4.7 Article

Accessibility, affordability, and equity in long-term spatial planning: Perspectives from a developing country

Journal

TRANSPORT POLICY
Volume 120, Issue -, Pages 104-119

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.tranpol.2022.03.007

Keywords

Accessibility; Affordability; Equity; Land use modelling; Public transport; Spatial planning

Ask authors/readers for more resources

City planners aim to create more equitable spaces by improving access to benefits of living in cities for previously disadvantaged urban communities. However, existing accessibility studies tend to focus on one element, limiting their usefulness in decision-making for city planners. This paper argues for expanding these measurements and adopting a nuanced view on accessibility by considering multiple factors, in order to improve urban planning practices and achieve greater equity.
City planners attempt to create more equitable spaces by providing and improving access to benefits of living in cities, especially for previously disadvantaged urban communities. To this extent, evidence-based decision making is required to adequately plan for and improve accessibility to several types of facilities. Accessibility studies in literature focus mostly on one element, which is sufficient when presenting methodological advancements, but it is limiting when providing decision support to city planners. This paper argues that these measurements should be expanded and there is a need for a nuanced view on accessibility for improved urban planning practices. Such a view is presented by simultaneously considering various categories of supply (employment, housing, transportation, health, education, police), multiple modes of transport (walking, private vehicle, numerous transit modes), two cost thresholds (distance-based and monetary cost), level of access (percentage of facilities that can be reached), while distinguishing between the socio-economic profiles of regions in the city on the demand side. This improves the understanding of affordability and equity in the study of accessibility. Furthermore, this paper expands two categories (education and housing) to explain the influence of capacity on accessibility and equity. Lastly, it couples a land-use model to some of the accessibility measures to show the usefulness of using such a combination in long-term spatial planning and what the effects will be without government intervention, again contributing to the understanding of, and planning for, more inclusive and equitable cities.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Computer Science, Information Systems

Modelling Representative Population Mobility for COVID-19 Spatial Transmission in South Africa

A. Potgieter, I. N. Fabris-Rotelli, Z. Kimmie, N. Dudeni-Tlhone, J. P. Holloway, C. Janse van Rensburg, R. N. Thiede, P. Debba, R. Manjoo-Docrat, N. Abdelatif, S. Khuluse-Makhanya

Summary: The COVID-19 pandemic has changed people's lives globally, emphasizing the importance of studying human mobility patterns for understanding virus transmission. This paper compares different mobility data sources and provides insights on when to choose a particular data source through hierarchical clustering analysis.

FRONTIERS IN BIG DATA (2021)

Article Audiology & Speech-Language Pathology

Is Phonological Awareness Related to Pitch, Rhythm, and Speech-in-Noise Discrimination in Young Children?

Renata Eccles, Jeannie van der Linde, Mia le Roux, Jenny Hollovvay, Douglas MacCutcheon, Robert Ljung, De Wet Swanepoel

Summary: The study identified medium strength correlations between phonological awareness and pitch, rhythm, and speech-in-noise discrimination in children aged 5-7 years old. Pitch and diotic digit-in-noise discrimination were found to be the strongest predictors of phoneme-grapheme correspondence.

LANGUAGE SPEECH AND HEARING SERVICES IN SCHOOLS (2021)

Article Education & Educational Research

Effect of music instruction on phonological awareness and early literacy skills of five- to seven-year-old children

Renata Eccles, Jeannie van der Linde, Mia le Roux, Jenny Holloway, Douglas MacCutcheon, Robert Ljung, De Wet Swanepoel

Summary: Multiple studies have shown that music instruction can improve phonological awareness and early literacy skills in children, but varying results require at least one academic year of exposure to conclude the effects.

EARLY CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND CARE (2021)

Article Transportation

Integrated land use and transportation modelling and planning: A South African journey

Louis Waldeck, Jenny Holloway, Quintin Van Heerden

JOURNAL OF TRANSPORT AND LAND USE (2020)

Article Economics

Crowding multipliers on shared transportation in New York City: The effects of COVID-19 and implications for a sustainable future

Tomas Rossetti, Ricardo A. Daziano

Summary: This study investigates the changes in crowding multipliers for subway, ridehailing, and microtransit in New York City during and after the COVID-19 pandemic. The results show that post-pandemic crowding multipliers are either similar or lower than during the pandemic, depending on the transportation mode and masking compliance. Vaccination requirements did not significantly impact respondents' choices, but respondents were willing to pay to reduce their transportation mode's carbon footprint. The study suggests that commuters' aversion to crowding will gradually decrease, but it remains uncertain whether crowding multipliers will return to pre-pandemic levels or establish a new normal.

TRANSPORT POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Modelling benefit-to-cost ratio for initial phase electrification using battery electric bus

Utsav Panta, Pranav Gairola, N. Nezamuddin

Summary: Electric buses are being considered as an important part of future urban transportation systems due to concerns regarding environmental pollution, greenhouse gas emissions, and depleting petroleum resources. However, the transition process requires substantial financial resources. To assist decision-making within financial constraints, an optimization framework has been developed. This framework focuses on maximizing the benefit-to-cost ratio by evaluating fuel savings and emissions reduction when transitioning to electric buses. The framework has been tested in Delhi, India and suggests that at least 30% of the electricity should come from clean energy sources to maximize the environmental benefits of bus electrification. This framework is an important tool for public transit agencies in planning the initial phases of bus electrification.

TRANSPORT POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Examining market segmentation to increase bike-share use and enhance equity: The case of the greater Sacramento region

Hossain Mohiuddin, Dillon T. Fitch-Polse, Susan L. Handy

Summary: As bike-share systems spread in the US, understanding the different segments of bike-share users is crucial in expanding and benefiting more people. This study analyzes bike-share user data in Sacramento and identifies low-income individuals, zero-car households, students, and transit and car-share users as significant market segments. The results show that bike-share is widely adopted, particularly by those with limited means of transportation. Targeting low-income and zero-car owners can help increase bike-share demand and enhance social equity.

