4.7 Review

Marriage of membrane filtration and sulfate radical-advanced oxidation processes (SR-AOPs) for water purification: Current developments, challenges and prospects

Journal

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL
Volume 433, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCIENCE SA
DOI: 10.1016/j.cej.2021.133802

Keywords

Membrane; Peroxymonosulfate; Peroxydisulfate; Filtration; Wastewater treatment; Membrane fouling

Funding

  1. National Natural Science Foundation of China [52070133]
  2. Chengdu Science and Technology Project [2021-YF05-00892-SN]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The integration of membrane filtration (MF) and sulfate radical-advanced oxidation processes (SR-AOPs) has gained extensive attention in environmental remediation for its simultaneous degradation and filtration of pollutants in wastewater. This review comprehensively summarizes the classification, preparation methods, and properties of different types of membrane-based materials and filtration devices, as well as the mechanisms, technical challenges, and prospects of the collaborative mixing process.
Integration of membrane filtration (MF) and sulfate radical-advanced oxidation processes (SR-AOPs) has progressively attracted extensive attention for environmental remediation because of simultaneous degradation and filtration of pollutants in wastewater. Current development of the integration of MF and SR-AOPs can be divided into three main categories: (1) peroxymonosulfate (PMS)/peroxydisulfate (PDS) are activated by membrane materials to achieve the purpose of synergistic oxidation-filtration process; (2) removal of contaminants was achieved by filtering through the membrane, and then adding PMS/PDS to regenerate the membrane; (3) the membrane can be directly used as an oxidant-catalyst/water contactor to promote SR-AOPs. On this basis, this review comprehensively summarizes the classification, preparation methods and properties of different types of membrane-based materials and filtration devices. In addition, the antifouling effect and self-purification regeneration ability of different SR-AOPs systems on the membrane are highlighted. Moreover, the main mechanisms including the analysis of active sites, the generation of free radicals, and the theoretical calculations in integration of MF and SR-AOPs are defragmented and discussed. Finally, the technical challenges of coupling technology in wastewater treatment are discussed, and the development and application prospects of the collaborative mixing process are prospected.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Engineering, Environmental

Removal of Bisphenol A via peroxymonosulfate activation over graphite carbon nitride supported NiCx nanoclusters catalyst: Synergistic oxidation of high-valent nickel-oxo species and singlet oxygen

Junjie You, Junyi Li, Heng Zhang, Mengfan Luo, Bo Xing, Yi Ren, Yang Liu, Zhaokun Xiong, Chuanshu He, Bo Lai

Summary: In this study, a g-C3N4 supported NiCx nanoclusters catalyst (NiCx-CN) was developed and its capability in activating peroxymonosulfate (PMS) was investigated. The mechanism investigation revealed that singlet oxygen (1O2) formed during the catalytic process had limited contribution to BPA elimination. Interestingly, high-valent nickel-oxo species (Ni&+=O) generated after the interaction of NiCx-CN and PMS were identified as the dominant reactive oxygen species (ROS). The prepared NiCx-CN also exhibited excellent resistance to interference from inorganic anions. Three BPA degradation routes were proposed based on the transformation intermediates. This study provides a new approach for the efficient degradation of organic pollutants using heterogeneous Ni-based catalysts through PMS activation via a nonradical mechanism.

JOURNAL OF HAZARDOUS MATERIALS (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Vanadium as co-catalyst for exceptionally boosted Fenton and Fenton-like oxidation: Vanadium species mediated direct and indirect routes

Feng Cheng, Yongfei Tong, Yang Liu, Yue Yuan, Zhiqiang Chen, Juan Liang, Yongli Zhang, Peng Zhou, Xiaoguang Duan, Bo Lai

Summary: In this study, vanadium powder (V) was used as a cocatalyst to enhance the Fenton-like system, which could rapidly produce hydroxyl radicals and completely oxidize chloramphenicol with high stability. The low-valent vanadium sites on the surface played a crucial role in direct H2O2 activation and Fe(III) reduction induced by H2O2, leading to the production of hydroxyl radicals. The self-cleaning effect of vanadium under acidic conditions maintained reactive sites for sustainable electron donation and long-lasting enhanced Fenton oxidation.

