4.7 Article

Viewpoint: The far-reaching dangers of rolling back environmental licensing and impact assessment legislation in Brazil

Journal

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW
Volume 94, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCIENCE INC
DOI: 10.1016/j.eiar.2022.106742

Keywords

Environmental licensing policy; Environmental impact assessment; Brazil; Environmental law-making; Environmental governance

Funding

  1. National Science Foundation (NSF) [1617413]
  2. Brazilian National Council for Scientific and Technological Development (CNPq) [311202/2018-0, 30352/2020-9]
  3. Sao Paulo Research Foundation (FAPESP) [2019/18988-9, 2019/17113-9]
  4. Direct For Biological Sciences
  5. Division Of Environmental Biology [1617413] Funding Source: National Science Foundation

Ask authors/readers for more resources

In Brazil, the newly passed General Law of Environmental Licensing may further weaken the country's environmental protection and public participation in decision-making, with far-reaching implications for environmental protection, governance, and human rights. Scientists can play a crucial role in debunking the dangerous effects of the bill and advising Senators and the public.
In the context of compounding health, environmental, and climatic crises, Brazil may witness two of its most important environmental policy instruments, environmental licensing and impact assessment, be severely weakened. On May 13, 2021, the Chamber of Deputies passed a new General Law of Environmental Licensing, ignoring the concerns of civil society, scientists, and other relevant parties. If approved by the Senate and ratified by President Bolsonaro, this law will further undermine Brazil's increasingly fragile environmental protection and public participation in decision-making. Here, we review the bill's main provisions, highlighting potential far-reaching implications for environmental protection and governance, public participation in decision-making, and human rights in Brazil and beyond. Scientists can play an important role in debunking misinformation and advising Senators and the public opinion on the bill's dangerous effects.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Environmental Sciences

Investigating Changes Driving Cumulative Impacts on Native Vegetation in Mining Regions in the Northeastern Brazilian Amazon

Juliana Siqueira-Gay, Diogo Santos, Wilson R. Nascimento Jr, Pedro Walfir M. Souza-Filho, Luis Enrique Sanchez

Summary: Developing conservation strategies to mitigate cumulative impacts requires understanding the historical changes in land use and land cover. A study on northeastern Amazon reveals that major mining and industrial investments can lead to cumulative losses of native vegetation, with the specific industries and infrastructure associated with the projects determining the spatial distribution and accumulation trends of the impacts.

ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

Addressing ecosystem services from plan to project to further tiering in impact assessment: Lessons from highway planning in Sa∼o Paulo, Brazil

Amarilis Lucia Casteli Figueiredo Gallardo, Josianne Claudia Sales Rosa, Luis Enrique Sanchez

Summary: This paper explores the use of the ecosystem services concept as a thread to tiering in impact assessment from the strategic to the project level using the tiered planning of transportation infrastructure in Sa similar to o Paulo, Brazil. It highlights the importance of explicit and upfront consideration of ecosystem services to support integrated assessment and structured consideration of socioecological systems in decision-making.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2022)

Review Water Resources

What does it mean to 'decharacterize' tailings dams? A systematic literature review

Rafaela Shinobe Massignan, Luis Enrique Sanchez

Summary: The study reviewed 105 papers published since 1983 on decharacterization and decommissioning methods for tailings storage facilities, revealing a lack of research on environmental impacts of TSFs closure works, representing a global issue.

ENGENHARIA SANITARIA E AMBIENTAL (2022)

Review Ecology

Quantifying the avoided biodiversity impacts associated with economic development

Joseph W. Bull, Laura J. Sonter, Ascelin Gordon, Martine Maron, Divya Narain, April E. Reside, Luis E. Sanchez, Nicole Shumway, Amrei von Hase, Fabien Quetier

Summary: Using the mitigation of biodiversity impacts by development projects as an example, this article explores the challenges of defining and measuring impact avoidance and presents a framework for assessing biodiversity impact avoidance.

FRONTIERS IN ECOLOGY AND THE ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Strategic planning to mitigate mining impacts on protected areas in the Brazilian Amazon

Juliana Siqueira-Gay, Jean Paul Metzger, Luis E. Sanchez, Laura J. Sonter

Summary: This study examines the impacts of five policy scenarios under which combinations of protected areas (PAs) allow mining in the Brazilian Amazon, and emphasizes the importance of long-term planning to safeguard biodiversity. The study finds that opening the entire network of PAs for mining would result in extensive deforestation and road construction. Reducing the number of protected areas can mitigate the impacts of mining expansion but would require longer access roads.

