4.2 Review

From Hazard Mitigation to Climate Adaptation: A Review of Home Buyout Program Literature

Journal

HOUSING POLICY DEBATE
Volume 32, Issue 1, Pages 152-170

Publisher

ROUTLEDGE JOURNALS, TAYLOR & FRANCIS LTD
DOI: 10.1080/10511482.2021.1931930

Keywords

buyouts; organized retreat; climate adaptation; disaster; literature review; HMGP

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This systematic literature review of voluntary buyouts in the United States distills key learnings, identifies remaining gaps, presents avenues for future research, and makes policy recommendations. It finds that the buyout literature is nascent, but coalesces around the topics of buyout experience, practice and implementation, housing policy, flood reduction, and justice and equity. Recommendations include an increased emphasis on theory, contexts in which buyouts occur, longitudinal studies, and more explicit recognition of researcher and discipline bias.
With the onset of climate change resulting in more frequent hazard events and coastal inundation, communities are considering buyouts as a tool for climate adaptation. Despite a growing body of research, there has never been a systematic review of the literature on buyout programs, although our ability to implement buyouts successfully relies on a thorough understanding of buyout policy, design, implementation, and impacts. In this systematic literature review of voluntary buyouts in the United States, we distill key learnings, identify remaining gaps, present avenues for future research, and make policy recommendations. We find that the buyout literature is nascent, but coalesces around the topics of buyout experience, buyout practice and implementation, housing policy, flood reduction, and justice and equity. Recommendations for future research include an increased emphasis on theory, the contexts in which buyouts occur, longitudinal studies, and more explicit recognition of researcher and disciplinary bias.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.2
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Engineering, Civil

Household adjustment to seismicity in Oklahoma

Alex Greer, Hao-Che Wu, Haley Murphy

EARTHQUAKE SPECTRA (2020)

Article Engineering, Civil

Perceived Stakeholder Information Credibility and Hazard Adjustments: A Case of Induced Seismic Activities in Oklahoma

Hao-Che Wu, Alex Greer, Haley Murphy

NATURAL HAZARDS REVIEW (2020)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

A system disconnected: perspectives on post-disaster housing recovery policy and programs

Alex Greer, Joseph E. Trainor

Summary: This study provides insights from individuals working to reestablish permanent housing in Sea Bright, NJ, following Hurricane Sandy. Data was collected through questionnaires and interviews, revealing a fundamental disconnect between policymakers and homeowners in the housing recovery process. Survivors highlighted issues with complex paperwork, unfavorable government interactions, and constantly changing rules associated with aid.

NATURAL HAZARDS (2021)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Enhancing adaptive performance in emergency response: Empowerment practices and the moderating role of tempo balance

David Huntsman, Alex Greer, Haley Murphy, Steven Haynes

Summary: The study found that empowerment practices positively impact firefighters' adaptive performance, helping them cope with stress and fatigue by compensating for poor tempo balance in fire departments, thus enabling them to better deal with complex incidents.

SAFETY SCIENCE (2021)

Article Environmental Studies

What Matters? Exploring Drivers of Basic and Complex Adjustments to Tornadoes among College Students

David Huntsman, Hao-Che Wu, Alex Greer

Summary: This study explores the impact of threat and coping appraisals on hazard adjustment intentions among college students in response to tornado risk. Findings indicate that threat appraisals become more important for influencing adjustment intentions when activities are complex, while coping appraisals are crucial for basic hazard adjustment intentions. These insights have practical implications for emergency management and future hazard adjustment studies.

WEATHER CLIMATE AND SOCIETY (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Does etiology matter? Exploring attitudes towards tornado and earthquake hazards

Alex Greer, Hao-Che Wu, Haley Murphy

Summary: This study explores the factors that shape Oklahomans' attitudes toward tornado and earthquake hazards. Findings suggest that Oklahomans believe the earthquake threat is more novel than the tornado threat, and that they have slightly more dread regarding earthquakes than tornadoes on average. Furthermore, respondents who identify as more liberal are more likely to have negative emotions regarding earthquakes, but not tornadoes. Several demographic variables also predict differences in negative emotion toward earthquakes and tornadoes.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DISASTER RISK REDUCTION (2022)

Article Social Sciences, Interdisciplinary

The effects of empowerment at multiple leadership levels in the fire service: a moderated mediation model

David Huntsman, Alex Greer, Haley Murphy, Xiangyu (Dale) Li

Summary: This study shows that mid-level supervisors can help firefighters enhance improvisation skills during emergency response, leading to improved adaptive performance in fire departments. It also suggests that effective, empowering senior leaders are necessary to achieve higher levels of empowerment and adaptive performance, especially when immediate supervisors play a key role in overcoming senior leader deficiencies.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EMERGENCY SERVICES (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Using the past to understand future property acquisitions: an examination of historic voluntary and mandatory household relocations

Elyse Zavar, Sherri Brokopp Binder, Alex Greer, Amber Breaux

Summary: As climate change worsens hazard losses in the USA, communities are seeking to relocate households permanently to reduce exposure to hazards. Harris County, Texas, has used both voluntary buyouts and eminent domain to relocate households out of flood-prone areas, but there is limited research on mandated relocations due to climate-induced hazards.

NATURAL HAZARDS (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

Household hurricane evacuation during a dual-threat event: Hurricane Laura and COVID-19

Alex Greer, David Huntsman, Hao-Che Wu, Haley Murphy, Lauren Clay

Summary: This study explores household-level evacuation decision-making during Hurricane Laura and investigates the impact of COVID-19 measures on evacuation. The results show that while COVID-19 measures did not have a direct effect on evacuation, they had indirect effects through other factors. The study also found other common drivers of evacuation decisions.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART D-TRANSPORT AND ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

Home buyouts: a tool for mitigation or recovery?

Sherri Brokopp Binder, Alex Greer, Elyse Zavar

DISASTER PREVENTION AND MANAGEMENT (2020)

Article Public Administration

Leveraging Justice: How Leaders Influence Performance Determinants in the Fire Service

David Huntsman, Alex Greer, Haley Murphy

RISK HAZARDS & CRISIS IN PUBLIC POLICY (2020)

Article Demography

Place attachment in disaster studies: measurement and the case of the 2013 Moore tornado

Alex Greer, Sherri Brokopp Binder, Alexis Thiel, Mehdi Jamali, Ali Nejat

POPULATION AND ENVIRONMENT (2020)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Association between long-term stressors and mental health distress following the 2013 Moore tornado: a pilot study

Lauren A. Clay, Alex Greer

JOURNAL OF PUBLIC MENTAL HEALTH (2019)

Article Regional & Urban Planning

Maintaining the status quo: understanding local use of resilience strategies to address earthquake risk in Oklahoma

Ray HsienHo Chang, Alex Greer, Haley Murphy, Hao-Che (Tristan) Wu, Steven Melton

LOCAL GOVERNMENT STUDIES (2019)

No Data Available