4.5 Article

Collating stock assessment packages to improve stock assessments

Journal

FISHERIES RESEARCH
Volume 236, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.fishres.2020.105844

Keywords

Stock assessment; Packages; Specifications; Toolbox; Web-site

Categories

Funding

  1. Fisheries Research and Development Corporation, Australia [2018-148]
  2. CSIRO
  3. Cathy Dichmont Consulting

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Stock assessments are crucial for fisheries management, and there is a growing demand for assessments based on population dynamics models. The trend is shifting towards using flexible, documented software packages to improve efficiency and consistency. A website has been developed to collate available stock assessment packages and facilitate feedback between users and developers for designing the next generation of assessment tools.
Stock assessments are integral to fisheries management, and the demand for stock assessments based on population dynamics models continues to increase. Historically, stock assessments have been based on bespoke methods and software. There is now a trend towards the use of flexible, documented, tested and maintained software packages, because use of such packages increases efficiency and consistency in assessments and should lead to more reliable and repeatable assessment outcomes. We have developed a web-site that collates available stock assessment packages (from data-limited to-rich) to provide assessment analysts with a single platform that summarizes the features of the available packages in a consistent manner. We also highlight current state-of-theart packages, and those that are no longer supported or have been superseded. In addition to providing the packages, the web-site facilitates users of packages to provide feedback to developers regarding which features of other packages could be included in future versions of their packages. We see this effort as a way to support the design of the next generation stock assessment package.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Fisheries

Operationalizing triple bottom line harvest strategies

Catherine M. Dichmont, Natalie A. Dowling, Sean Pascoe, Toni Cannard, Rachel J. Pears, Sian Breen, Tom Roberts, George M. Leigh, Marc Mangel

Summary: Over the past 50 years, there has been a shift in actively managed fisheries from primarily data-rich industrial sectors to more socially, economically, and environmentally complex multispecies and multisector fisheries. This change has led to a broadening of management objectives to include social and economic considerations, known as the triple bottom line, which are incorporated into harvest strategies. The need for a paradigm shift towards more representative participatory management systems and a broader set of objectives is highlighted, along with the modification of tools and data collection methods to support these strategies.

ICES JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE (2021)

Article Fisheries

Can a length-based pseudo-cohort analysis (LBPA) using multiple catch length-frequencies provide insight into population status in data-poor situations?

Cristian M. Canales, Andre E. Punt, Mauricio Mardones

Summary: This study introduces a Length-Based Pseudo-cohort Analysis (LBPA) model for estimating stock status in data-poor fisheries using multiple length-frequency samples, showing better performance compared to traditional methods. Simulations indicate that LBPA outperforms the length-based spawning potential ratio (LBSPR), especially under high exploitation rates.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2021)

Article Fisheries

Implementing the precautionary approach into fisheries management: Biomass reference points and uncertainty buffers

Tobias K. Mildenberger, Casper W. Berg, Alexandros Kokkalis, Adrian R. Hordyk, Chantel Wetzel, Nis S. Jacobsen, Andre E. Punt, J. Rasmus Nielsen

Summary: The study compares the effectiveness of two precautionary approaches in recovering over-exploited fish stocks, finding that both methods reduce the risk of overfishing at the expense of expected yield. The success of these strategies depends on HCRs, life-history parameters, and the level of scientific uncertainty.

FISH AND FISHERIES (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Redesigning harvest strategies for sustainable fishery management in the face of extreme environmental variability

Laura K. Blamey, Eva E. Plaganyi, Trevor Hutton, Roy A. Deng, Judy Upston, Annie Jarrett

Summary: This study tested the robustness of harvest control rules for a large prawn stock in Australia to environmental variability using a management strategy evaluation approach. Model fits to catch per unit effort were good, and stakeholders ultimately selected a permanent closure of the first fishing season as the optimal management option. This simulation approach enabled the selection of an optimal yet pragmatic solution for addressing economic and conservation objectives under a variable environment with extreme events.

