4.7 Article

ASHRAE Likelihood of Dissatisfaction: A new right-here and right-now thermal comfort index for assessing the Likelihood of dissatisfaction according to the ASHRAE adaptive comfort model

Journal

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS
Volume 250, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCIENCE SA
DOI: 10.1016/j.enbuild.2021.111286

Keywords

Thermal comfort; ASHRAE Standard 55; Adaptive comfort; Logistic regression; Likelihood of dissatisfied

Funding

  1. European Union [894712]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study proposes a new index ALD for assessing short-term thermal comfort conditions in buildings, which has been successfully externally validated and shown to be reliable and generalizable.
ABSTR A C T The assessment of local and short-term thermal discomfort in buildings has been widely investigated, and different metrics are available in the literature to predict the likelihood of dissatisfied people. These metrics are named right-here and right-now discomfort indexes and constitute the basis for evalu-ating long-term thermal comfort conditions in buildings. Well-known examples are the Predicted Percentage of Dissatisfied (PPD) part of the Fanger comfort model included in the ISO standard 7730 and the Overheating risk index (NaOR), built upon the EN adaptive thermal comfort model. This study proposes a new index for use with the ASHRAE adaptive thermal comfort model to fill a gap in the liter-ature and standard. It is called the ASHRAE Likelihood of Dissatisfaction (ALD) and is obtained from a logistic regression of the right-here and right-now thermal comfort field data contained in the 1990s ASHRAE RP-884 database. The recent release of another, more extensive database of thermal comfort field studies, the ASHRAE Global Thermal Comfort Database II, provides an opportunity to validate ALD with an independent dataset and assess its generalisability. The successful external validation of ALD and its agreement with NaOR give support to the reliability of the novel right-here and right-now index and open to the possibility to use it for assessing short-term thermal comfort conditions in buildings, cal-culating long-term thermal comfort indices based on the ASHRAE adaptive model, optimising both the design of new buildings and renovations and for assessing the operational thermal comfort performance of existing buildings. (c) 2021 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Construction & Building Technology

The health benefits of greening strategies to cool urban environments-A heat health impact method

Mahsan Sadeghi, Timothy Chaston, Ivan Hanigan, Richard de Dear, Mattheos Santamouris, Bin Jalaludin, Geoffrey G. Morgan

Summary: This study develops a novel method to quantify the benefits of green infrastructure on urban heat balance and population mortality. The results demonstrate that green infrastructure can cool urban environments and reduce heatwave-related mortality.

BUILDING AND ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Solar Chimney Power Plants: A Review of the Concepts, Designs and Performances

Erdem Cuce, Pinar Mert Cuce, Salvatore Carlucci, Harun Sen, Kumarasamy Sudhakar, Md. Hasanuzzaman, Reza Daneshazarian

Summary: This research comprehensively evaluates solar chimney power plants as a reliable source of renewable electricity generation, covering design aspects, theoretical and experimental findings, and performance. It discusses the optimization strategies, advantages, disadvantages, limitations, energy storage aspects, and hybrid system designs of solar chimney power plants. The study provides valuable insights for designers and policymakers to make better-informed decisions.

SUSTAINABILITY (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Associations between spatial attributes, IEQ exposures and occupant movement behaviour in an open-plan office

Brett Pollard, Lina Engelen, Fabian Held, Joseph Van Buskirk, Richard Spinney, Richard de Dear

Summary: The movement behavior of office workers is influenced by spatial and environmental attributes. Increased visibility of colleagues is associated with reduced movement, while the distance to office destinations is positively associated with the duration of movement. Associations with IEQ exposures are primarily related to stationary behaviors. These findings suggest potential avenues for design and policy-based interventions to reduce stationary time and increase movement in the workplace.

BUILDING AND ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Comparison of residential thermal comfort in two different climates in Australia

Bongchan Jeong, Jungsoo Kim, Dong Chen, Richard de Dear

Summary: This study examines the perception of thermal comfort and behavioral adaptation of residents in Sydney and Brisbane, Australia. The statistical analysis reveals that the current international standard of adaptive comfort model may not be suitable for residential buildings, and suggests expanding the acceptable temperature range to around 11 K. The findings also demonstrate that the climate influences the shifting of the 80% acceptability range.

BUILDING AND ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Developing a window behaviour model incorporating A/C operation states

Bongchan Jeong, Jungsoo Kim, Dong Chen, Richard de Dear

Summary: This study aimed to develop a stochastic window operation model that considers the interdependency between occupant's window and A/C operation. The proposed model was tested through field observations and simulations, and a critical temperature for the influence of outdoor temperature on window opening was identified. The model can improve the accuracy of building energy performance and indoor environment simulations.

