4.7 Article

The generalizability of pre-processing techniques on the accuracy and fairness of data-driven building models: A case study

Journal

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS
Volume 268, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCIENCE SA
DOI: 10.1016/j.enbuild.2022.112204

Keywords

Fairness; Generalizability; Accuracy; Data-driven Model; Building

Ask authors/readers for more resources

In recent years, the development and application of data-driven building models have been a hot research topic due to the massive data collected from buildings. This study proposes a sequentially balanced sampling (SBS) technique to address the issues of data volume variation and fairness. The performance of SBS is compared with four existing pre-processing techniques, showing comparable performance in accuracy and fairness improvement.
In recent years, massive data collected from buildings made development and application of data-driven building models is a hot research topic. Due to the variation of data volume in different conditions, existing data-driven building models (DDBMs) would present distinct accuracy for different users or periods. This may create further fairness problems. To solve these issues, balancing training dataset between different conditions using pre-processing techniques could help. In this study, a sequentially balanced sampling (SBS) technique is proposed. Its generalizability to improve fairness and preserve accuracy of DDBMs is compared with four existing pre-processing techniques-random sampling (RS), sequential sampling (SS), reversed preferential sampling (RPS), and sequential preferential sampling (SPS). Totally, 4960 cases are carried out to apply these pre-processing techniques to process training dataset before developing 4 types of classifiers for one-week ahead lighting status prediction of 155 lights in 16 apartments through a year. Note that the collected data show 5 distribution modes. The newly proposed SBS shows comparable performance to RPS. They significantly improve predictive accuracy for minority classes but decrease the accuracy for majority classes. On the other hand, SS and SPS show a slight accuracy improvement for minority classes with an acceptable price of accuracy decrease on majority classes. In terms of fairness improvement, SBS, RS, and RPS could effectively increase the recall rate. However, RS and RPS show more negative effect on accuracy rate and specificity rate. The results of this study provide guidance for researchers to select proper pre-processing techniques to improve the preferred predictive performance under different data distribution. (c) 2022 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Thermodynamics

Experimental and numerical study of a vertical earth-to-air heat exchanger system integrated with annular phase change material

Zhengxuan Liu, Zhun (Jerry) Yu, Tingting Yang, Mohamed El Mankibi, Letizia Roccamena, Ying Sun, Pengcheng Sun, Shuisheng Li, Guoqiang Zhang

ENERGY CONVERSION AND MANAGEMENT (2019)

Review Construction & Building Technology

A review of the -state-of-the-art in data -driven approaches for building energy prediction

Ying Sun, Fariborz Haghighat, Benjamin C. M. Fung

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2020)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Performance of a self-learning predictive controller for peak shifting in a building integrated with energy storage

Jianing (Tom) Luo, Mahmood Mastani Joybari, Karthik Panchabikesan, Ying Sun, Fariborz Haghighat, Alain Moreau, Miguel Robichaud

SUSTAINABLE CITIES AND SOCIETY (2020)

Article Thermodynamics

Trade-off between accuracy and fairness of data-driven building and indoor environment models: A comparative study of pre-processing methods

Ying Sun, Fariborz Haghighat, Benjamin C. M. Fung

Summary: Data-driven models in the building domain have attracted much attention, but fairness-aware prediction of these models is a new research problem addressed in this paper. Different fairness definitions and pre-processing methods are introduced to improve fairness Type I and Type II while maintaining predictive accuracy. Sequential sampling is found to be a good option for improving fairness Type II with an acceptable decrease in accuracy.

ENERGY (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Development of advanced controllers to extend the peak shifting possibilities in the residential buildings

Ying Sun, Karthik Panchabikesan, Fariborz Haghighat, Jianing (Tom) Luo, Alain Moreau, Miguel Robichaud

Summary: This study developed two advanced controllers to achieve peak shifting and heating cost-saving by controlling electrically heated floor and heat extraction system. The results showed that the developed controllers effectively shift energy consumption from the peak period and decrease heating cost by around 33%.

JOURNAL OF BUILDING ENGINEERING (2021)

Article Construction & Building Technology

In-Processing fairness improvement methods for regression Data-Driven building Models: Achieving uniform energy prediction

Ying Sun, Benjamin C. M. Fung, Fariborz Haghighat

Summary: This study proposes four in-processing methods to improve the predictive fairness of regression models in terms of having similar predictive performance between different conditions. The results show that the mean square error constrained (MSEC) method is the most effective in improving fairness, while the mean square error penalized (MSEP) method is another good option without significantly decreasing the overall accuracy. The mean residual difference constrained (MRDC) method effectively improves the similarity of absolute mean residual difference between different conditions, while the mean residual difference penalized (MRDP) method does not affect the predictive result.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Platform Development of BIM-Based Fire Safety Management System Considering the Construction Site

Yapin Yang, Ying Sun, Mingsi Chen, Yuekuan Zhou, Ran Wang, Zhengxuan Liu

Summary: This paper develops a BIM-based fire safety management system platform for construction sites, which includes four subsystems: remote monitoring, fire visualization, multi-stage fire alarm, and escape route optimization. Results show that this system can provide informative and on-time fire protection measures to construction sites.

