4.5 Article

Public perceptions of using forests to fuel the European bioeconomy: Findings from eight university cities

Journal

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS
Volume 140, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.forpol.2022.102749

Keywords

Lay perception; Legitimacy; Network analysis; Public discourse; Risk perception; Socio-technical transition

Funding

  1. Euro-pean Forest Institute (EFI)
  2. Kone Foundation [201805496]
  3. FORMAS - the Swedish Research Council for Sustainable Development [942-2016-30]
  4. FFG - the Austrian Research Promotion Agency [865905]
  5. Strategic Research Council [335241]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The political project on bioeconomy aims to combine economic growth with environmental sustainability, but the contradictions between plans and goals raise sustainability concerns in Europe. This study explores how citizens perceive this discourse in urban areas, identifying different communities and their traits. City of residence and familiarity with bioeconomy interact with perception, suggesting deeper social tension beyond public discourse.
The political project on bioeconomy strives to address multiple societal aspirations, namely combine economic growth with environmental sustainability in some socially acceptable manner. The contradictions between the goals and the concrete plans to increase production, processing, and consumption of forest biomass in Europe have however raised sustainability concerns within and beyond its borders. While political actors articulate such contradictions differently and compete for traction for their viewpoints in the public discourse, little is known about how citizens of urban areas perceive this discourse. Conceptualising perception as a multidimensional construct, data from eight European university cities (Bordeaux, Bratislava, Freiburg, Helsinki, Padua, St. Petersburg, Uppsala, Vienna) are statistically analysed to explore its dimensions, the communities of like-minded citizens forming across those dimensions, and the traits associating with membership in each such community. Five communities across six dimensions from biocentrism through distributional aspects to adherence to political goals are identified: adherent-environmentalist, adherent-governmentalist, critical-reformist, critical -agriculturalist, and indifferent. City of residence and perceived familiarity with bioeconomy clearly interact with perception. There is however considerable variation in communities within and across the eight cities, suggesting deeper social tension beyond the public discourse. Much of the within-community variation remains unexplained, though, calling for more work locally. Implications for forest policy are derived.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Forestry

The role of harvester measurement in the wood supply chain

Per Eriksson, Anders Roos, Cecilia Mark-Herbert

Summary: This study analyzes the impact of harvester measurement on the wood procurement process. Harvester measurement has the potential to increase the purchaser's incentive to preserve value and improve control of the supply chain, leading to more efficient resource use. It also simplifies the price list, increasing transparency and improving supplier relationships. Additionally, forest industries may increase profitability levels and competitiveness due to increased supply chain surplus and reduced total costs.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF FOREST ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Materials Science, Paper & Wood

Impact of prospective residents' dwelling requirements on preferences for house construction materials

Anders Roos, Hans-Fredrik Hoen, Francisco X. Aguilar, Antti Haapala, Elias Hurmekoski, Jaakko Jussila, Katja Lahtinen, Cecilia Mark-Herbert, Tomas Nord, Ritva Toivonen, Anne Toppinen

Summary: This study examines people's requirements and preferences for multi-story housing attributes and the difference between wooden-structure and steel/concrete-structure apartments. The results show that Swedish respondents have higher requirements for environmental and social sustainability factors compared to Finnish respondents. The requirements in both countries can be categorized into three factors: environmental and social sustainability, quality, and design. Socioeconomic sub-groups and urban vs non-urban respondents have different preferences for quality-related attributes. Preferences for apartments in wooden buildings are positively associated with the requirements for environmental and social sustainability, while preferences for apartments in non-wooden structure houses show the opposite relationship in the Swedish sample. Design requirements have no significant association with preferences for a specific material in load-bearing structures in both countries.

WOOD MATERIAL SCIENCE & ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Increased appreciation of forests and their restorative effects during the COVID-19 pandemic

Magdalena Pichlerova, Jozef Vybost'ok, Dilek Onkal, Kiki Ekiawan Lamatungga, Dhanalakshmi Tamatam, Lenka Marcinekova, Viliam Pichler

Summary: Public expectations of forests as restorative environments have been increasing, and the COVID-19 pandemic has further emphasized their importance as places for stress relief and well-being. This study aimed to explore the effects of the pandemic on the relationships between forest visits, well-being and stress relief, emotions, perception of nature, pro-environmental behavior, and societal expectations of forests. The results highlighted the need to prioritize forest recreation and raise awareness of conservation requirements among forest visitors.

