4.7 Review

Advancing adaptive governance of social-ecological systems through theoretical multiplicity

Journal

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY
Volume 57, Issue -, Pages 1-9

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.envsci.2015.11.011

Keywords

Adaptive governance; Systematic literature review; Theoretical multiplicity

Funding

  1. UK Research Council NERC/ESRC/DFID ESPA programme (Adaptive governance of mountain ecosystem services for poverty alleviation enabled by environmental virtual observatories Mountain-EVO) [NE-K010239-1]
  2. NERC [NE/K010123/1, NE/K010204/1] Funding Source: UKRI
  3. Natural Environment Research Council [NE/K010123/1, NE/K010204/1] Funding Source: researchfish

Ask authors/readers for more resources

In recent years there has been rising scientific and policy interest in the adaptive governance of social ecological systems. A systematic literature review of adaptive governance research during the period 2005-2014, demonstrates a vibrant debate taking place that spans a variety of empirical and theoretical approaches. The particular strength of adaptive governance is that it provides a theoretical lens for research that combines the analyses of novel governance capacities such as adaptive capacity, collaboration, scaling, knowledge and learning. As a way to give greater depth and analytical rigour to future studies over the next decade and beyond, we highlight the added value of theoretical multiplicity (i.e., focusing on the combination of theories to address complex problems). We argue that theoretical multiplicity can encourage stronger synergies between adaptive governance and other theoretical approaches and can help address epistemologically grey areas in adaptive governance scholarship, such as power and politics, inclusion and equity, short term and long term change, the relationship between public policy and adaptive governance. (C) 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Environmental Sciences

Scale-sensitive governance in forest and landscape restoration: a systematic review

Daniel Wiegant, Pieter van Oel, Art Dewulf

Summary: Building on existing governance literature, this study proposes a conceptual framework for nine scale-sensitive governance arrangements that aim to improve coordination between governance and ecological scales, as well as alignment between different governance levels. Through a systematic review of 84 empirical journal articles on forest and landscape restoration governance, the study identifies eight out of the nine scale-sensitive governance arrangements. These arrangements, such as task-specific organizations and multilevel networks, play important roles in promoting restoration efforts.

REGIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGE (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Using Adaptive Capacity to Shift Absorptive Capacity: A Framework of Water Reallocation in Highly Modified Rivers

Peter M. Rudberg, Timos Karpouzoglou

Summary: Damming and water regulation create modified rivers with limited ecosystem integrity and resilience, and coupled with the ongoing global biodiversity crisis, river restoration becomes a priority that requires water reallocation. The proposed analytical framework combines insight from social-hydrological resilience and water reallocation research to identify the adaptive capacity in highly modified rivers as the capacity for water reallocation. The analysis of Sweden pre- and post-2019 shows an increase in adaptive capacity post-2019, with water reallocation occurring in smaller rivers and tributaries while leaving larger rivers with limited or increased water allocation to hydropower. The framework has broad general interest and contributes to understanding governance processes and outcomes in terms of modified resource management and resilience shifts.

WATER (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Drought Diagnosis: What the Medical Sciences Can Teach Us

David W. Walker, Louise Cavalcante, Sarra Kchouk, Germano G. Ribeiro Neto, Art Dewulf, Rubens S. Gondim, Eduardo S. Passos Rodrigues Martins, Lieke A. Melsen, Francisco de Assis de Souza Filho, Noemi Vergopolan, Pieter R. Van Oel

Summary: This article introduces a conceptual drought diagnosis framework inspired by diagnostic concepts from the field of medicine, and illustrates the need for this approach through four case studies. The authors argue that current drought management approaches are often reactive and that a comprehensive and proactive diagnosis is needed for more successful prevention and treatment of drought.

EARTHS FUTURE (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Designing fit-for-context climate change adaptation tracking: Towards a framework for analyzing the institutional structures of knowledge production and use

Lucy Njuguna, Robbert Biesbroek, Todd A. Crane, Peter Tamas, Art Dewulf

Summary: This article emphasizes the importance of institutional structures in adaptation tracking and proposes a framework consisting of six dimensions to facilitate the design and use of programs, tools, and practices for tracking adaptation progress.

CLIMATE RISK MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Usability of weather information services for decision-making in farming: Evidence from the Ada East District, Ghana

Rebecca Sarku, Erik Van Slobbe, Katrien Termeer, Gordana Kranjac-Berisavljevic, Art Dewulf

Summary: Smallholder farmers in the Ada East District in Ghana have access to multiple weather information services (WIS), with varying levels of utilization. The usability of existing WIS for farming is influenced by factors such as information source, interaction level with farmers, and continuity in information delivery.

