4.7 Article

Headwater-to-consumer Drinking Water Security Assessment Framework and Associated Indicators for Small Communities in High-income Countries

Journal

WATER RESOURCES MANAGEMENT
Volume 36, Issue 3, Pages 805-834

Publisher

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s11269-021-02985-2

Keywords

Local water security; Drinking water security framework; Small systems; Rural remote or otherwise marginalized (RRM) communities; Assessment indicators and indices

Funding

  1. Natural Science and Engineering Research Council of Canada [NETGP-494312-16]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Drinking water insecurity in small and rural, remote, or otherwise marginalized communities in Canada is a complex issue with various challenges. Currently, there is a lack of academic literature on assessment frameworks for drinking water security in these communities, particularly in high income countries. This study introduces an indicator-based framework for assessing drinking water security in small and rural, remote, or otherwise marginalized communities. The framework focuses on four dimensions: upstream watershed security, source water security, community needs and engagement, and treatment and distribution infrastructure.
Drinking water insecurity in small and rural, remote, or otherwise marginalized communities in Canada is pervasive and complex with multiple dimensions and impacts. These communities face challenges such as variable source water quality, lack of resources, inappropriate treatment technologies, lack of access to training, difficulties retaining qualified personnel, and ineffective governance structures. Currently, there is a gap in the academic literature with respect to drinking water security assessment frameworks or tools for small and rural, remote, or otherwise marginalized communities, particularly in high income countries. Thus, the objective of this study is to introduce a framework for assessing drinking water security, from headwater to consumer, in the context of small and rural, remote, or otherwise marginalized communities. An indicator-based framework has been developed to evaluate drinking water security, prioritize actions and investments, and support decision-making. The framework builds on expert knowledge and a critical review of security, sustainability, and performance indices of water supply and treatment processes obtained from the literature. The framework is organised into four dimensions of drinking water security from headwaters to consumer: upstream watershed security; source water security; community needs and engagement; and treatment and distribution infrastructure. A list of relevant indicators for each dimension has been compiled to support framework application in a format that is accessible to decision-makers in small and rural, remote, or otherwise marginalized communities.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Environmental Sciences

Examining influential drivers of private well users' perceptions in Ontario: A cross-sectional population study

Sarah Lavallee, Paul D. Hynds, R. Stephen Brown, Corinne Schuster-Wallace, Sarah Dickson-Anderson, Stephanie Di Pelino, Rylan Egan, Anna Majury

Summary: The study found that private well users have a low awareness of waterborne pathogens, with factors such as geographic location, gender, and well type being associated with attitudes and risk perceptions towards personal well water supply. Residential presence during well construction was linked to higher awareness levels and lower risk perception scores, while previous cases of acute gastrointestinal illness in the household were associated with negative attitudes towards well water and higher risk perception scores regarding the quantity of local groundwater sources.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2021)

Article Water Resources

Transport pathway identification in fractured aquifers: A stochastic event synchrony-based framework

Ahmed Yosri, Sarah Dickson-Anderson, Ahmad Siam, Wael El-Dakhakhni

Summary: This study introduces a novel approach for mapping transport pathways in fractured systems by analyzing the relationship between solute transport and time series, accurately representing direct paths and identifying hydrogeological characteristics.

ADVANCES IN WATER RESOURCES (2021)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Analytical description of colloid behavior in single fractures under irreversible deposition

Ahmed Yosri, Sarah Dickson-Anderson, Ahmad Siam, Wael El-Dakhakhni

Summary: This study developed an analytical relationship between the deposition coefficient (kappa) and the fraction of colloids retained in single fractures (F-r) for irreversible colloid deposition in groundwater-saturated fractures. The global sensitivity analysis showed that colloid deposition variability is primarily controlled by fracture length, aperture size, and deposition coefficient. The analytical relationship efficiently replicated experimental observations, supporting the understanding that colloid deposition is controlled by physicochemical properties of the system.

JOURNAL OF COLLOID AND INTERFACE SCIENCE (2021)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Drinking Water Consumption Patterns among Private Well Users in Ontario: Implications for Exposure Assessment of Waterborne Infection

Sarah Lavallee, Tessa Latchmore, Paul D. Hynds, R. Stephen Brown, Corinne Schuster-Wallace, Sarah Dickson-Anderson, Anna Majury

Summary: Understanding water consumption patterns among private well users in Ontario helps in developing accurate risk assessments for waterborne infections. This study found that factors such as gender and previous experiences with waterborne illnesses can influence well water consumption rates. Additionally, respondents who reported previous testing or ongoing water treatment had higher rates of well water consumption.

RISK ANALYSIS (2021)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Exploration of E. coli contamination drivers in private drinking water wells: An application of machine learning to a large, multivariable, geo-spatio-temporal dataset

Katie White, Sarah Dickson-Anderson, Anna Majury, Kevin McDermott, Paul Hynds, R. Stephen Brown, Corinne Schuster-Wallace

Summary: Groundwater resources in Ontario, Canada are facing increasing threats from contamination and overuse, with well characteristics, sampling frequencies, and microbiological contamination indicators (specifically E. coli) being important factors. Analysis of a dataset from over 250,000 unique wells revealed that bedrock wells in sedimentary or igneous rock are more susceptible to contamination, shallow wells pose a greater risk to consumers, and well testing practices are influenced by previous test results. Further exploration of these trends is needed to understand the bases for such occurrences.