AMBIO (2023)

Article Forestry

Beliefs on environmental impact of wood construction

Anders Roos, Elias Hurmekoski, Liina Haeyrinen, Jaakko Jussila, Katja Laehtinen, Cecilia Mark-Herbert, Emil Nagy, Ritva Toivonen, Anne Toppinen

Summary: This study investigates public beliefs in Finland and Sweden about the environmental and climate impacts of using wood as a construction material for multi-story buildings.

SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF FOREST RESEARCH (2023)

Article Business

Use-oriented business model

Moa Nyvall, Thomas Zobel, Cecilia Mark-Herbert

Summary: In a world facing sustainability challenges, using a use-oriented product-service system can encourage resource efficiency. A case study on the rental business models in the outdoors apparel industry in Scandinavia identified the challenges faced by companies introducing use-oriented services and emphasized the importance of overcoming these challenges.

CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AND ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Paradoxical tensions in exploiting data to implement circular economy in the textile industry

Paeivi Luoma, Esko Penttinen, Petri Tapio, Anne Toppinen

Summary: Increasing utilization of data enabled by digitalization drives circular economy, but can also create paradoxical tensions. A two-round disaggregative Delphi study identified three themes of tension: consumer concurrence, business transparency, and technology relevance. Businesses should address both positive and negative effects and adapt to the changing business environment to successfully utilize data for circular economy promotion.

AMBIO (2023)

Article Economics

Is a sustainability transition possible within the decision-support services provided to Finnish forest owners?

Tuomo Takala, Minna Tanskanen, Maria Brockhaus, Teija Kanniainen, Jukka Tikkanen, Ari Lehtinen, Teppo Hujala, Anne Toppinen

Summary: Decision-support service providers in North Europe have been advised to move beyond wood production and focus on fulfilling the diverse needs of forest owners. However, little change has been seen so far in the service sector. This study examines the discourses of Finnish forest owners and consulting professionals to determine if they recognize the need for decision-support services that promote sustainable forest use.

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

How motivation, opportunity, and ability impact sustainable consumption behaviour of fresh berry products

Lingyun Tong, Anne Toppinen, Lei Wang, Sami Berghall

Summary: This study investigates the sustainable consumption behavior in the fresh berry sector in China and identifies motivation, opportunity, intentions, and ability as significant factors driving sustainable consumption behavior. The study contributes to the literature on Sustainable Development Goals (SDG) by providing suggestions and guidelines for policymakers, farmers, and marketers aiming to expand the natural food markets in a sustainable manner.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

Clash or concert in European forests? Integration and coherence of forest ecosystem service-related national policies

Karin Beland Lindahl, Charlotta Soderberg, Natalia Lukina, Daria Tebenkova, Mireia Pecurul, Helga Pulzl, Metodi Sotirov, Camilla Widmark

Summary: This paper compares the integration of forest ecosystem service-related policies in different European forest governance contexts. Efforts to achieve policy integration at the EU and national levels have been described as limited success. Through the analysis of different policies, the authors argue that integration outcomes depend on the degree and nature of policy integration, environmental policy integration, and multilevel coherence within the forest governance system. Failures to safeguard biodiversity and other ecosystem services during the integration process can have significant consequences.

LAND USE POLICY (2023)

Article Business

The value of data for environmental sustainability as perceived by the customers of a tissue-paper supplier

Paivi Luoma, Romana Rauter, Esko Penttinen, Anne Toppinen

Summary: Companies require better and more versatile data to successfully manage their ambitious environmental agendas, however, the ways in which businesses and the environment benefit from data is still unclear. A single-case-study setting was used to examine the perceived value of data for environmental sustainability, revealing its multifaceted nature and ability to support decision-making and activities that promote environmental improvements. To fully utilize data for environmental sustainability, there is a need for more detailed product-specific data, transparency in value chains and environmental impacts, and improved data management and sharing. The insights gained from understanding the value of data can help companies support their customers' environmental performance.

CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY AND ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

Consumer housing choices among residents living in wooden multi-storey buildings

J. Jussila, F. Franzini, L. Hayrinen, K. Lahtinen, E. Nagy, C. Mark-Herbert, A. Roos, A. Toppinen, R. Toivonen

Summary: Buyers of newly built wooden multi-storey apartments mainly base their choices on traditional housing criteria, such as location, floor plan, and affordability. Although wood material is considered environmentally friendly and appealing, residents expressed that the newly developed neighborhoods have limited services, but they trusted that future development would improve service availability.

