4.5 Article

Building-level wastewater surveillance using tampon swabs and RT-LAMP for rapid SARS-CoV-2 RNA detection

Journal

Publisher

ROYAL SOC CHEMISTRY
DOI: 10.1039/d1ew00496d

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. UGA College of Public Health and Athens-Clarke County
  2. NSF [2027752]
  3. University of Notre Dame COVID response unit
  4. Div Of Chem, Bioeng, Env, & Transp Sys
  5. Directorate For Engineering [2027752] Funding Source: National Science Foundation

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Wastewater surveillance for SARS-CoV-2 RNA has shown correlation with COVID-19 cases and clinical testing. This study trialed tampons and RT-LAMP for wastewater monitoring, providing rapid results within three hours. Despite lower sensitivity than RT-ddPCR, this method demonstrated comparable predictive values to RT-qPCR and offers a cost-effective and rapid approach for scalable COVID-19 wastewater surveillance.
Wastewater surveillance for severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) RNA has demonstrated useful correlation with both coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) cases and clinical testing positivity at the community level. Wastewater surveillance on college campuses has also demonstrated promising predictive capacity for the presence and absence of COVID-19 cases. However, to date, such monitoring has most frequently relied upon composite samplers and reverse transcription quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR) techniques, which limits the accessibility and scalability of wastewater surveillance, particularly in low-resource settings. In this study, we trialed the use of tampons as passive swabs for sample collection and reverse transcription loop-mediated isothermal amplification (RT-LAMP), which does not require sophisticated thermal cycling equipment, to detect SARS-CoV-2 RNA in wastewater. Results for the workflow were available within three hours of sample collection. The RT-LAMP assay is approximately 20 times less analytically sensitive than RT-droplet digital PCR. Nonetheless, during a building-level wastewater surveillance campaign concurrent with independent weekly clinical testing of all students, the method demonstrated a three-day positive predictive value (PPV) of 75% (excluding convalescent cases) and same-day negative predictive value (NPV) of 80% for incident COVID-19 cases. These predictive values are comparable to that reported by wastewater monitoring using RT-qPCR. These observations suggest that even with lower analytical sensitivity the tampon swab and RT-LAMP workflow offers a cost-effective and rapid approach that could be leveraged for scalable building-level wastewater surveillance for COVID-19 potentially even in low-resource settings.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Producing ratio measures of effect with quantitative microbial risk assessment

Drew Capone, Aaron Bivins, Joe Brown

Summary: This paper discusses the importance of estimating the risk of pathogen exposure in quantitative microbial risk assessment (QMRA) and proposes a general method for calculating ratio measures of effect. These ratio estimates can be used for evaluating interventions and conducting systematic reviews and meta-analyses.

RISK ANALYSIS (2023)

Article Polymer Science

Simple fabrication of an electrospun polystyrene microfiber filter that meets N95 filtering facepiece respirator filtration and breathability standards

Madeline G. Jensen, Patrick T. O'Shaughnessy, Marlee Shaffer, Sooyoun Yu, Yun Young Choi, Megan Christiansen, Charles O. Stanier, Michael Hartley, Joey Huddle, Jed Johnson, Kyle Bibby, Nosang V. Myung, David M. Cwiertny

Summary: During the global spread of COVID-19, the high demand and limited availability of melt-blown filtration material led to a manufacturing backlog of N95 Filtering Facepiece Respirators (FFRs). An alternative filter material, consisting of electrospun polystyrene (PS) microfibers, showed favorable performance in terms of filtration efficiency and antibacterial activity, potentially making it a suitable option for use in N95 FFRs.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED POLYMER SCIENCE (2023)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Particle size influences decay rates of environmental DNA in aquatic systems

Pedro F. P. Brandao-Dias, Daniel M. C. Hallack, Elise D. D. Snyder, Jennifer L. L. Tank, Diogo Bolster, Sabrina Volponi, Arial J. J. Shogren, Gary A. A. Lamberti, Kyle Bibby, Scott P. P. Egan

Summary: Environmental DNA (eDNA) analysis is a powerful tool for detecting target organisms remotely. This study explores the possibility of obtaining longitudinal dynamics information on targets by separating different size components of eDNA within a sample. The results show that medium-sized particles decay more slowly and increase in proportion over time. Different sizes of eDNA particles do not decay independently, but a parsimonious mathematical model best explains the data. A framework for discerning target distance and abundance with eDNA data is proposed.