WATER RESEARCH (2021)

Review Health Policy & Services

Culturally sensitive palliative care in humanitarian action: Lessons from a critical interpretive synthesis of culture in palliative care literature

C. J. Schuster-Wallace, E. Nouvet, I. Rigby, G. Krishnaraj, S. de Laat, L. Schwartz, M. Hunt

Summary: This study examines the influence of culture on palliative care, emphasizes the importance of providing culturally sensitive care in humanitarian crises, and provides recommendations to avoid othering and reductionistic understandings.

PALLIATIVE & SUPPORTIVE CARE (2022)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Analytical model for solute transport in discrete fracture networks: 2D spatiotemporal solution with matrix diffusion

Mohamed Khafagy, Wael El-Dakhakhni, Sarah Dickson-Anderson

Summary: The study introduces a computationally efficient analytical network (AN) model for simulating solute transport in discrete fracture networks (DFNs). The AN model was verified to show excellent agreement with numerical models and investigated the sensitivity of mass sharing methods to dominant transport mechanisms. The model was found to be at least 97% more efficient than numerical models and provides a useful reference tool for verifying numerical dual-porosity fracture network simulations.

COMPUTERS & GEOSCIENCES (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

A conceptual framework for gender and climate mainstreaming to mitigate water inaccessibility in rural sub-Saharan Africa

Gervin A. Apatinga, Corinne J. Schuster-Wallace, Sarah E. Dickson-Anderson

Summary: This article explores the reasons and consequences of water inaccessibility for women in rural sub-Saharan Africa, as well as coping strategies. The study highlights the complex interlinkages between gender, climate, and water accessibility, calling for more comprehensive research to inform policy and practice.

WILEY INTERDISCIPLINARY REVIEWS-WATER (2022)

Review Development Studies

Urban water insecurity and its gendered impacts: on the gaps in climate change adaptation and Sustainable Development Goals

Indrakshi Tandon, Corinne Wallace, Martina Angela Caretta, Sumit Vij, Alison Irvine

Summary: This paper evaluates the existing literature on climate change adaptation in relation to water and gender in urban and peri-urban contexts. The research highlights the lack of studies in this field, primarily focusing on low- and middle-income countries in Asia and sub-Saharan Africa, with little attention given to South America. Furthermore, there is a lack of evidence demonstrating the interlinkages between gender, climate change adaptations, and gender-sensitive dissemination of disaster warnings. The paper emphasizes the need for practical research assessing the gendered dimensions of all adaptations and promoting gender equality and empowerment through strengthened legislation.

CLIMATE AND DEVELOPMENT (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Biological Filtration is Resilient to Wildfire Ash-Associated Organic Carbon Threats to Drinking Water Treatment

Emma A. J. Blackburn, Sarah E. Dickson -Anderson, William B. Anderson, Monica B. Emelko

Summary: Water with elevated/altered levels of dissolved organic matter (DOM) after wildfire can be difficult to treat. This study investigated the ability of biological treatment to remove postfire dissolved organic carbon (DOC) resulting from wildfire ash. The results showed that the biofilter effectively removed turbidity and DOC in stable source water, and the biofilters buffered the increase in water extractable organic matter caused by ash addition. However, the balance between readily removed and recalcitrant fractions of DOM may affect the operational resilience of the biofilter.

ACS ES&T WATER (2023)

Review Humanities, Multidisciplinary

Synergies and trade-offs between climate change adaptation options and gender equality: a review of the global literature

Joyashree Roy, Anjal Prakash, Shreya Some, Chandni Singh, Rachel Bezner Kerr, Martina Angela Caretta, Cecilia Conde, Marta Rivera Ferre, Corinne Schuster-Wallace, Maria Cristina Tirado von der Pahlen, Edmond Totin, Sumit Vij, Emily Baker, Graeme Dean, Emily Hillenbrand, Alison Irvine, Farjana Islam, Katriona McGlade, Hanson Nyantakyi-Frimpong, Federica Ravera, Alcade Segnon, Divya Solomon, Indrakshi Tandon

Summary: This paper investigates whether reported climate change adaptation actions contribute to advancing gender equality (SDG 5) or not. The study finds positive links to nine targets under SDG 5 in adaptation actions consciously designed to advance gender equality. However, in certain sectors, more negative links than positive links are found. Intentional consideration of gender-focused targets is necessary for adaptation actions to have positive impacts on gender equality.

HUMANITIES & SOCIAL SCIENCES COMMUNICATIONS (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Advancing on the promises of techno-ecological nature-based solutions: a framework for green technology in water supply and treatment

Emma A. J. Blackburn, Monica B. Emelko, Sarah Dickson-Anderson, Micheal Stone

Summary: Nature-based solutions are increasingly proposed to address societal challenges, but they are not always suitable for providing safe drinking water. Green technologies in the water industry must be evaluated based on attributes such as natural-resource basis, energy consumption, waste production, and footprint, in relation to the environment and other technologies being considered.

BLUE-GREEN SYSTEMS (2021)

No Data Available