4.7 Review

Carbon dioxide thickening: A review of technological aspects, advances and challenges for oilfield application

Journal

FUEL
Volume 315, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.fuel.2021.122947

Keywords

CO2 thickening; Chemical classification; Gas solubility-viscosity relationship; EOR and fracturing; Molecular dynamics simulation

Funding

  1. Saudi Aramco [OSR: 44436]
  2. Department of Science & Technology, SERB, India [CRG/2020/000828]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This article reviews the technical advances, challenges, and applicability of CO2 thickeners, particularly for hydrocarbon recovery. Different types of thickeners, including binary co-polymers and small molecule compounds, have been investigated and show promise for CO2 thickening.
The relatively low density and viscosity of carbon dioxide (CO2) in supercritical state create several drawbacks, including gravity override, viscous fingering, water production/treatment problems, and poor proppant trans-port for the petroleum industry. The introduction of CO2 thickeners offers a promising additive technology with sufficient solubility and viscosity enhancement attributes. The current article reviews the technical advances, challenges, and applicability of thickened CO2, particularly for hydrocarbon recovery. Different types of thick-eners, including polymers, tailor-made surfactants, and small associating compounds, were investigated in terms of their nature, physicochemical traits, cost, and applications. The molecular weight and concentration, shear rate, co-solvent composition, temperature, and pressure play a significant role in the intermolecular forces and miscibility effect of thickeners in the presence of dense CO2. Binary co-polymers (non-fluorinated non-siloxane materials) and small molecule (associating) compounds are promising options for CO2 thickening owing to their enhanced performance, cost-effectiveness, and low ecological footprint. This study provides a comprehensive review of existing technologies, outline the gaps, potential, and required area for improvement.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Optimization and Uncertainty Quantification Method for Reservoir Stimulation through Carbonate Acidizing

Qasim Sahu, Marwan Fahs, Hussein Hoteit

Summary: Reservoir stimulation techniques, particularly in carbonate formations, are commonly used in the oil and gas industry to enhance productivity. This study develops an optimization workflow under uncertainty for matrix acidizing using a reactive transport model and surrogate modeling. The research investigates the impact of various parameters on the stimulation efficiency and provides physical insights into the matrix acidizing process.

ACS OMEGA (2023)

Article Chemistry, Physical

A mechanistic study of low salinity water-based nanoparticle-polymer complex fluid for improved oil recovery in sandstone reservoirs

Rohit Kumar Saw, Anshuman Singh, Neetish Kumar Maurya, Ajay Mandal

Summary: Low salinity water flooding is cost-effective and environmentally friendly, and the addition of nanoparticles and polymers can significantly increase oil recovery. The viscosity of complex chemical slugs can be increased by adding nanoparticles to polymer solutions. Low salinity water requires a lower concentration of polymer to reach the target viscosity compared to high saline formation water. The addition of nanoparticles reduces interfacial tension and contact angle, leading to higher oil recovery in low salinity water. Injection of low salinity water-based complex fluid results in incremental recovery of OOIP compared to low salinity water and conventional formation water flooding.

COLLOIDS AND SURFACES A-PHYSICOCHEMICAL AND ENGINEERING ASPECTS (2023)

Article Energy & Fuels

Uncertainty Analysis of CO2 Storage in Deep Saline Aquifers Using Machine Learning and Bayesian Optimization

Abdulwahab Alqahtani, Xupeng He, Bicheng Yan, Hussein Hoteit

Summary: This study presents a machine learning-assisted workflow for uncertainty and global sensitivity analysis of CO2 storage prediction. It includes steps for dataset generation, ML model development, and Monte Carlo simulations. The workflow is accurate and efficient for CO2 sequestration prediction.

ENERGIES (2023)

Article Energy & Fuels

Effect of Methyl Orange on the Hydrogen Wettability of Sandstone Formation for Enhancing the Potential of Underground Hydrogen Storage

Fatemah Alhamad, Rossen Sedev, Mujahid Ali, Muhammad Ali, Hussein Hoteit, Stefan Iglauer, Alireza Keshavarz

Summary: Hydrogen is expected to be a significant clean energy carrier, but the development of a hydrogen economy requires large-scale hydrogen storage. Different underground formations can be used for hydrogen storage, and wettability is an important factor in determining the containment security and storage capacity. This study investigates the use of a toxic dye, methyl orange, to alter the wettability of reservoirs for hydrogen geo-storage.

