4.4 Article

Feedback between climate change and eutrophication: revisiting the allied attack concept and how to strike back

Journal

INLAND WATERS
Volume 12, Issue 2, Pages 187-204

Publisher

TAYLOR & FRANCIS LTD
DOI: 10.1080/20442041.2022.2029317

Keywords

cyanobacteria; feedback; greenhouse gases; nutrients; resilience; temperature

Funding

  1. ANII
  2. CSIC I +D [511]
  3. USA-NSF [1831096, 1840715]
  4. NIH [1P01ES028939-01]
  5. TUBITAK [BIDEB2232 (118C250)]
  6. Danmarks Frie Forskningsfond Naturog Univers project GREENLAKES [9040-00195B]
  7. European Union [869296]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This article summarizes the latest advancements in the understanding of the interaction between eutrophication and climate change, with a focus on shallow lakes. Climate change can influence nutrient loading and impact biotic communities, leading to increased eutrophication and the emission of greenhouse gases. The article also highlights the potential feedback among eutrophication, cyanobacterial blooms, and climate change.
Despite its well-established negative impacts on society and biodiversity, eutrophication continues to be one of the most pervasive anthropogenic influences along the freshwater to marine continuum. The interaction between eutrophication and climate change, particularly climate warming, was explicitly focused upon a decade ago by Brian Moss and others in Allied attack: climate change and eutrophication, which called for an integrated response to both problems, given their apparent synergy. In this review, we summarise advances in the theoretical framework and empirical research on this issue and analyse the current understanding of the major drivers and mechanisms by which climate change can enhance eutrophication, and vice versa, with a particular focus on shallow lakes. Climate change can affect nutrient loading through changes at the catchment and landscape levels by affecting hydrological patterns and fire frequency and through temperature effects on nutrient cycling. Biotic communities and their interactions can also be directly and indirectly affected by climate change, leading to an overall weakening of resilience to eutrophication impacts. Increasing empirical evidence now indicates several mechanisms by which eutrophying aquatic systems can increasingly act as important sources of greenhouse gases to the atmosphere, particularly methane. We also highlight potential feedback among eutrophication, cyanobacterial blooms, and climate change. Facing both challenges simultaneously is more pressing than ever. Meaningful and strong measures at the landscape and waterbody levels are therefore required if we are to ensure ecosystem resilience and safe water supply, conserve biodiversity, and decrease the carbon footprint of freshwaters.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Bimodality and alternative equilibria do not help explain long-term patterns in shallow lake chlorophyll-a

Thomas A. Davidson, Carl D. Sayer, Erik Jeppesen, Martin Sondergaard, Torben L. Lauridsen, Liselotte S. Johansson, Ambroise Baker, Daniel Graeber

Summary: The relationship between shallow lake chlorophyll-a and nutrient enrichment is not in line with the theory of alternative stable states. This study combines empirical data and simulations to show that a predictable linear relationship between nutrient concentration and chlorophyll-a becomes evident when observed over a longer time period (>3 years), suggesting the absence of alternative stable states.

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2023)

Article Plant Sciences

Activity and abundance of methane-oxidizing bacteria on plants in experimental lakes subjected to different nutrient and warming treatments

Chiara Esposito, Thomas P. A. Nijman, Annelies J. Veraart, Joachim Audet, Eti E. Levi, Torben L. Lauridsen, Thomas A. Davidson

Summary: Shallow lakes produce and emit significant amounts of methane, and methane-oxidizing bacteria play a role in reducing these emissions. However, the role of aquatic plants in methane oxidation is not well understood. This study compared methane oxidation rates and bacteria abundance associated with different types of aquatic plants. The results showed that various plant types have different rates of methane oxidation, and high biomass of macrophytes is associated with reduced methane concentration in the water.

AQUATIC BOTANY (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Recent increases of rainfall and flooding from tropical cyclones (TCs) in North Carolina (USA): implications for organic matter and nutrient cycling in coastal watersheds

Hans W. Paerl, Nathan S. Hall, Alexandria G. Hounshell, Karen L. Rossignol, Malcolm A. Barnard, Richard A. Luettich Jr, Jacob C. Rudolph, Christopher L. Osburn, Jerad Bales, Lawrence W. Harding Jr

Summary: Coastal North Carolina has experienced 36 tropical cyclones in the past two decades, and three of them (Hurricanes Floyd-1999, Matthew-2016, and Florence-2018) caused significant floods. These floods led to catastrophic flooding, changes in water quality, fisheries habitat, and ecological conditions in the Albemarle-Pamlico Sound. The study found an increase in precipitation and flooding associated with tropical cyclones, which resulted in high storm-related freshwater discharge and nutrient loadings in the Neuse River Estuary, a major sub-estuary of the Albemarle-Pamlico Sound. The findings highlight the importance of event-scale discharge in carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus loadings and the potential impacts on hydrology, water quality, and habitat conditions in estuarine and coastal waters.

