4.4 Article

Can Filter Bubbles Protect Information Freedom? Discussions of Algorithmic News Recommenders in Eastern Europe

Journal

DIGITAL JOURNALISM
Volume -, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ROUTLEDGE JOURNALS, TAYLOR & FRANCIS LTD
DOI: 10.1080/21670811.2021.1970601

Keywords

Digital news; news personalization; algorithms; filter bubbles; post-Soviet

Categories

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The increasing use of recommender systems for personalized news delivery has global influence on media systems. Assessments of news personalization effects are mainly based on observations from Western democracies, raising concerns about their applicability to other contexts. This study examines the promises and threats of news personalization in countries with limited press freedom, such as Belarus, Russia, and Ukraine.
The increasing use of recommender systems to provide personalized news delivery influences media systems worldwide. Using different data sources to predict what content will be interesting for specific readers, recommender systems can better accommodate individual information needs, but also raise concerns about potential audience fragmentation. However, current assessments of the effects of news personalization are predominantly based on observations from Western democracies. This Western-centric approach raises concerns about these assessments' applicability to other contexts, in particular non-democratic ones, and brings to question the influence of prevalent Western conceptualisations of news personalization (e.g., filter bubbles) on attitudes towards it in non-Western countries. To address this gap, we scrutinize discussions of the promises and threats of news personalization in countries characterized by limited press freedom: Belarus, Russia and Ukraine. Using document analysis, we examine how three categories of actors-academics, journalists and IT specialists-discuss news personalization and the ways it can affect the public sphere. Through our analysis we uncover how Western conceptualisations of news personalization interact with discussions about it in non-democratic media systems and scrutinize whether existing concerns about personalization are applicable to non-Western contexts.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

The Matter of Chance: Auditing Web Search Results Related to the 2020 US Presidential Primary Elections Across Six Search Engines

Aleksandra Urman, Mykola Makhortykh, Roberto Ulloa

Summary: The study reveals substantial differences in search results among different search engines under non-personalized conditions, as well as discrepancies within results generated for different agents. The randomization of search results determines if users see certain information, and some search engines prioritize different categories of information sources for specific candidates.

SOCIAL SCIENCE COMPUTER REVIEW (2022)

Article Communication

Selling internet control: the framing of the Russian ban of messaging app Telegram

Marielle Wijermars

Summary: This article examines how the Russian government justifies and garners popular support for restricting online freedoms, with a focus on the case of Telegram being banned in 2018. The study found that media framing of the ban was more diverse than the official governmental line, with the 'rule of law' frame occurring most frequently.

INFORMATION COMMUNICATION & SOCIETY (2022)

Article Communication

How to Reach Nirvana: Yandex, News Personalisation, and the Future of Russian Journalistic Media

Olga Dovbysh, Marielle Wijermars, Mykola Makhortykh

Summary: Technological corporations and digital services are increasingly influential in news production and dissemination, particularly through the use of algorithmic recommender systems. This article investigates the relationship between Russian media outlets and Yandex, focusing on the personalized content recommendation platform Yandex.Zen and its content prioritization program Nirvana. It explores how power dynamics within the recommender system's multi-stakeholder environment affect journalistic practices.

DIGITAL JOURNALISM (2022)

Article Computer Science, Information Systems

Scaling up search engine audits: Practical insights for algorithm auditing

Roberto Ulloa, Mykola Makhortykh, Aleksandra Urman

Summary: This article discusses the challenges, methodological details, recommendations, lessons learned, and limitations of using virtual agents for algorithm audits. It demonstrates successful experiences in setting up experiments for different search engines and multiple data collections, highlighting changes and strategies to improve method quality.

JOURNAL OF INFORMATION SCIENCE (2022)

Article Communication

Sociotechnical imaginaries of algorithmic governance in EU policy on online disinformation and FinTech

Marielle Wijermars, Mykola Makhortykh

Summary: The use of datafication and algorithmic systems blurs boundaries between policy fields, as seen in the European Union's different sociotechnical imaginaries of algorithmic governance in online disinformation and FinTech.

NEW MEDIA & SOCIETY (2022)

Article Communication

Not all who are bots are evil: A cross-platform analysis of automated agent governance

Mykola Makhortykh, Aleksandra Urman, Felix Victor Muench, Amelie Heldt, Stephan Dreyer, Matthias C. Kettemann

Summary: The growth of online platforms has led to the increasing use of automated agents. While primarily discussed in the context of opinion manipulation, agents play diverse roles within platform ecosystems, necessitating governance approaches that go beyond monitoring agents' undesirable behavior. To provide a more comprehensive understanding of agent governance, an analytical framework is introduced to differentiate between different aspects and forms of governance. This framework is then applied to examine the governance of agents across nine platforms. The findings show that while platforms acknowledge the various roles of agents, they tend to focus on governing specific forms of misuse. Variations in governance approaches, particularly concerning agent rights/obligations and transparency of policing mechanisms, are also observed. These observations underscore the need for advancing research on algorithmic governance and developing a generalizable normative framework for agent governance.