JOURNAL OF HAZARDOUS MATERIALS (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Identifying the evolution of primary oxidation mechanisms and pollutant degradation routes in the electro-cocatalytic Fenton-like systems

Xianhu Long, Hongle Shi, Rongfu Huang, Lingyun Gu, Yang Liu, Chuan-shu He, Ye Du, Zhaokun Xiong, Wen Liu, Bo Lai

Summary: In this study, sustainable Fe(III)/Fe(II) cycles in different inorganic peroxides activation systems were accelerated by using electro-catalysis (EC) as the electron donor. The electro-cocatalytic Fenton-like systems exhibited excellent degradation efficiency of sulfamethoxazole (SMX). Various reactive oxygen species (ROS) including hydroxyl radical ((OH)-O-center dot), singlet oxygen (O-1(2)), and sulfate radical (SO4 center dot-) were produced in EC/Fe(III)/PMS system, contributing to 38%, 37%, and 24% respectively. The dominant ROS in EC/Fe(III)/ PDS and EC/Fe(III)/HP processes was (OH)-O-center dot. The study provides a strong basis for constructing suitable systems to achieve different treatment requirements.

JOURNAL OF HAZARDOUS MATERIALS (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Enhancing zerovalent iron-based Fenton-like chemistry by copper sulfide: Insight into the active sites for sustainable Fe(II) supply

Can Feng, Heng Zhang, Yi Ren, Mengfan Luo, Siying Yu, Zhaokun Xiong, Yang Liu, Peng Zhou, Bo Lai

Summary: Copper sulfide was found to enhance the degradation of organic pollutants in the zerovalent iron/hydrogen peroxide system by accelerating the dissolution of iron and the cycling of Fe(III)/Fe(II). The introduction of copper sulfide resulted in a sustainable and high-efficiency iron-based oxidation system for the removal of organic contaminants. This study provides insights into the promotion effects of copper sulfide on zerovalent iron dissolution and Fe(III)/Fe(II) cycling in zerovalent iron-based Fenton-like processes.

JOURNAL OF HAZARDOUS MATERIALS (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Peracetic acid activation via the synergic effect of Co and Fe in CoFe-LDH for efficient degradation of pharmaceuticals in hospital wastewater

Zhi-Hui Xie, Chuan-Shu He, Yong-Li He, Shu-Run Yang, Si-Ying Yu, Zhaokun Xiong, Ye Du, Yang Liu, Zhi-Cheng Pan, Gang Yao, Bo Lai

Summary: In this study, Co2Fe1-LDH was found to have excellent PAA activation ability and efficiently degrade various pharmaceuticals, with a removal efficiency ranging from 82.3% to 100%. It was discovered that the organic radical (R-O center dot) was the primary reactive oxygen species responsible for contaminants degradation. The Co2Fe1-LDH/PAA system showed the ability to resist the influence of water matrix and effectively remove pollutants in actual hospital wastewater, while also improving the biodegradability of the wastewater.

WATER RESEARCH (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Adsorption behavior of antibiotics with different structures onto vivianite in the presence of dissolved organic matter during the phosphorus recovery process

Wang-Xiao Jia, Wen-Qiang Li, Zhi-Hui Xie, Pu-Can Guo, Zhi-Long Ye, Zhao-Kun Xiong, Chuan-Shu He, Bo Lai

Summary: This study analyzed the interaction relationship and mechanism between vivianite, antibiotics, and dissolved organic matters. It was found that fulvic acid greatly enhanced the adsorption of antibiotics onto vivianite, while the adsorption of different antibiotics by vivianite was significantly related to the molecular weight of dissolved organic matter. The results of this study will expand our knowledge about the fate of antibiotics and phosphorus recovery from urban sewage and livestock wastewater in the formation of vivianite.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2023)