NATURE SUSTAINABILITY (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

Enhancing ecological connectivity through biodiversity offsets to mitigate impacts on habitats of large mammals in tropical forest environments

Josianne Claudia Sales Rosa, Pedro Bueno Rocha Campos, Caroline Bianca Nascimento, Barbara Almeida Souza, Rebeca Valetich, Luis Enrique Sanchez

Summary: This study analyzed the impact of a mining project on the dispersal of large mammals in the Atlantic rainforest region of Brazil and predicted the long-term outcomes of restoration offsets. The results showed that offsets can enhance ecological connectivity and provide alternative habitats for animals affected by habitat loss and fragmentation. Careful planning of restoration areas is necessary to maximize their contribution to increasing ecological connectivity and enhancing habitat quality.

IMPACT ASSESSMENT AND PROJECT APPRAISAL (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

Translating Best Practice Principles into criteria for evaluating the consideration of biodiversity in SEA practice

Amarilis Lucia Casteli Figueiredo Gallardo, Cintia Aparecida da Conceicao Dos Santos, Alan Bond, Evandro Mateus Moretto, Marcelo Montano, Simone Athayde

Summary: This paper aims to develop an easily applied, criteria-based approach for evaluating biodiversity assessment within Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) practices. A test application of the evaluation framework demonstrates its success in identifying whether the main elements of biodiversity were considered in a SEA report. However, further research is needed to develop evaluative approaches for the substantive inclusion of biodiversity in SEA practice.

IMPACT ASSESSMENT AND PROJECT APPRAISAL (2022)

Book Review Environmental Studies

It is the scale of issues that is important: a review of Handbook on cumulative impact assessment

Luis E. Sanchez

IMPACT ASSESSMENT AND PROJECT APPRAISAL (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Mainstreaming Flora Conservation Strategies into the Mitigation Hierarchy to Strengthen Environmental Impact Assessment

Tais Nogueira Fernandes, Fernando Marino Gomes dos Santos, Flavio Dayrell Gontijo, Joao Alves da Silva Filho, Alexandre Franco Castilho, Luis Enrique Sanchez

Summary: Applying the mitigation hierarchy to mining projects in areas of locational overlap between endemic flora and mineral deposits is challenging. We conducted flora surveys in connection with environmental impact assessments of iron ore mining projects in the Eastern Amazon to discuss the practical implications of anticipating conservation strategies. By conducting desktop studies and reviewing secondary data, we extended the known distribution of 45 out of 46 endemic plant species to new areas. Anticipating conservation strategies can minimize time-lag uncertainties, reducing risks to biodiversity and increasing restoration success and biodiversity offsets.

ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Evaluating the potential of biodiversity offsets to achieve net gain

Barbara Almeida Souza, Josianne Claudia Sales Rosa, Pedro Bueno R. Campos, Luis Enrique Sanchez

Summary: Evaluating the outcomes and tracking the trajectory of biodiversity offsets is crucial for demonstrating their effectiveness in balancing development and conservation. This study reviewed literature to establish the principles and criteria for evaluating biodiversity offsets at the project level. The core principles of equivalence, additionality, and permanence were used to assess the offsets of an iron ore mining project in Brazil. The study found that while forested areas achieved ecological equivalence and improved landscape connectivity, there were challenges in achieving equivalence and permanence for grasslands and fauna. Ongoing monitoring, evaluation, and adaptive management are necessary for successful biodiversity offsets.