NEW MEDIA & SOCIETY (2022)

Article Communication

Laughing to forget or to remember? Anne Frank memes and mediatization of Holocaust memory

Juan Manuel Gonzalez-Aguilar, Mykola Makhortykh

Summary: The rise of user-generated content presents both positive and negative impacts on the mediatization of historical memory. Internet memes have various functions, including trivializing Holocaust memory, reinforcing canonical narratives, and depending on other forms of memory mediatization.

MEDIA CULTURE & SOCIETY (2022)

Article Communication

News, Threats, and Trust: How COVID-19 News Shaped Political Trust, and How Threat Perceptions Conditioned This Relationship

Ernesto de Leon, Mykola Makhortykh, Teresa Gil-Lopez, Aleksandra Urman, Silke Adam

Summary: This study examines the changes in political trust during the COVID-19 pandemic outbreak in Switzerland and investigates the roles of media consumption and threat perceptions in individuals' trust in politics. The findings reveal that political trust increased following the lockdown, while consumption of mainstream news on COVID-19 hindered this increase. Moreover, threat perceptions to health and government policy response had opposite effects on political trust, and these perceptions also moderated the impact of COVID-19 news consumption on government trust.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PRESS-POLITICS (2023)

Article Communication

Media Trust and the COVID-19 Pandemic: An Analysis of Short-Term Trust Changes, Their Ideological Drivers and Consequences in Switzerland

Silke Adam, Aleksandra Urman, Dorothee Arlt, Teresa Gil-Lopez, Mykola Makhortykh, Michaela Maier

Summary: We analyzed short-term changes in media trust during the COVID-19 pandemic in German-speaking Switzerland, focusing on its ideological drivers and consequences. Our findings highlight the significance of media trust in influencing people's willingness to comply with COVID-19 regulations. Media trust levels decreased for most media outlets during the pandemic, with the exception of public service broadcasting. Unlike the United States, Switzerland did not experience a partisan trust divide.

COMMUNICATION RESEARCH (2023)

Article Communication

Populist Right Parties on TikTok: Spectacularization, Personalization, and Hate Speech

Juan Manuel Gonzalez-Aguilar, Francisco Segado-Boj, Mykola Makhortykh

Summary: This article examines the strategies used by right-wing populist parties and politicians on TikTok, focusing on the presence of hate speech and entertaining features in their videos. The study finds that Vox and UKIP use TikTok to convey their ideology and target the state as the enemy, while Kast utilizes the platform to build his leadership image and share humorous content. Only 19% of the analyzed videos include hate speech, which not only is uncommon but also deters user engagement. In contrast, humor and entertainment enhance user engagement. The study suggests that TikTok may downplay the most controversial issues of right-wing populism.

MEDIA AND COMMUNICATION (2023)

Article Communication

The politics of internet freedom rankings

Tetyana Lokot, Marielle Wijermars

Summary: International rankings have a significant impact on defining and highlighting the issues they aim to capture. In the past two decades, the proliferation of indexes measuring internet freedom worldwide has increased due to the expansion of internet access. This article examines the politics behind these rankings, which have become influential in shaping the understanding of internet freedom and serving as tools of political or diplomatic influence.

INTERNET POLICY REVIEW (2023)

Article Communication

#Azovsteel: Comparing qualitative and quantitative approaches for studying framing of the siege of Mariupol on Twitter

Michael Tschirky, Mykola Makhortykh

Summary: Social media platforms play a crucial role in shaping public perception of contemporary wars, including the ongoing Russian invasion of Ukraine. However, studying how these platforms represent violence and the aspects that users emphasize presents multiple challenges. The authors compare qualitative content analysis and topic modeling to investigate the framing of the siege of Mariupol in 2022 on Twitter during the Russian-Ukrainian war. Their findings reveal similarities in the prevalence of human interest and conflict frames, consistent with previous research, but also identify differences in the visibility of less common frames such as morality and responsibility, depending on the method used.

MEDIA WAR AND CONFLICT (2023)

Article Communication

Personalizing the war: Perspectives for the adoption of news recommendation algorithms in the media coverage of the conflict in Eastern Ukraine

Mykola Makhortykh, Mariella Bastian

Summary: The use of algorithmically tailored individual news feeds is seen as an important strategy for legacy media to meet consumers' information needs. However, this personalization of news distribution raises concerns about the societal function of legacy media, especially when dealing with traumatic and divisive content. This article provides a conceptual assessment of adopting personalization for conflict coverage in Ukraine and Russia, where press freedom is limited.

MEDIA WAR AND CONFLICT (2022)

Article Communication

Animating the subjugated past: digital greeting cards as a form of counter-memory

Mykola Makhortykh, Maryna Sydorova

Summary: This article discusses the interaction between digital greeting cards and hegemonic historical narratives in war remembrance contexts. It uses Foucault's concept of counter-memory to analyze the interaction between user-generated mnemonic content and historical power relations. Through content analysis of amateur greeting cards, the authors investigate how these cultural products engage with official and counter-official memory practices in Russia related to the Soviet victory in the Second World War. The article explores how different visual elements are used to (de)construct specific narratives about the Soviet victory and discusses how the use of computer graphics, particularly animation, influences the potential role of greeting cards in resurrecting the suppressed past.

VISUAL COMMUNICATION (2022)

No Data Available