TRANSPORT POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Priority areas of intervention for improving pedestrian infrastructure and facilities at tourist destinations in India

Priyanka Das, Swati Maitra

Summary: An investigation was conducted on improving pedestrian infrastructure and facilities at tourist destinations in India. The study found that the pedestrian infrastructure and facilities in these destinations are generally deficient and immediate interventions are required. The study also emphasized the need for developing infrastructure and facilities according to tourists' requirements to promote tourism.

TRANSPORT POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Policy, management, and operation practices in US microtransit systems

Subid Ghimire, Eleni Bardaka, Kai Monast, Juan Wang, Waugh Wright

Summary: This paper examines the challenges and practices in planning, management, and operation of microtransit systems in the U.S. It discusses the formation of public-private partnerships, cost elements, funding sources, ADA compliance requirements, safety risks, and supply-demand balancing in microtransit systems.

TRANSPORT POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Joint decision of green technology adoption and sailing pattern for a coastal ship under ECAs

Ming Zhang, Xianyang Zeng, Zhijia Tan

Summary: This study investigates the choice of green fuel and green technology for ships and derives the sufficient and necessary conditions for adopting scrubber installation strategy. The study finds that introducing scrubber technology can reduce evasion behavior of ships but also increase total emissions in coastal areas.

TRANSPORT POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Managing travelers' mode choices in the era of shared mobility through traditional traffic regulation policies

Xiaolei Wang, Fangfang Yuan

Summary: The study models the mode choices of travelers in a simple urban transportation scenario with and without ride-hailing services, and examines the potential of ride-hailing in mitigating congestion. It also investigates the impacts of three traffic regulation policies and their ability to achieve system optimum in the presence of ride-hailing.

TRANSPORT POLICY (2024)

Review Economics

Integrating equity in transportation scenario planning: A systematic review

Meiyu (Melrose) Pan, Stephen Wong, Francis Tainter, Steve Woelfel, Alyssa Ryan

Summary: This paper presents a systematic literature review on how equity has been considered and evaluated in scenario planning. The findings suggest the need for more vertical equity evaluations, the construction of robustness and justice indicators, and the adoption of a flexible mindset of planning for various scenarios. This work adds value to the existing body of knowledge and has important policy implications for future transportation planning.

TRANSPORT POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Broad support vs. deep opposition: The politics of bus rapid transit in low-and middle-income countries

Nicholas Goedeking

Summary: This paper addresses the politics of bus rapid transit (BRT) in low- and middle-income countries, providing new insights through expert interviews and proposing two analytical frameworks. The first framework highlights the contentious nature of BRT proposals, while the second framework challenges the conventional view on the durability of BRT systems.

TRANSPORT POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Pursuing cycling equity? A mixed-methods analysis of cycling plans in European cities

Isabel Cunha, Cecilia Silva, Benjamin Buettner, Tuuli Toivonen

Summary: This study investigates the equity impacts of cycling plans and infrastructure allocation in three European cities. The research finds that cycling planning often prioritises advantaged areas and central zones, neglecting disadvantaged socio-economic zones.

TRANSPORT POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

How do I want the city council to spend our budget? Conceiving MaaS from a citizen's perspective ... (as well as biking infrastructure and public transport)

Francisco J. Bahamonde-Birke, Iris M. Geigenmueller, Niek Mouter, Dea S. van Lierop, Dick F. Ettema

Summary: This study uses Participatory Value Evaluation to analyze the differences in social desirability between MaaS services and public investments in biking infrastructure and public transport. The results show that people are more willing to allocate resources to bike infrastructure and public transport than to MaaS subsidies, with sustainability-focused subsidies showing greater social valuation. There are also negative synergies among similar projects, indicating a preference for diversifying public resources across different types of investment projects.

TRANSPORT POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Fiscal sustainability and the composition of government investment: The case of investment in road infrastructure

Timo Valila

Summary: Road infrastructure investment is influenced by fiscal policy considerations, which is used by governments to address debt sustainability and smooth out debt volatility. It competes with investment in health and education, and its impact on congestion is limited and uncertain.

TRANSPORT POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Study on the truck axle load limit for rural roads based on the cost of the concerned entities in China

Jinyu Jiang, Zhongzhen Yang

Summary: The axle load limit plays a crucial role in determining the costs associated with highway construction and truck transportation. This study examines the optimization of the axle load limit for rural roads, taking into account advancements in road construction technology, construction funding, and vehicle manufacturing techniques. A programming model is developed to maximize the cost gap between scenarios with and without incremental limits. The findings suggest that a limit of 13 tons maximizes the reduction in system costs, resulting in significant annual benefits.

TRANSPORT POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

The impact of civil airspace policies on the viability of adopting autonomous unmanned aerial vehicles in last-mile applications

Mo ElSayed, Ahmed Foda, Moataz Mohamed

Summary: This study evaluates the impact of UAV flight policies on energy consumption and the required charging infrastructure. The results show that policy strictness increases the demand for charging stations and leads to increased cost per parcel delivery.

TRANSPORT POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Spatial equity of micromobility systems: A comparison of shared E-scooters and docked bikeshare in Washington DC

Lin Su, Xiang Yan, Xilei Zhao

Summary: Dockless e-scooter services can expand mobility options for underserved neighborhoods but may widen access gaps. Compared to docked bikeshare, shared e-scooters have higher overall spatial accessibility but longer idle time. Bikeshare system's equity program is more effective than e-scooter operators' in promoting usage in low-income neighborhoods.

TRANSPORT POLICY (2024)