HOUSING STUDIES (2023)

Article Economics

A tale of five cities: The role of municipalities in the market diffusion of wooden residential multistory construction and retrofits

A. Viljanen, K. Lahtinen, V. Kanninen, A. Toppinen

Summary: In order to promote sustainable urban development, cities can contribute to the market diffusion of wooden multistory residential construction and wooden retrofits by using policy instruments and collaborating in local business ecosystems. Our study shows that both policy instruments and collaboration in business ecosystems can accelerate the market diffusion of WMC and wooden retrofits. Therefore, cities should take a proactive collaborative role and implement a comprehensive range of policy measures to accelerate the diffusion of WMC and wooden retrofits.

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2023)

Article Economics

Resilient forest-based value chains? Econometric analysis of roundwood prices in five European countries in the era of natural disturbances

Raphael Asada, Elias Hurmekoski, Annechien Dirkje Hoeben, Marco Patacca, Tobias Stern, Anne Toppinen

Summary: Climate change is a growing threat to European forests, with increasing storms and insect outbreaks causing disturbances. These disturbances affect the volume and quality of harvested wood, leading to increased salvage loggings and reduced roundwood prices. The study assesses the impact of supply and demand shocks on roundwood prices in five European countries, finding that disturbances tend to increase prices for high-quality wood while decreasing prices for pulpwood. Strategic management and international trade may be resilience predictors, but their potential is limited.

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2023)

Article Economics

Whose forest? A two-level collective action perspective on struggles to reach polycentric governance

Sara Lorenzini, Nadia von Jacobi

Summary: This paper fills the gap in the literature on polycentric governance by focusing on the micro-processes of conflict that precede its establishment. Through a comparative analysis of four case studies, the authors find that conflict can lead to negotiations and the eventual establishment of common procedural rules, which can sustain polycentric governance.

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2024)

Article Economics

Was stakeholder participation in the PEFC revision process successful in Slovakia?

Hubert Palus, Lenka Marcinekova, Jaroslav Salka

Summary: The complexity and comprehensiveness of sustainability issues in forest certification schemes require knowledge based and transparent decision-making processes, which involve open and multi-stakeholder participation. This study examines the latest PEFC national sustainable forest management standard revision process in Slovakia from the viewpoint of stakeholder participation. The results highlight the importance of stakeholder understanding, trust, and satisfaction in the effectiveness of the revision process.

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2024)

Article Economics

Developing community-based criteria for sustaining non-timber forest products: A case study with the Missanabie Cree First Nation

Nicholas Palaschuk, Jason Gauthier, Ryan Bullock

Summary: Non-timber forest products (NTFPs) are important for the spiritual and cultural identity of Indigenous communities, but current forest policies in Canada do not adequately protect these resources. This research used a participatory approach and community interviews to document local criteria, elements, and values related to NTFP development and conservation. The resulting framework can guide decision making and promote socio-economic benefits for the Missanabie Cree First Nation.

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2024)

Article Economics

The coalitional politics of the European Union Regulation on deforestation-free products

Laila Berning, Metodi Sotirov

Summary: This paper analyzes the coalition politics driven by beliefs and interests in the new European Union Regulation on deforestation-free products (EUDR). The study identifies pro-regulation and contra-regulation coalitions and highlights the strategic alliance formed between pro-EUDR business actors and other pro-coalitions. Despite opposition from a weaker contra-regulation coalition, the EUDR was ultimately institutionalized as a compromise solution accommodating different beliefs and interests of state and non-state actors.

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2024)

Article Economics

Is there a future for smallholder farmers in bioeconomy? The case of 'improved' seeds in South Punjab, Pakistan

Mehwish Zuberi, Michael Spies, Jonas o. Nielsen

Summary: Smallholder farmers play a crucial role in agrarian value chains in the Global South, but they are often neglected in technology-oriented agricultural interventions. However, they face challenges such as lack of resources, established crop rotation patterns, and market and climatic factors.

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2024)

Article Economics

Harnessing the full potential of a global forest-based bioeconomy through non-timber products: Beyond logs, biotechnology, and high-income countries

James Chamberlain, Carsten Smith-Hall

Summary: More countries are adopting novel approaches to transition to a forest-based bioeconomy, which can address global challenges such as sustainable forest management, poverty alleviation, and climate change mitigation. Utilizing non-timber forest products is crucial for the realization of a forest-based bioeconomy.

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2024)

Article Economics

Commercial timber plantations and community livelihoods: Insights from comparative case studies in southern Laos

Keith Barney

Summary: The social impacts of industrial wood plantations in Southeast Asia, specifically in Laos, are debated. This study finds that under certain conditions, these plantations can positively contribute to local livelihoods, but there are still issues of land dispossession and inadequate compensation.

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2024)