: Efficient learning can be achieved when learners actively generate text content rather than passively receive it. A meta-analysis shows that generation interventions significantly improve learning compared to reading (Hedges' g = .41). This benefit is independent of time-on-task and can be observed in various learning conditions and settings. The analysis further suggests that the effectiveness of text generation in learning is maximized when it complements the cognitive processes stimulated by the text. Overall, the findings support the suitability of text generation for educational applications under certain conditions.

EDUCATIONAL PSYCHOLOGY REVIEW (2023)

Article Psychology, Educational

The Influence of Diagnostic Labels on the Evaluation of Students: a Multilevel Meta-Analysis

David J. Franz, Tobias Richter, Wolfgang Lenhard, Peter Marx, Roland Stein, Christoph Ratz

Summary: Research found that children with different disorders may be evaluated differently due to the presence of a diagnostic label. A meta-analysis of experimental studies examined the label effects and potential moderators. It was found that labeling a child can worsen academic, behavioral, personality, and overall evaluations of the child.

EDUCATIONAL PSYCHOLOGY REVIEW (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

Promoting students' argument comprehension and evaluation skills: Implementation of two training interventions in higher education

Hannes Muenchow, Simon P. P. Tiffin-Richards, Lorena Fleischmann, Stephanie Pieschl, Tobias Richter

Summary: The study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of two training interventions in improving university students' comprehension and evaluation skills of informal arguments. The results showed that voluntary online training interventions can effectively enhance various aspects of scientific literacy. However, the study also found an interference effect between the training interventions, suggesting difficulties in integrating the different aspects of scientific literacy targeted in the interventions.

ZEITSCHRIFT FUR ERZIEHUNGSWISSENSCHAFT (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

Metacognitive Comprehension Monitoring: Cognitive Abilities Explain Performance Differences Between Younger and Older Adults

Catharina Tibken, Tobias Richter, Wienke Wannagat

Summary: The present study extends previous results on the role of basic cognitive abilities for explaining differences between age groups in metacognitive comprehension monitoring in younger compared to older adults.

SCIENTIFIC STUDIES OF READING (2023)

Article Psychology, Educational

Emotional shifts, event-congruent emotions, and transportation in narrative persuasion

Marie-Luise C. R. Schmidt, Julia R. Winkler, Markus Appel, Tobias Richter

Summary: Emotional shifts in stories can enhance engagement with the story and contribute to narrative persuasion. The persuasive effect of the story may depend on the congruency between the audience's emotional experience and the emotions implied by the story.

DISCOURSE PROCESSES (2023)

No Data Available