4.8 Article

Quantitative evaluation of the feasibility of sampling the ice plumes at Enceladus for biomarkers of extraterrestrial life

Publisher

NATL ACAD SCIENCES
DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2106197118

Keywords

planetary exploration; ocean worlds; ice particle impacts; astrobiology; space sciences instrumentation

Funding

  1. NASA [80NSSC17K0600]
  2. United Kingdom Science and Technology Facilities Council [ST/S000348/1]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Experiments on sampling ice particles from Enceladus plumes reveal that organic capture efficiency depends on impact velocity, particle size, and capture surface, with the system predicted to detect organic molecules in plume ice at the 1 nM level, providing meaningful information for probing habitability and biosignatures.
Enceladus, an icy moon of Saturn, is a compelling destination for a probe seeking biosignatures of extraterrestrial life because its subsurface ocean exhibits significant organic chemistry that is directly accessible by sampling cryovolcanic plumes. State-of-the-art organic chemical analysis instruments can perform valuable science measurements at Enceladus provided they receive sufficient plume material in a fly-by or orbiter plume transit. To explore the feasibility of plume sampling, we performed light gas gun experiments impacting micrometer-sized ice particles containing a fluorescent dye biosignature simulant into a variety of soft metal capture surfaces at velocities from 800 m . s(-1) up to 3 km . s(-1). Quantitative fluorescence microscopy of the capture surfaces demonstrates organic capture efficiencies of up to 80 to 90% for isolated impact craters and of at least 17% on average on indium and aluminum capture surfaces at velocities up to 2.2 km . s(-1). Our results reveal the relationships between impact velocity, particle size, capture surface, and capture efficiency for a variety of possible plume transit scenarios. Combined with sensitive microfluidic chemical analysis instruments, we predict that our capture system can be used to detect organic molecules in Enceladus plume ice at the 1 nM level-a sensitivity thought to be meaningful and informative for probing habitability and biosignatures.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.8
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Fine-grained material associated with a large sulfide returned from Comet81P/Wild 2

Z. Gainsforth, A. J. Westphal, A. L. Butterworth, C. E. Jilly-Rehak, D. E. Brownlee, D. J. Joswiak, R. C. Ogliore, M. E. Zolensky, H. A. Bechtel, D. S. Ebel, G. R. Huss, S. A. Sandford, A. J. White

METEORITICS & PLANETARY SCIENCE (2019)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Characterizing organic particle impacts on inert metal surfaces: Foundations for capturing organic molecules during hypervelocity transits of Enceladus plumes

J. S. New, R. A. Mathies, M. C. Price, M. J. Cole, M. Golozar, V. Spathis, M. J. Burchell, A. L. Butterworth

METEORITICS & PLANETARY SCIENCE (2020)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Feasibility of Enceladus plume biosignature analysis: Successful capture of organic ice particles in hypervelocity impacts

James S. New, Bahar Kazemi, Mark C. Price, Mike J. Cole, Vassi Spathis, Richard A. Mathies, Anna L. Butterworth

METEORITICS & PLANETARY SCIENCE (2020)

Article Chemistry, Analytical

Optimization of Fluorescence Labeling of Trace Analytes: Application to Amino Acid Biosignature Detection with Pacific Blue

Laura D. Casto-Boggess, Matin Golozar, Anna L. Butterworth, Richard A. Mathies

Summary: Fluorescence labeling and detection platforms are powerful tools for high-sensitivity bioanalysis, especially when targeting trace levels of analytes. This study optimized the labeling and detection of Pacific Blue-tagged amino acids, achieving 100 pM sensitivities and high-efficiency separations. The research developed a quantitative optimization model that can be applied to various reactive probes and targets, making it particularly useful for analyzing trace amine and amino acid biosignatures in extraterrestrial samples.

ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

The Winchcombe meteorite, a unique and pristine witness from the outer solar system

Ashley J. King, Luke Daly, James Rowe, Katherine H. Joy, Richard C. Greenwood, Hadrien A. R. Devillepoix, Martin D. Suttle, Queenie H. S. Chan, Sara S. Russell, Helena C. Bates, James F. J. Bryson, Patricia L. Clay, Denis Vida, Martin R. Lee, Aine O'Brien, Lydia J. Hallis, Natasha R. Stephen, Romain Tartese, Eleanor K. Sansom, Martin C. Towner, Martin Cupak, Patrick M. Shober, Phil A. Bland, Ross Findlay, Ian A. Franchi, Alexander B. Verchovsky, Feargus A. J. Abernethy, Monica M. Grady, Cameron J. Floyd, Matthias Van Ginneken, John Bridges, Leon J. Hicks, Rhian H. Jones, Jennifer T. Mitchell, Matthew J. Genge, Laura Jenkins, Pierre-Etienne Martin, Mark A. Sephton, Jonathan S. Watson, Tobias Salge, Katherine A. Shirley, Rowan J. Curtis, Tristram J. Warren, Neil E. Bowles, Finlay M. Stuart, Luigia Di Nicola, Domokos Gyore, Adrian J. Boyce, Kathryn M. M. Shaw, Tim Elliott, Robert C. J. Steele, Pavel Povinec, Matthias Laubenstein, David Sanderson, Alan Cresswell, Anthony J. T. Jull, Ivan Sykora, Sanjana Sridhar, Richard J. Harrison, Francesca M. Willcocks, Catherine S. Harrison, Daniel Hallatt, Penny J. Wozniakiewicz, Mark J. Burchell, Luke S. Alesbrook, Aishling Dignam, Natasha Almeida, Caroline L. Smith, Brett Clark, Emma R. Humphreys-Williams, Paul F. Schofield, Luke T. Cornwell, Vassilia Spathis, Geraint H. Morgan, Mark J. Perkins, Richard Kacerek, Peter Campbell-Burns, Francois Colas, Brigitte Zanda, Pierre Vernazza, Sylvain Bouley, Simon Jeanne, Mike Hankey, Gareth S. Collins, John S. Young, Clive Shaw, Jana Horak, Dave Jones, Nick James, Steve Bosley, Alan Shuttleworth, Paul Dickinson, Ian McMullan, Derek Robson, Andrew R. D. Smedley, Ben Stanley, Richard Bassom, Mark McIntyre, Adam A. Suttle, Richard Fleet, Luc Bastiaens, Mira B. Ihasz, Sarah McMullan, Sarah J. Boazman, Zach Dickeson, Peter M. Grindrod, Annemarie E. Pickersgill, Colin J. Weir, Fiona M. Suttle, Sarah Farrelly, Ieun Spencer, Sheeraz Naqvi, Ben Mayne, Dan Skilton, Dan Kirk, Ann Mounsey, Sally E. Mounsey, Sarah Mounsey, Pamela Godfrey, Lachlan Bond, Victoria Bond, Cathryn Wilcock, Hannah Wilcock, Rob Wilcock

Summary: Direct links between carbonaceous chondrites and their parent bodies in the solar system are rare. The Winchcombe meteorite, being the most accurately recorded carbonaceous chondrite fall, provides evidence of the composition and origins of these meteorites. Its composition, largely unmodified by terrestrial environment, contains hydrated silicates and organic matter, including soluble protein amino acids. Furthermore, its near-pristine hydrogen isotopic composition is similar to that of Earth's hydrosphere, suggesting the role of volatile-rich carbonaceous asteroids in the origin of Earth's water.

SCIENCE ADVANCES (2022)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

On the Feasibility of Informative Biosignature Measurements Using an Enceladus Plume Organic Analyzer

Richard A. A. Mathies, James S. S. New, Matin Golozar, Anna L. L. Butterworth

Summary: Through experiments and simulations, scientists have found that the ice plumes at Enceladus can efficiently capture organic-rich ice particles, providing a unique opportunity to explore traces of extraterrestrial life.

PLANETARY SCIENCE JOURNAL (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Fabrication of high-quality glass microfluidic devices for bioanalytical and space flight applications

Matin Golozar, Wai K. Chu, Laura D. Casto, Jeremy McCauley, Anna L. Butterworth, Richard A. Mathies

METHODSX (2020)

Article Astronomy & Astrophysics

Measurement of the Oxidation State of Fe in the ISM Using X-Ray Absorption Spectroscopy

Andrew J. Westphal, Anna L. Butterworth, John A. Tomsick, Zack Gainsforth

ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL (2019)

No Data Available