4.6 Article

Quantifying the effects of varietal types x management on the spatial variability of sorghum biomass across US environments

Journal

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY BIOENERGY
Volume 14, Issue 3, Pages 411-433

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/gcbb.12919

Keywords

APSIM; bioenergy; feedstock; genotype; irrigation; model upscaling; pSIMS; regional modeling; spatial variability; variance partitioning

Funding

  1. Agriculture and Food Research Initiative Competitive, National Institute of Food and Agriculture [2011-68005-30411]
  2. Advanced Research Projects Agency -Energy [DE-AR0001135]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Regional-scale estimations of sorghum biomass production can identify the optimal combinations of genotype, environment, and management for bioenergy generation. This study determined the contributions of genotype, environment, and management to sorghum biomass variability in the United States. The results showed that genotype had the largest impact on biomass variability, followed by environment and management. The findings emphasize the importance of considering these factors in future biomass projections of energy sorghum genotypes.
Regional-scale estimations of sorghum biomass production allow identification of optimum genotypexenvironmentxmanagement (GxExM) combinations for bioenergy generation. The objective of this study was to determine the degree of contributions of G, E, and M toward variability in sorghum biomass in the United States. Using the Agricultural Production Systems sIMulator in a grid computing platform, biomass was simulated for irrigated and rainfed conditions for 30 years across the United States for four sorghum varietal types (grain-GS, sudangrass-SS, photosensitive-PS, and photo-insensitive-PI). Simulated biomass was assessed by environments clustered using the sum of intercepted solar radiation (ir), mean of temperature stress factor (tp) and water stress factor (sw). Simulated biomass ranged from 5.8 t ha(-1) (GS-rainfed) to 27.5 t ha(-1) (PI-irrigated). Under high-temperature environments (mean annual temperature = 25 degrees C), rainfed biomass between 40 and 80 days after planting (DAP) was strongly correlated with sw (r = 0.64-0.86) and irrigated biomass with ir (r = 0.68-0.81). Under low-temperature environments (mean annual temperature = 18 degrees C) after 40 DAP, tp and ir had greater effects than sw (r = 0.55-0.82). Biomass variance was mainly explained by varietal type (50%-76%) in all environmentsxirrigation combinations, except in the high- and mid-temperature environments under rainfed conditions where rainfall had the major effect (25%-45%). However, when mean temperature during the growing season decreased from 25 degrees C (high environments) to 18 degrees C (low environments), the contribution of mean temperature to biomass variance increased from 7% to 34% (rainfed) and from 4% to 36% (irrigated). Varietal type had the larger interactions with other factors independently of the environment and irrigation. We demonstrated a need to quantify (i) the main GxExM drivers of biomass variability based on environmental stress factors and (ii) the variance contribution of these drivers on sorghum biomass. Our regional-scale estimations are key inputs for future robust biomass projections of energy sorghum genotypes integrating GxExM under climate change scenarios.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Agronomy

Sustained improvement in tolerance to water deficit accompanies maize yield increase in temperate environments

Carlos Messina, Ignacio Antonio Ciampitti, Dan Berning, Dave Bubeck, Graeme Hammer, Mark Cooper

Summary: This study evaluated the changes in yield and yield stability after two decades of breeding by comparing two cohorts of hybrids released by the AQUAmax program to a non-AQUAmax control. The results showed that AQUAmax hybrids yielded more than non-AQUAmax hybrids under water deficit conditions, and the difference depended on plant density. The study concluded that deliberate selection of hybrids for yield performance under water deficit contributed to the sustained improvement in yield stability.

CROP SCIENCE (2022)

Review Agronomy

Decomposing crop model uncertainty: A systematic review

Ranju Chapagain, Tomas A. Remenyi, Rebecca M. B. Harris, Caroline L. Mohammed, Neil Huth, Daniel Wallach, Ehsan Eyshi Rezaei, Jonathan J. Ojeda

Summary: Crop models are important tools for analyzing the impact of climate variability and change on crop growth and development. However, these models have inherent uncertainties that are difficult to classify and quantify. This study conducted a systematic review on uncertainty assessments of crop model outputs and found that there is a need for standard procedures to estimate and evaluate crop model uncertainty. The study also highlighted the focus on input uncertainty assessments and the use of sensitivity analysis to quantify different sources of uncertainty.

