4.4 Review

No Uniformity in the References of Clinical Practice Guidelines for Bariatric Surgery: a Review of 3 Similar Guidelines Published in 2020.

Journal

OBESITY SURGERY
Volume 31, Issue 12, Pages 5427-5440

Publisher

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s11695-021-05746-7

Keywords

Bariatric Surgery; Clinical practice guidelines; Subjectivity; Non-uniformity; References

Categories

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The study found significant differences in references among three medical guidelines, indicating subjectivity in clinical practice guidelines development. It is suggested that more international cooperation is needed to address this issue.
In 2020, updated versions of the clinical practice guidelines of the European Association for Endoscopic Surgery, the Canadian Adult Obesity Clinical Practice Guidelines and the Dutch Federation for Medical Specialist clinical practice guidelines on bariatric surgery were published. We systematically reviewed and compared them on recommendations and references. Although the authors would have had access to the same literature, only 5 out of 655 unique references were used by all 3 guidelines and just 49 references by any combination of 2 guidelines. These findings attest to the subjectivity involved in clinical practice guidelines development and could be the cause for the observed differences in recommendations. International cooperation in guideline development might be a conceivable solution.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Endocrinology & Metabolism

30-day morbidity and mortality of sleeve gastrectomy, Roux-en-Y gastric bypass and one anastomosis gastric bypass: a propensity score-matched analysis of the GENEVA data

Rishi Singhal, Victor Roth Cardoso, Tom Wiggins, Jonathan Super, Christian Ludwig, Georgios Gkoutos, Kamal Mahawar

Summary: This global study found no significant difference in the 30-day morbidity and mortality of SG, RYGB, and OAGB in propensity score-matched cohorts.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF OBESITY (2022)

Correction Surgery

Guidelines for Perioperative Care in Bariatric Surgery: Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS) Society Recommendations: A 2021 Update (Jan, 10.1007/s00268-021-06394-9, 2022)

Erik Stenberg, Luiz Fernando dos Reis Falcao, Mary O'Kane, Ronald Liem, Dimitri J. Pournaras, Paulina Salminen, Richard D. Urman, Anupama Wadhwa, Ulf O. Gustafsson, Anders Thorell

WORLD JOURNAL OF SURGERY (2022)

Review Surgery

Guidelines for Perioperative Care in Bariatric Surgery: Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS) Society Recommendations: A 2021 Update

Erik Stenberg, Luiz Fernando dos Reis Falcao, Mary O'Kane, Ronald Liem, Dimitri J. Pournaras, Paulina Salminen, Richard D. Urman, Anupama Wadhwa, Ulf O. Gustafsson, Anders Thorell

Summary: This article presents the second updated guideline from the Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS) Society, providing a consensus and recommendations for optimal perioperative care in bariatric surgery. Through a comprehensive evaluation of literature, evidence-based consensus was achieved.

WORLD JOURNAL OF SURGERY (2022)

Article Endocrinology & Metabolism

Outcomes of the first global multidisciplinary consensus meeting including persons living with obesity to standardize patient-reported outcome measurement in obesity treatment research

Claire E. E. de Vries, Caroline B. Terwee, May Al Nawas, Bart A. van Wagensveld, Ignace M. C. Janssen, Ronald S. L. Liem, Simon W. Nienhuijs, Ricardo Cohen, Elisabeth F. C. van Rossum, Wendy A. Brown, Amir A. Ghaferi, Johan Ottosson, Karen D. Coulman, Tarissa B. Z. Petry, Stephanie Sogg, Lisa West-Smith, Jason C. G. Halford, Ximena Ramos Salas, John B. Dixon, Salman Al-Sabah, Wei-Jei Lee, John Roger Andersen, Stuart W. Flint, Maarten M. Hoogbergen, Brooke Backman, Ellen Govers, Nadya Isack, Caroline Clay, Susie Birney, Maureen Gunn, Paul Masterson, Audrey Roberts, Jacky Nesbitt, Riccardo Meloni, Sarah le Brocq, Sandra de Blaeij, Christina Kraaijveld, Floor van der Steen, Bibian Visser, Petra Hamers, Valerie M. Monpellier

Summary: The lack of standardization in measuring patient-reported outcomes (PROs) and PRO measures (PROMs) has led to the quality of life being underrepresented in obesity treatment research. The S.Q.O.T. initiative aims to standardize the measurement of quality of life in obesity treatment, and the first consensus meeting brought together experts and patients to identify key PROs and preferred PROMs. This meeting provided a first step towards standardizing PROs and PROMs in obesity treatment research.