Review Engineering, Environmental

Review of characteristics, generation pathways and detection methods of singlet oxygen generated in advanced oxidation processes (AOPs)

Zhi-Hui Xie, Chuan-Shu He, Dan-Ni Pei, Yudan Dong, Shu-Run Yang, Zhaokun Xiong, Peng Zhou, Zhi-Cheng Pan, Gang Yao, Bo Lai

Summary: This review comprehensively summarizes the characteristics, generation pathways, detection methods, and application of singlet oxygen (1O2) in wastewater treatment. It provides detailed information on the characteristics, generation pathways, and detection methods of 1O2, and identifies the current deficiencies in its mechanism exploration and practical application. It is expected to inspire further research on 1O2-mediated advanced oxidation processes (AOPs).

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

In Situ Regulation of MnO2 Structural Characteristics by Oxyanions to Boost Permanganate Autocatalysis for Phenol Removal

Mengfan Luo, Heng Zhang, Yi Ren, Hongyu Zhou, Peng Zhou, Chuan-Shu He, Zhaokun Xiong, Ye Du, Yang Liu, Bo Lai

Summary: Oxyanions, natural constituents in water, have been shown to enhance the decontamination efficiency of permanganate. However, the mechanism behind this enhancement is not well understood. This study systematically investigated the role of oxyanions in regulating the structural parameters of colloidal MnO2, leading to increased autocatalytic activity of Mn(VII). The results showed that oxyanions such as bicarbonate can improve the degradation of phenol by Mn(VII) through improved autocatalytic processes and structural changes in MnO2. Other oxyanions with appropriate ionic potentials also showed similar activation mechanisms. These findings enhance our understanding of Mn(VII) oxidation behavior and provide a theoretical foundation for designing enhanced Mn(VII) oxidation systems.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Metal Borides as Excellent Co-Catalysts for Boosted and Long-Lasting Fenton-like Reaction: Dual Co-Catalytic Centers of Metal and Boron

Shuang Meng, Minglu Sun, Peng Zhang, Chenying Zhou, Chuanshu He, Heng Zhang, Yang Liu, Zhaokun Xiong, Peng Zhou, Bo Lai

Summary: Metal borides act as a new class of co-catalysts to enhance Fenton-like oxidation for environmental remediation, by steadily donating electrons to inactive Fe(III) and overcoming the drawbacks of Fenton-like reactions.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Review Engineering, Chemical

Synthesis of Fe-Mn-Based Materials and Their Applications in Advanced Oxidation Processes for Wastewater Decontamination: A Review

Yu-Dan Dong, Yang Shi, Yong-Li He, Shu-Run Yang, Si-Ying Yu, Zhaokun Xiong, Heng Zhang, Gang Yao, Chuan-Shu He, Bo Lai

Summary: With the development of industry and agriculture, environmental pollution and water quality deterioration have become increasingly serious, posing a threat to human health. Fe-Mn-based materials, which are nontoxic, low-cost, easy to prepare, and highly efficient, have been widely used for wastewater decontamination. This review summarizes the synthesis methods and application progress of Fe-Mn-based materials in various catalysis processes, highlighting their potential in environmental remediation.

INDUSTRIAL & ENGINEERING CHEMISTRY RESEARCH (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Activation of periodate by N-doped iron-based porous carbon for degradation of sulfisoxazole: Significance of catalyst-mediated electron transfer mechanism

Kaiyuan Luo, Yang Shi, Rongfu Huang, Xipeng Wei, Zelin Wu, Peng Zhou, Heng Zhang, Yin Wang, Zhaokun Xiong, Bo Lai

Summary: This study demonstrated the efficient degradation of sulfisoxazole (SIZ) using N-doped iron-based porous carbon (Fe@N-C) as a catalyst to activate periodate (PI). The Fe@N-C catalyst exhibited high catalytic activity, stable structure, and excellent electron transfer activity. The non-radical pathway was identified as the dominant degradation mechanism, which was supported by scavenging experiments, electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) analysis, salt bridge experiments, and electrochemical experiments. Fe@N-C mediated the electron transfer from organic contaminant molecules to PI, improving the efficiency of PI utilization. This study provides new insights into the application of Fe@N-C activated PI in wastewater treatment.

