4.8 Article

Testing the climate intervention potential of ocean afforestation using the Great Atlantic Sargassum Belt

Journal

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS
Volume 12, Issue 1, Pages -

Publisher

NATURE PORTFOLIO
DOI: 10.1038/s41467-021-22837-2

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. Australian Research Council [FL160100131]
  2. CSHOR
  3. Australian Research Council [FL160100131] Funding Source: Australian Research Council

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The study highlights ocean afforestation as an important method for CO2 removal, but biogeochemical feedback mechanisms reduce its efficiency. Additionally, the increased ocean albedo due to floating Sargassum may have a greater impact on climate change, indicating the importance of considering multifaceted Earth-system feedback mechanisms when evaluating carbon dioxide removal methods.
Ensuring that global warming remains < 2 degrees C requires rapid CO2 emissions reduction. Additionally, 100-900 gigatons CO2 must be removed from the atmosphere by 2100 using a portfolio of CO2 removal (CDR) methods. Ocean afforestation, CDR through basin-scale seaweed farming in the open ocean, is seen as a key component of the marine portfolio. Here, we analyse the CDR potential of recent re-occurring trans-basin belts of the floating seaweed Sargassum in the (sub)tropical North Atlantic as a natural analogue for ocean afforestation. We show that two biogeochemical feedbacks, nutrient reallocation and calcification by encrusting marine life, reduce the CDR efficacy of Sargassum by 20-100%. Atmospheric CO2 influx into the surface seawater, after CO2-fixation by Sargassum, takes 2.5-18 times longer than the CO2-deficient seawater remains in contact with the atmosphere, potentially hindering CDR verification. Furthermore, we estimate that increased ocean albedo, due to floating Sargassum, could influence climate radiative forcing more than Sargassum-CDR. Our analysis shows that multifaceted Earth-system feedbacks determine the efficacy of ocean afforestation.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.8
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Limnology

Sinking dead-How zooplankton carcasses contribute to particulate organic carbon flux in the subantarctic Southern Ocean

Svenja Halfter, Emma L. Cavan, Philip Butterworth, Kerrie M. Swadling, Philip W. Boyd

Summary: Zooplankton carcasses play a significant role in carbon sinking flux, acting as microbial hotspots with substantial sinking velocities of organic carbon particles to the deep ocean. Carcass flux is sensitive to changes in sinking velocity but appears less sensitive to fluctuations in microbial decomposition rate. Further research is needed on zooplankton mortality and factors influencing carcass sinking through the water column.

LIMNOLOGY AND OCEANOGRAPHY (2022)

Article Marine & Freshwater Biology

The ongoing need for rates: can physiology and omics come together to co-design the measurements needed to understand complex ocean biogeochemistry?

Robert F. Strzepek, Brook L. Nunn, Lennart T. Bach, John A. Berges, Erica B. Young, Philip W. Boyd

Summary: Understanding the impact of global ocean change on marine life has highlighted gaps in our knowledge of fundamental principles. Physiological research has stagnated due to the dominance of molecular biological techniques. Despite the potential of omics-based studies, converting physiological potential into measurable rates and biogeochemical fluxes remains a challenge.

JOURNAL OF PLANKTON RESEARCH (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Optimisation of at-sea culture and harvest conditions for cultivated Macrocystis pyrifera: yield, biofouling and biochemical composition of cultured biomass

C. Biancacci, W. Visch, D. L. Callahan, G. Farrington, D. S. Francis, P. Lamb, A. McVilly, A. Nardelli, J. C. Sanderson, J. Schwoerbel, C. L. Hurd, B. Evans, C. Macleod, A. Bellgrove

Summary: Seaweed cultivation is gaining interest worldwide, and this study evaluates the suitability of native kelp Macrocystis pyrifera for aquaculture in Tasmania, Australia. The results show that yield and biochemical composition of the cultivated biomass are influenced by time, location, and depth, and specific harvesting time is needed to optimize yield and quality. These findings have important implications for the management and development of kelp aquaculture in Tasmania and globally.