CONSERVATION BIOLOGY (2022)

Article Oceanography

Modeling in an integrated ecosystem research framework to explore recruitment in Gulf of Alaska groundfish - Applications to management and lessons learned

Georgina A. Gibson, Matthew R. Baker, William T. Stockhausen, Sarah Hinckley, Carolina Parada, Kerim Aydin, Kenneth O. Coyle, Albert J. Hermann, Thomas P. Hurst, Andre E. Punt

Summary: The Gulf of Alaska Integrated Ecosystem Research Program (GOAIERP) conducted a multi-disciplinary study to examine the influence of the environment on the survival and recruitment of early life stages of commercially and ecologically important groundfish species. The integration of Eulerian ecosystem models and Lagrangian Individual-Based Models provided valuable insights into recruitment processes and their potential application to fisheries management. However, coordination between model development, experimentation, and field sampling is challenging and requires careful consideration of data analysis and model validation.

DEEP-SEA RESEARCH PART II-TOPICAL STUDIES IN OCEANOGRAPHY (2022)

Article Fisheries

Evaluating methods for estimating shark natural mortality rate and management reference points using life-history parameters

Shijie Zhou, Roy A. Deng, Matthew R. Dunn, Simon D. Hoyle, Yeming Lei, Ashley J. Williams

Summary: Sharks typically have long lifespans, slow growth rates, and low fecundity, making them vulnerable to fishing. Developing management reference points for elasmobranchs based on their life-history information is more feasible than traditional stock assessments. Evaluating natural mortality rate estimators is crucial for developing reference points, with different methods producing varying results for estimating fishing mortality reference points.

FISH AND FISHERIES (2022)

Article Fisheries

Estimating growth from length frequency distribution: comparison of ELEFAN and Bayesian approaches for red endeavour prawns (Metapenaeus ensis)

Shijie Zhou, Trevor Hutton, Yeming Lei, Margaret Miller, Tonya van der Velde, Roy Aijun Deng

Summary: Using length frequency distribution data (LFD) is a cost-effective way to estimate somatic growth in fish or invertebrates. This study compares the ELEFAN approach with a Bayesian approach in analyzing LFD and finds that the Bayesian method can accurately estimate L-inf and K, but estimating t(0) is more challenging.

ICES JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE (2022)

Review Fisheries

Oceans of plenty? Challenges, advancements, and future directions for the provision of evidence-based fisheries management advice

Daniel R. Goethel, Kristen L. Omori, Andre E. Punt, Patrick D. Lynch, Aaron M. Berger, Carryn L. de Moor, Eva E. Plaganyi, Jason M. Cope, Natalie A. Dowling, Richard McGarvey, Ann L. Preece, James T. Thorson, Milani Chaloupka, Sarah Gaichas, Eric Gilman, Sybrand A. Hesp, Catherine Longo, Nan Yao, Richard D. Methot

Summary: Marine population modeling is an important research field that supports fisheries interventions. It has made recent advancements to address challenges like climate change and enduring issues such as data limitations. The review highlights the integration of various dimensions in fisheries models, facilitated by interdisciplinary research teams and improved data collection protocols. However, the implementation of model-based advice and sharing of confidential data remain challenges. The authors recommend participatory co-management approaches, wider inclusion of local knowledge and stakeholder input, and improved communication and engagement in fisheries management to make better informed decisions.

REVIEWS IN FISH BIOLOGY AND FISHERIES (2023)

Article Fisheries

Estimating economic-based target reference points for key species in multi-species multi-metier fisheries

Sean Pascoe, Andre E. Punt, Trevor Hutton, Paul Burch, Pia Bessell-Browne, L. Richard Little

Summary: Consideration of economic outcomes is common in fisheries management globally, but few jurisdictions prioritize economic objectives. Australia's federally managed fisheries have adopted maximum economic yield (MEY) as their primary objective, with biomass-based target reference points used in harvest control rules. In the absence of explicit estimates for biomass-based MEY (BMEY), proxy estimates based on maximum sustainable yield (BMSY) are used. However, estimating BMEY in multi-species fisheries is challenging due to assessments conducted at the individual species level, while economic activity spans across species. This complexity is further compounded in fisheries with multiple fishing gears and targeting practices. Using an age-structured bioeconomic model, this study estimates BMEY for key species in a multi-species, multi-metier fishery, revealing higher optimal biomass levels compared to the current proxy-based system, with economic targets sensitive to changing prices and fishing costs.

