4.8 Article

Correcting Laser-Based Water Stable Isotope Readings Biased by Carrier Gas Changes

Journal

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
Volume 50, Issue 13, Pages 7074-7081

Publisher

AMER CHEMICAL SOC
DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.6b01124

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. state of Baden-Wurttemberg, Germany (Forschungsprogramm Biookonomie) [TP6S, 7533-10-5-109]
  2. Helmholtz WasserZentrum Munchen of the SolFlux Platform of the Helmholtz Water Network

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Recently, laser-based water stable isotope spectrometers have become popular as they enable previously impossible approaches of environmental observations. Consequently, they have been subjected to increasingly heterogeneous atmospheric conditions. However, there is still a severe lack of data on the impact of nonstandardized gas matrices on analyzer performances. Against this background, we investigated the influence of changing proportions of N-2, O-2, and CO2 in the carrier gas on the isotope measurements of a typical laser-based water stable isotope analyzer (Picarro L2120-0. We combined environmentally relevant mixtures of N-2, O-2, and CO2 with referenced, flash-evaporated water and found that isotope readings of the same water were altered by up to +14.57 parts per thousand for delta O-18 and -35.9 parts per thousand for delta H-2. All tested relationships between carrier gas changes and respective isotope readings were strongly linearly correlated (R-2 > 0.99). Furthermore, an analyzer-measured variable allowed for reliable postcorrection of the biased isotope readings, which we additionally tested on field data. Our findings are of importance for environmental data obtained by analyzers based on the same technology. They are relevant for assays where inconsistent gas matrices or a mismatch in this regard between unknown and reference analyses cannot be excluded, which is in particular common when investigating the soil-vegetation-atmosphere continuum.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.8
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Plant Sciences

Drought reduces water uptake in beech from the drying topsoil, but no compensatory uptake occurs from deeper soil layers

Arthur Gessler, Lukas Bachli, Elham Rouholahnejad Freund, Kerstin Treydte, Marcus Schaub, Matthias Haeni, Markus Weiler, Stefan Seeger, John Marshall, Christian Hug, Roman Zweifel, Frank Hagedorn, Andreas Rigling, Matthias Saurer, Katrin Meusburger

Summary: The study found that European beech mainly takes up water from the topsoil during the early stages of a drought, reduces water uptake as the drought progresses, and cannot compensate for the reduced topsoil water availability by additional uptake from deeper soil layers. After rewetting following a drought, beech can restore water uptake from the topsoil to pre-drought levels.

NEW PHYTOLOGIST (2022)

Article Ecology

Influence of sample preparation procedures on water stable isotopes in plant organs using the water-vapour equilibrium method

Sabrina Santos Pires, Barbara Herbstritt, Christine Stumpp, Markus Weiler, Michael Paul Stockinger

Summary: Water is essential for plant development, and understanding the plant-water relationship is crucial for ensuring food security and conserving ecosystems. Stable isotopes of water are widely used to study ecohydrological processes, such as root water uptake. However, obtaining water samples from plants for stable isotope analysis is laborious and challenging. In this study, the water-vapour equilibrium method was tested to determine stable water isotopes in different plant organs. The study found that cutting samples and equilibrating for 24 hours produced the most reliable isotope ratios. The results were consistent with current understanding of water isotopes in plants, demonstrating the feasibility of the chosen sample preparation method.

ECOHYDROLOGY (2022)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Balancing exploitation and exploration: A novel hybrid global-local optimization strategy for hydrological model calibration

Giuseppe Brunetti, Christine Stumpp, Jiri Simunek

Summary: This paper proposes a hybrid strategy, G-CLPSO, which combines global search properties with exploitation capability for solving optimization problems in hydrological modeling. The results from benchmark tests and synthetic modeling scenarios demonstrate that G-CLPSO outperforms other methods in terms of accuracy and convergence.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

Influence of equilibration time, soil texture, and saturation on the accuracy of porewater water isotope assays using the direct H2O(liquid)-H2O(vapor) equilibration method

