4.7 Article

Incentivizing REDD plus : How developing countries are laying the groundwork for benefit-sharing

Journal

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY
Volume 63, Issue -, Pages 44-54

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.envsci.2016.04.018

Keywords

Deforestation; Climate change; REDD; Readiness; Environmental governance; Benefit-sharing

Funding

  1. Spanish Research, Development and Innovation Secretariat through a 'Ramon y Cajal' research fellowship [RYC-2010-07183]
  2. UAB-Banco de Santander Talent Retention Programme
  3. Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research [W 07.68.415]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Benefit distribution plays a central role in incentivizing action in REDD+ (Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Degradation and forest enhancement). Conceived as a global performance-based incentive mechanism to reduce land-use emissions in developing countries, REDD+ involves changes in resource governance by many actors at multiple scales, in order to minimize the climate impact of land use activities or to maximize their contribution to reducing greenhouse gas emissions. A key governance issue for developing countries is how to incentivize action among stakeholders and the way countries design their benefit-sharing mechanisms (BSMs) is therefore seen as a critical factor in determining the success of REDD+ in the long term. This comprehensive research investigates up-to-date national level REDD+ planning documents to provide new evidence on how countries are planning to implement BSMs, including an analysis of common governance themes and where gaps exist. Our unique comparative study based on five country cases reveals that there is a lack of comprehensive participatory, transparent and accountable processes among country strategies and in particular, shortcomings in preparation for local and subnational governance, financial disbursement and dispute-resolution mechanisms. Furthermore, countries are making slow progress on land tenure and carbon rights reform. In fact, such ambiguous legislation on carbon benefits, coupled with weak institutional capacity and ineffective dispute-resolution mechanisms, may make it difficult for REDD+ stakeholders to participate fully in initiatives and receive a fair distribution of benefits. This research indicates that REDD+ actors including donors and national governments will need to further rethink strategies and policy frameworks to improve their BSMs and to guarantee effective, equitable and efficient REDD+ outcomes in the long term. (C) 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Global patterns of adaptation to climate change by Indigenous Peoples and local communities. A systematic review

Anna Schlingmann, Sonia Graham, Petra Benyei, Esteve Corbera, Irene Martinez Sanesteban, Andrea Marelle, Ramin Soleymani-Fard, Victoria Reyes-Garcia

Summary: Indigenous Peoples and local communities around the world have implemented a diverse range of responses to climate change, with about one-third of these responses involving activities beyond adjustments to livelihoods based on natural resources. Local responses to climate change impacts are more likely to be shaped by people's livelihoods globally.

CURRENT OPINION IN ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY (2021)

Article Ecology

Local responses to design changes in payments for ecosystem services in Chiapas, Mexico

Santiago Izquierdo-Tort, Esteve Corbera, Alicia Barceinas Cruz, Julia Naime, Paola Angelica Vazquez-Cisneros, Julia Carabias Lillo, Elisa Castro-Tovar, Fiorella Ortiz Rosas, Nuria Rubio, Leonora Torres Knoop, Jerome Dupras

Summary: PES programs in Mexico have evolved over time to include concerns about production, organization, and social inclusion alongside forest conservation. Local communities have responded to these design changes by trying to ensure continued participation, adjusting benefit-sharing and participation agreements, and experiencing discontinuities in enrollment due to specific design feature changes. Participants' interests align with forest protection goals, but show limited community involvement in conservation efforts.

ECOSYSTEM SERVICES (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Ten facts about land systems for sustainability

Patrick Meyfroidt, Ariane de Bremond, Casey M. Ryan, Emma Archer, Richard Aspinall, Abha Chhabra, Gilberto Camara, Esteve Corbera, Ruth DeFries, Sandra Diaz, Jinwei Dong, Erle C. Ellis, Karl-Heinz Erb, Janet A. Fisher, Rachael D. Garrett, Nancy E. Golubiewski, H. Ricardo Grau, J. Morgan Grove, Helmut Haberl, Andreas Heinimann, Patrick Hostert, Esteban G. Jobbagy, Suzi Kerr, Tobias Kuemmerle, Eric F. Lambin, Sandra Lavorel, Sharachandra Lele, Ole Mertz, Peter Messerli, Graciela Metternicht, Darla K. Munroe, Harini Nagendra, Jonas Ostergaard Nielsen, Dennis S. Ojima, Dawn Cassandra Parker, Unai Pascual, John R. Porter, Navin Ramankutty, Anette Reenberg, Rinku Roy Chowdhury, Karen C. Seto, Verena Seufert, Hideaki Shibata, Allison Thomson, Billie L. Turner Ii, Jotaro Urabe, Tom Veldkamp, Peter H. Verburg, Gete Zeleke, Erasmus K. H. J. zu Ermgassen