ENERGY & FUELS (2023)

Article Energy & Fuels

Experimental and Computational Fluid Dynamics Investigation of Mechanisms of Enhanced Oil Recovery via Nanoparticle-Surfactant Solutions

Nurudeen Yekeen, Ali Masoud Ali Elakkari, Javed Akbar Khan, Muhammad Ali, Ahmed Al-Yaseri, Hussein Hoteit

Summary: This study investigated the influence of multiwalled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs), silicon dioxide (SiO2), and aluminum oxide (Al2O3) nanoparticles on the enhanced oil recovery (EOR) properties of a conventional surfactant (sodium dodecyl benzene sulfonate, SDBS). The results showed that adding nanoparticles to SDBS solutions reduced the fingering and channeling effect, and increased the oil recovery factor. The study highlights the importance of the nanoparticle-surfactant EOR mechanisms.

ENERGY & FUELS (2023)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Experimental evaluation of surfactant-stabilized microemulsions for application in reservoir conformance improvement technology

Nilanjan Pal, Yara Alzahid, Abdulkareem M. AlSofi, Muhammad Ali, Xuan Zhang, Hussein Hoteit

Summary: This article discusses the use of microemulsion-assisted conformance improvement technology (ME-CIT) to decrease the water-to-oil ratio during production operations. Experimental validation is carried out to identify the phase behavior of surfactant-based microemulsions. The results show the presence of different Winsor phases at varying salinity levels and demonstrate the favorable flow attributes of microemulsions.

JOURNAL OF MOLECULAR LIQUIDS (2023)

Article Energy & Fuels

Experimental and Numerical Investigation of Spontaneous Imbibition in Multilayered Porous Systems

Jamal Alaamri, Viswasanthi Chandra, Mouadh Addassi, Hussein Hoteit

Summary: Spontaneous imbibition is a crucial mechanism in multiphase fluid flow in porous media, with applications in oil extraction and CO2 storage. Traditional Amott cell experiments do not accurately mimic reservoir conditions, limiting their effectiveness. This study introduces the use of micro-CT and dynamic pore-scale imaging to visualize and quantify rock-to-rock imbibition within heterogeneous porous media, providing a new approach to evaluate imbibition mechanisms across different formations.

ENERGY & FUELS (2023)

Article Energy & Fuels

Hydrogen, carbon dioxide, and methane adsorption potential on Jordanian organic-rich source rocks: Implications for underground H2 storage and retrieval

Amer Alanazi, Hussein Rasool Abid, Muhammad Usman, Muhammad Ali, Alireza Keshavarz, Volker Vahrenkamp, Stefan Iglauer, Hussein Hoteit

Summary: This study thoroughly investigated the storage efficiency of hydrogen (H2) and the selectivity of cushion gases (CO2 and CH4) in organic-rich carbonate-rich Jordanian source rock samples. Results showed that organic residuals significantly influenced H2 storage efficiency and CO2 demonstrated preferential behavior as a cushion gas compared to CH4. This study provides fundamental data for understanding H2 potential storage issues in an organic-rich rock formation and aids in the industrial implementation of an H2 supply chain.
Article Energy & Fuels

Experimental investigation on fluid/fluid and rock/fluid interactions in enhanced oil recovery by low salinity water flooding for carbonate reservoirs

Rohit Kumar Saw, Ajay Mandal

Summary: The low salinity water flooding (LSWF) technique is cost-effective and environmentally friendly, but its mechanisms are not yet clear. Recovery in LSWF depends on fluid/fluid and rock/fluid interactions. This study investigated both interactions and found different optimal conditions for improved oil recovery. Rock/fluid interaction showed an incremental recovery of 14%, while fluid/fluid interaction showed an incremental recovery of 7% over simple seawater injection. Results highlight the importance of considering both interactions and wettability alteration in LSWF design.
Article Energy & Fuels

Hydrogen physisorption in earth-minerals: Insights for hydrogen subsurface storage

Hesham Abdulelah, Alireza Keshavarz, Hussein Hoteit, Hussein Abid, Eirini Goudeli, Jonathan Ennis -King, Stefan Iglauer

Summary: This study investigated the physisorption behavior of hydrogen on various earth minerals. The results showed that illite had the highest adsorption capacity, and high-surface-area materials like clays or kerogen exhibited better adsorption performance. These findings are important for evaluating the feasibility of underground hydrogen storage.

JOURNAL OF ENERGY STORAGE (2023)

Article Energy & Fuels

Effect of methylene blue on wetting characteristics of quartz/H2/brine systems: Implication for hydrogen geological storage

Fatemah Alhammad, Mujahid Ali, Nurudeen Peter Yekeen, Muhammad Ali, Hussein Hoteit, Stefan Iglauer, Alireza Keshavarz

Summary: Hydrogen (H2) shows great potential as an environmentally friendly alternative to fossil fuels, but storing large quantities of it poses challenges due to its compressibility and volatility. Underground hydrogen storage (UHS) is the best option for large-scale storage, and rock wettability plays a crucial role in determining the storage capacity and security. This study explores the use of methylene blue (MB) as a wettability modifier to enhance H2 storage in quartz contaminated with stearic acid.