BUILDING AND ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Effect of adaptive opportunity on cognitive performance in warm environments

Naoe Nishihara, Jing Xiong, Jungsoo Kim, Hui Zhu, Richard de Dear

Summary: This study investigates the impact of thermal adaptive opportunities on cognitive performance and mental workload of building occupants. The findings suggest that the availability of adaptive opportunities can improve cognitive task performance and reduce mental fatigue, especially in a moderately warm environment.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Urban vulnerability in the EMME region and sustainable development goals: A new conceptual framework

Ioanna Kyprianou, Despina Serghides, Salvatore Carlucci

Summary: This study aims to investigate urban vulnerabilities related to climate change, focusing on urban centers in the Eastern Mediterranean and Middle East region. Using a content-based approach similar to bibliometrics, the study identifies major trends in urban vulnerability research and offers a tentative definition of its impact on public health.

SUSTAINABLE CITIES AND SOCIETY (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Restorative benefits of semi-outdoor environments at the workplace: Does the thermal realm matter?

Kun Lyu, Richard de Dear, Arianna Brambilla, Anastasia Globa

Summary: The experience of nature has psychological benefits and incorporating natural elements in workplaces can improve productivity and well-being. However, the role of thermal perception in psychological restoration has been overlooked. This study found a significant association between thermal pleasure and restorative benefits in semi-outdoor workplace environments.

BUILDING AND ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Adapting the two-node model to evaluate sleeping thermal environments

Shujie Yan, Jing Xiong, Jungsoo Kim, Richard de Dear

Summary: This study proposes a method to assess sleeping thermal environment by modifying and converting an existing model, which has been validated through practical application. The research findings provide guidance for developing optimal bedroom temperature control strategies to enhance sleep thermal comfort.

BUILDING AND ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Thermodynamics

Development of a probabilistic behavioural model creating diverse A/C operation patterns of households

Bongchan Jeong, Jungsoo Kim, Dong Chen, Richard de Dear

Summary: Studies on modelling residential occupant behaviour have gained popularity, but average behaviour profiles are insufficient for accurately predicting energy consumption. This study aims to develop a model that incorporates the diversity of occupants' behaviours and accurately predicts air-conditioning usage in residential settings. Field observations and simulations were conducted, demonstrating the model's predictive skill.

ENERGY (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Analysis of subjective thermal comfort data: A statistical point of view

Matteo Favero, Antonio Luparelli, Salvatore Carlucci

Summary: Thermal comfort research aims to study the relationship between thermal environment and human sense of warmth, usually through subjective thermal response. However, using linear regression to analyze ordinal data may result in severe errors. This study establishes methodological foundations for analyzing subjective thermal comfort data and demonstrates the practical consequences of fallacious assumptions through a Bayesian approach. The findings highlight the importance of using ordinal models instead of metric models for analyzing ordinal data.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Mitigation and adaptation strategies to offset the impacts of climate change on urban health: A European perspective

Ioanna Kyprianou, Georgios Artopoulos, Anna Bonomolo, Timothy Brownlee, Rita Avila Cachado, Chiara Camaioni, Vladan Dokic, Rosalba D'Onofrio, Zoran Dukanovic, Salvatore Fasola, Caterina Francesca Di Giovanni, Roberta Cocci Grifoni, Panos Hadjinicolaou, Giacomo Ilardo, Predrag Jovanovic, Stefania La Grutta, Velia Malizia, Graziano Enzo Marchesani, Maria Federica Ottone, Elio Trusiani, Jelena Zivkovic, Salvatore Carlucci

Summary: Climate change poses a threat to urban health, and urban regeneration initiatives should incorporate strategies to mitigate climate-exacerbated phenomena. Engaging civic society and promoting collaboration are key factors in designing equitable urban spaces and addressing vulnerabilities.

BUILDING AND ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

A socio-cultural perspective to semi-outdoor thermal experience and restorative benefits-Comparison between Chinese and Australian cultural groups

Kun Lyu, Arianna Brambilla, Anastasia Globa, Richard de Dear

Summary: Thermal experiences in outdoor and semi-outdoor environments have a significant impact on people's overall nature experience and restorative benefits. This research compares the differences in thermal pleasure, adaptive behaviours, and restorative benefits between Chinese and Australian cultural groups in identical semi-outdoor environments. The study found that Chinese participants generally felt thermally unpleasant and engaged in sunlight avoidance behaviours, while Australian participants felt thermally pleasant and engaged in sunlight maximising behaviours. Access to shade as an adaptive opportunity can potentially reduce cultural differences in thermal pleasure and restorative benefits resulting from outdoor exposures.

BUILDING AND ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

A comparison of air temperature thresholds for warm thermal discomfort between pre- and post-menopausal women

Sarah Carter, Nicole T. Vargas, Richard de Dear, Kirsten I. Black, Ollie Jay

Summary: The study compared the ambient temperature thresholds for warm thermal discomfort, thermal unacceptability, and preference for cooler environment between post- and pre-menopausal women at different metabolic rates. The results showed that while a higher metabolic rate led to a lower air temperature threshold for warm thermal discomfort, there was no difference in this threshold between pre-menopausal and post-menopausal women, regardless of metabolic rate. However, post-menopausal women reported an environment to be unacceptably warm and expressed a preference for a cooler temperature at a lower ambient and forehead skin temperature.