CONSERVATION BIOLOGY (2023)

Letter Multidisciplinary Sciences

Conserving Brazil's free-flowing rivers

Stephannie Fernandes, Thiago B. A. Couto, Manuel Ferreira, Paulo S. Pompeu, Simone Athayde, Elizabeth P. Anderson, Geraldo W. Fernandes

SCIENCE (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

Delivering an analytical framework for evaluating the delivery of biodiversity objectives at strategic and project levels of impact assessment

Amarilis Lucia Casteli Figueiredo Gallardo, Alan Bond

Summary: "Transferring Biodiversity Knowledge Between SEA and EIA Assessments" aims to explore the potential for knowledge transfer in biodiversity assessment between Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) and Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA). By analyzing existing literature and using a novel analytical framework, the paper identifies 18 biodiversity objectives and assesses their coverage in SEA and EIA. The findings highlight opportunities for improving the tiering of biodiversity knowledge in impact assessment.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Diverse values of nature for sustainability

Unai Pascual, Patricia Balvanera, Christopher B. Anderson, Rebecca Chaplin-Kramer, Michael Christie, David Gonzalez-Jimenez, Adrian Martin, Christopher M. Raymond, Mette Termansen, Arild Vatn, Simone Athayde, Brigitte Baptiste, David N. Barton, Sander Jacobs, Eszter Kelemen, Ritesh Kumar, Elena Lazos, Tuyeni H. Mwampamba, Barbara Nakangu, Patrick O'Farrell, Suneetha M. Subramanian, Meine van Noordwijk, SoEun Ahn, Sacha Amaruzaman, Ariane M. Amin, Paola Arias-Arevalo, Gabriela Arroyo-Robles, Mariana Cantu-Fernandez, Antonio J. Castro, Victoria Contreras, Alta De Vos, Nicolas Dendoncker, Stefanie Engel, Uta Eser, Daniel P. Faith, Anna Filyushkina, Houda Ghazi, Erik Gomez-Baggethun, Rachelle K. Gould, Louise Guibrunet, Haripriya Gundimeda, Thomas Hahn, Zuzana V. Harmackova, Marcello Hernandez-Blanco, Andra-Ioana Horcea-Milcu, Mariaelena Huambachano, Natalia Lutti Hummel Wicher, Cem Iskender Aydin, Mine Islar, Ann-Kathrin Koessler, Jasper O. Kenter, Marina Kosmus, Heera Lee, Beria Leimona, Sharachchandra Lele, Dominic Lenzi, Bosco Lliso, Lelani M. Mannetti, Juliana Mercon, Ana Sofia Monroy-Sais, Nibedita Mukherjee, Barbara Muraca, Roldan Muradian, Ranjini Murali, Sara H. Nelson, Gabriel R. Nemoga-Soto, Jonas Ngouhouo-Poufoun, Aidin Niamir, Emmanuel Nuesiri, Tobias O. Nyumba, Begum Ozkaynak, Ignacio Palomo, Ram Pandit, Agnieszka Pawlowska-Mainville, Luciana Porter-Bolland, Martin Quaas, Julian Rode, Ricardo Rozzi, Sonya Sachdeva, Aibek Samakov, Marije Schaafsma, Nadia Sitas, Paula Ungar, Evonne Yiu, Yuki Yoshida, Eglee Zent

Summary: Twenty-five years after the initial publications on valuing ecosystem services for human well-being, barriers to incorporating nature's diverse values into decision-making still exist. These barriers are supported by powerful interests and legal rules, such as property rights, which determine whose values of nature are considered. It is crucial to understand why and how nature is undervalued. Despite agreements to incorporate nature's values into actions, current environmental and development policies prioritize certain values over others and disregard alternative ways in which people benefit from nature. This 'values crisis' underlies biodiversity loss, climate change, pandemics, and socio-environmental injustices. The Intergovernmental Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (IPBES) has assessed knowledge on nature's diverse values and proposed values-centered approaches to improve valuation and address barriers to uptake, aiming for more just and sustainable futures.

NATURE (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Philosophies of good living and values of nature: power and uncertainties in decision-making to achieve social- environmental in the Americas

Elena Lazos-Chavero, Agnieszka Pawlowska-Mainville, David Gonzalez-Jimenez, Mariana Cantu-Fernandez, Simone Athayde

Summary: In this article, the authors examine how values of nature are incorporated into decision-making processes among Indigenous peoples of the Americas through the philosophies of 'good living'. They also analyze the influence of power dynamics and uncertainties on decision making, and their potential to hinder or enable the achievement of socio-environmental justice.