CANADIAN JOURNAL OF FISHERIES AND AQUATIC SCIENCES (2023)

Article Fisheries

Accounting for risk-catch-cost trade-offs in a harvest strategy for a small, highly variable fishery

Eva E. Plaganyi, Laura K. Blamey, Roy Aijun Deng, Margaret Miller

Summary: Formal harvest strategies are important for decision-making processes in fisheries. This study focuses on the revision of the harvest strategy for Australia's redleg banana prawn fishery to address the challenges posed by short-lived highly-variable stocks. The study discusses the implementation of a seasonal closure, modification of the stock assessment model, and selection of a data-sufficient threshold to determine the need for a stock assessment in a particular year. The revised harvest strategy successfully balances the value of the fishery with the costs of data collection and analysis, while also considering the risks to the fish stock.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2023)

Article Fisheries

Unintended consequences of climate-adaptive fisheries management targets

Cody S. Szuwalski, Anne B. Hollowed, Kirstin K. Holsman, James N. Ianelli, Christopher M. Legault, Michael C. Melnychuk, Dan Ovando, Andre E. Punt

Summary: Climate change can impact global fisheries productivity. Maintaining current management targets is more beneficial for biodiversity protection than increasing catch through climate adaptation in maximum sustainable yield (MSY) based management. The conservation gain of maintaining management targets increases as the harmful impacts of climate change on productivity worsen. New management tools are needed to balance conservation and food production in ecosystems with non-stationary productivity.

FISH AND FISHERIES (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Identifying demographic and environmental drivers of population dynamics and viability in an endangered top predator using an integrated model

A. J. Warlick, G. K. Himes Boor, T. L. McGuire, K. E. W. Shelden, E. K. Jacobson, C. Boyd, P. R. Wade, A. E. Punt, S. J. Converse

Summary: Knowledge about demographic and environmental factors is crucial for designing effective conservation measures. This study used an integrated population model to analyze the endangered Cook Inlet population of beluga whales. The research revealed possible depression in survival and fecundity, and predicted a continued decline with a 17-32% probability of extinction in 150 years. The study highlights the usefulness of integrated population modeling in understanding population dynamics and identifying factors contributing to the failure of protected populations to recover.

ANIMAL CONSERVATION (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Integrated assessment of river development on downstream marine fisheries and ecosystems

Eva Plaganyi, Rob Kenyon, Laura Blamey, Julie Robins, Michele Burford, Richard Pillans, Trevor Hutton, Justin Hughes, Shaun Kim, Roy Aijun Deng, Toni Cannard, Annie Jarrett, Adrianne Laird, Emma Lawrence, Margaret Miller, Chris Moeseneder

Summary: Global demands for freshwater are increasing, leading to substantial downstream impacts on fisheries and ecosystems due to water resource development. This study evaluated the trade-offs between different dam and water extraction options and the functioning of downstream ecosystems. The findings showed that the impacts of water resource development varied depending on species, scenarios, and cross-catchment synergies. The study highlighted the need to consider marine ecosystems and fisheries in the sustainable management of remaining free-flowing rivers globally.

