4.7 Review

Improved soil structural stability under no-tillage is related to increased soil carbon in rice paddies: Evidence from literature review and field experiment

Journal

ENVIRONMENTAL TECHNOLOGY & INNOVATION
Volume 26, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.eti.2021.102248

Keywords

Aggregate carbon mineralization; Aggregate stability; Carbon mineralization; Soil structural stability; Soil carbon accumulation; No-tillage

Funding

  1. National Key Research and Development Program of China [2016YFD0300201]
  2. China Scholarship Council, China [201906350044]
  3. Department of Agroecology and iClimate, Aarhus University

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Improving soil structural stability (SSS) and soil organic carbon (SOC) are critical for soil health and environmental pollution mitigation. No-tillage can increase macroaggregate content, wet stability of aggregates (WSA), and mean weight diameter (MWD, contributing to improved soil structural stability, especially in rice paddies.
Improving soil structural stability (SSS) and soil organic carbon (SOC) are critical for soil health and environmental pollution mitigation. No-tillage alters many soil properties (e.g., SOC), however, its effects on SSS in rice paddies are unclear. Therefore, we used field experiment and meta-analysis to determine the effects of no-tillage on wet stability of aggregates (WSA), clay dispersibility (ClayDis), mean weight diameter (MWD), and aggregate SOC distribution and mineralization in rice paddies. The field experiment included four tillage practices: no-tillage, rotary tillage and moldboard plow tillage with rice straw retention (NTS, RTS and CTS respectively), and moldboard plow tillage with rice straw removal (CT). The WSA at 0-5 cm soil depth was significantly higher under NTS compared with CTS. The ClayDis at 5-10 cm soil depth under NTS was 36% lower (P < 0.05) than CTS. The relationship between SOC and WSA fits a broken stick model, with an inflection point of clay/SOC ratio at 12.5. Higher SOC under no-tillage might result from the protection of >2 mm aggregates (macroaggregates) and lower SOC mineralization of < 2 mm aggregates. Additionally, the meta-analysis showed that no-tillage increased (P < 0.05) the macroaggregate content, WSA and MWD. However, the current research regarding tillage effects on paddy ClayDis is insufficient. In rice paddies, the increased macroaggregate content may contribute to increasing SOC, which improves SSS under no-tillage. (C) 2021 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier B.V.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Soil Science

Discrete element modeling of aggregate shape and internal structure effects on Weibull distribution of tensile strength

Luis Alfredo Pires Barbosa, Kirill M. Gerke, Lars J. Munkholm, Thomas Keller, Horst H. Gerke

Summary: This study used Discrete Element Modeling (DEM) to simulate the rupture of soil aggregates with different shapes but the same assumed distributions of cementing agents. The results showed that the Weibull modulus can be used to describe the heterogeneity of particle binding forces within the aggregate, and the sensitivity of this modulus to the heterogeneity of the binding force distribution increases with aggregate sphericity.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2022)

Article Soil Science

Modeling soil aggregate fracture using the discrete element method

Frederik F. Foldager, Lars J. Munkholm, Ole Balling, Radu Serban, Dan Negrut, Richard J. Heck, Ole Green

Summary: The Discrete Element Method (DEM) is a suitable approach for modeling arable soil and tillage processes. This study focuses on modeling soil fragmentation and proposes a method for computing the indirect tensile strength of soil aggregates through simulation, which is calibrated and validated using experimental data.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Influence of environmental factors on soil organic carbon in different soil layers for Chinese Mollisols under intensive maize cropping

Weijun Zhang, Lars J. Munkholm, Tingting An, Xu Liu, Bin Zhang, Yingde Xu, Zhuang Ge, Yan Zhang, Jiuming Zhang, Shuangyi Li, Jingkuan Wang