BIOGEOCHEMISTRY (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Cost effectiveness, nitrogen, and phosphorus removal in field-based woodchip bioreactors treating agricultural drainage water

Finn Plauborg, Maja H. Skjodt, Joachim Audet, Carl C. Hoffmann, Brian H. Jacobsen

Summary: Nitrogen and phosphorus losses to surface and coastal waters remain high, but woodchip bioreactors in Denmark have shown promise in reducing nitrogen levels in agricultural drainage water, although they are costly.

ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING AND ASSESSMENT (2023)

Article Marine & Freshwater Biology

Challenges and opportunities in the use of ponds and pondscapes as Nature-based Solutions

M. Cuenca-Cambronero, M. Blicharska, J. -a. Perrin, T. A. Davidson, B. Oertli, M. Lago, M. Beklioglu, M. Meerhoff, M. Arim, J. Teixeira, L. De Meester, J. Biggs, J. Robin, B. Martin, H. M. Greaves, C. D. Sayer, P. Lemmens, D. Boix, T. Mehner, M. Bartrons, S. Brucet

Summary: Ponds and pondscapes play a crucial role in providing multiple benefits to both biodiversity and humans. However, they are often overlooked as Nature-based Solutions and there is a lack of knowledge on how to manage and restore them to maximize their potential in climate change resilience. To address this, it is important to generate and integrate various knowledge domains. Therefore, evidence-based guidance is needed to support the broader use of ponds.

HYDROBIOLOGIA (2023)

Article Marine & Freshwater Biology

Environmental and aquatic macroinvertebrates metrics respond to the Eucalyptus afforestation gradient in subtropical lowland streams

Margenny Barrios, Giancarlo Tesitore, Maite Burwood, Barbara Suarez, Mariana Meerhoff, Jimena Alonso, Blanca Rios Touma, Franco Teixeira de Mello

Summary: We assessed the potential effects of Eucalyptus afforestation on water quality and macroinvertebrate assemblage. Nutrient concentrations, conductivity, and total dissolved solids showed positive responses to increasing afforestation, but the responses varied among seasons. Macroinvertebrate metrics showed negative and positive responses to afforestation, with densities of sensitive taxa decreasing and others increasing. The use of water quality parameters in combination with macroinvertebrates assemblage contributes to managing streams affected by afforestation.

HYDROBIOLOGIA (2023)

Article Marine & Freshwater Biology

Differences in food web structure and composition between new and nearby older lakes in West Greenland suggest succession trajectories driven by glacier retreat

Erik Jeppesen, Thomas A. Davidson, Mariana Meerhoff, Luc De Meester, Ivan Gonzalez-Bergonzoni, Nicolas Vidal, Hartmut Arndt, Klaus Juergens, Ruben Sommaruga, Korhan Ozkan, Torben L. Lauridsen, Sh Tserenpil

Summary: With the retreat of glaciers, new ponds and lakes are formed, which become more productive as vegetation develops. Our study in West Greenland found that older lakes had higher nutrient concentrations and organic matter content, as well as higher biomass and richness of certain aquatic organisms. The food web in the older lakes was more complex, with a longer food chain and higher taxonomic diversity, suggesting a succession process following glacial retreat.

HYDROBIOLOGIA (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Pollution caused by mining reshaped the structure and function of bacterial communities in China?s largest ion-adsorption rare earth mine watershed

Wang Shu, Fadong Li, Qiuying Zhang, Zhao Li, Yunfeng Qiao, Joachim Audet, Gang Chen

Summary: Ion-adsorption rare earth mining leads to high levels of nitrogen, multiple metals, and strong acidic mine drainage, which have unclear impacts on microbial assembly and ecological functions. We studied river sediments from China's largest ion-adsorption rare earth mine and found that bacterial community assembly was weakly influenced by spatial dispersion. Dispersal limitation and homogeneous selection were the dominant ecological processes, and bacterial alpha diversity decreased with pollution. Bacteria developed survival strategies to adapt to the extreme environment, sustaining species diversity and community stability.

JOURNAL OF HAZARDOUS MATERIALS (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Northern expansion is not compensating for southern declines in North American boreal forests

Ronny Rotbarth, Egbert H. Van Nes, Marten Scheffer, Jane Uhd Jepsen, Ole Petter Laksforsmo Vindstad, Chi Xu, Milena Holmgren

Summary: Climate change is causing a northward shift of the boreal biome, but evidence of this shift is rare. Using satellite data, researchers found that tree cover change in the North American boreal biome has a strong north-south asymmetry, with no expansion at the northern boundary but a marked increase in the core range. However, tree cover declined at the southern boundary due to wildfires and logging, indicating a possible contraction of the biome that could lead to long-term carbon declines.

