A comparison study of applying natural iron minerals and zero-valent metals as Fenton-like catalysts for the removal of imidacloprid

Natural iron minerals and zero-valent metals have been widely tested as catalysts for the Fenton-like process, but the systematical comparison study about their catalytic performance was rarely conducted, and the risk of the secondary pollution of toxic heavy metals was still not uncertain. In this paper, a comparison study of applying pyrite, ilmenite, vanadium titano-magnetite (VTM), zero-valent iron (ZVI), and zero-valent copper (ZVC) as Fenton-like catalysts for the removal of imidacloprid was performed. The results showed that ZVI exhibited the highest activity among the recyclable solid catalysts with a removal rate of 96.8% at initial pH 3 using 10.78 mmol/L H2O2, due to iron corrosive dissolution. Vanadium titano-magnetite (VTM) exhibited the best activity at first use among tested minerals but with low reusability. Pyrite with stable morphology showed a medium but sustainable ability to degrade imidacloprid, achieving a removal rate of 10.5% in the fifth use. The reaction much favored the acidic condition of initial pH around 2 or 3. Meanwhile, there was a significant positive correlation between removal efficiency and dissolved Fe or Cu concentration. Pyrite was considered to be a promising catalyst in Fenton-like reaction. It was suggested that the system proceeded predominantly through a homogeneous route via dissolved Fe or Cu ions. Except ZVC and VTM, other tested catalysts showed the low possibility of causing secondary pollution of toxic metals in the application of Fenton-like process.

Automated summary

In this study, a comparison of different iron minerals and zero-valent metals as catalysts for the Fenton-like process for the removal of imidacloprid was conducted. Zero-valent iron (ZVI) showed the highest activity among the recyclable solid catalysts, while pyrite exhibited stability and sustainable ability, making it a promising catalyst for Fenton-like reactions. The system predominantly proceeded through a homogeneous route via dissolved Fe or Cu ions, with low possibility of causing secondary pollution of toxic metals for most tested catalysts.