BUILDINGS (2022)

Article Energy & Fuels

Enhancement in peak shifting and shaving potential of electrically heated floor residential buildings using heat extraction system

Ying Sun, Karthik Panchabikesan, Mahmood Mastani Joybari, Dave Olsthoorn, Alain Moreau, Miguel Robichaud, Fariborz Haghighat

JOURNAL OF ENERGY STORAGE (2018)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Cool roof strategies for urban thermal resilience to extreme heatwaves in tropical cities

Samiran Khorat, Debashish Das, Rupali Khatun, Sk Mohammad Aziz, Prashant Anand, Ansar Khan, Mattheos Santamouris, Dev Niyogi

Summary: Cool roofs can effectively mitigate heatwave-induced excess heat and enhance thermal comfort in urban areas. Implementing cool roofs can significantly improve urban meteorology and thermal comfort, reducing energy flux and heat stress.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2024)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Estimating omnidirectional urban vertical wind speed with direction-dependent building morphologies

Qi Li, Jiayu Chen, Xiaowei Luo

Summary: This study focuses on the vertical wind conditions as a main external factor that limits the energy assessment of high-rise buildings in urban areas. Traditional tools for energy assessment of buildings use a universal vertical wind profile estimation, without taking into account the unique wind speed in each direction induced by the various shapes and configurations of buildings in cities. To address this limitation, the study developed an omnidirectional urban vertical wind speed estimation method using direction-dependent building morphologies and machine learning algorithms.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2024)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Towards a blockchain and machine learning-based framework for decentralised energy management

Xiaojun Luo, Lamine Mahdjoubi

Summary: This paper presents an integrated blockchain and machine learning-based energy management framework for multiple forms of energy allocation and transmission among multiple domestic buildings. Machine learning is used to predict energy generation and consumption patterns, and the proposed framework establishes optimal and automated energy allocation through peer-to-peer energy transactions. The approach contributes to the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and enhances environmental sustainability.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2024)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Dual-layer optimization design method for collaborative benefits of renewable energy systems in building clusters: Case study of campus buildings

Ying Yu, Yuanwei Xiao, Jinshuai Chou, Xingyu Wang, Liu Yang

Summary: This study proposes a dual-layer optimization design method to maximize the energy sharing potential, enhance collaborative benefits, and reduce the storage capacity of building clusters. Case studies show that the proposed design significantly improves the performance of building clusters, reduces energy storage capacity, and shortens the payback period.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2024)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Model predictive control of distributed energy resources in residential buildings considering forecast uncertainties

Felix Langner, Weimin Wang, Moritz Frahm, Veit Hagenmeyer

Summary: This paper compares two main approaches to consider uncertainties in model predictive control (MPC) for buildings: robust and stochastic MPC. The results show that compared to a deterministic MPC, the robust MPC increases the electricity cost while providing complete temperature constraint satisfaction, while the stochastic MPC slightly increases the electricity cost but fulfills the thermal comfort requirements.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2024)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Comprehensive assessment of double skin façades: A mathematical model for evaluating influence of KL ratio on electrical and thermal performances, and indoor conditions

Somil Yadav, Caroline Hachem-Vermette

Summary: This study proposes a mathematical model to evaluate the performance of a Double Skin Facade (DSF) system and its impact on indoor conditions. The model considers various design parameters and analyzes their effects on the system's electrical output and room temperature.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2024)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Improving building resilience in the face of future climate uncertainty: A comprehensive framework for enhancing building life cycle performance

Ruijun Chen, Holly Samuelson, Yukai Zou, Xianghan Zheng, Yifan Cao

Summary: This research introduces an innovative resilient design framework that optimizes building performance by considering a holistic life cycle perspective and accounting for climate projection uncertainties. The study finds that future climate scenarios significantly impact building life cycle performance, with wall U-value, windows U-value, and wall density being major factors. By using ensemble learning and optimization algorithms, predictions for carbon emissions, cost, and indoor discomfort hours can be made, and the best resilient design scheme can be selected. Applying this framework leads to significant improvements in building life cycle performance.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2024)