4.6 Article

Digital fisheries data in the Internet age: Emerging tools for research and monitoring using online data in recreational fisheries

Journal

FISH AND FISHERIES
Volume 23, Issue 4, Pages 926-940

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/faf.12663

Keywords

catch-and-release; culturomics; fisheries management; iEcology; recreational fishing; social media

Categories

Funding

  1. German Federal Ministry of Education and Research [01LC1826D, 02WRM046A]
  2. 'Juan de la Cierva Incorporacion' research fellowship - Spanish Ministry of Science and Innovation [IJC2018-035389-I]
  3. Spanish government through the 'Severo Ochoa Centre of Excellence' [CEX2019-000928-S]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Recreational fisheries provide important ecosystem services to marine and freshwater ecosystems, and online data have the potential to contribute to their research, monitoring, and management. Online platforms, such as social media, allow recreational fishers to share their experiences, providing valuable information about their activities and sentiments. Despite challenges, fisheries managers are expected to increasingly utilize online fisheries data to supplement traditional methods, and scientists are encouraged to develop and validate digital tools for fisheries research.
Recreational fisheries are diverse in scale, scope, and participation worldwide, constituting an important ecosystem service of marine and freshwater ecosystems. Management of these socio-ecological systems is challenged by monitoring gaps, stemming from difficulties engaging with participants, biased sampling, and insufficient resources to conduct biological or social surveys of fish and human populations. In the Internet age, online data have great potential to make a meaningful contribution to recreational fisheries research, monitoring, and management. Recreational fishers in some countries increasingly use social and other digital media to share their experiences with followers, with most data freely available to web scrapers that compile databases of text (e.g. tweets, status updates, comments), photos, videos and other media that contain information about spatiotemporal activity, sentiments towards catches/experiences, targeted and bycatch species, effort levels, and more. Although the future of recreational fisheries research, monitoring and management will likely involve more digital scraping, uptake is only just beginning and there are several challenges including tool availability/accessibility, sampling biases, and making findings relevant and usable to practitioners. Despite these challenges, we envision fisheries managers will increasingly turn towards online sources of fisheries data to supplement conventional methods. We challenge scientists to work towards continued method development and validation of various digital fisheries data tools and emphasize how biases from the online behaviour of users may complicate interpretations of these data for fisheries management.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Ecology

Spatial-temporal patterns of Permit (Trachinotus falcatus) habitat residency in the Florida Keys, USA

Jacob W. Brownscombe, Lucas P. Griffin, Danielle Morley, Alejandro Acosta, Ross Boucek, Aaron J. Adams, Andy J. Danylchuk, Steven J. Cooke

Summary: The study found that Permit mainly reside in artificial reefs in the Caribbean Sea region, with their residency peaking in the spring and summer months. The high residency of Permit at important spawning sites indicates vulnerability to fishing pressure and inadequate current regulations. Additionally, seagrass flats in close proximity to spawning locations are important food sources for Permit during the extensive spawning season.

ENVIRONMENTAL BIOLOGY OF FISHES (2023)

Article Ecology

Awareness and use of the Society for Ecological Restoration's International Principles and Standards for the Practice of Ecological Restoration in Canada

Sonia A. Voicescu, John-Francis Lane, Steven J. Cooke, Eric Higgs, Alina C. Fisher, Line Rochefort, Nancy Shackelford, Stephen Murphy

Summary: This study found that the awareness and use of the "International Principles and Standards for the Practice of Ecological Restoration" among restoration practitioners was lower than expected. Some reasons for this included low awareness of the document and concerns about its structure, added value, and suitability. Further analysis and improvements are needed to address this disconnection.

RESTORATION ECOLOGY (2023)

Review Fisheries

Enhancing our understanding of fish movement ecology through interdisciplinary and cross-boundary research

Pieterjan Verhelst, Rein Brys, Steven J. Cooke, Ine Pauwels, Mehis Rohtla, Jan Reubens

Summary: Animals need to move between different habitats to complete their life cycle, but anthropogenic activities and infrastructure have a negative impact on animal movement, especially in aquatic habitats. Understanding fish movement is crucial for understanding how human activities affect the spatial ecology of fish, which can inform management strategies. Various methods, such as observation, tracking, and DNA analysis, can be used to study fish movement, and combining these methods can improve management efforts. It is important for different jurisdictions to collaborate in managing fish that move across boundaries. Interdisciplinary data analysis can provide a holistic understanding of fish movement and help in selecting cost-effective and evidence-based management actions that balance the needs of fish and human activities.