MOLECULAR ECOLOGY RESOURCES (2023)

Review Environmental Sciences

Monkeypox outbreak: Wastewater and environmental surveillance perspective

Ananda Tiwari, Sangeet Adhikari, Devrim Kaya, Md. Aminul Islam, Bikash Malla, Samendra P. Sherchan, Ahmad I. Al-Mustapha, Manish Kumar, Srijan Aggarwal, Prosun Bhattacharya, Kyle Bibby, Rolf U. Halden, Aaron Bivins, Eiji Haramoto, Sami Oikarinen, Annamari Heikinheimo, Tarja Pitkaenen

Summary: Monkeypox disease, caused by the monkeypox virus, has become a global concern. Wastewater-based surveillance can be a useful tool for early detection of the virus, but there are challenges to overcome.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Coral Disease and Ingestion: Investigating the Role of Heterotrophy in the Transmission of Pathogenic Vibrio spp. using a Sea Anemone (Exaiptasia pallida) Model System

William A. Norfolk, Carolina Melendez-Declet, Erin K. Lipp

Summary: The mucus membrane is the front line of defense against pathogens in corals. Understanding disease transmission in corals is complicated, but most of the established transmission pathways are associated with damage rather than evasion of immune defenses. However, this study suggests that ingestion may be an important pathway for the transmission of coral pathogens that bypasses the mucus membrane.

APPLIED AND ENVIRONMENTAL MICROBIOLOGY (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Highly socially vulnerable communities exhibit disproportionately increased viral loads as measured in community wastewater

William M. Baldwin, Robert D. Dayton, Aaron W. Bivins, Rona S. Scott, Andrew D. Yurochko, John A. Vanchiere, Terry Davis, Connie L. Arnold, Jose. E. T. Asuncion, Mohammad A. N. Bhuiyan, Brandon Snead, William Daniel, Deborah G. Smith, Nicholas E. Goeders, Christopher G. Kevil, Jennifer Carroll, Kevin S. Murnane

Summary: Wastewater surveillance is a useful tool in fighting against the SARS-CoV-2 virus, especially at the population level. In this study, wastewater samples were collected from three communities with different social vulnerability indices in Shreveport, Louisiana, to monitor the spread of the virus. The results showed that communities with higher social vulnerability had higher viral loads in wastewater.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Persistence of Antibiotic Resistance Genes Varies with Particle Size and Substrate Conditions in Recirculating Streams

Olivia Ginn, Jennifer L. Tank, Andrei Badilla-Aguilar, Elise Snyder, Pedro F. P. Brandao-Dias, Emma Thrift, Diogo Bolster, Kyle Bibby

Summary: Environmental factors play a critical role in understanding the fate and transport of antibiotic resistance in impacted streams. This study examines the impact of stream characteristics and particle size association on the removal of antimicrobial resistance genes over time. The findings suggest that both substrate and particle size influence the behavior and removal rates of antibiotic resistance genes in surface waters.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Occurrence of multiple respiratory viruses in wastewater in Queensland, Australia: Potential for community disease surveillance

Warish Ahmed, Aaron Bivins, Mikayla Stephens, Suzanne Metcalfe, Wendy J. M. Smith, Kwanrawee Sirikanchana, Masaaki Kitajima, Stuart L. Simpson

Summary: This study analyzed wastewater samples from four wastewater treatment plants in Queensland, Australia, and found the presence of 13 respiratory viruses. The results were compared with clinical cases, showing the potential of wastewater surveillance in viral disease monitoring. The most commonly detected viruses were bocavirus, parechovirus, rhinovirus A, and rhinovirus B.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

A Model-Based Framework to Assess the Feasibility of Monitoring Zika Virus with Wastewater-Based Epidemiology

William Chen, Kyle Bibby

Summary: Wastewater-based epidemiology (WBE) is a community-level monitoring technique used to track diseases, but its feasibility for monitoring vector-borne pathogens like Zika virus is uncertain. Monte Carlo simulation was used to generate distributions for total Zika RNA shedding and the process limit of detection (PLOD), and the probability of detecting Zika RNA in wastewater was calculated. Results suggest that successful Zika WBE application is unlikely in the United States but likely in Zika-endemic countries with decreased wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) per capita flows. However, the great discrepancy between true and reported clinical cases suggests that Zika WBE may be feasible even in the absence of outbreaks in endemic countries.