CURRENT OPINION IN ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

Online and offline cooperation promotion mechanism in the E-waste recycling industry

Gang Tian, Ziyi Xia, Ruoxi Tian, Huaping Sun, Liping Yu, Dongyin Sun

Summary: This paper examines the cooperation between online recyclers and offline formal disposing enterprises in the e-waste recycling industry and emphasizes the importance of government regulations. The study reveals the threshold for the ratio of cooperation costs to excess benefits and the effect of government subsidies and penalties. These findings provide guidance for governments in promoting cooperation between these two types of enterprises.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2024)

Article Environmental Studies

Treat and halt: Occurrence of spatially heterogeneous cropland degradation in the peri-urban area

Zhuoran Yan, Dongyan Wang, Wenbo Li, Zhaomin Tong, Yuanli Zhu, Feng Shen

Summary: Globally, city region food systems are facing continuous disruptions from weather, disease, and geopolitical crisis. Prioritizing peri-urban agriculture is seen as a way to enhance the resilience of these systems, but there is limited research on combating land degradation threats in peri-urban areas.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2024)

Article Environmental Studies

Carbon emissions marginal abatement cost and its influencing factors from the construction and hygienic ceramics manufacturing industries in China

Yujiao Xian, Nan Li, Ke Wang

Summary: This study provides an innovative estimation of marginal abatement cost (MAC) for construction and hygienic ceramic enterprises in China. The results show that the average MAC for construction ceramics manufacturing is lower than that for hygienic ceramics manufacturing. Construction ceramics enterprises tend to downscale production while hygienic ceramics enterprises prefer increasing the intermediate input. Energy use efficiency positively influences MACs for both types of enterprises, while intermediate input rate, energy consumption structure, and profitability are negatively related to MAC.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2024)

Article Environmental Studies

Abandoned cropland compensates the decrease in net ecosystem productivity of impervious surface expansion in China

Mengdi Li, Yaoping Cui, Jinwei Dong, Yaochen Qin

Summary: This study examines the impacts of abandoned cropland and impervious surface expansion on net ecosystem productivity (NEP) in China. The findings suggest that abandoned cropland plays a crucial role in enhancing natural carbon sinks, while impervious surface expansion contributes significantly to carbon sources.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2024)

Article Environmental Studies

Synergy among finance, energy and CO2 emissions in a dynamic setting: Measures to optimize the carbon peaking path

Yaxian Wang, Xiaoyu Wang, Tomas Balezentis, Haijun Wang

Summary: This paper constructs a model covering finance and energy consumption to analyze the impact of financial development and energy consumption on CO2 emission changes in China. The results indicate that energy structure and carbon factor remain the principal drivers for CO2 emission growth.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2024)

Article Environmental Studies

Do different types of urban streets lead to varying COVID-19 risk perceptions? An empirical study from a spatial heterogeneity perspective

Yongqi Hou, Chongxian Chen, Xiaoling Lin, Zhitong Zhang, Xinyi Liu, Jiehang Xie, Shaoping Guan

Summary: This study explores how different types of street environments influence people's COVID-19 risk perception. The results showed that openness was the most important influencing factor, while visual crowdedness was the least important one. High-value clusters of COVID-19 risk perception were mainly found in poor-quality commercial streets, residential streets, and leisure streets close to the plaza, while low-value aggregations were mainly found in high-quality commercial streets, residential streets, and leisure streets close to blue space. The importance of environmental factors varied greatly by location.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2024)

Article Environmental Studies

Unlocking the potential of collaborative innovation to narrow the inter-city urban land green use efficiency gap: Empirical study on 19 urban agglomerations in China

Wenbo Hu, Zhuofan Li, Danling Chen, Ziyang Zhu, Xiaotao Peng, Yanbing Liu, Dongming Liao, Ke Zhao

Summary: This paper explores the impact of collaborative innovation on the gap in urban land green use efficiency (ULGUE) between cities, and proposes a theoretical framework. Through an analysis of a sample of 19 urban agglomerations in China, the study finds that collaborative innovation can significantly reduce the gap in ULGUE within urban agglomerations, exhibiting a double-threshold effect. Government intervention can mitigate the effects of collaborative innovation on the inter-city ULGUE gap.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2024)

Article Environmental Studies

Is there heterogeneity in ESG disclosure by mining companies? A comparison of developed and developing countries