Devakunjari Vadibeler, Michael P. Stockinger, Leonard I. Wassenaar, Christine Stumpp

Summary: The experiments showed that the equilibration time for isotopic analysis of water in different textured soils and porewater saturation levels varies, with different optimal times for different soil types and saturation levels. The presence of organic carbon in soil also impacts the equilibration time needed for isotopic equilibrium to be reached, requiring longer times for soils with higher organic carbon content.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2022)

Article Water Resources

Measuring zero water level in stream reaches: A comparison of an image-based versus a conventional method

Amelie Herzog, Kerstin Stahl, Veit Blauhut, Markus Weiler

Summary: The limited number of gauging stations hampers the understanding of the interaction between streamflow, groundwater, and water usage during drought. Non-commercial measurement devices can help overcome this lack of monitoring, but they need thorough testing. The Dreisam River in Germany provided a useful case study area for water quality and quantity monitoring.

HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES (2022)

Article Agronomy

Estimation of evaporation and transpiration rates under varying water availability for improving crop management of soybeans using oxygen isotope ratios of pore water

Gunther C. Liebhard, Andreas Klik, Christine Stumpp, Angela G. Morales Santos, Josef Eitzinger, Reinhard Nolz

Summary: This study investigated the weekly evaporation and transpiration rates in a soybean field under varying soil water conditions. The results showed that vertical soil water distribution and meteorological conditions influenced the transpiration/evaporation rates. During dry periods, evaporation was almost zero, while a wet surface layer increased evaporation.

INTERNATIONAL AGROPHYSICS (2022)

Article Chemistry, Inorganic & Nuclear

Stable isotope patterns of German rivers with aspects on scales, continuity and network status

Paul Koeniger, Christine Stumpp, Axel Schmidt

Summary: River monitoring for tritium in Germany began in the early 1970s and now includes 50 stations and stable isotopes. The stable isotope time series show contributions of snow and ice melt in the Rhine and Danube rivers during summer months. Close to the northern coasts, stable isotope patterns reflect the influence of seawater and tides. Surprisingly, there were no extreme changes in stable isotope patterns during the dry season of 2018/2019, but rather an indication of enhanced groundwater contribution. Continual long-term data across different river basins of varying sizes and altitudes highlight the importance of a co-organized national network.

ISOTOPES IN ENVIRONMENTAL AND HEALTH STUDIES (2022)

Article Chemistry, Inorganic & Nuclear

Nitrate isotopes reveal N-cycled waters in a spring-fed agricultural catchment

Ioannis Matiatos, Luis Araguas-Araguas, Leonard Wassenaar, Lucilena Rebelo Monteiro, Astrid Harjung, Cedric Douence, Martin Kralik

Summary: Nitrate stable isotopes were measured to understand nitrate contamination and microbial cycling processes. In the Fischa-Dagnitz spring and river system in Austria, nitrate concentrations showed minor annual variance, while nitrate isotopes exhibited surprising variability. The isotopic composition helped differentiate between denitrified groundwater inputs and biochemical cycling processes, despite the stable nitrate concentration.

ISOTOPES IN ENVIRONMENTAL AND HEALTH STUDIES (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Reproducible measurements of the 62 H composition of non-exchangeable hydrogen in complex organic materials using the UniPrep2 online static vapour equilibration and sample drying system

Leonard I. Wassenaar, Leonardo Sisti, Matthias Pilecky, Martin Kainz

Summary: Non-exchangeable hydrogen-isotope (62Hn) measurements are important in forensics for sample authenticity, traceability, and provenance determination. However, the measurements are often complicated due to uncontrolled exchangeable hydrogen and moisture contamination, leading to incomparability among laboratories. A revised technical solution (UniPrep2) is introduced to control hydrogen-isotope exchange and enable robust online sample drying and vapor equilibration. This solution empowers isotope analysts to conduct reproducible controlled vapor equilibrations and vacuum-oven evacuation with helium drying, providing accurate and precise 62Hn values for various organic sample types.