Summary: This study investigates the response of soil organic carbon (SOC) content to environmental factors in different soil layers in the Mollisol region of Northeast China. The results show that SOC content is primarily influenced by climatic factors, while soil properties play a significant role in the subsoil layer. Furthermore, geographical factors indirectly affect SOC content through their influence on climate factors, with mean annual temperature being the most important factor affecting SOC content.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Soil Science

Soil characteristics and root growth in a catena across and outside the wheel tracks for different slurry application systems

Per Schjonning, Lars J. Munkholm, Mathieu Lamande

Summary: The compaction of subsoils is becoming increasingly problematic due to the increasing weight and power of field machinery. In a field experiment comparing two different machinery systems used in slurry application, it was found that the machinery had significant effects on soil properties, causing soil loosening and a decrease in rooting depth for crops.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2022)

Article Agronomy

Grass-clover response to cattle slurry N-rates: Yield, clover proportion, protein concentration and estimated N2-fixation

Henrik Thers, Johannes L. Jensen, Jim Rasmussen, Jorgen Eriksen

Summary: This study investigated the effects of different nitrogen application rates on the yield, crude protein content, and clover proportion of grass-clover leys. Results showed that the highest yield was achieved with nitrogen application rates of 200 and 300 kg/ha. Increasing nitrogen application rates led to a decrease in clover proportion and had no significant effect or a decrease in crude protein content.

FIELD CROPS RESEARCH (2022)

Article Soil Science

Soil organic C and N stock changes in grass-clover leys: Effect of grassland proportion and organic fertilizer

Johannes L. Jensen, Amelie M. Beucher, Jorgen Eriksen

Summary: Grass-clover leys in crop rotations on dairy farms can help mitigate climate change by sequestering soil organic carbon (SOC). However, accurately quantifying the SOC sequestration potential of grass-clover leys is challenging. This study found that grassland proportion and slurry C-input significantly influenced SOC storage based on a long-term experiment, and also demonstrated that soil nitrogen is stored along with SOC in equal proportions.

GEODERMA (2022)

Article Soil Science

Soil aggregate microstructure and microbial community structure mediate soil organic carbon accumulation: Evidence from one-year field experiment

Weijun Zhang, Lars J. Munkholm, Xu Liu, Tingting An, Yingde Xu, Zhuang Ge, Ninghui Xie, Aimeng Li, Yuqi Dong, Chang Peng, Shuangyi Li, Jingkuan Wang

Summary: Tillage managements, especially subsoiling with straw residue incorporation, can improve soil aggregate microstructure and microbial community structure, leading to enhanced soil organic carbon (SOC) accumulation in the topsoil and subsoil layers. The variation in SOC within aggregates is primarily influenced by soil microbial characteristics rather than soil aggregate structure characteristics. Bacteria play a significant role in explaining the variation in SOC within aggregates. The interaction mechanism between pore characteristics, microbial structure, and SOC differs between the topsoil and subsoil layers, affecting the influx of organic C, pore size distribution, and microbial adaptability.

GEODERMA (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

A 40 % paddy surface soil organic carbon increase after 5-year no-tillage is linked with shifts in soil bacterial composition and functions

Jian-Ying Qi, Xiang-Bin Yao, Jian Lu, Long-Xin He, Jun-Li Cao, Zheng-Rong Kan, Xing Wang, Sheng-Gang Pan, Xiang-Ru Tang

Summary: Soil organic carbon (SOC) is important for soil fertility, crop yield, and climate change mitigation. This study examined the effects of different tillage practices on SOC accumulation in paddy fields and its relationship with soil bacteria in southern China. The results showed that no-tillage (NT) increased rice residue carbon inputs, SOC content, and CO2 flux compared to reduced tillage (RT) and conventional tillage (CT). NT also significantly altered the soil bacterial community. The study suggests that the rapid increase in paddy SOC is influenced by both residue C input and the degradation functions regulated by soil bacteria.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Soil Science

Effects of freeze-thaw cycles on soil structure under different tillage and plant cover management practices

