4.5 Article

Express yourself: Facial expression of happiness, anger, fear, and sadness in funding pitches

Journal

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS VENTURING
Volume 36, Issue 4, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.jbusvent.2021.106109

Keywords

Entrepreneurial funding pitch; Emotion; Emotional expression; Facial expression; Basic emotions; Object of emotion; Mixed methods; Qualitative; Happiness; Anger; Fear; Sadness; Passion

Categories

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The study examines the relationship between facial expressions of happiness, anger, fear, and sadness and entrepreneurial fundraising, finding that frequent expression of happiness, anger, and fear is positively correlated with funding, while frequent expression of sadness is negatively correlated. Additionally, the frequency of changes in entrepreneurs' facial expressions is shown to promote funding.
We build upon theory from evolutionary psychology and emotional expression, including basic emotion theory and the dual threshold model of anger in organizations, to extend knowledge about the influence of facial expressions of emotion in entrepreneurial fundraising. First, we conduct a qualitative analysis to understand the objects of entrepreneurs' facial expressions of four basic emotions in their pitches: happiness, anger, fear, and sadness. This provides a base for our theorizing that the frequency of entrepreneurs' facial expression of each of these emotions exhibits an inverted U-shaped relationship with funding. We also argue that the frequency of changes in entrepreneurs' facial expressions is positively related to funding. We test our predictions with a sample of 489 funding pitches using computer-aided facial expression analysis. Results support inverted U-shaped relationships of the frequency of facial expression of happiness, anger, and fear with funding, but show a negative relationship of sadness with funding. Results further support that the frequency of change in entrepreneurs' facial expressions promotes funding.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Business

Venturing for Others, Subject to Role Expectations? A Role Congruity Theory Approach to Social Venture Crowd Funding

Aaron H. Anglin, Christopher Courtney, Thomas H. Allison

Summary: The differences in fundraising for social versus commercial ventures have not been given much attention. Women and people of color tend to perform better in raising capital for social ventures due to their congruence with role expectations attributed to social entrepreneurs. However, entrepreneur race can heighten fundraising differences for men and women, with women experiencing better funding performance when funding a social venture, especially women of color. Men of color, on the other hand, experience worse performance when funding a social venture, while no significant differences were found for White men.

ENTREPRENEURSHIP THEORY AND PRACTICE (2022)

Article Business

Gender and Counterstereotypical Facial Expressions of Emotion in Crowdfunded Microlending

Blakley C. Davis, Benjamin J. Warnick, Aaron H. Anglin, Thomas H. Allison

Summary: Crowdfunded microlending research suggests that women benefit from stereotypically masculine facial expressions of anger and disgust, while men benefit from stereotypically feminine facial expressions of sadness and happiness. Gender-counterstereotypical facial expressions provide entrepreneurs with a means to project missing agentic or communal characteristics.

ENTREPRENEURSHIP THEORY AND PRACTICE (2021)

Article Business

Role Theory Perspectives: Past, Present, and Future Applications of Role Theories in Management Research

Aaron H. Anglin, Paula A. Kincaid, Jeremy C. Short, David G. Allen

Summary: Role theories examine how individual behavior is influenced by social roles and how behavior is perceived by others in the context of these roles. Management research has explored various aspects of role theory, including roles and identity, career life cycles, ethics, and other-oriented behavior. These studies are important for understanding individual and organizational behavior and their impact.

JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Business

More Than One Way to Tell a Story: A Configurational Approach to Storytelling in Crowdfunding

Aaron H. Anglin, Shane W. Reid, Jeremy C. Short

Summary: Scholars in entrepreneurship argue that effective storytelling plays a critical role in the fundraising process. However, there has been limited research on how including core story elements, such as characters, plot, or setting, affects fundraising effectiveness. This study draws from narrative theory and narrative analysis research to examine how the inclusion of fundamental story elements impacts fundraising in 359 crowdfunding campaigns. Utilizing fuzzy set qualitative comparative analysis, the study identifies five storytelling configurations that result in superior funding performance. The findings contribute to a deeper understanding of storytelling in resource acquisition and have both theoretical and practical implications.

ENTREPRENEURSHIP THEORY AND PRACTICE (2023)

Article Management

Standing out in a crowd of victim entrepreneurs: How entrepreneurs' language-based cues of personality traits affect public support

Thomas H. Allison, Aaron H. Anglin, Blakley C. Davis, Pyayt Oo, Stella K. Seyb, Jeremy C. Short, Marcus T. Wolfe

Summary: This study examines the relationship between language-based cues in charitable appeals and public support, focusing on the proactive actions of entrepreneurs during catastrophic events and their use of crowdfunding for fundraising. The findings suggest that the language-based cues of personality traits embedded in appeals have a significant association with public support, and appeals that highlight the impact of the pandemic increase donation effects.