JOURNAL OF ENERGY STORAGE (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

First assessment of hydrogen/brine/Saudi basalt wettability: implications for hydrogen geological storage

Amer Alanazi, Ahmed Al-Yaseri, Mahmoud Mowafi, Mahmoud Leila, Hussein Hoteit

Summary: This study evaluates the wettability of Saudi basalt as a caprock for underground hydrogen storage. The results show that Saudi basalt is water-wet and does not achieve full wetting of hydrogen even at high pressures. However, it has the potential to store a large volume of H-2 and maintain its excellent storage capacity in deep, high-pressure regimes.

FRONTIERS IN EARTH SCIENCE (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

An experimental workflow to assess the applicability of microemulsions for conformance improvement in oil-bearing reservoir

Nilanjan Pal, Yara Alzahid, Abdulkareem M. Alsofi, Muhammad Ali, Nurudeen Yekeen, Hussein Hoteit

Summary: This paper presents a systematic approach for designing and formulating surfactant-stabilized microemulsions for enhanced oil recovery. The methodology involves extensive laboratory work and functional assessments, considering factors such as cost, environment, and reservoir considerations.

HELIYON (2023)

Article Energy & Fuels

Experimental and kinetic modelling studies on the gas hydrate inhibition effect of PVP K-90 in drilling fluids

Moumita Maiti, Ajoy Kumar Bhaumik, Ajay Mandal

Summary: Hydrate inhibitors are crucial for preventing hydrate growth and ensuring smooth drilling operations. Water-soluble polymers, such as polyvinyl pyrrolidone (PVP K-90), have been found effective in reducing hydrate formation rates. This study investigates the influence of PVP K-90 concentration on hydrate inhibition in predesigned drilling fluids containing methane, ethane, and propane.

GAS SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Enhanced oil recovery using a novel non-ionic surfactant synthesized from olive oil: Performance and synergistic effects

Rohit Kumar Saw, Pranali M. Rane, Dinesh Joshi, Shubham Prakash, Lavisha Jangid, Ajay Mandal

Summary: In recent years, there has been increasing interest in the application of natural surfactants in enhanced oil recovery (EOR) due to environmental concerns. This study introduces a novel non-ionic surfactant synthesized from olive oil and evaluates its properties. The synthesized surfactant showed effective emulsification, wettability modification, and efficient oil displacement. Additionally, the surfactant had a low critical micelle concentration, indicating its ability to reduce interfacial tension.

JOURNAL OF MOLECULAR LIQUIDS (2023)

Article Energy & Fuels

Preparation of surface modified nano-hydrotalcite and its applicaiton as a flow improver for crude oil

Yingna Du, Chen Huang, Wei Jiang, Qiangwei Yan, Yongfei Li, Gang Chen

Summary: In this study, anionic surfactants modified hydrotalcite was used as a flow improver for crude oil under low-temperature conditions. The modified hydrotalcite showed a significant viscosity reduction effect on crude oil. The mechanism of the modified hydrotalcite on viscosity and pour point of crude oil was explored through characterization and analysis of the modified hydrotalcite and oil samples.
Article Energy & Fuels

Effect of incorporated hybrid MIL-53(Al) and MWCNT into PES membrane for CO2/CH4 and CO2/N2 separation

Mohammad Saeid Rostami, Mohammad Mehdi Khodaei

Summary: In this study, a hybrid structure, MIL-53(Al)@MWCNT, was synthesized by combining MIL-53(Al) particles and -COOH functionalized multi-walled carbon nanotube (MWCNT). The hybrid structure was then embedded in a polyethersulfone (PES) polymer matrix to prepare a mixed matrix membrane (MMM) for CO2/CH4 and CO2/N2 separation. The addition of MWCNTs prevented MIL-53(Al) aggregation, improved membrane mechanical properties, and enhanced gas separation efficiency.
Article Energy & Fuels

Phase behaviour and physical properties of dimethyl ether (DME)/flue gas/ water/heavy oil systems under reservoir conditions