Jorge F. Miranda-Velez, Frederic Leuther, John Maximilian Koehne, Lars J. Munkholm, Iris Vogeler

Summary: Soil structure plays a crucial role in environmentally relevant soil processes, and the effects of freeze-thaw on soil structure depend on its preexistent strength and cohesion. Management choices such as tillage and plant cover strongly influence soil structure and its response to freeze-thaw. The study found that freeze-thaw caused crumbling of soil around coarse macropores, creating new very fine macropores and expanding previously indiscernible macropores.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2023)

Article Agronomy

Additional phosphorus intensity analysis needed to identify phosphorus requirement on acid sandy soils with high Olsen-P contents

Ingeborg Frosig Pederson, Lars J. Munkholm, Camilla Lemming, Maarit Maenpaa, Gitte H. Rubaek

Summary: Meeting the phosphorus (P) requirement of crops is crucial for achieving yield potential. It is important to assess the ability of soils to supply P to crops, in order to identify soils in need of P fertilization and to avoid unnecessary P fertilization.

FIELD CROPS RESEARCH (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Effects of contrasting tillage managements on the vertical distribution of plant- and microbial-derived carbon in rice paddy

Jian-Ying Qi, Xiang-Bin Yao, Mei-Yang Duan, Xiang-Wen Huang, Mei-Yi Fan, Ya Yang, Hao-Wen Luo, Xiang-Ru Tang

Summary: The tillage and rice residue management practices have effects on the vertical distribution of microbial necromass and plant residues in rice paddy soils. The no-tillage (NT) practice resulted in higher microbial-derived carbon (C) in the soil, but did not significantly affect microbial-derived C contents and soil organic carbon (SOC) mineralization. However, it significantly decreased plant-derived C contents in the total SOC.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Soil Science

Vertical and horizontal stresses from a lightweight autonomous field robot during repeated wheeling

A. Calleja-Huerta, M. Lamande, O. Green, L. J. Munkholm

Summary: This experiment aimed to study the vertical and horizontal stresses during repeated wheeling from a lightweight autonomous robot and compare the measurements with calculations. The results showed a significant increase in mean ground pressure with repeated wheeling, measured values of maximum vertical stresses were 32% larger than the ones predicted by the model. These findings suggest that using static loads from this machine as inputs in models can result in inaccurate predictions of soil-tyre interface parameters.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2023)

Article Soil Science

Impacts of load and repeated wheeling from a lightweight autonomous field robot on the physical properties of a loamy sand soil

A. Calleja-Huerta, M. Lamande, O. Green, L. J. Munkholm

Summary: The increasing size of agricultural machinery has led to increased risk of soil compaction. Lightweight autonomous robots have been proposed as a solution, but they may increase the area affected by traffic and repeated wheeling. This study evaluated the effects of load and repeated wheeling from a lightweight autonomous robot on soil physical properties. The results showed that load configuration and the number of passes both had significant effects on rut depth, apparent cohesion, penetration resistance, air permeability, and effective air-filled porosity.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2023)

Article Soil Science

Evaluation of the relation between soil biomass of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi and glomalin-related soil protein in conservation agriculture

Stamatios Thomopoulos, Lars Elsgaard, Lars Juhl Munkholm, Sabine Ravnskov

Summary: This study investigated the correlation between different fractions of glomalin-related soil protein (GRSP) and fatty acid fractions in soil, as well as the impact of conservation agriculture practices on arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) biomass and GRSP content. The results showed a positive correlation between easily extractable (EE) GRSP and phospholipid fatty acid (PLFA) 16:1 omega 5, indicating the complexity of GRSP dynamics and the need for further research. Additionally, mechanical soil management had a greater impact on AMF biomass and EE-GRSP compared to residue management, suggesting that tillage practices exert a stronger influence on AMF abundance and GRSP content than residue management.

SOIL BIOLOGY & BIOCHEMISTRY (2023)

No Data Available