4.7 Article

A data-driven study of thermostat overrides during demand response events

Journal

ENERGY POLICY
Volume 153, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.enpol.2021.112290

Keywords

Demand response; Connected thermostat; Occupant behavior; Override; Decision tree

Funding

  1. Saint-Gobain Nordic A/S
  2. Danish Innovation Fund
  3. Realdania [7038-00224A]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The study investigates users' thermostat overriding behavior during demand response events and finds that the override rate is influenced by occupants' habitual setpoint change frequency, outdoor temperature, event duration, and occupants' previous experience with demand response. Overrides significantly affect power usage during events.
In the context of increasing renewable energy penetration in energy systems, demand response is acknowledged as a solution to guarantee grid stability and security of supply. Direct control of appliances by utilities, however, may lead to user dissatisfaction and disengagement via overrides. The present study, based on data from 6,389 connected thermostats in North America in the summer of 2019, investigates users' thermostat overriding behavior during demand response events targeting their air conditioners. An average event in this dataset was triggered around 3 p.m. and lasted three hours. The overall override rate was 12.9%. Overrides critically affected power usage during an event, with the share of the expected power demand reduction missed due to overrides being of the same order of magnitude as the override rate. In a decision tree analysis, the override rate showed to be particularly affected by occupants' habitual setpoint change frequency, outdoor temperature, event duration, and occupants' previous experience with demand response. Even though the dataset is not representative of all types of demand response events, this study highlights the potential lying in connected thermostat data for utilities to design tailored demand response events with an increased success rate and a smaller impact on occupant comfort.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Thermodynamics

Using long-term measurements of airflow, electrical power, indoor temperature, and CO2-concentration for evaluating sizing and performance of an all-air HVAC system in an office building-a case study

Donya Sheikh Khan, J. Kolarik, C. A. Hviid, P. Weitzmann

Summary: Monitoring the performance of HVAC systems during building operation can help improve energy efficiency and indoor conditions. This case study demonstrates that some AHUs met design requirements while others had issues with energy efficiency and thermal conditions.

SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY FOR THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT (2021)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Method for long-term mapping of occupancy patterns in open-plan and single office spaces by using passive-infrared (PIR) sensors mounted below desks

Donya Sheikh Khan, Jakub Kolarik, Christian Anker Hviid, Peter Weitzmann

Summary: The study evaluated the use of passive-infrared sensors for collecting long-term occupancy data, achieving an accuracy of 87.5% compared to manual observations. The gathered occupancy data can be used to generate occupancy schedules for building simulation models, potentially reduce design ventilation airflows for HVAC sizing, and evaluate decisions to change office space layouts for more efficient space-use.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2021)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Laboratory-based investigation of the materials' water activity and pH relative to fungal growth in internally insulated solid masonry walls

Nickolaj Feldt Jensen, Soren Peter Bjarlov, Carsten Rode, Birgitte Andersen, Eva B. Moller

Summary: The project investigated fungal growth conditions in artificially contaminated interfaces between solid masonry and adhesive mortar for internal insulation, finding that high pH adhesive mortars can effectively prevent fungal growth, but volatile organic compounds may affect indoor air quality.

INDOOR AIR (2021)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Comfort and technical installations in Danish low-energy homes: reconnecting design intention and domestic perceptions

Lucile Sarran, Simon Westergaard Lex, Elisabeth Heimdal Waersted

Summary: The study found that there is a disconnect between occupants' actual use and perception of underfloor heating and mechanical ventilation technologies in new and retrofitted dwellings, with design assumptions sometimes failing to meet occupants' expectations. Installation and operational failures are frequent and difficult for users to diagnose and correct, leading occupants to resort to alternative ways of control, potentially impacting energy use and indoor environmental quality.

BUILDING RESEARCH AND INFORMATION (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

An ontology to support flow system descriptions from design to operation of buildings

Ville Kukkonen, Ali Kucukavci, Mikki Seidenschnur, Mads Holten Rasmussen, Kevin Michael Smith, Christian Anker Hviid

Summary: This paper explores the challenges of information interoperability in the architecture, engineering, and construction (AEC) fields, with a focus on using linked data and semantic web technologies to establish an extendable data model. The study introduces the Flow Systems Ontology (FSO) for describing flow systems and their mass and energy flows, along with example models and SPARQL queries for validation. The main contribution is the development of FSO as a complementary ontology to existing ones, and a roadmap is introduced for future developments.