Summary: The paper synthesizes 10 important truths in land use, which help explain the challenges of achieving sustainability in land use and point toward solutions. These facts have important implications for guiding scientists, policymakers, and practitioners in meeting sustainability challenges in land use.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (2022)

Article Anthropology

Participatory injustice in Mexico's Readiness process to Reduce Emissions from Deforestation and forest Degradation (REDD plus )

Horacio Almanza-Alcalde, Poshendra Satyal, Esteve Corbera, Alma Patricia SotoSanchez, Martha Pskowski

Summary: Research in Mexico has shown that in the early stages of REDD+, insufficient involvement, particularly the lack of participation from rural communities, has decreased the legitimacy of REDD+ efforts. It is recommended to strengthen the involvement of rural local actors in decision-making forums, provide more information for better understanding, and give them the chance to implement REDD+ activities based on their own institutions and practices.

HUMAN ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Smart, Commodified and Encoded: Blockchain Technology for Environmental Sustainability and Nature Conservation

Andrea Stuit, Dan Brockington, Esteve Corbera

Summary: This article explores the implications of blockchain technology for conservation and environmental policy. The analysis of 27 initiatives reveals that there is no coherent approach yet, with a variety of environmental focuses and the role of blockchain technology in achieving the goals. However, these initiatives share a faith in environmental-commodity markets, surveillance, and lack a critical analysis of the main causes of environmental problems. Blockchain initiatives form a growing community of praxis and deepen ongoing trends in neoliberal environmental governance.

CONSERVATION & SOCIETY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Contradictory distributive principles and land tenure govern benefit-sharing of payments for ecosystem services (PES) in Chiapas, Mexico

Santiago Izquierdo-Tort, Esteve Corbera, Drian Martin, Julia Carabias Lillo, Jerome Dupras

Summary: Payments for Ecosystem Services (PES) provide economic incentives for natural resources management, and this study examines the distributional justice in community-based PES in Chiapas, Mexico. The analysis reveals both continuity and change in how communities share PES benefits, reflecting contradictory justice principles. The distribution of benefits is influenced by pre-existing land tenure features and norms, but communities continuously adjust benefit-sharing arrangements in response to distributional challenges. This study provides novel insights on the evolution, diversity, and complexity of distributive justice in community-based PES.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2022)

Correction Anthropology

Participatory injustice in Mexico's Readiness process to Reduce Emissions from Deforestation and forest Degradation (REDD +) (vol 50, pg 79, 2021)

Horacio Almanza-Alcalde, Poshendra Satyal, Esteve Corbera, Alma Patricia Soto Sanchez, Martha Pskowski

HUMAN ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Integrating justice in Nature-Based Solutions to avoid nature-enabled dispossession

Isabelle Anguelovski, Esteve Corbera

Summary: Nature-Based Solutions (NBS) have received significant attention in global research and policy agreements. However, there is ongoing debate over their ability to achieve environmental and social goals. Current designs often prioritize economic and elite interests, neglecting nature-inspired justice and equity.

AMBIO (2023)

Article Development Studies

How are institutions included in Integrated Conservation and Development Projects? Developing and testing a diagnostic approach on the World Bank's Forest and Community project in Salta, Argentina

Louise Marie Busck-Lumholt, Esteve Corbera, Ole Mertz

Summary: This study develops a diagnostic approach based on Telecoupling theory to assess the level of institutional distance and opportunity for collective decision-making in Integrated Conservation and Development Projects (ICDPs). The findings challenge the notion that participatory implementation is solely determined by project design, highlighting the importance of including local project actors to achieve collaboration, relevance, and social justice.