OBESITY REVIEWS (2022)

Article Surgery

The Benefits of Banded over Non-banded Roux-en-Y Gastric Bypass in Patients with Morbid Obesity: a Multi-center Study

Marijn T. F. Jense, Inge H. Palm-Meinders, Rochelle Sigterman-Nelissen, Evert-Jan G. Boerma, Ronald S. L. Liem, Dingeman J. Swank, Jan Willem M. Greve

Summary: This study compared the effect of banded and non-banded Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (RYGB) on long-term weight loss results and comorbidities. The results showed that banded RYGB had superior weight loss compared to non-banded RYGB, while there was no significant difference in the effect on comorbidity improvement or remission. Therefore, performing banded RYGB is recommended due to the similar complication rates and significantly greater weight loss.

OBESITY SURGERY (2022)

Article Surgery

Predicting serious complication risks after bariatric surgery: external validation of the Michigan Bariatric Surgery Collaborative risk prediction model using the Dutch Audit for Treatment of Obesity

Erman O. Akpinar, Amir A. Ghaferi, Ronald S. L. Liem, Aaron J. Bonham, Simon W. Nienhuijs, Jan Willem M. Greve, Perla J. Marang-van de Mheen

Summary: The risk-prediction model for serious complications from the Michigan Bariatric Surgery Collaborative (MBSC) was found to be inaccurately predicting outcomes for Dutch bariatric patients based on external validation with the Dutch Audit for Treatment of Obesity (DATO) data. However, despite this, the model could still offer valuable information for doctor-patient (shared) decision making in clinical practice.

SURGERY FOR OBESITY AND RELATED DISEASES (2023)

Article Surgery

Weight recurrence after Sleeve Gastrectomy versus Roux-en-Y gastric bypass: a propensity score matched nationwide analysis

Erman Akpinar, Ronald S. L. Liem, Simon Nienhuijs, Jan Willem M. Greve, Perla J. Marang-van de Mheen

Summary: This study compared the extent of weight recurrence between patients who received Sleeve Gastrectomy (SG) and Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (RYGB) after adequate weight loss at 1-year follow-up. The results showed that patients undergoing SG had a higher likelihood of weight recurrence up to 5 years and were less likely to achieve remission of comorbidities such as type 2 diabetes, hypertension, dyslipidemia, gastroesophageal reflux, and obstructive sleep apnea syndrome.

SURGICAL ENDOSCOPY AND OTHER INTERVENTIONAL TECHNIQUES (2023)

Article Surgery

Development of a Bariatric Surgery Core Data Set for an International Registry

Karen D. D. Coulman, Katy Chalmers, Jane Blazeby, John Dixon, Lilian Kow, Ronald Liem, Dimitri J. J. Pournaras, Johan Ottosson, Richard Welbourn, Wendy Brown, Kerry Avery

Summary: This study developed a Core Registry Set (CRS) - core data to include in bariatric surgery registries globally, which is the first step towards unifying bariatric surgery registries internationally. We recommend the CRS is included as a minimum dataset in all bariatric registries worldwide. Adoption of the CRS will enable meaningful international comparisons of bariatric operations.

OBESITY SURGERY (2023)

Review Endocrinology & Metabolism

Genetic variants associated with weight loss and metabolic outcomes after bariatric surgery: A systematic review

Rieneke van Der Meer, Siham A. Mohamed, Valerie M. Monpellier, Ronald S. L. Liem, Eric J. Hazebroek, Paul W. Franks, Timothy M. Frayling, Ignace M. C. Janssen, Mireille J. Serlie

Summary: Limited evidence exists for the role of specific genetic variants in surgical outcomes after bariatric surgery, based on a review of current research on the association between genetic variations and weight loss and metabolic changes post-surgery.

OBESITY REVIEWS (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Daily disease severity in patients with COVID-19 admitted to the hospital: The SCODA (severity of coronavirus disease assessment) score

Simone A. Joosten, Mark J. R. Smeets, M. Sesmu Arbous, Judith Mannien, Sander Laverman, Merijn M. G. Driessen, Suzanne C. Cannegieter, Anna H. E. Roukens

Summary: The Severity of COronavirus Disease Assessment (SCODA) score is developed to track the disease severity of hospitalized COVID-19 patients. It includes parameters related to breathing and oxygenation, and has been applied to the BEAT-COVID cohort to describe the severity of COVID-19 and determine the timing of clinical recovery. This score enhances understanding of the pathophysiology of COVID-19 and evaluation of interventions.