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Loss of Earth system resilience during early Eocene transient global warming events

Shruti Setty, Margot J. Cramwinckel, Egbert H. van Nes, Ingrid A. van de Leemput, Henk A. Dijkstra, Lucas J. Lourens, Marten Scheffer, Appy Sluijs

Summary: In this study, we analyze climate and carbon cycle indicators from marine sediments to investigate three major punctuated events during the late Paleocene-early Eocene warming. The results suggest that these events were triggered by climate-driven carbon cycle tipping points, and there is an intensifying coupling between the carbon cycle and climate during the long-term warming trend.

SCIENCE ADVANCES (2023)

Article Ecology

Unlocking environmental archives in the Arctic-insights from modern diatom-environment relationships in lakes and ponds across Greenland

Kaarina Weckstrom, Jan Weckstrom, Juliane Wischnewski, Thomas A. Davidson, Torben L. Lauridsen, Frank Landkildehus, Kirsten S. Christoffersen, Erik Jeppesen

Summary: With the help of paleolimnology, the relationship between diatoms and environmental drivers in the Arctic lakes and ponds of Greenland was explored. The study found that climate and lake ontogeny were the main factors determining diatom communities. The species diversity declined towards the North, and diatoms were proven to be an excellent proxy for climate-mediated lake ecosystem change in the Arctic.

FRONTIERS IN ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2023)

Letter Ecology

Five fundamental ways in which complex food webs may spiral out of control

J. Jelle Lever, Egbert H. H. Van Nes, Marten Scheffer, Jordi Bascompte

Summary: Theory suggests that long, negative feedback loops may destabilize food webs as complexity increases. However, the specific ways in which these feedbacks affect ecosystems' response to environmental change have received less attention. In this study, we describe five ways in which these feedbacks might lead to abrupt transitions and species losses. By combining models, we show that the likelihood of such transitions increases with the number of interacting species and the stability of network patterns. These findings raise questions about the stability of ecosystems under global environmental change.

ECOLOGY LETTERS (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

CO2, CH4, and N2O emissions from dredged material exposed to drying and zeolite addition under field and laboratory conditions

Jose R. Paranaiba, Quinten Struik, Maite Erdociain, Gijs van Dijk, Alfons J. P. Smolders, Judith van der Knaap, Annelies J. Veraart, Sarian Kosten

Summary: Dredging can significantly reduce aquatic greenhouse gas emissions, but the potential emissions from sludge depots and how to reduce them are unknown. This study found that permanently inundating sludge can reduce emissions, but adding zeolite does not decrease total greenhouse gas emissions.

ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Sustainable lake restoration: From challenges to solutions

Olga Tammeorg, Ingrid Chorus, Bryan Spears, Peeter Noges, Gertrud K. Nurnberg, Priit Tammeorg, Martin Sondergaard, Erik Jeppesen, Hans Paerl, Brian Huser, Jukka Horppila, Tom Jilbert, Agnieszka Budzynska, Renata Dondajewska-Pielka, Ryszard Goldyn, Sina Haasler, Seppo Hellsten, Laura H. Harkonen, Mina Kiani, Anna Kozak, Niina Kotamaki, Katarzyna Kowalczewska-Madura, Silvia Newell, Leena Nurminen, Tiina Noges, Kasper Reitzel, Joanna Rosinska, Jukka Ruuhijarvi, Soila Silvonen, Christian Skov, Tamara Vazic, Anne-Mari Ventela, Guido Waajen, Miquel Lurling

Summary: Sustainable management of lakes requires addressing ecological, economic, and social challenges, with a focus on achieving ecological improvement in a co-beneficial context. In-lake restoration measures can bring rapid ecosystem responses, especially when combined with circular economy practices. However, lake restoration approaches need to be carefully assessed to ensure they effectively address lake-specific problems, are cost-effective, and promote valuable ecosystem services.

WILEY INTERDISCIPLINARY REVIEWS-WATER (2023)

Article Ecology

Drainage ditches are year-round greenhouse gas hotlines in temperate peat landscapes

Lisanne Hendriks, Stefan Weideveld, Christian Fritz, Tatiana Stepina, Ralf C. H. Aben, Ngum E. Fung, Sarian Kosten

Summary: The emissions of greenhouse gas (GHG) from drained peatlands and ditches were studied. The main gases emitted were methane (CH4), carbon dioxide (CO2), and nitrous oxide (N2O). The study found that the emissions from ditches were higher than those from surrounding drained peatlands, indicating their importance on the landscape scale and highlighting the need for their inclusion in national greenhouse gas reporting.

FRESHWATER BIOLOGY (2023)

No Data Available