AUTOMATION IN CONSTRUCTION (2022)

Article Energy & Fuels

Numerical Feasibility Study of Self-Regulating Radiant Ceiling in Combination with Diffuse Ceiling Ventilation

Marie Rugholm Krusaa, Christian Anker Hviid

Summary: This paper presents a novel indoor comfort solution called HVACeiling, which combines a suspended radiant ceiling with diffuse ventilation. The study shows that HVACeiling can achieve thermal comfort with minimal temperature offset, reduce energy consumption and peak power, and support the use of renewable energy sources in a European context.

ENERGIES (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Experimental investigation of integrated radiant ceiling panel and diffuse ceiling ventilation under cooling conditions

Marie Rugholm Krusaa, Ida Orduk Hoffmann, Christian Anker Hviid

Summary: This paper experimentally investigates the cooling performance of a concept where a radiant ceiling is suspended from a hollow-core concrete slab and ventilation air is distributed without ducts and air terminals. The results show that the concept performs well in terms of thermal comfort and draught, and offers streamlined installation procedures.

ENERGY AND BUILDINGS (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

A common data environment for HVAC design and engineering

Mikki Seidenschnur, Ali Kucukavci, Esben Visby Fjerbaek, Kevin Michael Smith, Pieter Pauwels, Christian Anker Hviid

Summary: This article introduces a cloud-based Common Data Environment (CDE) called Virtual Commissioning (VC) for HVAC system commissioning in the architecture, engineering, and construction industry. The microservice architecture of the CDE is proven to be capable of running Modelica simulations. The robustness of the system architecture is tested using example models.

AUTOMATION IN CONSTRUCTION (2022)

Article Thermodynamics

Staged control of domestic hot water storage tanks to support district heating efficiency

Abdelkarim Tahiri, Kevin Michael Smith, Jan Eric Thorsen, Christian Anker Hviid, Svend Svendsen

Summary: This paper proposes two novel control concepts to optimize the charging of domestic hot water (DHW) tanks in large buildings supplied by district heating systems. The first concept employs a smart energy meter, while the second concept uses staged proportional gain with an added temperature sensor. By implementing these control methods, comfort and hygienic requirements are met, and energy consumption and total flow are reduced.

ENERGY (2023)

Article Thermodynamics

Grey-box modelling and virtual sensors enabling continuous commissioning of hydronic floor heating

Lucile Sarran, Kevin M. Smith, Christian A. Hviid, Carsten Rode

Summary: Operating district heating systems with low supply and return temperatures improves efficiency and allows for greater use of renewable heat sources. This paper proposes a method to improve the operation of hydronic floor heating systems by using data to identify and diagnose faults, as well as predict minimum permissible supply temperatures. Testing this method in a low-energy apartment in Denmark resulted in significant reductions in energy consumption.

ENERGY (2022)

Editorial Material Construction & Building Technology

Editorial: Special issue IBPC2021

Menghao Qin, Carsten Rode

JOURNAL OF BUILDING PHYSICS (2023)

Article Thermodynamics

How to ensure occupant comfort and satisfaction through deep building retrofit? Lessons from a Danish case study

Lucile Sarran, Christian Anker Hviid, Carsten Rode

Summary: This study explores the successes and challenges of building retrofit projects, particularly focusing on indoor environmental quality and occupants' satisfaction with technical installations. The findings reveal that the retrofit significantly improved winter thermal comfort and indoor air quality, but issues such as overheating in summer and faults in mechanical ventilation units need to be addressed.

SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY FOR THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Proceedings Paper Construction & Building Technology

Low-Energy Retrofitted Homes from their Occupants' Perspectives: Indoor Environmental Quality and Satisfaction with Heating and Mechanical Ventilation Systems

Lucile Sarran, Carsten Rode, Christian A. Hviid

Summary: This study aimed to gather feedback from occupants of low-energy retrofitted houses on indoor environmental quality (IEQ) and building systems. The results showed a significant improvement in IEQ satisfaction in retrofitted houses compared to non-retrofitted ones, although issues such as overheating in summer and dry air persisted. Additionally, occupants of retrofitted houses expressed strong interest in receiving information on IEQ, energy use, and system status, highlighting the need for better communication and guidance in residential retrofit projects.

