4.2 Article

Managing disaster risk associated with critical infrastructure systems: a system-level conceptual framework for research and policy guidance

Journal

CIVIL ENGINEERING AND ENVIRONMENTAL SYSTEMS
Volume 39, Issue 2, Pages 123-143

Publisher

TAYLOR & FRANCIS LTD
DOI: 10.1080/10286608.2022.2067848

Keywords

Infrastructure systems; electric power; water; societal impact; adaptations

Funding

  1. NSF [CMMI-1735483]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This paper presents a new conceptual framework for understanding the disaster risk of critical infrastructure systems in terms of societal impacts. It discusses each component of the framework and possible uses, such as guiding research and stimulating discussions on resilience within utility and emergency management organizations and the larger community.
This paper presents a new conceptual framework of the disaster risk of critical infrastructure systems in terms of societal impacts. Much research on infrastructure reliability focuses on specific issues related to the technical system or human coping. Focusing on the end goal of infrastructure services - societal functioning - this framework offers a new way to understand how those more focused research areas connect and the current thinking in each. Following an overview of the framework, each component is discussed in turn, including the initial buildout of physical systems; event occurrence; service interruptions; service provider response; user adaptations to preserve or create needed services; and the ending deficit in societal function. Possible uses of the framework include catalysing and guiding a systematic research agenda that could ultimately lead to a computational framework and stimulating discussion on resilience within utility and emergency management organisations and the larger community.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.2
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Perceived attributes of hurricane-related retrofits and their effect on household adoption

Yilin Zou, Alexia Stock, Rachel Davidson, Linda Nozick, Joseph Trainor, Jamie Kruse

NATURAL HAZARDS (2020)

Article Engineering, Civil

Multihazard Scenarios for Regional Seismic Risk Assessment of Spatially Distributed Infrastructure

Nafiseh Soleimani, Rachel A. Davidson, Craig Davis, Thomas D. O'Rourke, Linda K. Nozick

Summary: This study introduces a method for creating an ensemble of multihazard scenarios for efficient evaluation of spatially distributed infrastructure. The combination of a small set of multihazard scenarios with computed weights accurately represents the probabilistic hazard, allowing for further reduction in scenario quantity based on desired tradeoff between acceptable errors and computational efficiency.

JOURNAL OF INFRASTRUCTURE SYSTEMS (2021)

Article Business, Finance

Dynamic modeling of public and private decision-making for hurricane risk management including insurance, acquisition, and mitigation policy

Cen Guo, Linda Nozick, Jamie Kruse, Meghan Millea, Rachel Davidson, Joseph Trainor

Summary: The developed computational framework supports government decision-making in hurricane risk management by modeling regional natural catastrophe losses dynamically and stochastically. It includes various interacting models to simulate hazard events, estimate losses, capture homeowners' behaviors, and represent an insurance market. The framework can optimize decision-making to minimize hurricane losses by coordinating insurance, retrofit, and acquisition policies effectively.

RISK MANAGEMENT AND INSURANCE REVIEW (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

Evaluation of Hurricane Evacuation Order Plans: Hurricane Florence Case Study

Kun Yang, Rachel A. Davidson, Brian Blanton, Brian Colle, Randall Kolar, Linda K. Nozick, Tricia Wachtendorf, Nicholas Leonardo, Humberto Vergara, Kendra Dresback

Summary: This paper introduces an approach to evaluate the performance of hurricane evacuation plans and demonstrates its application in the case of Hurricane Florence in North Carolina. The results suggest that the actual evacuation was effective and that the integrated scenario-based evacuation (ISE) decision support tool could have further improved the evacuation performance.

NATURAL HAZARDS REVIEW (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

Household Adaptations to Infrastructure System Service Interruptions

Abderrahmane Abbou, Rachel A. Davidson, James Kendra, V. Nuno Martins, Bradley Ewing, Linda K. Nozick, Zachary Cox, Maggie Leon-Corwin

Summary: This study investigates household adaptations during electric power and water service interruptions based on survey data from Los Angeles County, California. The research explores the prevalence of different adaptations, the variations in adaptation implementation based on infrastructure type, outage duration, and service usage, the association between household characteristics and adaptations, and the occurrence patterns of different adaptations. The findings provide insights into how households respond to disruptions in critical infrastructure systems.

JOURNAL OF INFRASTRUCTURE SYSTEMS (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Household impacts of interruption to electric power and water services

Alexia Stock, Rachel A. Davidson, James Kendra, V. Nuno Martins, Bradley Ewing, Linda K. Nozick, Kate Starbird, Maggie Leon-Corwin

Summary: This study investigates the societal impacts of infrastructure system disruptions on households. The results show that the impact on households increases nonlinearly with the duration of the disruption, and electric power disruptions have a greater impact than water supply disruptions. Unhappiness is better able to distinguish the effects of shorter-duration disruptions compared to willingness to pay. Additionally, factors such as the use of medical devices, worry about emergencies, and lower level of preparation are associated with increased household impact. Financial, time/effort, health, and stress concerns significantly influence the level of unhappiness.

