4.7 Article

Artifacts and misinterpretations in gas physisorption measurements and characterization of porous solids

Journal

ADVANCES IN COLLOID AND INTERFACE SCIENCE
Volume 311, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.cis.2022.102831

Keywords

BET area; DFT; GCMC kernels; In-bottle pores; Pore size distribution; False minimum

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This contribution critically reviews the use of gas physisorption for the characterization of porous solids, emphasizing the presence of artifacts in experimental data that can lead to misinterpretation of adsorption isotherm analysis results. Issues related to the determination of BET area and pore size distribution are particularly addressed, including the correct selection of the hysteresis loop branch and consideration of network effects. The article discusses pitfalls in both macroscopic and microscopic (DFT, GCMC) analysis methodologies, aiming to provide guidance for accurate calculations and interpretation of physisorption data.
This contribution provides a critical review of gas physisorption in the textural characterization of porous solids, with the focus on the artifacts in experimental data that lead to serious misinterpretation of the results derived from the analysis of adsorption isotherms. Apart from the problems related to the determination and interpre-tation of the BET area, we paid particular attention to the issues associated with the determination of pore size distribution; for example, the choice of the correct branch of the hysteresis loop and the network effects. Pitfalls in the analyses using either the classical macroscopic or the advanced microscopic (DFT, GCMC) methodology are addressed. The ultimate aim is to provide guidance for proper calculations and correct interpretation of physisorption data.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Materials Science, Ceramics

Influence of resorcinol-formaldehyde resin on the formation of alkali titanate fibers

Hirotoshi Iuchi, Toshihide Horikawa

Summary: In this study, ATO fibers were synthesized using a one-step calcination method with RF resin as the precursor, which effectively controlled the morphology and crystal structure of the fibers.

CERAMICS INTERNATIONAL (2022)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Significant role of counterion for lead(II) ion adsorption on carbon pore surface

Toshihide Horikawa, Miku Okamoto, Ayaka Kuroki-Matsumoto, Ken Yoshida

Summary: This study presents a predictive tool for describing Pb2+ adsorption on activated carbon (AC) and validates it through experiments. The tool can predict the amount of Pb2+ adsorption within 10% of accuracy, and molecular dynamic simulations reveal the role of counter anions in influencing the configuration and adsorption of Pb2+ ions. It is found that NO3- enhances the adsorption of Pb2+ due to its strong attraction to the surface of graphite, while Cl- does not show significant adsorption. This mechanism provides new insights into the complex phenomena of ion adsorption onto activated carbon.

CARBON (2022)

Article Energy & Fuels

Influence of metal-organic framework MOF-76(Gd) activation/carbonization on the cycle performance stability in Li-S battery

D. Capkova, T. Kazda, O. Cech, N. Kiraly, T. Zelenka, P. Cudek, A. Sharma, V. Hornebecq, M. Almasi, A. Strakova Fedorkova

Summary: Carbon materials improve the performance of lithium-sulphur batteries, while metal-organic frameworks confine polysulphides and restrain the shuttle effect.

JOURNAL OF ENERGY STORAGE (2022)

Article Agricultural Engineering

Porous carbon monoliths from ice-NaOH templated dissolved cellulose

Arjeta Kryeziu, Vaclav Slovak, Julien Parmentier, Tomas Zelenka, Severinne Rigolet

Summary: A simple and environmentally friendly method for transforming cellulose into porous carbon monoliths was developed. The method involves freezing the cellulose solution, followed by ethanol regeneration and water washing. The resulting cellulose monoliths exhibit significant macroporosity and microporosity.

INDUSTRIAL CROPS AND PRODUCTS (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Carbon dioxide and hydrogen adsorption study on surface-modified HKUST-1 with diamine/triamine

Tomas Zelenka, Klaudia Simanova, Robin Saini, Gabriela Zelenkova, Satya Pal Nehra, Anshu Sharma, Miroslav Almasi

Summary: The present article studied the influence of post-synthetic modification with ethylenediamine (en, diamine) and diethylenetriamine (deta, triamine) within the coordinatively unsaturated sites (CUSs) of HKUST-1 on carbon dioxide and hydrogen storage. The results showed that the modified samples exhibited high adsorption capacities for carbon dioxide and hydrogen, with deta-modified samples showing higher adsorption amounts compared to en-modified materials.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2022)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Carbonaceous Materials Porosity Investigation in a Wet State by Low-Field NMR Relaxometry

Eva Kinnertova, Vaclav Slovak, Tomas Zelenka, Cyril Vaulot, Luc Delmotte

Summary: The porosity of differently wetted carbonaceous material with disordered mesoporosity was investigated using low-field H-1 NMR relaxometry. A non-linear optimization method was used to convert relaxation curves to the distribution of relaxation times. It was found that up to five different relaxation times were sufficient to describe the observed relaxation, corresponding to different types of hydrogen nuclei in the sample.