FIELD CROPS RESEARCH (2022)

Article Agronomy

Retrospective study in US commercial sorghum breeding: II. Physiological changes associated to yield gain

Paula A. A. Demarco, Laura Mayor, Jose L. Rotundo, P. V. Vara Prasad, Geoffrey P. P. Morris, Javier A. A. Fernandez, Santiago Tamagno, Graeme Hammer, Carlos D. D. Messina, Ignacio A. A. Ciampitti

Summary: Understanding the physiological changes in response to long-term selection can inform breeding decisions and accelerate genetic gain for yield. This study characterized changes in yield-related physiological traits for grain sorghum hybrids released between 1963 and 2017. The findings suggest that water-soluble carbohydrates dynamics play a critical role in past genetic yield gain in sorghum and should be considered for future improvements.

CROP SCIENCE (2023)

Article Agronomy

Calibration of a crop growth model in APSIM for 15 publicly available corn hybrids in North America

Cassandra Anne Winn, Sotirios Archontoulis, Jode Edwards

Summary: The study aimed to calibrate and evaluate the accuracy of CGMs in predicting physiological trait differences among different genotypes of maize hybrids. It also aimed to understand the minimum data requirements for calibrating CGM cultivars and to analyze genotype by environment interactions for five traits. The calibration process reduced the error in predicting the traits and identified important physiological traits for further breeding efforts.

CROP SCIENCE (2023)

Article Plant Sciences

A cross-scale analysis to understand and quantify the effects of photosynthetic enhancement on crop growth and yield across environments

Alex Wu, Jason Brider, Florian A. Busch, Min Chen, Karine Chenu, Victoria C. Clarke, Brian Collins, Maria Ermakova, John R. Evans, Graham D. Farquhar, Britta Forster, Robert T. Furbank, Michael Groszmann, Miguel A. Hernandez-Prieto, Benedict M. Long, Greg Mclean, Andries Potgieter, G. Dean Price, Robert E. Sharwood, Michael Stower, Erik van Oosterom, Susanne von Caemmerer, Spencer M. Whitney, Graeme L. Hammer

Summary: Photosynthetic manipulation provides new opportunities for enhancing crop yield, but the understanding of its impact on crop growth and yield in different environments is limited. This study used simulations to predict the effects of altering photosynthesis on wheat and sorghum yield and uncovered the complex interactions between photosynthesis and crop dynamics.

PLANT CELL AND ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Agronomy

Modeling adaptation of sorghum in Ethiopia with APSIM-opportunities with GxExM

Alemu Tirfessa, Fikadu Getachew, Greg McLean, Erik van Oosterom, David Jordan, Graeme Hammer

Summary: Sorghum is an important crop in the dry lowland areas of Ethiopia, and understanding the interactions between traits, environments, and management strategies is crucial for optimizing grain and forage yield. Crop simulation modeling can provide insights into these interactions and help identify adaptation strategies to drought patterns. This study further parameterizes and validates the APSIM-sorghum model for Ethiopian germplasm and quantifies the productivity-risk trade-offs associated with early and late sowing strategies. The results show that late sowing tends to produce less biomass but higher grain yield, except in poor seasons. The study exemplifies a systems approach to identify traits and management options for crop adaptation and highlights the robustness of the sorghum model for this task.

AGRONOMY FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT (2023)

Article Plant Sciences

Differences in temperature responses among phenological processes in diverse Ethiopian sorghum germplasm can affect their specific adaptation to environmental conditions

Alemu Tirfessa, Greg McLean, Peter Baker, Miranda Mortlock, Graeme Hammer, Erik van Oosterom

Summary: Through creating temperature differences, it was found that temperature affects the total leaf number in sorghum, with a higher base temperature for leaf appearance rate than for pre-anthesis development rate. Genotypic and racial differences in responses to temperature can affect specific adaptation to agroecological zones.

ANNALS OF BOTANY (2023)

Article Agronomy

Retrospective study in US commercial sorghum breeding: I. Genetic gain in relation to relative maturity

Laura Mayor, Paula Demarco, Sara Lira, Yinan Fang, Tabare Abadie, Brenda L. L. Gambin, Graeme Hammer, Ignacio Ciampitti, Mark Cooper, Carlos Messina

Summary: This article reports the rate of sorghum genetic gain in a commercial breeding program in the United States and provides evidence that a modest yield improvement is an important factor limiting land allocation to this crop. The study shows a positive rate of genetic gain of 2.63 g m(-2) y(-1) on average across three different maturity groups grown in the United States. However, these rates are insufficient to reverse the negative trend in planted area.

