4.6 Article

A new method for earthquake-induced damage identification in historic masonry towers combining OMA and IDA

Journal

BULLETIN OF EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING
Volume 19, Issue 12, Pages 5307-5337

Publisher

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s10518-021-01167-0

Keywords

Earthquake-induced damage identification; Structural health monitoring; Digital twin; Incremental dynamic analysis; Surrogate modeling; Finite element modeling; Cultural heritage

Funding

  1. Italian Ministry of University and Research (MIUR)
  2. University of Perugia

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This paper introduces a novel method for rapidly addressing earthquake-induced damage in historic masonry towers, combining OMA, FE modeling, SM, and IDA. Through validation on the bell tower of the Basilica of San Pietro in Italy, the method successfully combines experimental vibration data and numerical modeling for post-earthquake damage localization and quantification.
This paper presents a novel method for rapidly addressing the earthquake-induced damage identification task in historic masonry towers. The proposed method, termed DORI, combines operational modal analysis (OMA), FE modeling, rapid surrogate modeling (SM) and non-linear Incremental dynamic analysis (IDA). While OMA-based Structural Health Monitoring methods using statistical pattern recognition are known to allow the detection of small structural damages due to earthquakes, even far-field ones of moderate intensity, the combination of SM and IDA-based methods for damage localization and quantification is here proposed. The monumental bell tower of the Basilica of San Pietro located in Perugia, Italy, is considered for the validation of the method. While being continuously monitored since 2014, the bell tower experienced the main shocks of the 2016 Central Italy seismic sequence and the on-site vibration-based monitoring system detected changes in global dynamic behavior after the earthquakes. In the paper, experimental vibration data (continuous and seismic records), FE models and surrogate models of the structure are used for post-earthquake damage localization and quantification exploiting an ideal subdivision of the structure into meaningful macroelements. Results of linear and non-linear numerical modeling (SM and IDA, respectively) are successfully combined to this aim and the continuous exchange of information between the physical reality (monitoring data) and the virtual models (FE models and surrogate models) effectively enforces the Digital Twin paradigm. The earthquake-induced damage identified by both data-driven and model-based strategies is finally confirmed by in-situ visual inspections.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

A method for structural monitoring of multispan bridges using satellite InSAR data with uncertainty quantification and its pre-collapse application to the Albiano-Magra Bridge in Italy

Elisabetta Farneti, Nicola Cavalagli, Mario Costantini, Francesco Trillo, Federico Minati, Ilaria Venanzi, Filippo Ubertini

Summary: Synthetic Aperture Radar Interferometry (InSAR) using satellite data is a promising tool for monitoring long-term deformation phenomena in critical infrastructural systems. However, its use in structural engineering, especially for bridge structures, is still limited. This paper proposes a post-processing methodology to derive two-dimensional displacement configurations of multi-span bridges with properly defined error bounds. The proposed method has been applied to the case study of the collapsed Albiano-Magra Bridge in Italy, demonstrating its effectiveness in supporting engineering assessments.

STRUCTURAL HEALTH MONITORING-AN INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL (2023)

Review Engineering, Geological

A Bayesian-based inspection-monitoring data fusion approach for historical buildings and its post-earthquake application to a monumental masonry palace

Laura Ierimonti, Nicola Cavalagli, Ilaria Venanzi, Enrique Garcia-Macias, Filippo Ubertini

Summary: Many countries, including Italy, face the challenge of promptly quantifying post-earthquake damages to their historical heritage. This research proposes a novel approach for structural condition assessment by aggregating different sources of information, such as monitoring and visual inspection, to make risk-informed decisions. The proposed approach includes vibration-based system identification, finite element modeling, Bayesian-based model updating, and visual inspections.

BULLETIN OF EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Autoencoders for unsupervised real-time bridge health assessment

Valentina Giglioni, Ilaria Venanzi, Valentina Poggioni, Alfredo Milani, Filippo Ubertini

Summary: This paper proposes an unsupervised learning method based on autoencoders for damage detection. The method can work at the single sensor level and utilizes ensemble learning strategy to combine predictive models. Experimental results show that the proposed method is effective for local damage detection with limited computational effort and a limited number of sensors, making it suitable for real-time bridge assessment.