NATURE SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

Article Fisheries

Lack of independence: An insidious and subtle pitfall in model fitting

Miguel Petrere Jr, Davi Butturi-Gomes

Summary: This short communication aims to raise awareness about the misuse of confidence intervals in Ecology and Fisheries statistical models that ignore the lack of independence.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Inclusion of ageing error and growth variability using a bootstrap estimation of age composition and conditional age-at-length input sample size for fisheries stock assessment models

Peter-John F. Hulson, Benjamin C. Williams

Summary: This study evaluates the impact of considering ageing error and growth variability on the determination of input sample size (ISS) in statistical catch-at-age assessment models. The results show that including these sources of uncertainty decreases the ISS determined through bootstrap methods. This indicates that there is more variability in age composition and conditional age-at-length data than previously accounted for. Including these sources of uncertainty improves the estimation of ISS and subsequently improves the quality of stock assessment models.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

The good practices of practicable alchemy in the stock assessment continuum: Fundamentals and principles of analytical methods to support science-based fisheries management under data and resource limitations

Jason M. Cope

Summary: Fishery resource assessment is a complex and challenging task, but with the use of different analysis methods and tools, effective management guidance can be provided even with limited data and resources.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Genomics goes deeper in fisheries science: The case of the blackspot seabream (Pagellus bogaraveo) in the northeast Atlantic

Regina L. Cunha, Joana I. Robalo, Sara M. Francisco, Ines Farias, Rita Castilho, Ivone Figueiredo

Summary: Recent advances in genomics have greatly contributed to the assessment of fish stocks by providing precise identification of genetic boundaries. This study used a genotyping-by-sequencing approach to reveal the existence of an additional genetic cluster of blackspot seabream in the northeast Atlantic, which was not previously identified. Factors such as ocean circulation patterns and local upwelling may play a role in the genetic differentiation observed in this study.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Good Practices for estimating and using length-at-age in integrated stock assessments

Huihua Lee, Mark N. Maunder, Kevin R. Piner

Summary: Estimating growth is important for fish population assessment. Integrated assessment models and the influence of misfitting size composition data have renewed interest in how growth is modeled. The available data types control how the length-at-age relationship is estimated. Estimating length-at-age is complex due to multiple sources of biological variability and difficulties in obtaining representative samples.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Role of material properties in acoustical target strength: Insights from two species lacking a swimbladder

A. Ladino, I. Perez-Arjona, V. Espinosa, M. Chillaron, V. Vidal, L. M. Godinho, G. Moreno, G. Boyra

Summary: This study examines the acoustic properties of skipjack tuna and Atlantic mackerel, both bladderless pelagic fish species, and explains the significant differences observed. The research shows that the differences in material properties of their tissues predict a more than 10 dB greater reduced target strength in skipjack compared to mackerel at certain frequencies.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Marine megafauna interactions with the Peruvian artisanal purse-seine fleet

Nelly Pena-Cutimbo, Cristel Cordero-Maldonado, Clara Ortiz-Alvarez, Joanna Alfaro-Shigueto, Jeffrey C. Mangel

Summary: Bycatch is a global problem for marine megafauna. This study assessed the bycatch interactions of the Peruvian artisanal purse-seine fishery in 2019 and found that all taxa groups were affected by bycatch. Dusky dolphins, guanay cormorants, and eagle rays were the most frequently reported bycatch species.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Analysis of the positioning factors affecting the sustainable fishing gear-Set net

Jen-Ming Liu, Po-Yuk So

Summary: The set-net fishery is an environmentally friendly fishery posing little risk to the marine ecosystem. This study identified ocean temperature, sea surface factors, and climatic factors as the main factors affecting the installation of set-nets.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)

Article Fisheries

Behavioural patterns, spatial utilisation and landings composition of a small-scale fishery in the eastern Mediterranean

Josie L. Palmer, Carina Armstrong, Hasan D. Akbora, Damla Beton, Cigdem Caglar, Brendan J. Godley, Kristian Metcalfe, Meryem Ozkan, Robin T. E. Snape, Annette C. Broderick

Summary: Small-scale fisheries are vital for global food security and cultural heritage, but the lack of information hampers effective management and mitigation of ecological impacts. This study provides the first comprehensive overview of the small-scale fishery fleet in Northern Cyprus. The fleet operates mainly over the continental shelf, using static and demersal gear types, and catches a diverse range of species, some of which are threatened. The findings can be used to improve fisheries management and conservation measures.

FISHERIES RESEARCH (2024)