JOURNAL OF SMALL BUSINESS MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Business

Third-Party Signals in Crowdfunded Microfinance: The Role of Microfinance Institutions

Aaron H. Anglin, Jeremy C. Short, David J. Ketchen, Thomas H. Allison, Aaron F. McKenny

ENTREPRENEURSHIP THEORY AND PRACTICE (2020)

Article Business

What Doesn't Get Measured Does Exist: Improving the Accuracy of Computer-Aided Text Analysis

Aaron F. McKenny, Herman Aguinis, Jeremy C. Short, Aaron H. Anglin

JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT (2018)

Article Business

The Impact of Collective Optimism on New Venture Creation and Growth: A Social Contagion Perspective

Aaron H. Anglin, Aaron F. McKenny, Jeremy C. Short

ENTREPRENEURSHIP THEORY AND PRACTICE (2018)

Review Business

A Review and Road Map of Entrepreneurial Equity Financing Research: Venture Capital, Corporate Venture Capital, Angel Investment, Crowdfunding, and Accelerators

Will Drover, Lowell Busenitz, Sharon Matusik, David Townsend, Aaron Anglin, Gary Dushnitsky

JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT (2017)

Article Business

An Archival Approach to Measuring Family Influence: An Organizational Identity Perspective

Aaron H. Anglin, Shane W. Reid, Jeremy C. Short, Miles A. Zachary, Matthew W. Rutherford

FAMILY BUSINESS REVIEW (2017)

Article Business

The power of positivity? The influence of positive psychological capital language on crowdfunding performance

Aaron H. Anglin, Jeremy C. Short, Will Drover, Regan M. Stevenson, Aaron F. McKenny, Thomas H. Allison

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS VENTURING (2018)

Article Business

Narcissistic rhetoric and crowdfunding performance: A social role theory perspective

Aaron H. Anglin, Marcus T. Wolfe, Jeremy C. Short, Aaron F. McKenny, Robert J. Pidduck

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS VENTURING (2018)

Article Psychology, Applied

Blazing new trails or opportunity lost? Evaluating research at the intersection of leadership and entrepreneurship

Shane W. Reid, Aaron H. Anglin, John E. Baur, Jeremy C. Short, M. Ronald Buckley

LEADERSHIP QUARTERLY (2018)

Article Business

Event-based entrepreneurship

Greg Fisher, Matthew A. Josefy, Emily Neubert

Summary: This article integrates entrepreneurship research, research on temporary organizational forms, stakeholder theory, and platform strategy to define Event-Based Entrepreneurship (EBE) and propose factors that account for the founding and scaling of event-based ventures. The study lays the conceptual foundations and provides theoretical and practical directions for an expanded research agenda on EBE.

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS VENTURING (2024)

Article Business

Breaking barriers or maintaining status quo? Female representation in decision-making group of venture capital firms and the funding of woman-led businesses

Lei Xu, Amy Y. Ou, Haemin Dennis Park, Han Jiang

Summary: This study examines the influence of female representation in decision-making groups of venture capital firms on the firms' decision to fund woman-led businesses. The findings suggest that in the male-dominated industry, decision-making groups with higher female representation are less likely to fund woman-led businesses. However, this negative effect can be mitigated when the decision-making group includes politically neutral members or members with shared prior employment affiliations.

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS VENTURING (2024)

Article Business

Just a number? Using artificial intelligence to explore perceived founder age in entrepreneurial fundraising

Michael J. Matthews, Aaron H. Anglin, Will Drover, Marcus T. Wolfe

Summary: This study investigates the impact of founder age on fundraising using a randomized experiment and AI manipulation. The research demonstrates that age perceptions significantly matter to investors, with appearing older benefiting entrepreneurs in seeking funding. However, as age perceptions increase, these benefits decline and eventually become detrimental to fundraising efforts, showing an inverted-U relationship.

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS VENTURING (2024)

Article Business

Interorganizational triads for foreign-market entry: Partnerships among Western, bridge-economy, and local VCs in mainland China

Jing Zhang, Wei Zhang, Andreas Schwab

Summary: This study introduces the concept of bridge-economy partners and highlights their potential benefits in foreign-market entry for Western firms. It provides initial empirical evidence for the relevance of interorganizational partnership triads involving Western, bridge-economy, and local firms. Various factors such as venture age, regional legal maturity, and accumulated local experience are identified as influential in the adoption of this type of collaboration. The findings emphasize the importance of accumulated host-country experiences and a mature legal environment in successful implementation. The study suggests that policymakers in emerging economies can create favorable legal environments to support such triadic collaborations, offering a promising policy option for foreign investment.