COMPUTER-AIDED CIVIL AND INFRASTRUCTURE ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Design of a smart lime mortar with conductive micro and nano fillers for structural health monitoring

Anastasios Drougkas, Vasilis Sarhosis, Muhammed Basheer, Antonella D'Alessandro, Filippo Ubertini

Summary: Structural health monitoring is important for assessing building and infrastructure performance, especially after critical events or structural interventions. Smart sensors based on construction materials offer a promising solution for inconspicuous and compatible monitoring of historic structures. In this paper, an experimental investigation of smart intervention materials for historic masonry structures is presented, which showed improvements in both mechanical properties and piezoresistivity.

CONSTRUCTION AND BUILDING MATERIALS (2023)

Article Materials Science, Composites

Self-Sensing Eco-Earth Composite with Carbon Microfibers for Sustainable Smart Buildings

Hasan Borke Birgin, Antonella D'Alessandro, Andrea Meoni, Filippo Ubertini

Summary: This paper proposes a new sustainable earth-cement building composite with multifunctional sensing features and investigates its properties through an experimental campaign. The proposed material couples the construction performance with self-sensing properties in order to monitor the structural performance during the servile life of the building. The results show that the samples with a filler percentage near the percolation zone, ranged between 0.025 and 0.25%, exhibit the best performance.

JOURNAL OF COMPOSITES SCIENCE (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Self-powered weigh-in-motion system combining vibration energy harvesting and self-sensing composite pavements

Hasan Borke Birgin, Enrique Garcia-Macias, Antonella D'Alessandro, Filippo Ubertini

Summary: Overloaded vehicles accelerate the degradation of road infrastructures. Recent advances in multifunctional composites have enabled the development of smart pavements as a cost-effective alternative. However, stable power supply remains a practical limitation.

CONSTRUCTION AND BUILDING MATERIALS (2023)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Roadmap on measurement technologies for next generation structural health monitoring systems

Simon Laflamme, Filippo Ubertini, Alberto Di Matteo, Antonina Pirrotta, Marcus Perry, Yuguang Fu, Jian Li, Hao Wang, Tu Hoang, Branko Glisic, Leonard J. Bond, Mauricio Pereira, Yening Shu, Kenneth J. Loh, Yang Wang, Siqi Ding, Xinyue Wang, Xun Yu, Baoguo Han, Yiska Goldfeld, Donghyeon Ryu, Rebecca Napolitano, Fernando Moreu, Giorgia Giardina, Pietro Milillo

Summary: Structural health monitoring (SHM) is the automation of assessing the condition of engineered systems. The challenge lies in designing cost-effective sensing solutions for large components or structures, and the implementation of these solutions is still limited due to economic and technical challenges.

MEASUREMENT SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

Residual service life prediction for bridges undergoing slow landslide-induced movements combining satellite radar interferometry and numerical collapse simulation

Elisabetta Farneti, Nicola Cavalagli, Ilaria Venanzi, Walter Salvatore, Filippo Ubertini

Summary: This paper proposes an innovative approach that combines InSAR displacement information with numerical modeling to predict the time to failure of bridges affected by slow deformation phenomena. The methodology involves advanced pre and post-processing techniques for satellite SAR acquisitions and numerical modeling to simulate damage propagation and structural behavior.

ENGINEERING STRUCTURES (2023)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Model-assisted clustering for automated operational modal analysis of partially continuous multi-span bridges

Elisa Tomassini, Enrique Garcia-Macias, Edwin Reynders, Filippo Ubertini

Summary: This study proposes a model-based machine learning approach to analyze the results of operational modal analysis (OMA) for multi-span bridges. By analyzing the analytical solution of the vertical free vibration response of multi-span girders, this method can estimate the modal features of any bridge configuration. Detailed parametric analysis and discussions are conducted to evaluate the correlation between rotational coupling and the clustering of modal poles in multi-span bridges, as well as the influence of damage severity and extension. Based on this, a model-based cut-off distance threshold for hierarchical clustering of stable poles is proposed to assist the automation of global OMA for multi-span bridges.

