4.7 Article

PFAS treatment with granular activated carbon and ion exchange resin: Comparing chain length, empty bed contact time, and cost

Journal

JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING
Volume 44, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.jwpe.2021.102342

Keywords

PFAS; Adsorption; Activated carbon; Ion exchange; Cost analysis

Funding

  1. U.S. Department of Defense Environmental Security Technology Certification Program [ER-5053]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) are highly persistent chemicals with significant global environmental challenges. A study comparing the removal performance of granular activated carbon (GAC) and ion exchange resin (IX) for PFASs found that the length of PFAS chains and functional groups determine the mass transfer zone (MTZ) height and optimal empty bed contact times (EBCTs). Cost sensitivity analysis showed that IX was the most cost-effective adsorbent for removing both long and short chain PFASs compared to GAC.
Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) are among the most recalcitrant chemicals ever manufactured and are associated with substantial global environmental challenges. PFAS removal performance of granular activated carbon (GAC) and ion exchange resin (IX) was evaluated and compared using a segmented column system with full scale media under continuous flow conditions. Results from the PFAS breakthrough analysis established via column operation under different empty bed contact times (EBCTs) was used to characterize the mass transfer zone (MTZ) of multiple PFASs and evaluate optimum EBCTs for GAC and IX treatment. The height of the MTZ corresponded to PFAS chain length and functional group, where the poorly removed short chain perfluorocarboxylic acids exhibited the longest MTZ. Elongated PFAS MTZs justified longer EBCTs required for treatment of short chain PFAAs compared to long chain PFAAs for GAC and IX. In addition, a cost sensitivity analysis was employed to demonstrate how unit media cost, changeout frequency, and treatment goal feasibility dictated annual operation and maintenance (O&M) costs associated with GAC and IX installations. IX was found to the most cost-effective adsorbent for the removal of long and short chain PFASs compared to GAC. Results from the cost analysis indicated that adsorbent selection was the most critical factor dictating treatment cost with marginal impact from unit media cost or expected changeout frequency.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Engineering, Environmental

Rejection of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) in aqueous film-forming foam by high-pressure membranes

Charlie J. Liu, Timothy J. Strathmann, Christopher Bellona

Summary: The widespread use of PFASs has led to water contamination globally. High-pressure membranes like NF and RO are effective barriers to PFASs, with NF showing higher rejection rates for PFAAs and lower rejection rates in AFFF-impacted groundwater matrices. Operating conditions did not significantly impact the rejection of PFASs, except for shorter chain PFSAs, where rejection increased with flux. Structure-activity analysis showed some correlation between rejection rates and compound molecular weight, with adsorptive losses of PFAAs observed in membrane elements and systems. Despite this, NF consistently maintained rejection rates > 98% over 13 days.

WATER RESEARCH (2021)

Review Environmental Sciences

Inexpensive Organic Materials and Their Applications towards Heavy Metal Attenuation in Waters from Southern Peru

Pablo Garcia-Chevesich, Vilma Garcia, Gisella Martinez, Julia Zea, Juana Ticona, Francisco Alejo, Johan Vanneste, Sarah Acker, Gary Vanzin, Aaron Malone, Nicole M. Smith, Christopher Bellona, Jonathan O. Sharp

WATER (2020)

Editorial Material Engineering, Civil

Potable Reuse Trends and Challenges: A Conversation With the Editorial Board of the AWWA Water Science Topical Collection on Potable Reuse

Kerry J. Howe, Brent Alspach, Christopher Bellona, Julie Minton, George Tchobanoglous

Summary: In 2020, AWWA Water Science published a topical collection on potable reuse to address issues raised by the increasing demand for water reuse. The collection covers topics such as source water management, pathogen detection and treatment, communications and outreach, and socioeconomics of potable reuse. The guest editors of the collection discussed lessons learned and future challenges for potable reuse regulation and research, highlighting the need for additional research to ensure its safety and reliability as a water supply.

JOURNAL AMERICAN WATER WORKS ASSOCIATION (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Destruction of perfluorooctanesulfonate (PFOS) in a batch supercritical water oxidation reactor

Brian R. Pinkard, Shreyas Shetty, Derek Stritzinger, Christopher Bellona, Igor Novosselov

Summary: Effective technologies, such as supercritical water oxidation (SCWO), are needed for the destruction of PFAS. This study found that destruction and defluorination efficiencies of PFOS via SCWO were influenced by temperature and residence time, with a maximum 70.0% PFOS destruction and 78.2% defluorination achieved at 500 degrees C after 60 minutes of reaction.

