Agrobiodiversity conservation with illegal-drug crops: An approach from the prisons in Oaxaca, Mexico*

Drawing on political-ecological vulnerability theory, this paper analyzes the impact of illegal-drug cultivation and its related violence on smallholder agrobiodiversity in the state of Oaxaca, Mexico. Oaxaca is a global agrobiodiversity hotspot where cannabis and opium poppy have been widely cultivated for decades. The study is based on 76 structured/semi-structured interviews with imprisoned farmers, harvest gatherers, and former soldiers in four state prisons. Results show that illegal-drug crops and native-food crops complement each other until a threshold of violence is crossed, which leads to the abandonment of agriculture due to murder, imprisonment, and out-migration. The specialization of smallholder agriculture in illegal-drug crops tends to favor crossing the threshold of violence. In most municipalities in this study, however, rather a diversification process took place in which illegal-drug crops were incorporated to food production systems, reducing both the exposure and the sensitivity of smallholders to structural and direct violence. Other adaptation strategies involved local organization and militarization of smallholders for collective-risk management and territorial control. Ultimately, by comparing five vulnerability scenarios, this paper argues that the combination of peasant organization, militarization, and crop/livelihood diversification in Oaxaca mitigates the violent agrarian change associated with this illegal economy, while conserving agrobiodiversity.

Automated summary

This paper analyzes the impact of illegal-drug cultivation and its related violence on smallholder agrobiodiversity in Oaxaca, Mexico. The results show that illegal-drug crops and native-food crops complement each other until a threshold of violence is crossed, leading to the abandonment of agriculture. However, in most areas, a diversification process took place, incorporating illegal-drug crops into food production systems and reducing the exposure and sensitivity of smallholders to violence. Local organization and militarization of smallholders were also mentioned as adaptation strategies.