MECHANICAL SYSTEMS AND SIGNAL PROCESSING (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

Effects of the soil-structure interaction and seismic vertical component on the response of a concrete surge tank

Arianna Lupattelli, Alban Kita, Diana Salciarini, Ilaria Venanzi, Filippo Ubertini

Summary: The seismic safety of hydroelectric power plants in earthquake-prone regions is a major concern. This paper focuses on the seismic performance assessment of a critical component, the surge tank, using complex models and different assumptions. The study evaluates the influence of two main modeling assumptions: considering or neglecting soil-structure interaction phenomena and considering or ignoring the vertical component of ground motion.

STRUCTURES (2023)

Proceedings Paper Engineering, Aerospace

A new methodology to prioritize Non-Destructive Evaluation based on risk conditions and costs assessment in the context of limited information

Andrea Meoni, Enrique Garcia-Macias, Ilaria Venanzi, Filippo Ubertini

Summary: Non-Destructive Evaluation (NDE) methods provide detailed information on the structural performance of bridges and viaducts, which is essential for risk assessment procedures. This paper introduces a new method that prioritizes NDE bridge inspections based on both risk and cost evaluations. By using the information gain criterion and incorporating GIS and spatial interpolation methods, the method enables the creation of informative risk maps and inspection plans.

SENSORS AND SMART STRUCTURES TECHNOLOGIES FOR CIVIL, MECHANICAL, AND AEROSPACE SYSTEMS 2023 (2023)

Proceedings Paper Engineering, Aerospace

Supervised machine learning techniques for predicting multiple damage classes in bridges

Valentina Giglioni, Ilaria Venanzi, Filippo Ubertini

Summary: The increasing number of bridge collapses has sparked interest in developing monitoring strategies for real-time damage assessment and structural integrity preservation. Recent advancements in sensor technology and computer science have led to the use of Machine Learning algorithms in vibration-based Structural Health Monitoring. This methodology combines Domain Adaptation with supervised learning methods to assign damage labels to statistically-aligned features. Natural frequencies obtained during healthy and abnormal conditions are selected as damage-sensitive quantities, providing information on global structural dynamics. The proposed technique aims to effectively identify and classify different types of damage cases, serving as an engineering decision-support tool for capturing damage-induced variations.

SENSORS AND SMART STRUCTURES TECHNOLOGIES FOR CIVIL, MECHANICAL, AND AEROSPACE SYSTEMS 2023 (2023)

Article Architecture

Mechanical and Durability Testing and XCT Imaging of a Lime-Based Micro-Scale Modified Smart Intervention Mortar

Anastasios Drougkas, Vasilis Sarhosis, Alice Macente, Muhammed Basheer, Antonella D'Alessandro, Filippo Ubertini

Summary: This study conducted mechanical and physical testing on a natural hydraulic lime-based mortar modified using carbon microfibres, aiming to evaluate its mechanical advantages as a repointing mortar for masonry structures compared to its unmodified counterpart. The results showed that the modified mortar exhibited enhanced mechanical strength and improved durability.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ARCHITECTURAL HERITAGE (2023)

Proceedings Paper Engineering, Civil

Remote Sensing Satellite Data and Progressive Collapse Analysis for Structural Monitoring of Multi-span Bridges

Elisabetta Farneti, Nicola Cavalagli, Mario Costantini, Francesco Trillo, Federico Minati, Ilaria Venanzi, Walter Salvatore, Filippo Ubertini

Summary: This work investigates the potential application of Synthetic Aperture Radar Interferometry (InSAR) in bridge monitoring, presenting a post-processing methodology to derive displacement configurations and define error bounds. The case study of the Albiano-Magra Bridge in Italy reveals anomalies in displacements prior to collapse, providing insights into the possible cause.

EUROPEAN WORKSHOP ON STRUCTURAL HEALTH MONITORING (EWSHM 2022), VOL 2 (2023)

Proceedings Paper Engineering, Civil

Deep Autoencoders for Unsupervised Damage Detection with Application to the Z24 Benchmark Bridge

Valentina Giglioni, Ilaria Venanzi, Alina Elena Baia, Valentina Poggioni, Alfredo Milani, Filippo Ubertini

Summary: Structural health monitoring is an important and challenging issue in modern society. To enhance bridge assessment and damage detection, researchers have applied machine learning algorithms and proposed a convolutional autoencoder-based damage detection technique.

EUROPEAN WORKSHOP ON STRUCTURAL HEALTH MONITORING (EWSHM 2022), VOL 2 (2023)

No Data Available