CROP SCIENCE (2023)

Editorial Material Environmental Sciences

The missing markets link in global-to-local-to-global analyses of biodiversity and ecosystem services

Alfredo Cisneros-Pineda, Jeffrey S. Dukes, Justin Johnson, Sylvie Brouder, Navin Ramankutty, Erwin Corong, Abhishek Chaudhary

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2023)

Review Plant Sciences

Two decades of harnessing standing genetic variation for physiological traits to improve drought tolerance in maize

Carlos D. Messina, Carla Gho, Graeme L. Hammer, Tom Tang, Mark Cooper

Summary: In this study, we reviewed maize breeding approaches for improved drought tolerance and found that after two decades of breeding efforts, the improvement rate under drought conditions increased, closing the genetic gain gap with water-sufficient conditions. This improvement was achieved by harnessing favorable alleles for physiological traits available in the reference population. We also demonstrated that incorporating physiological understanding into genomic selection methods using crop growth models can accelerate genetic gain under drought.

JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL BOTANY (2023)

Article Agronomy

Framework to develop an open-source forage data network to improve primary productivity and enhance system resiliency

A. J. Ashworth, L. Marshall, J. J. Volenec, M. D. Casler, M. T. Berti, E. van Santen, C. L. Williams, V. Gopakumar, J. L. Foster, T. Propst, V. Picasso, J. Su

Summary: This paper outlines the development of a community-driven forage database (Forage Data Hub) using legacy datasets to analyze system functionality and resiliency. The study demonstrates that diverse perennial systems have greater resiliency compared to annual forage systems under climate-related stresses. The development of the database underscores the benefits of community-driven data sharing and curation for sustainable agriculture.

AGRONOMY JOURNAL (2023)

Article Agronomy

Maize leaf angle genetic gain is slowing down in the last decades

Elvis F. Elli, Jode Edwards, Jianming Yu, Slobodan Trifunovic, Douglas M. Eudy, Kevin R. Kosola, Patrick S. Schnable, Kendall R. Lamkey, Sotirios V. Archontoulis

Summary: This study quantified historical changes in maize leaf angle and identified the factors affecting it. The research found that over a century of breeding, there has been a consistent trend towards more vertical leaves in maize hybrids. However, the genetic gain in leaf angle is slowing down in recent decades. Breeding and plant density have similarly contributed to leaf angle changes in the middle canopy, while changes in the bottom and top canopy leaves were mainly attributed to breeding. Vertical leaves at the top and horizontal leaves at the bottom were found to be beneficial for the yields of modern maize hybrids.

CROP SCIENCE (2023)

Article Ecology

Assessing the effect of using different APSIM model configurations on model outputs

Ranju Chapagain, Neil Huth, Tomas A. Remenyi, Caroline L. Mohammed, Jonathan J. Ojeda

Summary: The three major sources of uncertainty in crop models are model inputs, structure and parameters. This study aims to quantify the contribution of structural uncertainty to model outputs produced by the Agricultural Production Systems sIMulator (APSIM). Eight model structures were developed and tested under three contrasting environments. It was found that most structural uncertainty resulted from the choice of model components, rather than interactions between components. The effects of structural uncertainty were strongly impacted by site and climate conditions.

ECOLOGICAL MODELLING (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Sustainable intensification with irrigation raises farm profit despite climate emergency

Albert Muleke, Matthew Tom Harrison, Rowan Eisner, Peter de Voil, Maria Yanotti, Ke Liu, Marta Monjardino, Xiaogang Yin, Weilu Wang, Jiangwen Nie, Carla Ferreira, Jin Zhao, Feng Zhang, Shah Fahad, Narasinha Shurpali, Puyu Feng, Yunbo Zhang, Daniel Forster, Rui Yang, Zhiming Qi, Wang Fei, Xionghui Gao, Jianguo Man, Lixiao Nie

Summary: While comprising a small proportion of global agricultural land use, irrigated agriculture plays a crucial role in the global agricultural economy. To ensure profitability under future climates, sustainable intensification through crop rotations, efficient water application infrastructure, and increased farm area under irrigation is essential. This research highlights the complex interplay between climate change, land-use changes, and farm profitability.

PLANTS PEOPLE PLANET (2023)

Article Agronomy

Modelling the dynamics and phenotypic consequences of tiller outgrowth and cessation in sorghum

G. L. Hammer, G. Mclean, J. Kholova, E. van Oosterom

Summary: Tillering dynamics play a crucial role in crop growth and yield, and a generic model has been developed to predict tillering process, which has implications in studying crop adaptation, guiding molecular discovery and enhancing genetic gain in crops.

IN SILICO PLANTS (2023)

No Data Available