Shufei Huang, Jianping Ge

Summary: ESG disclosures are crucial for companies in terms of their legal operations, capital cost reduction, investment expansion, and especially for mining companies due to their vulnerability to significant ecological and social impacts. The study evaluates the quantity and quality of mining companies' ESG disclosures using panel data from 2011 to 2020. The results indicate improvements in both the quantity and quality of ESG disclosures. Developed countries have higher average scores and disclosure ratios for ESG indicators compared to developing countries, with the largest gap observed in the environmental indicators. There is a stronger correlation between ESG disclosure quality and market value for mining companies in developed countries.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2024)

Article Environmental Studies

What are the causal conditions that lead to high or low environmental performance? A worldwide assessment

Nuno Silva, Jose Alberto Fuinhas, Matheus Koengkan, Emad Kazemzadeh

Summary: This study uses fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis to identify causal conditions for high or low environmental performance (EPI). The findings suggest that there are multiple paths to improve environmental performance, contingent on the country's initial environmental development level.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2024)

Article Environmental Studies

Multi-information integration-based life cycle analysis of greenhouse gas emissions for prefabricated construction: A case study of Shenzhen

Yu Gao, Jiayuan Wang, Tak Wing Yiu

Summary: Prefabricated buildings have attracted significant attention in the global construction sector for their potential in reducing construction time, improving process efficiency, saving resources, and mitigating pollution. Research in China shows that GHG emissions in the production, transportation, and construction stages of prefabricated buildings are primarily concentrated in the production phase, accounting for 96.11% of total emissions. Choosing prefabricated construction can lead to a 31.62% reduction in total GHG emissions per square meter.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2024)

Article Environmental Studies

Estimates of population highly annoyed from transportation noise in the United States: An unfair share of the burden by race and ethnicity

Ching-Hsuan Huang, Edmund Seto

Summary: Transportation noise, especially aviation, road, and railway traffic noise, is a major source of annoyance in communities across the United States. This study estimated the population highly annoyed by transportation noise using a spatially resolved model and established exposure-response functions. The results showed disparities in noise exposure and annoyance among different race/ethnicity groups, with non-White populations being more highly annoyed. Targeted source-specific noise mitigation strategies and policies are needed to minimize the disproportionate impact of transportation noise in the US.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2024)

Article Environmental Studies

Analysing the drivers of ecological footprint in Africa with machine learning algorithm

Delphin Kamanda Espoir, Regret Sunge, Tii Nchofoung, Andrew Adewale Alola

Summary: Africa faces challenges in terms of socioeconomics and security, which are connected to the continent's natural capital. This study examines the drivers of ecological footprint (EFP) in Africa using panel data from 39 countries between 1996 and 2018. Various factors, such as the economy, globalization, governance, energy, and socioeconomic aspects, are considered. Machine learning algorithms and regression techniques are employed to determine the important drivers and their marginal effects on EFP. The findings provide insights for policymakers and environmentalists in Africa.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2024)

Article Environmental Studies

Overestimation of mitigation leads to underestimation of residual impacts

Alvaro Enriquez-de-Salamanca

Summary: The effectiveness of mitigation measures in environmental impact assessment (EIA) is uncertain and may lead to undesired effects, affecting the assessment of residual impacts. Overestimating mitigation effectiveness distorts decision-making, emphasizing the need for information and environmental follow-up.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2024)

Article Environmental Studies

Fine-scale collision risk mapping and validation with long-term mortality data reveal current and future wind energy development impact on sensitive species

Jon Morant, Eneko Arrondo, Jose Antonio Sanchez-Zapata, Jose Antonio Donazar, Antoni Margalida, Martina Carrete, Guillermo Blanco, Francisco Guil, David Serrano, Juan Manuel Perez-Garcia

Summary: The demand for renewable energy has led to the development of wind farms worldwide. This study used GPS-tracking data of griffon vultures in Spain to evaluate factors influencing vulnerability and exposure to collision risks. The results showed that food availability, distance to nesting areas, and the presence of conspecifics affected the vulnerability and exposure of vultures. The study emphasized the need to reduce mapping uncertainties and plan wind energy development spatially to ensure the safety of vulnerable species.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2024)

Article Environmental Studies

Analyzing the impact of natural capital on socio- economic objectives under the framework of sustainable development goals

Yating Dai, Yuze Ding, Shuya Fu, Lixin Zhang, Jian Cheng, Daolin Zhu

Summary: Natural capital plays a vital role in achieving sustainable socio-economic objectives, but its impact varies depending on the level of development and socio-economic conditions.

ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REVIEW (2024)