JOURNAL OF HAZARDOUS MATERIALS (2023)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Nitrogen doped biochar derived from algae as persulfate activator for the degradation of tetracycline: Role of exogenous N doping and electron transfer pathway

Qin Yin, Haihong Yan, Yu Liang, Haiyan Wang, Pingzhou Duan, Bo Lai

Summary: In this study, biochar derived from cyanobacteria was decorated with N atoms to enhance its catalytic performance in PDS activation. The mechanism of TC degradation was comprehensively studied, showing the crucial role of 1O2 formation and surficial reactive complexes derived from PDS attacking the adsorbed TC molecules. It was proven that N-doping accelerates electron transfer between TC and PDS and strengthens non-radical pathway mediated by sp2 defects.

SEPARATION AND PURIFICATION TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Selective elimination of sulfonamide antibiotics upon periodate/catechol process: Dominance of quinone intermediates

Shuai Yang, Yang Shi, Xinhao Wang, Yang Liu, Yi Ren, Wei Li, Heng Zhang, Xiaoqiang Dai, Weiyi Sun, Bo Lai

Summary: This study discovered that natural organic matter, especially ortho-quinones, can participate in the transformation of sulfonamide antibiotics. An efficient approach for sulfonamide antibiotics elimination was introduced by oxidizing ortho-dihydroxyl structures using periodate. The results showed the generation of ortho-benzoquinone in the periodate/catechol system and its high degradation capability towards sulfamethoxazole, as well as other sulfonamide antibiotics.

WATER RESEARCH (2023)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Enhanced contaminant degradation by FeS under oxic conditions with the coexistence of cobalt and nickel

Rongrong Ding, Guannan Zhou, Chuanshu He, Wenqiang Li, Yiran Wang, Xiaocheng Liu, Bo Lai, Yang Mu

Summary: This study highlights the influence of coexisting heavy metals on the degradation of contaminants during FeS oxygenation. The introduction of Co2+ and Ni2+ significantly enhances the degradation of bisphenol A by increasing the generation of reactive species.

APPLIED CATALYSIS B-ENVIRONMENT AND ENERGY (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

A metal-phenolic network-assembled nanotrigger evokes lethal ferroptosis via self-supply loop-based cytotoxic reactions

Xinping Zhang, Yuxin Guo, Xiaoyang Liu, Shun-Yu Wu, Ya-Xuan Zhu, Shao-Zhe Wang, Qiu-Yi Duan, Ke-Fei Xu, Zi-Heng Li, Xiao-Yu Zhu, Guang-Yu Pan, Fu-Gen Wu

Summary: This study develops a nanotrigger HCFT for simultaneous photodynamic therapy and light-triggered ferroptosis therapy. The nanotrigger can relieve tumor hypoxia, induce enhanced photodynamic reaction, and facilitate the continuation of Fenton reaction, ultimately leading to lethal ferroptosis in tumor cells.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

XAS and DFT investigation of atomically dispersed Cu/Co alloyed Pt local structures under selective hydrogenation of acetylene to ethylene

Olumide Bolarinwa Ayodele, Toyin Daniel Shittu, Olayinka S. Togunwa, Dan Yu, Zhen-Yu Tian

Summary: This study focused on the semihydrogenation of acetylene in an ethylene-rich stream using two alloyed Pt catalysts PtCu and PtCo. The PtCu catalyst showed higher activity and ethylene yield compared to PtCo due to its higher unoccupied Pt d-orbital density. This indicates that alloying Pt with Cu is more promising for industrial relevant SHA catalyst.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