FRONTIERS IN MARINE SCIENCE (2022)

Article Plant Sciences

Kelp nursery optimisation: density-dependent effects in early life-cycle stages of Ecklonia radiata (Laminariales)

Jakop Schwoerbel, Wouter Visch, Jeffrey T. Wright, Alecia Bellgrove, J. Craig Sanderson, Catriona MacLeod, Catriona L. Hurd

Summary: This study investigated the impact of different zoospore densities on the development of Ecklonia radiata gametophytes and sporophytes, finding significant effects on gametophyte size and sporophyte production based on initial zoospore density. The importance of initial zoospore density in optimizing the nursery stage of kelp aquaculture was clearly highlighted in the results.

BOTANICA MARINA (2022)

Review Plant Sciences

From Tasmania to the world: long and strong traditions in seaweed use, research, and development

Catriona L. Hurd, Jeffrey T. Wright, Cayne Layton, Elisabeth M. A. Strain, Damon Britton, Wouter Visch, Neville Barrett, Scott Bennett, Kim Jye Lee Chang, Graham Edgar, J. Helen Fitton, Dean Greeno, Ian Jameson, Craig R. Johnson, Sam S. Karpiniec, Gerald T. Kraft, Scott D. Ling, Catriona M. Macleod, Ellie R. Paine, Ahyoung Park, J. Craig Sanderson, Matthias Schmid, Fiona J. Scott, Victor Shelamoff, Damien N. Stringer, Masayuki Tatsumi, Camille A. White, Anusuya Willis

Summary: Tasmania is an island state in south-eastern Australia known for its extensive history of seaweed use and research. The Aboriginal peoples of Tasmania have utilized seaweed for thousands of years for various purposes, including food, shelter, and medicine. The ecological and physiological studies conducted in Tasmania have significantly contributed to the global understanding of seaweed systems, particularly in areas such as community resilience and responses to global change. The decline in seaweed canopy cover and the development of aquaculture initiatives are also notable features of Tasmania's seaweed industry.

BOTANICA MARINA (2023)

Article Fisheries

No effect of ocean acidification on growth, photosynthesis, or dissolved organic carbon release by three temperate seaweeds with different dissolved inorganic carbon uptake strategies

Ellie R. Paine, Damon Britton, Matthias Schmid, Elizabeth A. Brewer, Guillermo Diaz-Pulido, Philip W. Boyd, Catriona L. Hurd

Summary: This study compared the physiological responses of three seaweed species to ocean acidification and found that elevated CO2 concentrations did not benefit their growth and photosynthesis in a future ocean.

ICES JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE (2023)

Review Fisheries

A strategic review and research roadmap for offshore seaweed aquaculture-A case study from southern Australia

Wouter Visch, Cayne Layton, Catriona L. Hurd, Catriona Macleod, Jeffrey T. Wright

Summary: Global seaweed aquaculture production has significantly increased since 2002, mainly in Asian countries, and is predominantly carried out in nearshore areas with wave protection. To meet future demand, production needs to be moved to non-traditional regions and offshore waters. However, the challenges and uncertainties in cultivating seaweed in high-energy offshore environments must be addressed.

REVIEWS IN AQUACULTURE (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Seasonality of downward carbon export in the Pacific Southern Ocean revealed by multi-year robotic observations

Leo Lacour, Joan Llort, Nathan Briggs, Peter G. G. Strutton, Philip W. W. Boyd

Summary: At high latitudes, the gravitational sinking of particulate organic carbon has been considered as the sole particle export pathway of the biological carbon pump. However, recent studies suggest that particle injection pumps, such as the mixed layer and eddy subduction pumps, also contribute significantly to the downward flux of particulate organic carbon. In this study, we used year-round robotic observations and bio-optical signal analysis to concurrently investigate the functioning of these particle injection pumps and the gravitational pump in the Southern Ocean. Our results reveal the distinct seasonality and importance of different export pathways, providing insights into carbon sequestration efficiency over the annual cycle.

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2023)

Letter Limnology

Biogeochemical-Argo floats show that chlorophyll increases before carbon in the high-latitude Southern Ocean spring bloom

Clara R. Vives, Christina Schallenberg, Peter G. Strutton, Philip W. Boyd

Summary: In the Southern Ocean, understanding the timing of phytoplankton blooms is crucial for studying ecosystem dynamics and carbon export. Previous studies have yielded inconsistent findings regarding bloom timing. This study compares bloom dynamics based on different diagnostics and highlights the importance of considering phytoplankton physiology when choosing proxies for their growth.