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS VENTURING (2024)

Article Business

ESG and crowdfunding platforms

Douglas Cumming, Michele Meoli, Alice Rossi, Silvio Vismara

Summary: This study finds that environmental, social, and governance (ESG) goals are critical for crowdfunding platforms to attract investors and enhance their survival. Analyzing data from 508 security-based platforms established in 38 OECD countries between 2007 and 2020, it reveals that platforms with higher levels of ESG selection criteria are more likely to survive in the long run. The importance of ESG criteria is particularly pronounced for platforms operating in countries with lower power distance, with governance being the most significant component, and environmental criteria gaining importance for platform survival in recent years.

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS VENTURING (2024)

Article Business

A temporal typology of entrepreneurial opportunities: Implications for the optimal timing of entrepreneurial action

Jeffery S. Mcmullen, Jason R. Fitzsimmons, Khyati Shetty, Stratos Ramoglou

Summary: This paper examines the ephemerality and temporal variance of entrepreneurial opportunities and proposes a temporal typology of these opportunities based on consumer desire and technical feasibility. The analysis suggests that different types of opportunities emphasize different forms of asymmetry, which affects the optimal timing of entrepreneurial action.

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS VENTURING (2024)

Article Business

United we stand? Organizational groups and spinoff mortality in the context of academic entrepreneurship

Aleksios Gotsopoulos, Konstantinos Pitsakis

Summary: This study is important for understanding the failure of university spinoffs and the factors that influence them. It reveals the impact of population density and internal portfolio on individual spinoffs' propensity to fail, contributing to both organizational theory and literature on academic entrepreneurship.

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS VENTURING (2024)

Article Business

Social entrepreneurs concerned about Impact Drift. Evidence from contexts of persistent and pervasive need

Alessia Argiolas, Hans Rawhouser, Alisa Sydow

Summary: Social entrepreneurs in the Global North aim to do more for stakeholders than traditional businesses. In the Global South, social entrepreneurs face different stakeholder demands and concerns of impact drift due to persistent social problems. They respond with a norm-breaking approach to social impact, building novel coalitions and using heuristics to limit their focus.

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS VENTURING (2024)

Article Business

A chip off the old block: Founders' prior experience and the geographic diversification of export sales in international new ventures

Giuseppe Criaco, Lucia Naldi

Summary: This study integrates the cognition literature in entrepreneurship and strategy with the career imprinting literature, and examines the relationship between the geographic diversification of export sales in international new ventures (INVs) and the geographic diversification of founders' most recent employers. The findings support the theoretical propositions, except for the moderating role of founders' length of exposure.

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS VENTURING (2024)

Article Business

Star entrepreneurs on digital platforms: Heavy-tailed performance distributions and their generative mechanisms

Kaushik Gala, Andreas Schwab, Brandon A. Mueller

Summary: This study applies theories of star performers to digital platforms and suggests that the unique characteristics of digital platforms lead to heavy-tailed performance distributions, with proportional differentiation being the most likely mechanism for generating entrepreneurial performance in digital contexts. This provides theoretical and empirical evidence for non-normal entrepreneurial performance and has implications for scholars and practitioners of digital entrepreneurship.

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS VENTURING (2024)

Article Business

From distinctiveness to optimal distinctiveness: External endorsements, innovativeness and new venture funding

Kazem Mochkabadi, Simon Kleinert, Diemo Urbig, Christine Volkmann

Summary: This study examines how external endorsements influence the funding attractiveness of new ventures with varying degrees of innovation. The findings suggest that the effects of external endorsements depend on the unique relationship between legitimacy and distinctiveness for different audiences. Moreover, the performance implications of external endorsements differ for return-seeking audiences and novelty-seeking audiences.

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS VENTURING (2024)

Article Business

Doing the right things at the right times: The role of temporal enactment in venture outcome attainment

Trey Lewis, Diana M. Hechavarria, David W. Williams, Melissa S. Cardon

Summary: This study explores how nascent entrepreneurs can avoid the still trying status and achieve startup outcomes through temporal enactment. The findings suggest that the categories, pace, and sequential ordering of startup activities are important factors for reaching startup outcomes.

JOURNAL OF BUSINESS VENTURING (2024)