NATURAL HAZARDS (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Searching for signal and borrowing wi-fi: Understanding disaster-related adaptations to telecommunications disruptions through social media

Hannah Van Wyk, Osiris Cruz-Antonio, Diana Quintero-Perez, Sayra Damian Garcia, Rachel Davidson, James Kendra, Kate Starbird

Summary: Disaster events can expose the vulnerability of telecommunications infrastructure, leading to prolonged service disruptions. Understanding how people adapt to these disruptions can provide valuable insights for disaster preparation and response. In this research, the authors used Twitter data to examine how people in Puerto Rico adapted to extended telecommunications disruptions after Hurricane Maria in September 2017. They applied machine learning techniques to detect adaptations to telecommunication disruptions in the Twitter dataset, and used qualitative coding to analyze the different ways people adapted to disruptions in cell service, Wi-Fi access, and electricity for communication devices. The findings highlight the willingness of affected individuals to go to great lengths to access telecommunication services, as well as shifts in reliance on existing infrastructure.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DISASTER RISK REDUCTION (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Effects of Roof Shape and Roof Pitch on Extreme Wind Fragility for Roof Sheathing

Shuochuan Meng, Caroline J. J. Williams, Rachel A. A. Davidson, Ertugrul Taciroglu

Summary: Wind fragility curves were developed to investigate the effects of roof shape and pitch on roof sheathing performance. It was found that complex roof shapes are more susceptible to damage for gable roofs, while roof shape has minimal effect on hip roofs. Additionally, roof pitch has a greater impact on gable roofs than on hip roofs, with higher pitch angles leading to lower probability of roof sheathing failure.

JOURNAL OF STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Single-family housing inventory projection method for natural hazard risk modeling applications

Caroline J. Williams, Rachel A. Davidson, Linda K. Nozick, Meghan Millea, Jamie L. Kruse, Joseph E. Trainor

Summary: Today's regional natural hazards loss models seldom consider changes in the built environment over time, leading to underestimated natural hazard risk assessments. Available models that account for changes in the built environment lack a sufficiently granular spatiotemporal scale for regional natural hazards loss modeling. This study introduces the Housing Inventory Projection (HIP) method, which includes modules for estimating the annual housing units per county and the likely location of future single-family housing units. A case study in North Carolina estimates the number of single-family houses per 1 km(2) grid cell from 2020 to 2049, revealing increased construction in flood-prone areas.

NATURAL HAZARDS (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

Household Adaptations to and Impacts from Electric Power and Water Outages in the Texas 2021 Winter Storm

Nafiseh Soleimani, Rachel A. Davidson, James Kendra, Bradley Ewing, Linda K. Nozick

Summary: This paper investigates the household adaptations and reactions to the power and water supply interruptions caused by a winter storm in Texas. The study finds that almost everyone implemented at least one adaptation and the most common adaptations included using candles, flashlights, and/or lanterns, charging cell phones in the car, purchasing bottled water, and delaying or reducing consumption. The level of unhappiness varied with the duration of the outages and household characteristics, and financial, time/effort, health, and stress concerns influenced the extent of unhappiness.

NATURAL HAZARDS REVIEW (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Typology of household adaptations to infrastructure system service interruptions

Rachel A. Davidson, James Kendra, Kate Starbird, Linda K. Nozick, Bradley Ewing, Maggie Leon-Corwin

Summary: This paper introduces a typology of Household Adaptations to Service Interruption (HASI), which provides a systematic way to enumerate, organize, and describe adaptations when infrastructure system services are interrupted. The typology includes main groupings and additional adaptation characteristics that help understand the implementation and effects of adaptations. It offers a consistent vocabulary to discuss adaptations, identifies new forms of adaptations, and suggests future research questions.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DISASTER RISK REDUCTION (2023)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

A machine learning approach for predicting hurricane evacuee destination location using smartphone location data

Prosper K. Anyidoho, Xinglong Ju, Rachel A. Davidson, Linda K. Nozick

Summary: Evacuation destination choice modeling is crucial for evacuation planning, but it has not received enough attention. This study presents a new approach using smartphone location data to identify evacuees and determine their destinations and timing, and develops a machine learning model that predicts the number of evacuees between different areas. The model outperforms traditional gravity models, and hurricane characteristics are found to be important in evacuee destination choices.

COMPUTATIONAL URBAN SCIENCE (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Regional county-level housing inventory predictions and the effects on hurricane risk

Caroline J. Williams, Rachel A. Davidson, Linda K. Nozick, Joseph E. Trainor, Meghan Millea, Jamie L. Kruse

Summary: This study uses an LSTM neural network model to forecast the number of housing units in the southeastern United States for the next 20 years, and the results show that the model performs well in predicting. The LSTM outperforms other models. These projections of housing units can help evaluate changes in losses and other impacts caused by hurricanes.

NATURAL HAZARDS AND EARTH SYSTEM SCIENCES (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

Hurricane evacuation beliefs and behaviour of inland vs. coastal populations

Emily Mongold, Rachel A. Davidson, Jennifer Trivedi, Sarah DeYoung, Tricia Wachtendorf, Prosper Anyidoho

Summary: The study found that coastal populations are more likely to evacuate during hurricanes compared to inland populations. The difference in evacuation rates cannot be fully explained by geographic factors and receipt of evacuation orders. Risk perception may also contribute to the difference in evacuation behavior between inland and coastal populations.

ENVIRONMENTAL HAZARDS-HUMAN AND POLICY DIMENSIONS (2021)

No Data Available