CLIMATE SERVICES (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

Towards a modest imaginary? Sanitation in Kampala beyond the modern infrastructure ideal

Mary Lawhon, Gloria Nsangi Nakyagaba, Timos Karpouzoglou

Summary: The idea of the modern city has a significant impact on the concept and operation of infrastructure. In the case of sanitation policies and practices in Kampala, there is a growing acceptance and support for heterogeneous technological artefacts as part of wider infrastructures. The implications of this technological change for policies, permissions, and socio-economic relations are yet to be fully understood, but new patterns are emerging.

URBAN STUDIES (2023)

Article Development Studies

Investigating project sustainability. Technology as a development object in a community-based project in Naryn, Kyrgyzstan

Katarzyna Cieslik, Art Dewulf, J. Marc Foggin

Summary: The imperative of project sustainability is now a clear policy in development, especially in technology transfer. The link between project sustainability, technology and success needs deeper examination. By using actor-network theory, the study in Kyrgyzstan shows how technological objects shape development processes and attract new actors, enhancing project impact. The dynamic view of sustainability includes continuous delivery of goods and services, durability of achieved changes, and feasibility of independent growth.

OXFORD DEVELOPMENT STUDIES (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Ecuadorian water funds' use of scale-sensitive strategies to stay on course in forest and landscape restoration governance

Daniel Wiegant, Jara Bakx, Nina Flohr, Pieter van Oel, Art Dewulf

Summary: This study aims to identify and analyze the scale challenges faced by two water funds in Ecuador and discuss the scale-sensitive governance strategies they used to overcome these challenges. The study found that both funds had blind spots, temporal and spatial mismatches, and heterogeneity across levels regarding restoration purposes. They deployed tailored strategies to address these challenges and maintain cross-scale fit and cross-level alignment. However, some of these strategies resulted in new scale challenges.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Fighting against, and coping with, drought in Brazil: two policy paradigms intertwined

Louise Cavalcante, Art Dewulf, Pieter van Oel

Summary: This article examines the persistence, coexistence, intertwining, and evolution of drought policy paradigms in northeast Brazil by studying their influence on national policy responses in human-water systems. Through systematic analysis of policy documents, strategic plans, and interviews, the study found that the paradigms of fight-against-drought and cope-with-drought have gradually developed and evolved over time, establishing a coexistence and intertwining relationship in 2016. This research provides new insights into the role of ideas in influencing policy responses to drought.

REGIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGE (2022)

Article Economics

How does the UNFCCC enable multi-level learning for the governance of adaptation?

Javier Gonzales-Iwanciw, Sylvia Karlsson-Vinkhuyzen, Art Dewulf

Summary: Since the adoption of the Cancun Adaptation Framework and the Paris Agreement, adaptation has become a priority in global climate change governance. This paper aims to fill the knowledge gap by analyzing how multi-level learning is considered in the UNFCCC regime and its outcomes, using a legal-technical analysis and qualitative research methods.

INTERNATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL AGREEMENTS-POLITICS LAW AND ECONOMICS (2023)

Article Ecology

Unravelling cross-scale and cross-level challenges in Ethiopian forest and landscape restoration governance

Daniel Wiegant, Gete Zeleke Eshetu, Amare Mekonnen Muluken, Pieter van Oel, Art Dewulf

Summary: This study focuses on the cross-scale and cross-level challenges in Ethiopia's forest and landscape restoration governance context. Through analyzing efforts led by public and non-state actors in the Kafa Biosphere and Mount Guna landscapes, we identified five challenges, including mismatch between short-term tree planting campaigns and restoration timelines, mismatch between planning horizons of restoration-related international development projects and restoration timelines, mismatch between federal and international budget allocation for alternative livelihoods and sustained local restoration processes, mismatch between federal forest and land policies and the secure land tenure conditions needed to sustain local restoration efforts, and misalignment of the forest and landscape restoration portfolio in the cascading government structure.

ECOLOGY AND SOCIETY (2022)

Meeting Abstract Regional & Urban Planning

Political agenda-setting for strategic delta planning in the Mekong Delta: Converging or diverging agendas of policy actors and the Mekong Delta Plan?