CHEMOSPHERE (2021)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Pilot-scale field demonstration of a hybrid nanofiltration and UV-sulfite treatment train for groundwater contaminated by per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs)

Charlie J. Liu, Garrett McKay, Daqian Jiang, Raul Tenorio, J. Tani Cath, Camille Amador, Conner C. Murray, Juliane B. Brown, Harold B. Wright, Charles Schaefer, Christopher P. Higgins, Christopher Bellona, Timothy J. Strathmann

Summary: This study confirmed the effectiveness of a hybrid NF and UV-sulfite treatment system for the removal and destruction of PFASs from contaminated groundwater, with different rates of PFAS degradation observed. Energy input analysis showed varying requirements based on the type of PFAS, with opportunities for efficiency improvement in the UV reactor and water-cooling system.

WATER RESEARCH (2021)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Impact of ozone-biologically active filtration on the breakthrough of Perfluoroalkyl acids during granular activated carbon treatment of municipal wastewater effluent

Hooman Vatankhah, Bahareh Tajdini, Reid P. Milstead, Erica Clevenger, Conner Murray, Detlef Knappe, Christina K. Remucal, Christopher Bellona

Summary: This study investigates the use of ozone and biologically active filtration as standalone and combined pretreatments to enhance the removal of perfluoroalkyl acids in wastewater effluent. It is found that both processes significantly improve the performance of granular activated carbon for PFAA removal. The combination of ozone and biologically active filtration outperforms the standalone processes, indicating its potential for effective PFAA removal.

WATER RESEARCH (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Membrane Contactors as a Cost-Effective Cyanide Recovery Technology for Sustainable Gold Mining

Vincent Hammer, Johan Vanneste, David C. Vuono, Francisco D. Alejo-Zapata, Henry G. Polanco-Cornejo, Julia Zea, Hector G. Bolanos-Sosa, Carlos A. Zevallos Rojas, Linda A. Figueroa, Christopher Bellona

Summary: Cyanide is widely used in large-scale gold extraction and is replacing mercury in small-scale extraction. Current recovery and oxidation processes are expensive and not widely implemented. This study evaluates cyanide recovery using membranes and shows that pH, temperature, and feed cyanide concentration significantly impact the efficiency of the process. Techno-economic analysis shows that membrane contactors are cost-effective for cyanide recovery on both large and small scales.

ACS ES&T WATER (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Impact of effluent organic matter on perfluoroalkyl acid removal from wastewater effluent by granular activated carbon and alternative adsorbents

Bahareh Tajdini, Hooman Vatankhah, Conner C. Murray, Alexander Liethen, Christopher Bellona

Summary: The occurrence of perfluoroalkyl acids (PFAAs) in wastewater effluent has led to a greater need for effective sorption-based PFAA treatment methods. This study investigated the impact of ozone (O3)-biologically active filtration (BAF) as pretreatment options for nonselective and selective adsorbents. The results showed that O3-BAF in tandem achieved the highest PFAA removal performance improvement. Additionally, the transformation of hydrophobic effluent organic matter (EfOM) to hydrophilic molecules during O3 and biotransformation of EfOM during BAF were the main mechanisms responsible for improving PFAA removal.

WATER RESEARCH (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Removal of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances from contaminated groundwater by granular activated carbon and anion exchange resins: a pilot-scale comparative assessment

Charlie J. Liu, Conner C. Murray, R. Eric Marshall, Timothy J. Strathmann, Christopher Bellona

Summary: This study evaluated and compared the adsorption of PFASs in contaminated groundwater using granular activated carbon (GAC) and anion exchange resins (AER). The results showed that AERs adsorbed 6-7 times more PFASs than GAC based on media mass or volume. However, when considering the same flowrate, AERs performed similarly to GAC for PFCAs and better for PFSAs. The study also assessed the operational costs of both treatment methods and found that AER and GAC could have similar costs if the ratio of AER to GAC unit media costs was around 3.5.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE-WATER RESEARCH & TECHNOLOGY (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Photocatalytic Advanced Oxidation Processes for Neutralizing Free Cyanide in Gold Processing Effluents in Arequipa, Southern Peru

David C. Vuono, Johan Vanneste, Linda A. Figueroa, Vincent Hammer, Fredy N. Aguilar-Huaylla, Aaron Malone, Nicole M. Smith, Pablo A. Garcia-Chevesich, Hector G. Bolanos-Sosa, Francisco D. Alejo-Zapata, Henry G. Polanco-Cornejo, Christopher Bellona

Summary: The study aimed to optimize the use of UV radiation coupled with H2O2 to enhance the removal of cyanide in gold processing effluents. Higher UV intensity and H2O2 accelerated cyanide degradation, while a lower concentration effluent demonstrated faster removal rates compared to highly concentrated effluent._testing TiO2 photocatalyst with low stoichiometric ratios of CN-:H2O2 showed significant improvement in degradation rate within a short period of time.

