4.5 Article

Predicting the Thermodynamics of Ionic Liquids: What to Expect from PC-SAFT and COSMO-RS?


Volume 126, Issue 20, Pages 3717-3736


DOI: 10.1021/acs.jpcb.2c00685




  1. Czech Science Foundation [19-04150Y]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study benchmarks two thermodynamic modeling frameworks, PCSAFT equation of state and COSMO-RS model, for predicting the properties of ionic liquids (ILs) and the solubility of CO2 in ILs. The results show that the supermolecule approach yields better results for the vapor pressure and vaporization enthalpy of pure ILs, while the ion-based approach is more suitable for the solubility of CO2. COSMO-RS with the supermolecule approach demonstrates the best overall predictive capabilities, but the ion-based strategy has limitations in predicting the vaporization properties of ILs, which can be partially overcome with additional quantum mechanical calculations.
Two popular thermodynamic modeling frameworks, namely, the PCSAFT equation of state and the COSMO-RS model, are benchmarked for their performance in predicting the thermodynamic properties of pure ionic liquids (ILs) and the solubility of CO2 in ILs. The ultimate goal is to provide an illustration of what to expect from these frameworks when applied to ILs in a purely predictive way with established parametrization approaches, since the literature generally lacks their mutual comparisons. Two different modeling approaches with respect to the description of the molecular structure of ILs are tested within both models: a cation-anion pair as (i) a single electroneutral supermolecule and (ii) a pair of separately modeled counterions (ion-based approach). In general, we illustrate that special attention should be paid when estimating unknown thermodynamic data of ILs even with these two progressive thermodynamic frameworks. For both PC-SAFT and COSMO-RS, the supermolecule approach generally yields better results for the vapor pressure and the vaporization enthalpy of pure ILs, while the ion-based approach is found to be more suitable for the solubility of CO2. In spite of some shortcomings, COSMO-RS with the supermolecule approach shows the best overall predictive capabilities for the studied properties. The ion-based strategy within both models has significant limitations in the case of the vaporization properties of ILs. In COSMO-RS, these limitations can, to a certain extent, be surpassed by additional quantum mechanical calculations of the ion pairing in the gas phase, while the ion-based PC-SAFT approach still needs a sophisticated improvement to be developed. As an initiating point, we explore one possible and simple route considering a high degree of cross associations between the counterions in the gas phase.


I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.


Primary Rating

Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Scientific rigor
Rate this paper


Article Thermodynamics

Vapor Pressures and Thermophysical Properties of 1-Heptanol, 1-Octanol, 1-Nonanol, and 1-Decanol: Data Reconciliation and PC-SAFT Modeling

Vaclav Pokorny, Vojtech Stejfa, Martin Klajmon, Michal Fulem, Kvetoslav Ruzicka

Summary: In this study, vapor pressures and thermodynamic properties of long-chain alcohols were investigated through experimental and theoretical methods, and the results were validated and analyzed. The performance of the PC-SAFT equation of state in describing these properties was found to be satisfactory.


Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

Comparative Study of DSC-Based Protocols for API-Polymer Solubility Determination

Alex Mathers, Fatima Hassouna, Martin Klajmon, Michal Fulem

Summary: The study analyzed various DSC-based solubility determination methods and different equations and curve modeling approaches for constructing temperature-composition phase diagrams. Experimental results revealed that the S-WD method, used in conjunction with the Kwei equation, was the most reliable combination, predicting approximately 40 wt% IND solubility in PVP K12 at T = 25 degrees C.


Article Thermodynamics

Vapor Pressures and Thermophysical Properties of Dimethoxymethane, 1,2-Dimethoxyethane, 2-Methoxyethanol, and 2-Ethoxyethanol: Data Reconciliation and Perturbed-Chain Statistical Associating Fluid Theory Modeling

Vaclav Pokorny, Vojtech Stejfa, Jan Pavlicek, Martin Klajmon, Michal Fulem, Kvetoslav Ruzicka

Summary: This study measured and calculated the thermodynamic properties of four important industrial solvents to obtain a consistent thermodynamic description. Statistical thermodynamics calculations were performed using fundamental vibrational frequencies and molecular structure data, and new parameters were used in the PC-SAFT equation to achieve improved performance.


Article Pharmacology & Pharmacy

Ball milling and hot-melt extrusion of indomethacin-L-arginine-vinylpyrrolidone-vinyl acetate copolymer: Solid-state properties and dissolution performance

Anton Iemtsev, Alzbeta Zemankova, Fatima Hassouna, Alex Mathers, Martin Klajmon, Michaela Slamova, Lenka Malinova, Michal Fulem

Summary: This study focused on enhancing the dissolution properties of low water-soluble crystalline active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) through various methods. Binary and ternary formulations were prepared using ball milling and/or hot-melt extrusion, and extensively characterized. The results showed that ball-milled formulations were amorphous, while ternary formulations produced via hot-melt extrusion contained residual crystals. Dissolution tests revealed improved solubility for ternary systems prepared by hot-melt extrusion compared to pure crystalline APIs. The fully amorphous formulations remained stable without recrystallization during the preservation period.