PLOS ONE (2023)

Correction Surgery

Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on surgical care in the Netherlands (vol 109, znac301, 2022)

Michelle R. de Graaff, Rianne N. M. Hogenbirk, Yester F. Janssen, Arthur K. E. Elfrink, Ronald S. L. Liem, Simon W. Nienhuijs, Jean Paul P. M. de Vries, Jan Willem Elshof, Emiel Verdaasdonk, Jarno Melenhorst, H. L. van Westreenen, Marc G. H. Besselink, Jelle P. Ruurda, Mark I. van Berge Henegouwen, Joost M. Klaase, Marcel den Dulk, Mark van Heijl, Johannes H. Hegeman, Jerry Braun, Daan M. Voeten, Franka S. Wurdemann, Anne Loes K. Warps, Anna J. Alberga, J. Annelie Suurmeijer, Erman O. Akpinar, Nienke Wouters, Anne Loes van den Boom, Marieke J. Bolster-van Eenennaam, Peter van Duijvendijk, David J. Heineman, Michel W. J. M. Wouters, Schelto Kruijff

BRITISH JOURNAL OF SURGERY (2023)

Letter Surgery

Future surgeon: bridging the intergenerational gap

Floortje Huizing, Vincent Q. Sier, Jaco A. S. Tresfon, Joost R. Van der Vorst, Ronald S. L. Liem, Roderick F. Schmitz, Abbey Schepers, R. Marijn Houwert, Menno R. Vriens, Heleen S. Snijders, Joris J. Blok

BRITISH JOURNAL OF SURGERY (2023)

Article Surgery

Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on surgical care in the Netherlands

Michelle R. de Graaff, Rianne N. M. Hogenbirk, Yester F. Janssen, Arthur K. E. Elfrink, Ronald S. L. Liem, Simon W. Nienhuijs, Jean-Paul P. M. de Vries, Jan-Willem Elshof, Emiel Verdaasdonk, Jarno Melenhorst, H. L. van Westreenen, Marc G. H. Besselink, Jelle P. Ruurda, Mark I. van Berge Henegouwen, Joost M. Klaase, Marcel den Dulk, Mark van Heijl, Johannes H. Hegeman, Jerry Braun, Daan M. Voeten, Franka S. Wurdemann, Anne-Loes K. Warps, Anna J. Alberga, J. Annelie Suurmeijer, Erman O. Akpinar, Nienke Wolfhagen, Anne Loes van den Boom, Marieke J. Bolster-van Eenennaam, Peter van Duijvendijk, David J. Heineman, Michel W. J. M. Wouters, Schelto Kruijff

Summary: This study found that during the COVID-19 pandemic, surgical procedures in the Netherlands decreased by 13.6%, with no significant increase in adverse outcomes. Non-cancer procedures were most affected, while oncological surgeries had shorter hospital stays.

BRITISH JOURNAL OF SURGERY (2022)

Article Endocrinology & Metabolism

Effect of BMI on safety of bariatric surgery during the COVID-19 pandemic, procedure choice, and safety protocols - An analysis from the GENEVA Study

Rishi Singhal, Islam Omar, Brijesh Madhok, Christian Ludwig, Abd A. Tahrani, Kamal Mahawar

Summary: This study assessed the safety of expedited bariatric surgery for patients with a BMI > 60 kg/m2 during the COVID-19 pandemic. The results showed a higher 30-day mortality rate in patients with BMI > 60 kg/m2, but no significant difference in complication rates compared to other BMI groups, likely due to differences in procedure selection.

OBESITY RESEARCH & CLINICAL PRACTICE (2022)

Article Hematology

The risk of venous thromboembolism after minor surgical procedures: A population-based case-control study

Mark J. R. Smeets, Carolina E. Touw, Frits R. Rosendaal, Banne Nemeth, Suzanne C. Cannegieter

Summary: This study analyzed the influence of different surgical procedures on the risk of VTE. The results showed that although the VTE risk was generally low for most minor surgical procedures, venous stripping, open abdominal/inguinal hernia repair, and laparoscopic cholecystectomy were associated with a significantly increased risk of VTE within 90 postoperative days. These findings suggest the need for enhanced VTE prevention when performing these surgeries.

JOURNAL OF THROMBOSIS AND HAEMOSTASIS (2022)

No Data Available