Yunlong Li, Desheng Huang, Xiaomeng Dong, Daoyong Yang

Summary: This study develops theoretical and experimental techniques to determine the phase behavior and physical properties of DME/flue gas/water/heavy oil systems. Eight constant composition expansion (CCE) tests are conducted to obtain new experimental data. A thermodynamic model is used to accurately predict saturation pressure and swelling factors, as well as the phase boundaries of N2/heavy oil systems and DME/CO2/heavy oil systems, with high accuracy.
Article Energy & Fuels

Comparison of CO2 absorption in DETA solution and [bmim]-[PF6] using thermodynamic and process modelling

Morteza Afkhamipour, Ebad Seifi, Arash Esmaeili, Mohammad Shamsi, Tohid N. Borhani

Summary: Non-conventional amines are being researched worldwide to overcome the limitations of traditional amines like MEA and MDEA. Adequate process and thermodynamic models are crucial for understanding the applicability and performance of these amines in CO2 absorption, but studies on process modeling for these amines are limited. This study used rate-based modeling and Deshmukh-Mather method to model CO2 absorption by DETA solution in a packed column, validated the model with experimental data, and conducted a sensitivity analysis of mass transfer correlations. The study also compared the CO2 absorption efficiency of DETA solution with an ionic solvent [bmim]-[PF6] and highlighted the importance of finding optimum operational parameters for maximum absorption efficiency.
Article Energy & Fuels

Interfacial tension of smart water and various crude oils

Arastoo Abdi, Mohamad Awarke, M. Reza Malayeri, Masoud Riazi

Summary: The utilization of smart water in EOR operations has gained attention, but more research is needed to understand the complex mechanisms involved. This study investigated the interfacial tension between smart water and crude oil, considering factors such as salt, pH, asphaltene type, and aged smart water. The results revealed that the hydration of ions in smart water plays a key role in its efficacy, with acidic and basic asphaltene acting as intrinsic surfactants. The pH also influenced the interfacial tension, and the aged smart water's interaction with crude oil depended on asphaltene type, salt, and salinity.
Article Energy & Fuels

Co-based metal-organic frameworks confined N-hydroxyphthalimide for enhancing aerobic desulfurization of diesel fuels

Dongao Zhu, Kun Zhu, Lixian Xu, Haiyan Huang, Jing He, Wenshuai Zhu, Huaming Li, Wei Jiang

Summary: In this study, cobalt-based metal-organic frameworks (Co-based MOFs) were used as supports and co-catalysts to confine the NHPI catalyst, solving the leaching issue. The NHPI@Co-MOF with carboxyl groups exhibited stronger acidity and facilitated the generation of active oxygen radicals O2•, resulting in enhanced catalytic activity. This research provides valuable insights into the selection of suitable organic linkers and broadens the research horizon of MOF hybrids in efficient oxidative desulfurization (ODS) applications.
Article Energy & Fuels

Influence of carbon-coated zero-valent iron-based nanoparticle concentration on continuous photosynthetic biogas upgrading

Edwin G. Hoyos, Gloria Amo-Duodu, U. Gulsum Kiral, Laura Vargas-Estrada, Raquel Lebrero, Rail Munoz

Summary: This study investigated the impact of carbon-coated zero-valent nanoparticle concentration on photosynthetic biogas upgrading. The addition of nanoparticles significantly increased microalgae productivity and enhanced nitrogen and phosphorus assimilation. The presence of nanoparticles also improved the quality of biomethane produced.
Article Energy & Fuels

Effect of aqueous phase recycling on iron evolution and environmental assessment during hydrothermal carbonization of dyeing sludge

Yao Xiao, Asma Leghari, Linfeng Liu, Fangchao Yu, Ming Gao, Lu Ding, Yu Yang, Xueli Chen, Xiaoyu Yan, Fuchen Wang

Summary: Iron is added as a flocculant in wastewater treatment and the hydrothermal carbonization (HTC) of sludge produces wastewater containing Fe. This study investigates the effect of aqueous phase (AP) recycling on hydrochar properties, iron evolution and environmental assessment during HTC of sludge. The results show that AP recycling process improves the dewatering performance of hydrochar and facilitates the recovery of Fe from the liquid phase.
Article Energy & Fuels

Investigation on the lower flammability limit and critical inhibition concentration of hydrogen under the influence of inhibitors

He Liang, Tao Wang, Zhenmin Luo, Jianliang Yu, Weizhai Yi, Fangming Cheng, Jingyu Zhao, Xingqing Yan, Jun Deng, Jihao Shi

Summary: This study investigated the influence of inhibitors (carbon dioxide, nitrogen, and heptafluoropropane) on the lower flammability limit of hydrogen and determined the critical inhibitory concentration needed for complete suppression. The impact of inhibitors on explosive characteristics was evaluated, and the inhibitory mechanism was analyzed with chemical kinetics. The results showed that with the increase of inhibitor quantity, the lower flammability limit of hydrogen also increased. The research findings can contribute to the safe utilization of hydrogen energy.
Article Energy & Fuels