MATERIALS (2022)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Graphene as a promising additive to hierarchically porous carbon monoliths for enhanced H2 and CO2 sorption

Gabriela Zelenkova, Tomas Zelenka, Miroslav Almasi, Michala Soldanova

Summary: This study investigated the synthesis of hierarchically porous carbon monoliths doped with graphene oxide for H-2 and CO2 sorption applications. By adjusting the synthesis procedure and carbonization temperature, the degree of reduction of graphene oxide and its incorporation into the matrix were characterized. The addition of 10% graphene oxide at a pyrolysis temperature of 900 degrees C resulted in a promising material with high adsorption capacities for H-2 and CO2.

JOURNAL OF CO2 UTILIZATION (2023)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Sr(II) and Ba(II) Alkaline Earth Metal-Organic Frameworks (AE-MOFs) for Selective Gas Adsorption, Energy Storage, and Environmental Application

Nikolas Kiraly, Dominika Capkova, Robert Gyepes, Nikola Vargova, Tomas Kazda, Jozef Bednarcik, Daria Yudina, Tomas Zelenka, Pavel Cudek, Vladimir Zelenak, Anshu Sharma, Vera Meynen, Virginie Hornebecq, Andrea Strakova Fedorkova, Miroslav Almasi

Summary: Two new alkaline earth metal-organic frameworks, UPJS-15 and UPJS-16, were synthesized and characterized. UPJS-15 exhibited one-dimensional channels with a size of approximately 11 x 10 angstrom(2) and showed high adsorption capacity for CO2. UPJS-16, on the other hand, did not show significant adsorption for the tested gases.

NANOMATERIALS (2023)

Article Chemistry, Physical

The effect of porosity and particle size on the kinetics of porous carbon xerogels surface oxidation

Lucie Korena, Vaclav Slovak, Gabriela Zelenkova, Tomas Zelenka

Summary: The effects of porosity and particle size on carbon surface oxidation were investigated. Carbon xerogels with different porosity and particle size were prepared and characterized. Isothermal thermogravimetry experiments showed that particle size and porosity significantly influence diffusion and heat transfer during carbon oxidation. The apparent kinetic parameters were determined, and it was found that porosity and particle size do not affect the basic chemical reactions occurring on the carbon surface during oxidation.

CARBON (2023)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Evidence of bimolecular layer of ethanol on graphite at 190K-Experimental and simulation studies

Quang K. Loi, Krittamet Phothong, Ryuto Yuasa, Toshihide Horikawa, D. D. Do

Summary: The adsorption mechanism of ethanol on graphite was comprehensively investigated using experimental measurements and computer simulation. The study highlights the unique interplay of clustering and molecular layering of ethanol. Ethanol exhibits intermediate characteristics between simple gases and water during adsorption. The mechanism of ethanol adsorption involves the formation and growth of discrete clusters, predominantly in the form of tetramers and pentamers, followed by the coalescence of growing clusters. The interplay of clustering and coalescence depends on temperature.

CARBON (2024)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

A New Member of the Metal-Porphyrin Frameworks Family: Structure, Physicochemical Properties, Hydrogen and Carbon Dioxide Adsorption

Nikolas Kiraly, Vladimir Zelenak, Tomas Zelenka, Miroslav Almasi, Juraj Kuchar

Summary: A novel holmium-based porous metal-porphyrin framework (UPJS-17) with a three-dimensional open structure was synthesised by hydrothermal reaction. The compound exhibited adsorption capacity for Ar, CO2, and H2, but not for N2. The highest CO2 adsorption capacity of 7.0 wt % was observed at 0 degrees C, with an isosteric heat of 56.5 kJmol(-1). The hydrogen uptake of UPJS-17 at -196 degrees C and 1 bar was found to be 2.1 wt %.

CHEMISTRYOPEN (2023)

Meeting Abstract Chemistry, Physical

ADSORPTION PROPERTIES OF TEMPLATED NANOPOROUS CARBONS COMPRISING 1-2 GRAPHENE LAYERS

Hirotomo Nishihara, Hong-Wei Zhao, Kazuya Kanamaru, Keita Nomura, Mao Ohwada, Masashi Ito, Li-Xiang Li, Bai-Gang An, Toshihide Horikawa, Takashi Kyotani

CARBON (2023)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Characterization of non-graphitized carbon blacks: a model with surface crevices

Quang K. Loi, Toshihide Horikawa, D. D. Do, D. Nicholson

Summary: Experimental isotherms for argon and nitrogen adsorption on two non-graphitized carbon substrates, Carbopack B and Cabot BP280, do not obey Henry's Law in the accessible pressure range. The adsorbate density at the bulk coexistence pressure for Cabot BP280 is lower than Carbopack B, which is slightly lower than Carbopack F, indicating a long-range effect of surface structure on the accumulation of higher layers in non-graphitized carbon blacks.

PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY CHEMICAL PHYSICS (2021)

No Data Available