Federalism in post-conflict Somalia: A critical review of its reception and governance challenges

Somalia adopted federalism in 2004 and embarked on its implementation in 2012. This paper provides critical insights on the reception and performance of Somalia's federal project since 2012. The analysis has shown major practical challenges facing Somalia's federal structure: constitutional ambiguity and lack of consensus on federalism, difficulties regarding the formation of the federal member states and their border demarcations, the status of Mogadishu and questions concerning fiscal federalism. The paper argues these challenges as well as the general public's inadequate knowledge of federalism are pushing the nation towards decentralisation. It contends the regional politics and shifting alliances in the Horn of Africa and the Middle East are affecting Somalia's federal future, thus enforcing the 'federalism is a foreign initiative' notion. The paper suggests that a close study of Somali perceptions reveals that federalism is an externally imposed idea, which renders the weakening of the Somali state a strategic state policy.

Automated summary

Somalia adopted federalism in 2004 and began its implementation in 2012. However, there are major practical challenges facing Somalia's federal structure, including constitutional ambiguity, lack of consensus on federalism, difficulties in forming federal member states and their border demarcations, the status of Mogadishu, and questions regarding fiscal federalism. These challenges, along with inadequate knowledge of federalism among the general public, are pushing Somalia towards decentralization.