Hoang Thi Minh Vo, Gerardo van Halsema, Chris Seijger, Nhan Kieu Dang, Art Dewulf, Petra Hellegers

JOURNAL OF PLANNING LITERATURE (2022)

Meeting Abstract Regional & Urban Planning

Political agenda-setting for strategic delta planning in the Mekong Delta: Converging or diverging agendas of policy actors and the Mekong Delta Plan?

Hoang Thi Minh Vo, Gerardo van Halsema, Chris Seijger, Nhan Kieu Dang, Art Dewulf, Petra Hellegers

JOURNAL OF PLANNING LITERATURE (2022)

Meeting Abstract Regional & Urban Planning

Learning in multi-level governance of adaptation to climate change - A literature review

Javier Gonzales-Iwanciw, Art Dewulf, Sylvia Karlsson-Vinkhuyzen

JOURNAL OF PLANNING LITERATURE (2022)

Article Management

Governing long-term policy problems: Dilemmas and strategies at a Dutch water authority

Wieke D. Pot, Art Dewulf, Catrien J. A. M. Termeer

Summary: This article uses an ethnographic approach to analyze how members of a regional water authority understand and deal with long-term policy problems. It reveals three specific dilemmas and introduces the concept of strategic agility for organizations to proactively respond to unexpected developments.

PUBLIC MANAGEMENT REVIEW (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Defining successful climate services for adaptation with experts

Eva Boon, Jurian Vincent Meijering, Robbert Biesbroek, Fulco Ludwig

Summary: This article introduces a global Delphi study, which presents a widely supported definition for successful climate services. The definition emphasizes the importance of user satisfaction and highlights the need for climate service developers to consider climate change uncertainties, build trust and capacity with users, and tailor interactions based on user needs.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Common pool resource governance in strong-government context: A case study of caterpillar fungus (Ophiocordyceps sinensis) on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau

Zhiqi Zhang, Xiangyu Jia, Zeren Gongbu, Dingling He, Wenjun Li

Summary: This study conducted research in two villages on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau of China and found that the village with interactive and supportive government involvement achieved better outcomes compared to the village with forceful government intervention. This highlights the importance of congruence between government actions and community demands in developing self-governance institutions for natural resource management.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

The role of iconic places, collective efficacy, and negative emotions in climate change communication

Yolanda L. Waters, Kerrie A. Wilson, Angela J. Dean

Summary: This study found that climate messages centered around the Great Barrier Reef (GBR) are more effective in strengthening intentions to adopt energy reduction behaviors. However, they are limited in motivating more impactful civic and social behaviors, including those seeking to influence climate policy support. Messages emphasizing collective efficacy can enhance message effect and influence the uptake of a broader range of behaviors. Emotions related to distress played a significant role in this effect. This research offers an alternative for expanding beyond traditional climate communication strategies.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Investigating the barriers and pathways to implementing satellite data into air quality monitoring, regulation and policy design in the United Kingdom

Daniel A. Potts, Emma J. S. Ferranti, Joshua D. Vande Hey

Summary: This study investigates the barriers to integrating satellite data into air quality management and proposes the creation of a network of experts to facilitate collaboration and knowledge exchange between scientific research and air quality management.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Imagining reef futures after mass coral bleaching events

Amber W. Datta, Carina Wyborn, Brian C. Chaffin, Michele L. Barnes

Summary: Extreme climate events are changing social-ecological systems and challenging environmental governance paradigms. This study explores governance actors' perspectives on the future of reef management after a crisis and finds that multiple and conflicting visions are shaping the trajectory of coral reef governance.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Climate change resiliency response from and within cross-cultural children activities

Ranjan Datta, Prarthona Datta

Summary: This paper discusses the importance of learning climate change solutions from the activities of cross-cultural children, and introduces reflective learning, Indigenous Elders land-based teaching, music and arts learning, and positive interactions with cross-cultural children in a cross-cultural community garden.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Comparing biogenic blue mussel (Mytilus edulis) reef definitions in Northern Europe: Implications for management and conservation

Julie Lydia Stounberg, Karen Timmerman, Karsten Dahl, Maurizio Pinna, Jon C. Svendsen

Summary: To combat biodiversity loss, the European Union established the Natura 2000 network. However, some sites are still not mapped, and habitats remain undefined. This study compared the definitions of blue mussel reefs in different EU member states and identified significant variations in parameters and limits used for reef identification. The study also highlighted the need for compatible and justified habitat definitions to ensure a consistent level of protection.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Farmers perspectives on options for and barriers to implementing climate resilient agriculture and implications for climate adaptation policy