REVIEWS IN FISH BIOLOGY AND FISHERIES (2023)

Article Fisheries

Tensile strength and knot security of five suture materials exposed to natural summer conditions of a temperate lake

Connor H. Reid, Steven J. Cooke

Summary: This study investigated the degradation of different absorbable suture materials under biologically relevant conditions for temperate freshwater fish. The results showed that naturally derived collagen-based sutures experienced major decreases in tensile strength within 2 weeks of submersion but maintained high knot security throughout the study period, while synthetic sutures showed little to no degradation after 8 weeks. The findings have important implications for fish welfare considerations such as suture retention, wound healing, inflammation, and infection under natural conditions.

JOURNAL OF AQUATIC ANIMAL HEALTH (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Confronting a post-pandemic new-normal-threats and opportunities to trust-based relationships in natural resource science and management

A. M. Muir, J. R. Bernhardt, N. W. Boucher, C. Cvitanovic, J. M. Dettmers, M. Gaden, J. L. M. Hinderer, B. Locke, K. F. Robinson, M. J. Siefkes, N. Young, S. J. Cooke

Summary: Natural resource governance is complex due to its integration with socio-ecological systems. The COVID-19 pandemic has altered working arrangements, potentially impacting trust-based social networks crucial for resource management and transboundary governance. Our study on trust relationships in the Laurentian Great Lakes found that virtual engagement was effective in maintaining established relationships, but in-person engagement was deemed more effective for building and maintaining trust.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Ecosystem-based management outperforms species-focused stocking for enhancing fish populations

Johannes Radinger, Sven Matern, Thomas Klefoth, Christian Wolter, Fritz Feldhege, Christopher T. Monk, Robert Arlinghaus

Summary: Ecosystem-based management is costly, but its effectiveness compared to traditional species-focused alternatives in conservation is uncertain. This study conducted large-scale experiments in fish conservation, finding that adding coarse woody habitats did not enhance fish abundance, while creating shallow water habitat consistently improved the abundance of juvenile fish. Species-focused fish stocking as an alternative approach completely failed. The findings question the efficacy of species-focused conservation actions in aquatic ecosystems, and recommend ecosystem-based habitat management.

SCIENCE (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

People need freshwater biodiversity

Abigail J. Lynch, Steven J. Cooke, Angela H. Arthington, Claudio Baigun, Lisa Bossenbroek, Chris Dickens, Ian Harrison, Ismael Kimirei, Simone D. Langhans, Karen J. Murchie, Julian D. Olden, Steve J. Ormerod, Margaret Owuor, Rajeev Raghavan, Michael J. Samways, Rafaela Schinegger, Subodh Sharma, Ram-Devi Tachamo-Shah, David Tickner, Denis Tweddle, Nathan Young, Sonja C. Jaehnig

Summary: Freshwater biodiversity provides a wide range of services to humans, including food, health and genetic resources, material goods, culture, education and science, recreation, catchment integrity, climate regulation, water purification, and nutrient cycling. Protecting and conserving freshwater biodiversity, as well as increasing human appreciation for it, can contribute to human well-being and a sustainable future.

WILEY INTERDISCIPLINARY REVIEWS-WATER (2023)

Article Fisheries

Corroborating otolith age using oxygen isotopes and comparing outcomes to scale age: Consequences for estimation of growth and reference points in northern pike (Esox lucius)

Timo D. Rittweg, Clive Trueman, Elias Ehrlich, Michael Wiedenbeck, Robert Arlinghaus

Summary: Accurate age estimates are crucial for assessing fish life histories and providing management advice. This study validated age estimates for northern pike using oxygen isotopes and found that estimates from scales significantly underestimated the age of older fish. This underestimation has implications for population models and management regulations, leading to conservative management and lost yield.

FISHERIES MANAGEMENT AND ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Fisheries

Explaining attitudes to management actions and beliefs about other user groups and conservation with angler characteristics: A case study in a coastal pike (Esox lucius) fishery in the southern Baltic Sea, Germany

Catherine Slaton, Dieter Koemle, Max Birdsong, Robert Arlinghaus

Summary: Understanding the attitudes of recreational anglers is crucial for fisheries management. In this study, we examined the relationship between angler characteristics (specialization, catch orientation, place attachment, and demographics) and attitudes towards conservation and management of northern pike in Germany. Our results showed that angler specialization, catch orientations, place attachment, and demographics were consistent predictors of attitudes towards management and conservation. Addressing conflicts in the pike fishery can be achieved by targeting specialized and release-oriented anglers who have higher conflict sensitivity and are more willing to accept regulations.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2023)