Article Chemistry, Physical

Does Explicit Polarizability Improve Molecular Dynamics Predictions of Glass Transition Temperatures of Ionic Liquids?

Martin Klajmon, Ctirad Cervinka

Summary: Molecular dynamics simulations were used to predict the glass transition temperatures of a test set of five aprotic ionic liquids. The results showed that the polarizable simulations with the Drude model provided the best estimations with lower uncertainty compared to the nonpolarizable model.


Article Pharmacology & Pharmacy

Compatibility of selected active pharmaceutical ingredients with poly(D, L-lactide-co-glycolide): Computational and experimental study

Anton Iemtsev, Fatima Hassouna, Martin Klajmon, Alex Mathers, Michal Fulem

Summary: This study evaluates the compatibility between biodegradable polyesters and active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) and investigates the physical stability of drug carriers using phase diagrams. The results show varying levels of compatibility between different ratios of PLGA and model APIs, with only the IND-PLGA75 formulation remaining stable after storage.


Article Chemistry, Physical

Thermodynamic properties of water from SAFT and CPA equations of state: A comprehensive assessment

Ivo Nezbeda, Martin Klajmon, Jan Hruby

Summary: The performance of eight versions of SAFT equations and CPA equation for water is examined in different thermodynamic conditions. It is found that these equations have inconsistent results for different properties of water, making it practically impossible to draw a general conclusion. The equations can reasonably reproduce pressure dependence at isothermal conditions but fail in estimating isobaric properties. The Association Dependent PC-SAFT equation shows the most successful performance due to its fitting using a broader set of experimental data.


Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

Purely Predicting the Pharmaceutical Solubility: What to Expect from PC-SAFT and COSMO-RS?

Martin Klajmon

Summary: This study thoroughly benchmarks two popular thermodynamic models, PC-SAFT and COSMO-RS, for predicting the solubility of active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) in pure solvents. The results show that COSMO-RS outperforms PC-SAFT both qualitatively and quantitatively, even though COSMO-RS does not rely on experimental data. Interestingly, both models were found to often incorrectly predict the direction of deviations from ideality.


Article Chemistry, Physical

Assessing the quality of SAFT equations for the vapor-liquid equilibrium of pure water

Martin Klajmon, Ivo Nezbeda

Summary: This study examines the accuracy of eight representative SAFT equations of state for water and the cubic-plus-association equation in predicting the vapor-liquid equilibrium of water. The equations only use experimental equilibrium liquid densities and pressures for parameter evaluation, which leads to inaccuracies in determining equilibrium properties. The errors in predicted equilibrium densities, orthobaric pressures, and other related properties are determined and discussed.


Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Solid-Liquid Equilibrium in Co-Amorphous Systems: Experiment and Prediction

Alzbeta Zemankova, Fatima Hassouna, Martin Klajmon, Michal Fulem

Summary: In this work, the authors investigated the solid-liquid equilibrium (SLE) of four binary systems combining two active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) capable of forming co-amorphous systems (CAMs). The experimental results showed that all binary mixtures formed eutectic systems. The study also evaluated the ability of theoretical models to predict the phase diagrams for the investigated API-API binary systems.


Article Pharmacology & Pharmacy

Effect of Copolymer Properties on the Phase Behavior of Ibuprofen-PLA/PLGA Mixtures

Anton Iemtsev, Martin Klajmon, Fatima Hassouna, Michal Fulem

Summary: Prediction of API-polymer compatibility is crucial for drug delivery system design and long-term physical stability estimation. This study investigated the phase behavior of IBU with PLGA and PLA using experimental and computational methods. The phase diagrams constructed based on PC-SAFT EOS modeling demonstrated low solubility and limited miscibility of IBU with all polymers studied. The ability of PC-SAFT EOS to capture the observed trends in phase behavior with respect to copolymer composition and molecular weight was thoroughly investigated and evaluated.


Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

Can Pure Predictions of Activity Coefficients from PC-SAFT Assist Drug-Polymer Compatibility Screening?

Jachym Pavlis, Alex Mathers, Michal Fulem, Martin Klajmon

Summary: The bioavailability of poorly water-soluble APIs can be enhanced by formulating them into amorphous solid dispersions (ASDs) with suitable polymeric carriers. Traditional experimental methods for identifying optimal carriers are time-consuming and costly. In this study, the perturbed-chain statistical associating fluid theory (PC-SAFT) equation of state was evaluated for its ability to predict API-polymer compatibility without any fitted binary interaction parameters. The PC-SAFT predictions were compared to experimental data for 40 API-polymer combinations, and while the total average error was around 50%, the qualitative ranking of polymer compatibility was reasonably predicted.


Article Engineering, Chemical

Glass Transition and Structure of Organic Polymers from All-Atom Molecular Simulations

Martin Klajmon, Vladislav Aulich, Jan Ludik, Ctirad Cervinka

Summary: Molecular dynamics simulations at the all-atom level were used to investigate the relationship between structure and properties of polymer samples. The accuracy of the simulations was independently benchmarked for three selected polymers. It was found that the accuracy of predicting the glass transition temperature depends on the internal dynamics and trend shifts between the glass and liquid phases, with varying levels of performance among different polymers.


No Data Available