SUSTAINABILITY (2021)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Removal of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFASs) from contaminated groundwater using granular activated carbon: a pilot-scale study with breakthrough modeling

Charlie J. Liu, David Werner, Christopher Bellona

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE-WATER RESEARCH & TECHNOLOGY (2019)

Meeting Abstract Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Reaction mechanisms, efficiency, and optimization of reductive transformation of PFASs by hydrated electrons in contaminated groundwater

Garrett McKay, Raul Tenorio, Daniel Van Hoomissen, Jiaoqin Liu, Christopher Bellona, Christopher Higgins, Shubham Vyas, Timothy Strathmann

ABSTRACTS OF PAPERS OF THE AMERICAN CHEMICAL SOCIETY (2019)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Influence of groundwater conditions and co-contaminants on sorption of perfluoroalkyl compounds on granular activated carbon

Dinusha P. Siriwardena, Michelle Crimi, Thomas M. Holsen, Christopher Bellona, Craig Divine, Eric Dickenson

REMEDIATION-THE JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL CLEANUP COSTS TECHNOLOGIES & TECHNIQUES (2019)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Changes in Adsorption Behavior of Perfluorooctanoic Acid and Perfluorohexanesulfonic Acid Through Chemically-Facilitated Surface Modification of Granular Activated Carbon

Dinusha P. Siriwardena, Michelle Crimi, Thomas M. Holsen, Christopher Bellona, Craig Divine, Eric Dickenson

ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING SCIENCE (2019)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Cr(VI) removal from fiber cement process waters: a techno-economic assessment

Francisco de Borja Ojembarrena, Elena Fuente, Angeles Blanco, Carlos Negro

Summary: Accumulation of Cr(VI) in industrial fiber cement process water can affect product quality and health, and it needs to be removed to avoid environmental risks. The study found that cationic cellulose nanocrystals (CCNCs) have higher adsorption efficiency and lower cost compared to conventional adsorbents.

JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING (2024)

Review Engineering, Environmental

Current problems and countermeasures of constructed wetland for wastewater treatment: A review

Shentan Liu, Yangchen Zhang, Xiaojuan Feng, Sang-Hyun Pyo

Summary: This paper summarizes the common problems of constructed wetlands (CWs) and proposes corresponding optimized solutions, including thermal insulation and additional aeration in cold climates, choosing suitable plant species and planting patterns to enhance phytoremediation in CWs, using various methods to monitor and evaluate CW clogging, implementing anti-clogging measures, controlling greenhouse gas emissions during CW treatment, constructing and utilizing CW databases, designing appropriate CW types, and implementing strict technical management and supervision.

JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Unlocking the potential of Chlamydomonas sp. for sustainable nutrient removal from POME: A biokinetic investigation

Norzila Mohd, Nazlina Haiza Mohd Yasin, Wan Hasnidah Wan Osman, Mohd Sobri Takriff

Summary: This study demonstrates that Chlamydomonas sp. is effective in removing nutrients from palm oil mill effluent and shows particular efficiency in the removal of ammonium and phosphate.

JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

High-efficient co-removal of copper and zinc by modified biochar derived from tea stalk: Characteristics, adsorption behaviors, and mechanisms

Mingzhen Zhang, Guijian Liu, Ruijia Liu, Jinzhao Xu, Wen Si, Yong Wei

Summary: Tieguanyin tea stem was used to synthesize modified biochar for the adsorption of copper and zinc. Among the modified biochar, Fe-BCs had the highest adsorption capacity, with Fe-BC650 being the best adsorbent. It reached adsorption equilibrium in 1 minute and had a maximum adsorption capacity of 303.5996 mg/g for Cu (II) and 254.0711 mg/g for Zn (II) in single-metal solutions. However, there were antagonistic impacts between Cu2+ and Zn2+.

JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Ultra-high adsorption capacity and selectivity of photo-enhanced sulfur-rich M2S3 (M--Bi and Sb) for gold recovery from electronic wastewater

Lingling Zhao, Qiaoshu Zhou, Yun Yang, Yuan Zhang, Yewei Qiu, Yanjun Chen, Xian Jin, Xiangjun Yang, Shixiong Wang

Summary: This research presents a method for selectively recovering gold from e-waste water using metal sulfides microspheres prepared by hydrothermal technique. The results show that the assistance of visible light significantly improves the gold adsorption performance of metal sulfides. The metal sulfides exhibit excellent gold adsorption properties, high selectivity, ultra-high adsorption capacity, and good recyclability.

JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Design and performance assessment of novel Fe3O4 decorated nanoblend of guar gum/graphene oxide flakes and CuO for mitigation of fluoroquinolones from wastewater

Laishram Saya, W. Rameshwor Singh, Sunita Hooda

Summary: Organic-inorganic nanoblends, such as polysaccharide-blended-inorganic ones, have versatile applications and have gained significant research attention. In this study, a magnetic guar gum/graphene oxide nanocomposite blended with CuO was successfully prepared and investigated for its adsorption capacity for ciprofloxacin removal. The results showed that the nanocomposite exhibited excellent adsorption capacity and the adsorption process was spontaneous.

JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Fabrication of magnetic biochar-MIL-68(Fe)-supported cobalt composite material toward the catalytic reduction performance of crystal violet

Umit Ecer, Sakir Yilmaz

Summary: A novel and effective catalyst Co@MIL-68(Fe)@Fe3O4@CM-BC was synthesized and used for the catalytic reduction of crystal violet in aqueous environments. The catalyst showed high efficiency in degrading crystal violet under specific conditions, and exhibited good regeneration performance.

JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Single-stage partial nitrification/anammox process performance restoration by bio-augmenting nitrifiers with or without nitrite oxidizing bacteria suppression

Chi Zhang, Miao Zhang, Haohan Yang, Wei Cai, Jun Wu

Summary: Enhancing the bioaugmentation of common nitrifiers in the partial nitrification/anammox process can decrease the activity of nitrite oxidizing bacteria and increase the activity of anammox bacteria, leading to improved total nitrogen removal efficiency.

JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Employing low dissolved oxygen strategy to simultaneously improve nutrient removal, mitigate membrane fouling, and reduce energy consumption in an AAO-MBR system: Fine bubble or coarse bubble?

Runzhang Zuo, Dajun Ren, Yangfan Deng, Canhui Song, Yubin Yu, Xiejuan Lu, Feixiang Zan, Xiaohui Wu

Summary: This study found that fine bubble aeration in membrane bioreactors (MBR) can better control membrane fouling and reduce energy consumption. However, compared to fine bubble aeration, coarse bubble aeration released more proteins and polysaccharides, resulting in a decrease in functional bacteria and enzymes involved in nitrogen and phosphorus pathways.

JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Compact wirelessly-powered photocatalyst-coated spheres: Concept development and application for oxidative wastewater treatment and membrane fouling control

Ch Tahir Mehmood, Jiekai Dai, Hanjun Zhao, Ziyi Zhong

Summary: Wirelessly powered photocatalyst-coated spheres (WPS) have been developed and demonstrated for various applications, including photodegradation and fouling control. These WPS are cost-effective, easy to fabricate, and have excellent visible light sources, making them suitable as carriers for photocatalysts.

JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Cobalt-loaded carbon nanofibers as magnetic catalyst for tetracycline degradation through peroxydisulfate activation: Non-radical dominated mechanism

Yifan Wang, Xiaoxuan Kang, Yuting Li, Ruyi Li, Chang Wu, Luyao Wang, Chongqing Wang, Tao Yang, Ming Ge, Zhangxing He

Summary: Cobalt/carbon nanofibers (Co/CNF) were prepared and exhibited excellent catalytic activity in the degradation of tetracycline by activating peroxodisulfate (PDS). The effects of process parameters on tetracycline removal were studied, and the reaction mechanism was confirmed through experiments.

JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Developing a novel lightweight substrate for constructed treatment wetland: The idea and the reality

Ting Wei, Yaqian Zhao, Jia Guo, Bin Ji, Alvaro Pun Garcia, Abraham Esteve Nunez

Summary: This study developed a novel lightweight substrate (Al-NLS) composed of aluminum sludge and polyurethane, and investigated its effectiveness in constructed wetlands (CWs). Results showed that Al-NLS had favorable adsorption capacities for phosphorus and removal efficiencies for pollutants in real domestic wastewater. It also positively influenced the microbial community. Therefore, Al-NLS can be considered as a new alternative substrate in CWs technology.

JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Degradation of chromosomal and plasmid encoded extracellular and intracellular resistance genes across different types and sizes in water matrices during ozone-based oxidation process

Dabojani Das, Achinta Bordoloi, Heyang Yuan, Daniel J. Caldwell, Rominder P. S. Suri

Summary: This study evaluates the degradation kinetics of antibiotic resistance genes and mobile genetic elements in water matrices by ozone treatment. The results show that extracellular antibiotic resistance genes can be effectively removed, while intracellular genes are more resistant to degradation. The impact of wastewater matrix on gene degradation is minimal.

JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING (2024)