INDOOR ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY PERFORMANCE APPROACHES (IAQ 2020), PT 1 (2021)

Article Economics

Impact of real-time pricing and residential load automation on distribution systems

Marie-Louise Arlt, David Chassin, Claudio Rivetta, James Sweeney

Summary: This paper examines the impact of real-time pricing and load automation on residential distribution systems. The study finds that implementing real-time pricing can result in an aggregate welfare gain of 39 USD per customer and year. However, it also notes that RTP and load automation may significantly increase peak system load. Introducing a market-based demand management system can further enhance welfare gains and reduce grid investment.

ENERGY POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Impacts of different hydrogen demand levels and climate policy scenarios on the Chilean integrated hydrogen-electricity network

Javier Jorquera-Copier, Alvaro Lorca, Enzo Sauma, Stefan Lorenczik, Matias Negrete-Pincetic

Summary: As countries update their climate ambitions, low-carbon hydrogen production and use present opportunities for emissions reductions and economic development. A case study for Chile shows that integrating hydrogen and electricity networks can lower system costs and enhance renewable integration, but policy support is needed to address concerns related to water and land use.

ENERGY POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Moving Beyond Clean Cooking Energy adoption: Using Indian ACCESS panel data to understand solid fuel suspension

Dawit Guta, Hisham Zerriffi, Jill Baumgartner, Abhishek Jain, Sunil Mani, Darby Jack, Ellison Carter, Guofeng Shen, Jennifer Orgill-Meyer, Joshua Rosenthal, Katherine Dickinson, Rob Bailis, Yuta Masuda

Summary: Household solid fuel use is detrimental to health and the environment. The Indian government's PMUY subsidy has successfully promoted the adoption of LPG by millions of households. However, there is limited understanding of the decision-making process to reduce solid fuel use after transitioning to cleaner fuels. This study found that factors such as household wealth, social status, education level, and the prevalence of LPG use in the village are positively associated with LPG consumption and the discontinuation of solid fuel use. On the other hand, factors such as distance to LPG refill delivery, household size, and the PMUY subsidy are negatively associated with the share of LPG use.

ENERGY POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Network tariff design with flexible customers: Ex-post pricing and a local network capacity market for customer response coordination

Nicolas Morell-Dameto, Jose Pablo Chaves-Avila, Tomas Gomez San Roman, Pablo Duenas-Martinez, Tim Schittekatte

Summary: This paper assesses the performance of differently implemented forward-looking network tariff designs and proposes an innovative coordination mechanism to increase predictability in a future with many flexible customers. The study reveals that if large shares of customers synchronize their responses to highly time-varying and locational-specific network charges, it can lead to unexpected reinforcements.

ENERGY POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Gas and energy security in Germany and central and Eastern Europe

Alexandra Gritz, Guntram Wolff

Summary: Russia's weaponization of gas supplies shook the energy security of Central and Eastern Europe in 2022. The region responded by increasing alternative energy supplies and developing new gas supply routes. Renewable energy, nuclear energy, and hydrogen play important roles in the long-term. Mitigating the impact of this shock requires the EU to prioritize the integrity of its energy market.

ENERGY POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

How to finance green investments? The role of public debt

Jaroslaw Kantorowicz, Marion Collewet, Matthew DiGiuseppe, Hendrik Vrijburg

Summary: Economic costs are a major political obstacle to investing in climate change mitigation and adaptation measures. The method of financing plays a crucial role in determining public opposition to government green investments, with debt financing being less opposed than broad-based taxes. This study suggests that credit market tools, such as green bonds and debt for climate swaps, can be politically efficient in increasing support for green financing. Carbon taxes and wealth taxes are found to be the most preferred options.

ENERGY POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Energy trade stability of China: Policy options with increasing climate risks

Kun Guo, Liyuan Luan, Xiaoli Cai, Dayong Zhang, Qiang Ji

Summary: This paper investigates China's energy trade stability using a survival analysis approach. It finds that the energy trade linkages between China and 153 other countries are complex and unstable, with short periods of trade with many countries. Geopolitically risky regions, such as the Middle East and Africa, have the lowest trade stability. Climate risks have significant effects on energy trade stability. The paper proposes several policy options to improve energy trade stability in China, with special attention to increasing global climate risks.