A multifunctional emitter with synergistical adjustment of rigidity and flexibility for high-performance data-recording and organic light-emitting devices with hot exciton channel

Guowei Chen, Wen-Cheng Chen, Yaozu Su, Ruicheng Wang, Jia-Ming Jin, Hui Liang, Bingxue Tan, Dehua Hu, Shaomin Ji, Hao-Li Zhang, Yanping Huo, Yuguang Ma

Summary: This study proposes an intramolecular dual-locking design for organic luminescent materials, achieving high luminescence efficiency and performance for deep-blue organic light-emitting diodes. The material also exhibits unique mechanochromic luminescence behavior and strong fatigue resistance.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Cobalt/nickel purification by solvent extraction with ionic liquids in millifluidic reactors: From single-channel to numbered-up configuration with solvent recycle

Joren van Stee, Gregory Hermans, Jinu Joseph John, Koen Binnemans, Tom Van Gerven

Summary: This work presents a continuous solvent extraction method for the separation of cobalt and nickel in a millifluidic system using Cyphos IL 101 (C101) as the extractant. The optimal conditions for extraction performance and solvent properties were determined by investigating the effects of channel length, flow rate, and temperature. The performance of a developed manifold structure was compared to a single-channel system, and excellent separation results were achieved. The continuous separation process using the manifold structure resulted in high purity cobalt and nickel products.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Environment-triggered nanoagent with programmed gas release performance for accelerating diabetic infected wound healing

Yan Xu, Jingai Jiang, Xinyi Lv, Hui Li, Dongliang Yang, Wenjun Wang, Yanling Hu, Longcai Liu, Xiaochen Dong, Yu Cai

Summary: A programmed gas release nanoparticle was developed to address the challenges in treating diabetic infected wounds. It effectively removes drug-resistant pathogens and remodels the wound microenvironment using NO and H2S. The nanoparticle can eliminate bacteria and promote wound healing through antibacterial and anti-inflammatory effects.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Synergistic dopa-reinforced fluid hydrosol as highly efficient coal dust suppressant

Tong Xia, Zhilin Xi, Lianquan Suo, Chen Wang

Summary: This study investigated a highly efficient coal dust suppressant with low initial viscosity and high adhesion-solidification properties. The results demonstrated that the dust suppressant formed a network of multiple hydrogen bonding cross-linking and achieved effective adhesion and solidification of coal dust through various chemical reactions.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

First principle-based rate equation theory for the carbonation kinetics of CaO with CO2 in calcium looping

Jinzhi Cai, Zhenshan Li

Summary: A density functional theory-based rate equation was developed to predict the gas-solid reaction kinetics of CaO carbonation with CO2 in calcium looping. The negative activation energy of CaO carbonation close to equilibrium was accurately predicted through experimental validation.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Significant enhancement of high-temperature capacitive energy storage in dielectric films through surface self-assembly of BNNS coatings

Jianxiong Chen, Fuhao Ren, Ningning Yin, Jie Mao

Summary: This study presents an economically efficient and easily implementable surface modification approach to enhance the high-temperature electrical insulation and energy storage performance of polymer dielectrics. The self-assembly of high-insulation-performance boron nitride nanosheets (BNNS) on the film surface through electrostatic interactions effectively impedes charge injection from electrodes while promoting charge dissipation and heat transfer.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Medium entropy metal oxide induced *OH species targeted transfer strategy for efficient polyethylene terephthalate plastic recycling

Zijian Li, Zhaohui Yang, Shao Wang, Hongxia Luo, Zhimin Xue, Zhenghui Liu, Tiancheng Mu

Summary: This study reports a strategy for upgrading polyester plastics into value-added chemicals using electrocatalytic methods. By inducing the targeted transfer of *OH species, polyethylene terephthalate was successfully upgraded into potassium diformate with high purity. This work not only develops an excellent electrocatalyst, but also provides guidance for the design of medium entropy metal oxides.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

