4.3 Review

How International Health System Austerity Responses to the 2008 Financial Crisis Impacted Health System and Workforce Resilience - A Realist Review

Publisher

KERMAN UNIV MEDICAL SCIENCES
DOI: 10.34172/ijhpm.2022.7420

Keywords

Health System Resilience; Preparedness; Governance; Communication; Ethical Decision-Making; Moral Distress

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study examines the impact of austerity policies on health system resilience, particularly on workforce resilience. The findings highlight the potential consequences of such policies, including distrust in decision-making processes, resistance to change, and a misalignment of values with health professionals. These factors can adversely affect the readiness of health systems to deal with future shocks.
Background: The Great Recession, following the 2008 financial crisis, led many governments to adopt programmes of austerity. This had a lasting impact on health system functionality, resources, staff (numbers, motivation and morale) and patient outcomes. This study aimed to understand how health system resilience was impacted and how this affects readiness for subsequent shocks. Methods: A realist review identified legacies associated with austerity (proximal outcomes) and how these impact the distal outcome of health system resilience. EMBASE, CINAHL, MEDLINE, EconLit and Web of Science were searched (2007- May'21), resulting in 1,081 articles. Further theory-driven searches resulted in an additional 60 studies. Descriptive, inductive, deductive and retroductive realist analysis (utilising excel and Nvivo) aided the development of Context, Mechanism, Outcomes Configurations (CMOCs), alongside stakeholder engagement to confirm or refute emerging results. Causal pathways, and the interplay between context and mechanisms that led to proximal and distal outcomes, were revealed. The refined CMOCs and policy recommendations focused primarily on workforce resilience. Results: Five CMOCs demonstrated how austerity-driven policy decisions can impact health systems when driven by the priorities of external agents. This created a real or perceived shift away from the values and interests of health professionals, a distrust in decision-making processes and resistance to change. Their values were at odds with the realities of implementing such policy decisions within sustained restrictive working conditions (rationing of staff, consumables, treatment options). A diminished view of the profession and an inability to provide high-quality, equitable, and needs-led care, alongside stagnant or degraded working conditions, led to moral distress. This can forge legacies that may adversely impact resilience when faced with future shocks. Conclusion: This review reveals the importance of transparent, open communication, in addition to co-produced policies in order to avoid scenarios that can be detrimental to workforce and health system resilience.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.3
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

A comparison of 2020 health policy responses to the COVID-19 pandemic in Canada, Ireland, the United Kingdom and the United States of America

Lynn Unruh, Sara Allin, Greg Marchildon, Sara Burke, Sarah Barry, Rikke Siersbaek, Steve Thomas, Selina Rajan, Andriy Koval, Mathew Alexander, Sherry Merkur, Erin Webb, Gemma A. Williams

Summary: This paper compares health policy responses to COVID-19 in Canada, Ireland, the United Kingdom and United States of America (US) from January to November 2020, highlighting the common challenges faced by these countries and the differences in their responses due to variations in health system organization and financing, political leadership, and governance structures. Lack of universal health coverage and political pushback against scientific leadership were identified as barriers in the US.

HEALTH POLICY (2022)

Review Pediatrics

Neonatal sepsis definitions from randomised clinical trials

Rian Hayes, Jack Hartnett, Gergana Semova, Cian Murray, Katherine Murphy, Leah Carroll, Helena Plapp, Louise Hession, Jonathan O'Toole, Danielle McCollum, Edna Roche, Elinor Jenkins, David Mockler, Tim Hurley, Matthew McGovern, John Allen, Judith Meehan, Frans B. Plotz, Tobias Strunk, Willem P. de Boode, Richard Polin, James L. Wynn, Marina Degtyareva, Helmut Kuester, Jan Janota, Eric Giannoni, Luregn J. Schlapbach, Fleur M. Keij, Irwin K. M. Reiss, Joseph Bliss, Joyce M. Koenig, Mark A. Turner, Christopher Gale, Eleanor J. Molloy

Summary: Neonatal sepsis, a leading cause of infant mortality, has diverse definitions based on microbiological culture, laboratory tests, and clinical signs. An international consensus-based definition could improve research comparability and clinical outcomes.

PEDIATRIC RESEARCH (2023)

Article Rehabilitation

Does exercise therapy improve pulmonary function in patients with Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis?

Anthony Rafferty, Neil Fleming, Patrick Kiely, David Mockler, Sara Dockrell

Summary: This review analyzed the effect of exercise therapy on pulmonary function in patients with Adolescent Idiopathic Scoliosis (AIS). The results showed a positive effect of exercise therapy on lung volumes in AIS patients. However, the quality of many studies included in the review was only fair, indicating the need for higher quality clinical trials.

PHYSIOTHERAPY THEORY AND PRACTICE (2023)

Article Obstetrics & Gynecology

Elite female athletes' experiences of symptoms of pelvic floor dysfunction: A systematic review

Elizabeth Culleton-Quinn, Kari Bo, Neil Fleming, David Mockler, Cinny Cusack, Deirdre Daly

Summary: This article investigates the experiences of pelvic floor dysfunction (PFD) among elite female athletes through a comprehensive review of studies. The findings suggest a need for further research in this area, using qualitative methods or incorporating qualitative components.