LIMNOLOGY AND OCEANOGRAPHY LETTERS (2023)

Article Limnology

Toward a consensus framework to evaluate air-sea CO2 equilibration for marine CO2 removal

Lennart T. Bach, David T. Ho, Philip W. Boyd, Michael D. Tyka

LIMNOLOGY AND OCEANOGRAPHY LETTERS (2023)

Article Biology

Iron limitation of kelp growth may prevent ocean afforestation

Ellie R. Paine, Philip W. Boyd, Robert F. Strzepek, Michael Ellwood, Elizabeth A. Brewer, Guillermo Diaz-Pulido, Matthias Schmid, Catriona L. Hurd

Summary: Laboratory experiments show that insufficient iron availability in the open ocean is a major challenge for growing kelp for carbon sequestration. Carbon dioxide removal and emissions reduction are crucial for mitigating climate change. Ocean macroalgal afforestation is a CDR method that involves growing nearshore kelps offshore, but the limitation of dissolved iron supply is overlooked in discussions. The study finds that kelp growth and physiological functions are impaired at oceanic iron concentrations, which are 1000-fold lower than required by the kelp species. Additional iron fertilization may be necessary for successful ocean macroalgal afforestation.

COMMUNICATIONS BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Authigenic mineral phases as a driver of the upper-ocean iron cycle

Alessandro Tagliabue, Kristen N. N. Buck, Laura E. E. Sofen, Benjamin S. S. Twining, Olivier Aumont, Philip W. W. Boyd, Salvatore Caprara, William B. B. Homoky, Rod Johnson, Daniela Konig, Daniel C. C. Ohnemus, Bettina Sohst, Peter Sedwick

Summary: Iron is important in regulating the ocean carbon cycle, with organic ligands playing a crucial role in stabilizing dissolved iron concentrations. However, the role of authigenic iron phases and the inconsistencies observed in dissolved iron cycling challenge the primary control of ligands. Through a study in the Bermuda Atlantic Time-series Study (BATS) region, it was found that upper-ocean dissolved iron dynamics are decoupled from ligands, indicating the need for a mechanism that allows dissolved iron to escape ligand stabilization and form a reservoir of settling iron particles. When this mechanism was implemented in a global-scale biogeochemical model, it successfully reproduced seasonal iron-cycle dynamics and global datasets where previous models failed.

NATURE (2023)

Editorial Material Multidisciplinary Sciences

Reply to: Ocean afforestation is a potentially effective way to remove carbon dioxide

Lennart T. Bach, Veronica Tamsitt, Jim Gower, Catriona L. Hurd, John A. Raven, Philip W. Boyd

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2023)

Article Ecology

Upwelled plankton community modulates surface bloom succession and nutrientavailability in a natural plankton assemblage

Allanah Joy Paul, Lennart Thomas Bach, Javier Aristegui, Elisabeth von der Esch, Nauzet Hernandez-Hernandez, Jonna Piiparinen, Laura Ramajo, Kristian Spilling, Ulf Riebesell

Summary: Upwelling in the ocean has significant impacts on the productivity of ecosystems in eastern boundary upwelling systems. Besides traditional nutrients, subsurface waters also contain micronutrients, organic matter, and seed microbial communities, which may modify the response of the ecosystem to nutrient inputs. This study found that the ratio of inorganic nutrients and the presence of microbial communities are the most influential factors in driving the response of plankton communities to upwelling.

BIOGEOSCIENCES (2022)

Article Ecology

Assessing the influence of ocean alkalinity enhancement on a coastalphytoplankton community

Aaron Ferderer, Zanna Chase, Fraser Kennedy, Kai G. Schulz, Lennart T. Bach

Summary: Ocean alkalinity enhancement (OAE) is a proposed method to counteract climate change. In a closed experimental system, OAE was found to have significant but moderate effects on phytoplankton communities and heterotrophic bacteria, with the most pronounced effects observed on diatoms. However, the climate benefits of increasing the inorganic carbon sink of seawater outweigh the inadvertent effects of OAE on coastal phytoplankton communities.

BIOGEOSCIENCES (2022)

No Data Available