Phosphotungstic acid supported on Zr-SBA-15 as an efficient catalyst for one-pot conversion of furfural to ?-valerolactone

Zonghui Liu, Zhongze Zhang, Yali Zhou, Ziling Wang, Mingyang Du, Zhe Wen, Bing Yan, Qingxiang Ma, Na Liu, Bing Xue

Summary: In this study, high-performance solid catalysts based on phosphotungstic acid (HPW) supported on Zr-SBA-15 were synthesized and evaluated for the one-pot conversion of furfural (FUR) to γ-valerolactone (GVL). The catalysts were characterized using various techniques, and the ratio of HPW and Zr was found to significantly affect the selectivity of GVL. The HPW/Zr-SBA-15 (2-4-15) catalyst exhibited the highest GVL yield (83%) under optimized reaction conditions, and it was determined that a balance between Bronsted acid sites (BAS) and Lewis acid sites (LAS) was crucial for achieving higher catalytic performance. The reaction parameters and catalyst stability were also investigated.
Article Energy & Fuels

Experimental study of droplet vaporization for conventional and renewable transportation fuels: Effects of physical properties and chemical composition

Michael Stoehr, Stephan Ruoff, Bastian Rauch, Wolfgang Meier, Patrick Le Clercq

Summary: As part of the global energy transition, an experimental study was conducted to understand the effects of different fuel properties on droplet vaporization for various conventional and alternative fuels. The study utilized a flow channel to measure the evolution of droplet diameters over time and distance. The results revealed the temperature-dependent effects of physical properties, such as boiling point, liquid density, and enthalpy of vaporization, and showed the complex interactions of preferential vaporization and temperature-dependent influences of physical properties for multi-component fuels.
Article Energy & Fuels

An experimental and modeling study on the oxidation of ammonia-methanol mixtures in a jet stirred reactor

Yuan Zhuang, Ruikang Wu, Xinyan Wang, Rui Zhai, Changyong Gao

Summary: Through experimental validation and optimization of the chemical kinetic model, it was found that methanol can accelerate the oxidation reaction of ammonia, and methanol can be rapidly oxidized at high concentration. HO2 was found to generate a significant amount of OH radicals, facilitating the oxidation of methanol and ammonia. Rating: 7.5/10.
Article Energy & Fuels

Improving the biodiesel combustion and emission characteristics in the lean pre-vaporized premixed system using diethyl ether as a fuel additive

Radwan M. EL-Zohairy, Ahmed S. Attia, A. S. Huzayyin, Ahmed I. EL-Seesy

Summary: This paper presents a lab-scale experimental study on the impact of diethyl ether (DEE) as an additive to waste cooking oil biodiesel with Jet A-1 on combustion and emission features of a swirl-stabilized premixed flame. The addition of DEE to biodiesel significantly affects the flame temperature distribution and emissions. The W20D20 blend of DEE, biodiesel, and Jet A-1 shows similar flame temperature distribution to Jet A-1 and significantly reduces UHC, CO, and NOx emissions compared to Jet A-1.
Article Energy & Fuels

Condensation characteristics of ammonia vapor during supersonic separation: A novel approach to ammonia-hydrogen separation

Jiang Bian, Ziyuan Zhao, Yang Liu, Ran Cheng, Xuerui Zang, Xuewen Cao

Summary: This study presents a novel method for ammonia separation using supersonic flow and develops a mathematical model to investigate the condensation phenomenon. The results demonstrate that the L-P nucleation model accurately characterizes the nucleation process of ammonia at low temperatures. Numerical simulations also show that increasing pressure and concentration can enhance ammonia condensation efficiency.
Article Energy & Fuels

Multivariate time series prediction for CO2 concentration and flowrate of flue gas from biomass-fired power plants

Shiyuan Pan, Xiaodan Shi, Beibei Dong, Jan Skvaril, Haoran Zhang, Yongtu Liang, Hailong Li

Summary: Integrating CO2 capture with biomass-fired combined heat and power (bio-CHP) plants is a promising method for achieving negative emissions. This study develops a reliable data-driven model based on the Transformer architecture to predict the flowrate and CO2 concentration of flue gas in real time. The model validation shows high prediction accuracy, and the potential impact of meteorological parameters on model accuracy is assessed. The results demonstrate that the Transformer model outperforms other models and using near-infrared spectral data as input features improves the prediction accuracy.