ENERGY POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

An empirical investigation of the Indian households' willingness to pay to avoid power outages

Simona Bigerna, Piyush Choudhary, Nikunj Kumar Jain, Silvia Micheli, Paolo Polinori

Summary: This study estimates the willingness to pay of Indian urban consumers for a continuous supply of electricity using contingent valuation method. The findings show that the amount consumers are willing to pay depends on the duration of power outages, with households preferring shorter outages. Income and environmental attitude also positively influence higher willingness to pay. These insights can inform policymakers in designing more reliable and customer-centric energy generation and distribution models.

ENERGY POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Exploring the connections between mini-grid market regulation and energy access expansion: The case of Nigeria

Temilade Sesan, Unico Uduka, Lucy Baker, Okechukwu Ugwu, Ewah Eleri, Subhes Bhattacharyya

Summary: This study examines the impact of the regulatory framework on rural electrification and universal energy access goals in Nigeria's mini-grid sector. The findings suggest that while the current framework has fostered sector growth, additional measures are necessary to ensure equitable distribution of access among rural populations.

ENERGY POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Allocation of policy resources for energy storage development considering the Inflation Reduction Act

Rui Shan, Noah Kittner

Summary: Energy storage is a cornerstone in decarbonization planning as it reduces operational costs and greenhouse gas emissions, while enhancing resilience and renewables integration. However, storage developers in different regions have varying economic and environmental considerations, thereby requiring policy intervention to achieve long-term emission reductions.

ENERGY POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Generation failures, strategic withholding, and capacity payments in the Turkish electricity market

Tung Durmaz, Sevil Acar, Simay Kizilkaya

Summary: This study investigates the phenomenon of strategic capacity withholding in the Turkish electricity market and its relationship with the capacity remuneration mechanism. The empirical results provide strong evidence of strategic capacity withholding and show that the capacity mechanism contributes to the duration of failures. The study offers important insights for policymakers, including the implementation of a random verification mechanism and restructuring of the capacity mechanism in Turkey.

ENERGY POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Oil price shocks and energy transition in Africa

Tii N. Nchofoung

Summary: The study finds that oil price shocks have a negative impact on Africa's energy transition, particularly in rural areas and net crude oil exporting countries. However, oil price shocks cannot explain the urban-rural differences in clean energy access. Therefore, increasing investment in clean energy and technologies in rural areas is necessary to enhance the resilience of the energy sector to oil price shocks.

ENERGY POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Harnessing the synergistic impacts of environmental innovations, financial development, green growth, and ecological footprint through the lens of SDGs policies for countries exhibiting high ecological footprints

Najia Saqib, Muhammad Usman, Ilhan Ozturk, Arshian Sharif

Summary: This study examines the impact of environmental technologies, financial growth, and energy use on ecological footprint and green growth. Environmental innovation and renewable energy deployment contribute to green growth, while financial expansion and non-renewable energy use have negative effects on the environment. The study also identifies causal relationships between different factors.

ENERGY POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Renewable energy certificates and firm value: Empirical evidence in Taiwan

Yessica C. Y. Chung, Noxolo Kunene, Hung-Hao Chang

Summary: The Renewable Energy Certificate (REC) is considered an innovative technology for building a green society. This study investigates the impact of REC purchases on stock return and volume in Taiwan between 2017 and 2021. The findings suggest that REC purchases have a positive effect on stock returns of manufacturing firms but not service firms. The frequency of REC purchases is also an important factor in the relationship between REC purchase and firm value. Additionally, the study reveals that public attention to environmental pollution plays a crucial role in positive stock returns and volume, while ESG disclosure is negatively associated with returns and volume.

ENERGY POLICY (2024)

Article Economics

Governance of renewable energy procurement via private suppliers: The Ethiopian experience

Seife Ayele, Wei Shen, Yacob Mulugetta, Tadesse Kuma Worako

Summary: This paper addresses the challenges of governing energy procurement from a mix of non-hydropower renewable energy sources supplied by independent producers. Building on political economy analysis and five case studies of independent producer projects from Ethiopia, it seeks to understand the root causes of the protracted delays and limited extent of procurement by independent producers. The key contestations lie in managing long term contracts, risk, uncertainty and in developing the institutional and human capacity to transition.

ENERGY POLICY (2024)