Review Ecology

Positioning aquatic animals with acoustic transmitters

Robert J. Lennox, Kim Aarestrup, Josep Alos, Robert Arlinghaus, Eneko Aspillaga, Michael G. Bertram, Kim Birnie-Gauvin, Tomas Brodin, Steven J. Cooke, Lotte S. Dahlmo, Felicie Dhellemmes, Karl o. Gjelland, Gustav Hellstrom, Henry Hershey, Christopher Holbrook, Thomas Klefoth, Susan Lowerre-Barbieri, Christopher T. Monk, Cecilie Iden Nilsen, Ine Pauwels, Renanel Pickholtz, Marie Prchalova, Jan Reubens, Milan Riha, David Villegas-Rios, Knut Wiik Vollset, Samuel Westrelin, Henrik Baktoft

Summary: This paper provides an overview of the method of geolocating aquatic animals with acoustic tags, including considerations for designing receiver arrays, testing performance, synchronizing receiver clocks, and calculating positions from detection data. Common positioning algorithms, including open-source solvers and manufacturer-provided "black-box" methods, are also introduced. It is the first comprehensive overview of methods and considerations for designing and implementing better positioning studies in aquatic systems, aiming to support users and encourage further advances in knowledge.

METHODS IN ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

On the lack of scientific evidence for the Ontario cormorant cull and other cormorant management actions: a response to Dorr et al. (2022)

James P. Ludwig, Steven J. Cooke, Keith A. Hobson

AVIAN CONSERVATION AND ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Fisheries

Prospects of fish scale and fin samples usage for nonlethal monitoring of metal contamination: a study on five fish species from the Danube River

Katarina Jovicic, Sasa Jankovic, Dragica M. Nikolic, Vesna Dikanovic, Stefan Skoric, Jasmina Krpo-Cetkovic, Ivan Jaric

Summary: Nonlethal indicators such as fish scales and fin clips can be used to monitor water quality and contamination. This study found that scales and fins can accumulate high concentrations of metals and trace elements, making them potential indicators of muscle tissue contamination. The results also showed that fin clipping does not harm fish growth or survival.

KNOWLEDGE AND MANAGEMENT OF AQUATIC ECOSYSTEMS (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

On the troubling use of plastic 'habitat structures for fish in freshwater ecosystems - or - when restoration is just littering '

S. J. Cooke, J. C. Vermaire, A. E. Kirkwood

Summary: The use of plastic structures in freshwater ecosystems to enhance fish habitat or restore freshwater systems has become popular, but there are concerns about ecological benefits and potential pollution from plastic degradation. The evidence base for using plastic materials in these activities is limited, and there is a need to consider the full life cycle of restoration and potential environmental consequences. Natural materials should be embraced for habitat restoration, and stakeholders should have a say in material choices. Based on current evidence, the use of plastic for habitat enhancement or restoration in freshwater systems is littering.

FACETS (2023)

Article Communication

Exploring the hidden connections between information channel use and pro-environmental behavior among recreational anglers of the shore-based shark fishery in Florida, United States

Jessika D. Guay, Jill L. Brooks, Jacqueline M. Chapman, Hannah Medd, Steven J. Cooke, Vivian M. Nguyen

Summary: Shore-based shark fishing in Florida attracts a wide variety of anglers, and concerns about proper handling methods of caught fish arise due to the threat of extinction for many shark species. This study examined the information channels used by anglers to obtain knowledge about fishing skills and best practices for catch-and-release. The findings suggest that interpersonal communications and the internet are the main sources of information for anglers, and support for fisheries management is associated with pro-environmental behavior.

FRONTIERS IN COMMUNICATION (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

How involvement drives decision rules behind stated preferences for recreational-fisheries management

Dieter Koemle, Birgit Gassler, Gerard Kyle, Juergen Meyerhoff, Robert Arlinghaus

Summary: This paper examines the relationship between involvement in recreational fishing and decision rules, specifically regret-minimizing versus utility-maximizing behavior. The study finds that individuals who are more involved in fishing are more likely to exhibit regret-minimizing behavior. Factors such as behavioral commitment and psychological involvement are significantly related to the decision rule, while skills, attitudes, and place attachment do not impact the decision rules followed. The study also demonstrates that welfare estimates of policy changes are influenced by the decision rule, and assuming regret-minimizing behavior results in lower estimates compared to assuming utility maximization behavior.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

No Data Available