4.7 Article

A comparison of remotely sensed environmental predictors for avian distributions

Journal

LANDSCAPE ECOLOGY
Volume 37, Issue 4, Pages 997-1016

Publisher

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s10980-022-01406-y

Keywords

Remote sensing; Species distribution models; Landsat; Google Earth Engine

Funding

  1. National Aeronautics and Space Administration [80NSSC20K1664]
  2. National Science Foundation [NSF IIS 1910118]
  3. Bob and Phyllis Mace Professorship

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study evaluated the performance of Landsat data as predictor sets for species distribution models (SDMs), finding that mean values of raw spectral bands are strong predictors for avian SDMs, and that single index models greatly benefit from additional information such as standard deviation.
Context With greater accessibility and processing power from online platforms, summaries of remotely sensed data are increasingly used in species distribution models (SDMs). Comparisons of the predictive power of these environmental variables could inform SDMs moving forward. Objectives We evaluated the performance of freely available Landsat data as predictor sets for SDMs. Our objectives were to (1) compare the performance of single season SDMs built on mean values of raw spectral bands, Tasseled Cap transformations, and eight different indices, including NDVI, (2) evaluate the performance gain with the addition of standard deviation, textural metrics, and additional seasons, and (3) compare the performance of SDMs built on these continuous spectral predictor sets to SDMs built on classified land cover data (e.g., percent forest cover). Methods We used statewide point counts to build multi-scale SDMs for 13 avian species across Oregon, USA. We compared the performance of SDMs built on each predictor set based on our objectives. Results Of the Landsat-derived predictor sets, SDMs built on raw spectral bands had the highest overall performance with nearly equivalent performance in Tasseled-Cap models. While performance gains from standard deviations, textural metrics, and additional seasons were minimal in raw-band and Tasseled-Cap models, gains were appreciable in single-index models. Classified land cover models performed equivalently to raw band models. Conclusions When predictive performance is paramount, means of raw Landsat bands are strong predictors for avian SDMs. When parsimonious variables are essential, SDMs of single indices (e.g., NDVI) greatly benefit from additional information, such as standard deviation.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Building a better baseline to estimate 160 years of avian population change and create historically informed conservation targets

Tyler A. Hallman, W. Douglas Robinson, Jenna R. Curtis, Edward R. Alverson

Summary: The study used a hindcasting framework to estimate distribution and abundance change of 7 bird species in the Willamette Valley, Oregon, demonstrating significant declines in White-breasted Nuthatch and Western Meadowlark populations by 93% and 97% since the 1850s. Despite steep regional declines since the 1960s, five other species showed nearly stable or increasing populations. The historically based conservation targets developed from these estimates can inform current management practices.

CONSERVATION BIOLOGY (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

The influence of rare birds on observer effort and subsequent rarity discovery in the American birdwatching community

Jesse A. Laney, Tyler A. Hallman, Jenna R. Curtis, W. Douglas Robinson

Summary: The study investigated the draw and decay patterns of birders towards rare bird discoveries, revealing that birder effort increases after rarity events but gradually declines over time, with geography and time playing significant roles in attraction. The results did not support the social feedback loop hypothesis.

PEERJ (2021)

Article Ecology

Differential reliance on aquatic prey subsidies influences mercury exposure in riparian arachnids and songbirds

Allyson K. Jackson, Collin A. Eagles-Smith, W. Douglas Robinson

Summary: Cross-ecosystem subsidies play a crucial role in transferring nutrients between ecosystems. This study focuses on the reliance of riparian predators on aquatic prey sources and the correlation between aquatic prey sources and mercury concentrations in arachnids and songbirds. Results show that arachnid families and songbird species vary in their dependency on aquatic prey sources, with a positive correlation between the amount of aquatic prey in their diet and their mercury concentrations. The higher reliance on aquatic prey sources early in the season for songbirds may lead to elevated mercury exposure, potentially impacting their breeding and development.

ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2021)

Article Zoology

A Framework for Investigating Rules of Life Across Disciplines

Ashley W. Poust, Laura Bogar, W. Douglas Robinson, Geoffrey Poole

Summary: Clearly defining the Rules of Life has always been an attractive yet challenging prospect for biologists. This paper explores the interaction of constraints, mechanisms, and requirements, providing a conceptual framework for progress in identifying these rules.

INTEGRATIVE AND COMPARATIVE BIOLOGY (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Characterizing the Influence of Domestic Cats on Birds with Wildlife Rehabilitation Center Data

K. Grace Demezas, W. Douglas Robinson

Summary: The study found that domestic cats mainly prey on commonly near-ground-dwelling bird species, especially in urban environments. Most birds rescued from cats were in direct proportion to their regional abundance, but there was a lack of common species weighing less than 70 g, likely due to sampling bias.

DIVERSITY-BASEL (2021)

Article Ecology

Myoglobin as a conservation-relevant predictor of short-distance flight capacity in Neotropical forest birds

Kelsey Condell, W. Douglas Robinson, Randall P. Moore, Bryan Rourke

Summary: This study found a strong positive relationship between myoglobin concentration in the pectoralis muscles and average overwater flight distance, providing a mechanism to predict species at conservation risk in fragmented landscapes.

BIOTROPICA (2022)

Article Ecology

Rapid elevational shifts of Switzerland's avifauna and associated species traits

Tyler A. Hallman, Jerome Guelat, Sylvain Antoniazza, Marc Kery, Thomas Sattler

Summary: Global change in climate and land use has diverse effects on the geographic and elevational distribution of European birds. Some species show upslope shifts, while others show downslope shifts, and species traits are associated with different patterns of elevation change.

ECOSPHERE (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Dramatic Declines of Evening Grosbeak Numbers at a Spring Migration Stop-Over Site

W. Douglas Robinson, Jessica Greer, Juliana Masseloux, Tyler A. Hallman, Jenna R. Curtis

Summary: This study investigates the decline in Evening Grosbeak populations over the past four decades. The results show a significant decrease in population numbers, consistent with previous bird feeder and breeding bird surveys conducted in North America. Factors such as disease outbreaks and decreased forest structural diversity may contribute to the decline. Further surveys are needed to monitor the population of this charismatic species.

DIVERSITY-BASEL (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Changes over the Last 35 Years in Alaska's Glaciated Landscape: A Novel Deep Learning Approach to Mapping Glaciers at Fine Temporal Granularity

Ben M. Roberts-Pierel, Peter B. Kirchner, John B. Kilbride, Robert E. Kennedy

Summary: This study addresses the limitations of traditional methods for mapping glacier change by developing a novel deep-learning-based approach. The researchers successfully created a record of glacier change in Alaska for over three decades using this method. The results show that the deep learning model can accurately capture the changes in glacier coverage.

REMOTE SENSING (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

A re-survey in 2019-2021 of winter bird communities in the Oregon Coast Range, USA, initially surveyed in 1968-1970

Nolan M. Clements, W. Douglas Robinson

Summary: This study re-surveyed winter forest bird communities in the Pacific Northwest region of the USA to evaluate long-term changes in bird populations. The findings revealed fluctuations in bird populations during winter, providing important baseline data for future research.

BIODIVERSITY DATA JOURNAL (2022)

No Data Available