METHODSX (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Melting Alpine Water Towers Aggravate Downstream Low Flows: A Stress-Test Storyline Approach

Marit van Tiel, Markus Weiler, Daphne Freudiger, Greta Moretti, Irene Kohn, Kai Gerlinger, Kerstin Stahl

Summary: Droughts can cause extreme low flow in rivers, impacting negatively on their ecosystems. Melting snow and ice in mountain water towers can help alleviate the hydrological consequences of drought, but global warming threatens this cryosphere. A study on the European river Rhine basin shows that low flow situations worsen in future conditions due to increased meteorological drought and glacier ice melt contributions. These findings are important for adaptation planning and are relevant for other river basins.

EARTHS FUTURE (2023)

Article Biochemical Research Methods

Assessing the performance of international laboratories analysing the stable isotope composition (δ15N, δ18O, δ17O) of nitrate in environmental waters

Leonard I. Wassenaar, Cedric Douence, Jodie Miller

Summary: This study evaluated the accuracy and precision of stable-isotope analyses of nitrate conducted by international laboratories. The majority of laboratories were able to accurately determine delta N-15 and delta O-18 results, but had difficulties in determining delta O-17.

RAPID COMMUNICATIONS IN MASS SPECTROMETRY (2023)

Article Soil Science

Managing the pore system: Regenerating the functional pore spaces of natural soils by soil-health oriented farming systems

Gernot Bodner, Anna Zeiser, Katharina Keiblinger, Christoph Rosinger, Samuel Konrad Winkler, Christine Stumpp, Thomas Weninger

Summary: This study evaluates the restoration of soil pore characteristics in the transition towards soil-health oriented farming systems and identifies the factors shaping different pore domains. The results suggest that soil-health oriented pioneer farmers can effectively manage functionally relevant pore domains for climate change resilience by promoting biological agents of structure formation.

SOIL & TILLAGE RESEARCH (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Combining Daily Sensor Observations and Spatial LiDAR Data for Mapping Snow Water Equivalent in a Sub-Alpine Forest

Joschka Geissler, Lars Rathmann, Markus Weiler

Summary: Snow variability in forested environments is challenging to model due to its interactions with the environment. To better understand and validate snow models, reliable observation data at similar scales is required. This study presents a new extensive dataset of daily snow variability in a sub-alpine forest, Switzerland, obtained through a dense sensor network, high-resolution LiDAR data, and manual measurements. Machine learning algorithms are used to identify four spatial clusters with similar snow depth dynamics. By combining these clusters with observed snow depth time series, daily high-resolution maps of snow depth and snow water equivalent (SWE) are derived. These products are the first to provide continuous spatio-temporal snow depth and SWE based on field data.

WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH (2023)

Article Chemistry, Inorganic & Nuclear

Radiocarbon integrity of dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) samples stored in plastic and glass bottles: implications for reliable groundwater age dating

David X. Soto, Luis J. Araguas-Araguas, Liang-Feng Han, Leonard I. Wassenaar

Summary: This study evaluated the impact of storage protocols on carbon isotopes in groundwater and found that using plastic sampling bottles for storage led to contamination and underestimated age estimations. In contrast, using glass bottles for storage can avoid contamination and maintain higher analytical precision.

ISOTOPES IN ENVIRONMENTAL AND HEALTH STUDIES (2023)

Article Water Resources

Simulation of floods caused by intense rain events with the water balance model LARSIM

Ingo Haag, Julia Krumm, Dirk Aigner, Andreas Steinbrich, Markus Weiler

Summary: The distributed water balance model LARSIM has been improved by introducing an infiltration module to simulate infiltration excess, Horton Overland Flow (HOF), and pluvial floods due to intense rainfall. The introduced module has shown promising results in simulating intense rain events in different catchments, laying a foundation for future real-time forecasting of pluvial floods. However, uncertainties in radar-based rainfall estimation can cause disparities in discharge estimation, highlighting the need for further improvements in LARSIM and precipitation forecasting with weather radar.

HYDROLOGIE UND WASSERBEWIRTSCHAFTUNG (2022)

No Data Available