Association between industry payments and prescriptions of long-acting insulin: An observational study with propensity score matching

Background The rapidly increased spending on insulin is a major public health issue in the United States. Industry marketing might be one of the upstream determinants of physicians' prescription of long-acting insulin-the most commonly used and costly type of insulin, but the evidence is lacking. We therefore aimed to investigate the association between industry payments to physicians and subsequent prescriptions of long-acting insulin. Methods and findings Using the databases of Open Payments and Medicare Part D, we examined the association between the receipt of industry payments for long-acting insulin in 2016 and (1) the number of claims; (2) the costs paid for all claims; and (3) the costs per claim of long-acting insulin in 2017. We also examined the association between the receipt of payments and the change in these outcomes from 2016 to 2017. We employed propensity score matching to adjust for the physician-level characteristics (sex, years in practice, specialty, and medical school attended). Among 145,587 eligible physicians treating Medicare beneficiaries, 51,851 physicians received industry payments for long-acting insulin worth $22.3 million. In the propensity score-matched analysis including 102,590 physicians, we found that physicians who received the payments prescribed a higher number of claims (adjusted difference, 57.8; 95% CI, 55.8 to 59.7), higher costs for total claims (adjusted difference, +$22,111; 95% CI, $21,387 to $22,836), and higher costs per claim (adjusted difference, +$71.1; 95% CI, $69.0 to $73.2) of long-acting insulin, compared with physicians who did not receive the payments. The association was also found for changes in these outcomes from 2016 to 2017. Limitations to our study include limited generalizability, confounding, and possible reverse causation. Conclusions Industry marketing payments to physicians for long-acting insulin were associated with the physicians' prescriptions and costs of long-acting insulin in the subsequent year. Future research is needed to assess whether policy interventions on physician-industry financial relationships will help to ensure appropriate prescriptions and limit overall costs of this essential drug for diabetes care. Author summary Why was this study done? The financial relationships between physicians and pharmaceutical companies have received increased attention due to their potential to influence clinical decision-making. Although Medicare spending on insulin increased 840% over the last decade, empirical evidence about whether the physician-industry financial relationship contributes to physicians' prescriptions and costs of long-acting insulin, the most commonly used and most costly type of insulin, is lacking. To address this knowledge gap, we aimed to investigate the association between physicians' receipt of industry payments and their subsequent prescription of long-acting insulin in the United States. What did the researchers do and find? Among 145,587 physicians treating Medicare beneficiaries included in our study by linking databases of the Open Payments and the Medicare Part D, 51,851 physicians received industry payments for long-acting insulin worth $22.3 million. Using the propensity score-matched analysis adjusting for physician characteristics, we found that physicians who received the payments prescribed a higher number of claims, higher costs for total claims, and higher costs per claim of long-acting insulin, compared with physicians who did not receive the payments. The association was also found for changes in these outcomes from 2016 to 2017. Meals constituted 96% of the total number of industry payments for long-acting insulin, and we found the dose-response relationship between the number of meals received in 2016 and the utilization of long-acting insulin in 2017. What do these findings mean? Our findings indicate that industry marketing related to long-acting insulin, even those at relatively low dollar amounts such as meals, may influence physicians' prescriptions of long-acting insulin in clinical practice. Future research is needed to investigate whether policy interventions on the financial relationships between physicians and industry are effective to ensure appropriate prescriptions and save overall costs of long-acting insulin.

Automated summary

The study found that industry payments to physicians were associated with higher prescription rates and costs of long-acting insulin. Physicians who received payments prescribed a greater number of claims, had higher costs for total claims, and higher costs per claim of long-acting insulin compared to those who did not receive payments.