A novel environmental friendly and sustainable process for textile dyeing with sulphur dyes for cleaner production

Navneet Singh Shekhawat, Surendra Kumar Patra, Ashok Kumar Patra, Bamaprasad Bag

Summary: This study primarily focuses on developing a sulphur dyeing process at room temperature using bacterial Lysate, which is environmentally friendly, energy and cost effective, and sustainable. The process shows promising improvements in dye uptake and fastness properties.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Highly efficient and sustainable cationic polyvinyl chloride nanofibrous membranes for removal of E. coli and Cr (VI): Filtration and adsorption

Dengjia Shen, Hongyang Ma, Madani Khan, Benjamin S. Hsiao

Summary: This study developed cationic PVC nanofibrous membranes with high filtration and adsorption capability for the removal of bacteria and hexavalent chromium ions from wastewater. The membranes demonstrated remarkable performance in terms of filtration efficiency and maximum adsorption capacity. Additionally, modified nanofibrous membranes were produced using recycled materials and showed excellent retention rates in dynamic adsorption processes.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Concerted proton-coupled electron transfer promotes NiCoP nanowire arrays for efficient overall water splitting at industrial-level current density

Xiaoyan Wang, Zhikun Wang, Ben Jia, Chunling Li, Shuangqing Sun, Songqing Hu

Summary: Inspired by photosystem II, self-supported Fe-doped NiCoP nanowire arrays modified with carboxylate were constructed to boost industrial-level overall water splitting by employing the concerted proton-coupled electron transfer mechanism. The introduction of Fe and carboxyl ligand led to improved catalytic activity for HER and OER, and NCFCP@NF exhibited long-term durability for overall water splitting.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Self-limiting growth of thin dense LTA membranes boosts H2 gas separation performance

Pengyao Yu, Ge Yang, Yongming Chai, Lubomira Tosheva, Chunzheng Wang, Heqing Jiang, Chenguang Liu, Hailing Guo

Summary: Thin LTA zeolite membranes were prepared through secondary growth of nano LTA seeds in a highly reactive gel, resulting in membranes with superior permeability and selectivity in gas separation applications.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Prediction of phosphate adsorption amount, capacity and kinetics via machine learning: A generally physical-based process and proposed strategy of using descriptive text messages to enrich datasets

Baiqin Zhou, Huiping Li, Ziyu Wang, Hui Huang, Yujun Wang, Ruichun Yang, Ranran Huo, Xiaoyan Xu, Ting Zhou, Xiaochen Dong

Summary: The use of machine learning to predict the performance of specific adsorbents in phosphate adsorption shows great promise in saving time and revealing underlying mechanisms. However, the small size of the dataset and insufficient detailed information limits the model training process and the accuracy of results. To address this, the study employs a fuzzing strategy that replaces detailed numeric information with descriptive text messages on the physiochemical properties of adsorbents. This strategy allows the recovery of discarded samples with limited information, leading to accurate prediction of adsorption amount, capacity, and kinetics. The study also finds that phosphate uptake by adsorbents is generally through physisorption, with some involvement of chemisorption. The framework established in this study provides a practical approach for quickly predicting phosphate adsorption performance in urgent scenarios, using easily accessible information.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Absorption of hydrophobic volatile organic compounds in renewable vegetable oils and esterified fatty acids: Determination of gas-liquid partitioning coefficients as a function of temperature

Paula Alejandra Lamprea Pineda, Joren Bruneel, Kristof Demeestere, Lisa Deraedt, Tex Goetschalckx, Herman Van Langenhove, Christophe Walgraeve

Summary: This study evaluates the use of four esterified fatty acids and three vegetable oils as absorption liquids for hydrophobic VOCs. The experimental results show that isopropyl myristate is the most efficient liquid for absorbing the target VOCs.

CHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2024)