Shilpi Kundu, Edward A. Morgan, James C. R. Smart

Summary: Climate change impacts in low lying coastal areas, like Bangladesh, are negatively affecting food and livelihood security, necessitating adaptation measures to build resilience. However, the effective implementation of these measures is hindered by a lack of local-level knowledge.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Social equity and pluralism in Nature-based Solutions: Practitioners' perspectives on implementation

Theodore Tallent, Aiora Zabala

Summary: This study explores how pluralism and social equity are incorporated into the governance of Nature-based Solutions (NbS) in the field of conservation. Using a conceptual framework of social equity, the researchers analyze five exemplary cases to understand how practitioners assimilate these principles into their practices and governance processes. The findings highlight a strong commitment to participation and involvement of local communities, along with practices that aim to foster actor participation, build local capacity, and strengthen ownership. The study emphasizes the importance of considering diverse voices, perspectives, and forms of knowledge in conservation governance.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Lessons from a plain language analysis: US Clean Air Act Title V public notices as barriers to environmental justice

Natalie Sampson, Carmel Price, Melanie Sampson, Mary Bradshaw, Bianca Freeman

Summary: The Title V program of the Clean Air Act provides opportunities for public participation in permit-related decisionmaking, but there is a lack of substantive changes prioritizing environmental justice in overburdened communities. Increasing the use of plain language can improve public participation by enhancing access, transparency, and accountability. Analysis of public notices revealed poor writing quality and a lack of attention to writing strategies for improved understanding and addressing environmental health and justice. Suggestions for improving public notices are provided, emphasizing the need for plain language and environmental health literacy.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Building adaptive capacity to address coastal flooding: The case of a small Texas City

Karabi Bezboruah, Amruta Sakalker, Michelle Hummel, Oswald Jenewein, Kathryn Masten, Yonghe Liu

Summary: This study examines the role of a rural, community-based nonprofit organization in addressing coastal flooding. Through an analysis of the Ingleside on the Bay Coastal Watch Association (IOBCWA) in Texas, the study finds that the organization has improved the community's adaptive capacity through activities such as community organizing, advocacy, data collection, resident capacity building, and regional communication networks. However, more policies, partnerships, and inclusion of socially vulnerable groups are needed.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Knowledge co-production around the cormorant-fishing conflict using a joint fact-finding approach

Heli Saarikoski, Suvi Vikstrom, Lasse Peltonen

Summary: This paper examines the cormorant conflict in Finland, highlighting the frame conflict resulting from different scales of analysis. The study finds that knowledge co-production processes have the potential to address environmental conflicts and generate practical and contextually appropriate knowledge. Key factors include participants' control over information and third-party facilitation of dialogue.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Inviting a decolonial praxis for future imaginaries of nature: Introducing the Entangled Time Tree

Naomi Terry, Azucena Castro, Bwalya Chibwe, Geci Karuri-Sebina, Codruta Savu, Laura Pereira

Summary: The practice of envisioning the future has deep roots in African traditions, but is not widely used in conventional futuring methodologies. To achieve a decolonial approach to futuring, it is important to consider diverse pasts and storytelling forms. Stories can serve as mechanisms of power, healing, and diversification, leading to more just and ecologically sustainable futures.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Weather information, farm-level climate adaptation and farmers' adaptive capacity: Examining the role of information and communication technologies

Priya Chetri, Upasna Sharma, P. Vigneswara Ilavarasan

Summary: Previous studies have overlooked the role of information in farmers' capacity to adapt to weather and climate variability. This paper examines the relationship between farmers' access to weather information and the uptake of farm-level adaptation strategies, and highlights the potential of information in improving farmers' adaptive capacity. The paper also emphasizes the moderating effect of farmers' social ecosystem on this relationship.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Resource nexus perspectives in the Blue Economy of India: The case of sand mining in Kerala

Baker Matovu, Floor Brouwer, Raimund Bleischwitz, Firas Aljanabi, Meltem Alkoyak-Yildiz

Summary: This paper proposes a novel framework for sustainable sand mining based on Ecosystem Service Assessment. It analyzes the case of Kerala, India to demonstrate the impacts of sand mining on local ecosystems and livelihoods. The article also highlights seven key steps that can guide sustainable sand mining and promote integrated governance systems.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)