ACS ES&T WATER (2023)

Review Environmental Sciences

The lavatory lens: Tracking the global movement of pathogens via aircraft wastewater

Aaron Bivins, Robert Morfino, Andrew Franklin, Stuart Simpson, Warish Ahmed

Summary: Commercial air travel connects people but also facilitates the spread of infectious diseases. During the COVID-19 pandemic, public health agencies used control strategies to manage the risk of transmission associated with air travel, and aircraft wastewater surveillance emerged as a promising method to screen for COVID-19. By sampling aircraft wastewater, the global circulation of human pathogens can be monitored, leading to better targeted public health control measures during epidemics.

CRITICAL REVIEWS IN ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Suspended Materials Affect Particle Size Distribution and Removal of Environmental DNA in Flowing Waters

Pedro F. P. Brandao-Dias, Jennifer L. Tank, Elise D. Snyder, Ursula H. Mahl, Brett Peters, Diogo Bolster, Arial J. Shogren, Gary A. Lamberti, Kyle Bibby, Scott P. Egan

Summary: eDNA in aquatic systems is a complex mixture that includes dissolved DNA, intracellular DNA, and particle-adsorbed DNA. Understanding the composition and interactions of eDNA is crucial for determining the abundance and location of target organisms. This study found that eDNA rapidly adsorbs to other materials in the water column, affecting its concentration and particle size distribution. Only particulate organic matter affected the removal rate of eDNA. The removal of larger eDNA components was influenced by physical processes, while the removal of smaller eDNA components was driven by biological degradation.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Biochemical Research Methods

Influence of membrane pore-size on the recovery of endogenous viruses from wastewater using an adsorption-extraction method

Warish Ahmed, Wendy J. M. Smith, Kwanrawee Sirikanchana, Masaaki Kitajima, Aaron Bivins, Stuart L. Simpson

Summary: The ongoing COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted the importance of wastewater surveillance in monitoring and tracking the spread of infectious diseases, such as SARS-CoV-2. This study used the adsorption-extraction (AE) method with different pore size membranes to determine the concentrations of four types of endogenous viruses in wastewater samples. The results showed that the larger pore size membrane performed comparably to the smaller pore size membrane for virus detection/quantitation. The study provides valuable insights into the application of the AE method for virus recovery from wastewater, which is crucial for monitoring and tracking infectious diseases in communities.

JOURNAL OF VIROLOGICAL METHODS (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Making waves: Establishing a modeling framework to evaluate novel targets for wastewater-based surveillance

William Chen, Kyle Bibby

Summary: This paper discusses the importance of wastewater-based surveillance in understanding the occurrence and spread of infectious diseases and proposes a framework to assess the suitability of novel diseases for wastewater monitoring. The paper also explores five primary factors that influence the detection probability in wastewater-based surveillance and emphasizes the need for further research on these factors.

WATER RESEARCH (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Wastewater monitoring can anchor global disease surveillance systems

Aparna Keshaviah, Megan B. Diamond, Matthew J. Wade, Samuel V. Scarpino

Summary: We surveyed wastewater monitoring programmes in 43 countries to inform the development of global monitoring systems. Most programmes focused on urban populations. High-income countries primarily used composite sampling at treatment plants, while low-income and middle-income countries often used grab sampling from surface waters, drains, and latrines. Though most programmes analyzed samples domestically, there was a longer processing time in low-income and middle-income countries. While SARS-CoV-2 variant monitoring was common in high-income countries, it was less frequent in low-income and middle-income countries. Most programmes shared data internally, but not publicly. These findings emphasize the importance of integrating and expanding wastewater initiatives for global disease surveillance.

LANCET GLOBAL HEALTH (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Environmental DNA (eDNA) removal rates in streams differ by particle size under varying substrate and light conditions

Elise D. Snyder, Jennifer L. Tank, Pedro F. P. Branda, Kyle Bibby, Arial J. Shogren, Aaron W. Bivins, Brett Peters, Erik M. Curtis, Diogo Bolster, Scott P. Egan, Gary A. Lamberti

Summary: The use of environmental DNA (eDNA) as a sampling tool allows for the detection of invasive and/or rare aquatic species and enables biodiversity assessment without labor-intensive traditional sampling approaches. However, there is limited understanding of the environmental factors that impact the removal of eDNA in flowing waters. This study investigates the impact of light and substrate conditions on eDNA removal rates and suggests that changes in eDNA size classes over time and with differing environmental conditions could be used to predict the location of target organisms.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2023)

No Data Available