INTERNATIONAL UROGYNECOLOGY JOURNAL (2022)

Review Endocrinology & Metabolism

The Effect of Time-Restricted Eating on Insulin Levels and Insulin Sensitivity in Patients with Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome: A Systematic Review

R. Floyd, R. Gryson, D. Mockler, J. Gibney, S. N. Duggan, L. A. Behan

Summary: Polycystic ovarian syndrome (PCOS) is a common reproductive endocrinopathy in women, with associated metabolic symptoms. While the effects of time-restricted eating on metabolic profiles have been investigated in other endocrinopathies, there is limited data for PCOS. Only one study has explored the impact of time-restricted eating on insulin levels in PCOS patients, which showed no significant effect. However, based on studies in other patient groups, time-restricted eating may improve insulin resistance in PCOS patients, but further well-designed studies are needed.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENDOCRINOLOGY (2022)

Review Rehabilitation

Symptomatic hypermobility in children and young people: A scoping review of clinical characteristics using a developmental framework

Susan Ward, Emma Jane MacDermott, Jane Simmonds, Janet Deane, David Mockler, Sara Dockrell

Summary: This systematic scoping review evaluates the literature on children and young people with symptomatic hypermobility, finding that musculoskeletal and cutaneous characteristics are common in all developmental stages. Cardiovascular characteristics are more frequent in adolescents, while there is a lack of studies on young adults. Various diagnostic criteria and assessment methods were identified, lacking consensus. More standardized research and evaluation are needed.

PHYSIOTHERAPY PRACTICE AND RESEARCH (2022)

Review Health Care Sciences & Services

Effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of palliative care in natural experiments: a systematic review

Jingjing Jiang, Narae Kim, Melissa M. Garrido, Mireille Jacobson, David Mockler, Peter May

Summary: This study reviewed studies that employed 'natural experiments' to evaluate palliative care and discussed implications for expanding use of these methods. 17 studies were included, evaluating a wide range of interventions and populations. Most studies reported lower costs and improved outcomes associated with palliative care, but a third of utilization and place of death evaluations found no effect.

BMJ SUPPORTIVE & PALLIATIVE CARE (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Work like a Doc: A comparison of regulations on residents' working hours in 14 high-income countries

Rina Maoz Breuer, Ruth Waitzberg, Adin Breuer, Peter Cram, Lucie Bryndova, Gemma A. Williams, Kaija Kasekamp, Ilmo Keskimaki, Liina-Kaisa Tynkkynen, Verena van Ginneken, Eszter Kovacs, Sara Burke, Domhnall McGlacken-Byrne, Carol Norton, Barbara Whiston, Daiga Behmane, Ieva Grike, Ronald Batenburg, Tit Albreht, Rade Pribakovic, Enrique Bernal-Delgado, Francisco Estupinan-Romero, Ester Angulo-Pueyo, Adam J. Rose

Summary: Medical residents work long and continuous hours, which negatively affects the quality and safety of care and their quality of life. Many countries have attempted to regulate residents' work hours, but there are variations in the implementation and effectiveness of these regulations.

HEALTH POLICY (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

How to not revert to type: Complexity-informed learnings from the pandemic response for health system reform and universal access to integrated care

Sarah Parker, Luisne Mac Conghail, Rikke Siersbaek, Sara Burke

Summary: This research aims to explore how COVID-19 has provided opportunities for improving access to universal, integrated care in Ireland and to examine the implications for health reform. Findings from the study indicate that favorable conditions and strategies have emerged during the pandemic for the development of integrated care. The results of this research have policy and practice implications for future healthcare reform.

FRONTIERS IN PUBLIC HEALTH (2023)

Article Substance Abuse

Public attitudes to implementing financial incentives in stop- smoking services in Ireland

Ellen Cosgrave, Aishling Sheridan, Edward Murphy, Martina Blake, Rikke Siersbaek, Sarah Parker, Sara Burke, Frank Doyle, Paul Kavanagh

Summary: A telephone survey of 1000 people in Ireland revealed that almost half of the participants supported financial incentives, such as cash payments or shopping vouchers, to help quit smoking. This support was more prevalent among those with lower education levels, tobacco/e-cigarette users, and younger people. These findings suggest that financial incentives can be effective in improving stop-smoking service outcomes, especially for groups experiencing the greatest burden from smoking-related harm and who have the most capacity to benefit.

TOBACCO PREVENTION & CESSATION (2023)

Review Oncology

Diagnostic Accuracy of Blood-based Biomarkers for Pancreatic Cancer: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

Laura E. Kane, Gregory S. Mellotte, Eimear Mylod, Rebecca M. O'Brien, Fiona O'Connell, Croi E. Buckley, Jennifer Arlow, Khanh Nguyen, David Mockler, Aidan D. Meade, Barbara M. Ryan, Stephen G. Maher

Summary: This review assessed the diagnostic accuracy of blood-based biomarkers for pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC). The results showed that multi-biomarker panels performed better than single biomarkers in PDAC diagnosis. CA19-9 had limited utility when used alone, but performed better when included in multi-biomarker panels.

CANCER RESEARCH COMMUNICATIONS (2022)

Meeting Abstract Neurosciences

The 2019 Neuro-rehabilitation Implementation Framework in Ireland: Challenges for Implementation and the Implications for People with Brain Injuries

Grainne McGettrick, Karen Foley, Sara Burke, Sarah Barry, Manjula Manikandan

BRAIN INJURY (2022)

No Data Available