BUILDING AND ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Overheating calculation methods, criteria, and indicators in European regulation for residential buildings

Shady Attia, Caroline Benzidane, Ramin Rahif, Deepak Amaripadath, Mohamed Hamdy, Peter Holzer, Annekatrin Koch, Anton Maas, Sven Moosberger, Steffen Petersen, Anna Mavrogianni, Juan Maria Hidalgo-Betanzos, Manuela Almeida, Jan Akander, Hossein Khosravi Bakhtiari, Olivier Kinnane, Risto Kosonen, Salvatore Carlucci

Summary: This study investigates Europe's overheating calculation methods, indicators, and thresholds and evaluates their ability to address climate change and heat events. The study provides a cross-sectional overview of twenty-six European countries, listing the most influential overheating calculation criteria and ranking the best approaches. The results suggest a framework and key performance indicators that can help modify the EU's next building energy efficiency regulations.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Cool roof strategies for urban thermal resilience to extreme heatwaves in tropical cities

Samiran Khorat, Debashish Das, Rupali Khatun, Sk Mohammad Aziz, Prashant Anand, Ansar Khan, Mattheos Santamouris, Dev Niyogi

Summary: Cool roofs can effectively mitigate heatwave-induced excess heat and enhance thermal comfort in urban areas. Implementing cool roofs can significantly improve urban meteorology and thermal comfort, reducing energy flux and heat stress.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2024)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Estimating omnidirectional urban vertical wind speed with direction-dependent building morphologies

Qi Li, Jiayu Chen, Xiaowei Luo

Summary: This study focuses on the vertical wind conditions as a main external factor that limits the energy assessment of high-rise buildings in urban areas. Traditional tools for energy assessment of buildings use a universal vertical wind profile estimation, without taking into account the unique wind speed in each direction induced by the various shapes and configurations of buildings in cities. To address this limitation, the study developed an omnidirectional urban vertical wind speed estimation method using direction-dependent building morphologies and machine learning algorithms.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2024)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Towards a blockchain and machine learning-based framework for decentralised energy management

Xiaojun Luo, Lamine Mahdjoubi

Summary: This paper presents an integrated blockchain and machine learning-based energy management framework for multiple forms of energy allocation and transmission among multiple domestic buildings. Machine learning is used to predict energy generation and consumption patterns, and the proposed framework establishes optimal and automated energy allocation through peer-to-peer energy transactions. The approach contributes to the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and enhances environmental sustainability.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2024)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Dual-layer optimization design method for collaborative benefits of renewable energy systems in building clusters: Case study of campus buildings

Ying Yu, Yuanwei Xiao, Jinshuai Chou, Xingyu Wang, Liu Yang

Summary: This study proposes a dual-layer optimization design method to maximize the energy sharing potential, enhance collaborative benefits, and reduce the storage capacity of building clusters. Case studies show that the proposed design significantly improves the performance of building clusters, reduces energy storage capacity, and shortens the payback period.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2024)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Model predictive control of distributed energy resources in residential buildings considering forecast uncertainties

Felix Langner, Weimin Wang, Moritz Frahm, Veit Hagenmeyer

Summary: This paper compares two main approaches to consider uncertainties in model predictive control (MPC) for buildings: robust and stochastic MPC. The results show that compared to a deterministic MPC, the robust MPC increases the electricity cost while providing complete temperature constraint satisfaction, while the stochastic MPC slightly increases the electricity cost but fulfills the thermal comfort requirements.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2024)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Comprehensive assessment of double skin façades: A mathematical model for evaluating influence of KL ratio on electrical and thermal performances, and indoor conditions

Somil Yadav, Caroline Hachem-Vermette

Summary: This study proposes a mathematical model to evaluate the performance of a Double Skin Facade (DSF) system and its impact on indoor conditions. The model considers various design parameters and analyzes their effects on the system's electrical output and room temperature.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2024)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Improving building resilience in the face of future climate uncertainty: A comprehensive framework for enhancing building life cycle performance

Ruijun Chen, Holly Samuelson, Yukai Zou, Xianghan Zheng, Yifan Cao

Summary: This research introduces an innovative resilient design framework that optimizes building performance by considering a holistic life cycle perspective and accounting for climate projection uncertainties. The study finds that future climate scenarios significantly impact building life cycle performance, with wall U-value, windows U-value, and wall density being major factors. By using ensemble learning and optimization algorithms, predictions for carbon emissions, cost, and indoor discomfort hours can be made, and the best resilient design scheme can be selected. Applying this framework leads to significant improvements in building life cycle performance.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2024)