WORLD DEVELOPMENT (2022)

Review Environmental Sciences

Socio-ecological vulnerability in rural Spain: research gaps and policy implications

Francesco Facchini, Sergio Villamayor-Tomas, Esteve Corbera, Federica Ravera, Gerard Pocull-Belles, Gerard Lluis Codina

Summary: Through a systematic review, this study examines vulnerability research in rural Spain by analyzing scientific literature. The findings reveal an uneven distribution of studies across the country, with Andalucia and Catalunya being the most prevalent regions. Two main research strands, quantitative and qualitative, are identified, with varying scales of analysis. However, only a small percentage of the studies utilize vulnerability concepts and analytical frameworks, and attention to sensitivity factors and adaptive capacity is minimal.

REGIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL CHANGE (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Advancing the understanding of forest conservation dynamics through livelihood and landscape change scenarios: a case study in Chiapas, Mexico

Diana Alfonso-Becares, Mario Giampietro, Esteve Corbera, Tarik Serrano-Tovar

Summary: This article proposes a novel methodology to explore the relationship between livelihood heterogeneity and land use change at the community level, by combining the concept of archetype with the accounting scheme of MUlti-Scale Integrated Analysis of Societal and Ecosystem Metabolism to define and quantify the characteristics of livelihood typologies in socioeconomic and ecological terms. Conservation trade-offs of potential policies are explored through what if scenarios assuming changes in off-farm opportunities, population growth, and conservation/farming subsidies. The approach is tested with a case study of the community of San Isidro, in Chiapas, Mexico. We conclude that the concept of livelihood typologies is useful to inform the debate over conservation prospects in rural environments.

ENVIRONMENT DEVELOPMENT AND SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

From railroad imperialism to neoliberal reprimarization: Lessons from regime-shifts in the Global Soybean Complex

Finn Mempel, Esteve Corbera, Beatriz Rodriguez Labajos, Edward Challies

Summary: Soybeans play a significant role in the global food system and efforts to understand the impact of land use change caused by external factors. However, there is a lack of attention to the historical and social context of these relationships in land system science. This study examines the evolution of the global soybean complex and analyzes how soybeans have been integrated into different provisioning systems. The findings highlight the need for sustainable practices and public interventions to shape the future of the soybean industry.

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING E-NATURE AND SPACE (2023)

Article Ecology

Toward spatial fit in the governance of global commodity flows

Johanna Coenen, Gabi Sonderegger, Jens Newig, Patrick Meyfroidt, Edward Challies, Simon L. Bager, Louise M. Busck-Lumholt, Esteve Corbera, Cecilie Friis, Anna Frohn Pedersen, Perrine C. S. J. Laroche, Claudia Parra Paitan, Siyu Qin, Nicolas Roux, Julie G. Zaehringer

Summary: Global commodity flows pose challenges to sustainability governance due to difficulties in designing governance institutions that fit the scale of problems generated in telecoupled systems. Boundary and resolution mismatches are two types of governance discrepancies. Rescaling governance through trade agreements, due diligence laws, and landscape approaches can address these mismatches, but a combination of multiple approaches is necessary for effective governance.

ECOLOGY AND SOCIETY (2023)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Telecoupling as a framework to support a more nuanced understanding of causality in land system science

Louise Marie Busck-Lumholt, Johanna Coenen, Joel Persson, Anna Frohn Pedersen, Ole Mertz, Esteve Corbera

Summary: This article illustrates the potential of the telecoupling framework to improve causal attribution in land system science. Through reviewing 45 empirical telecoupling studies, the article demonstrates the diverse applications of telecoupling in LSS and its contribution to causal attribution.

JOURNAL OF LAND USE SCIENCE (2022)

Article Ecology

What does comanagement offer? Exploring users' knowledge through mental models in the fishery of La Encrucijada Biosphere Reserve, Mexico

Laia d'Armengol, Isabel Ruiz-Mallen, Cecile Barnaud, Esteve Corbera

Summary: In the comanaged small-scale fishery of La Encrucijada, Mexico, there is a strong consensus that the comanagement initiative is a government-led partnership to subsidize fishers, but there is diversity in views about the actors, their roles, and the resources involved. Limited understanding of the collaborative mechanisms established in the comanagement initiative among local participants may hinder the achievement of environmental and social goals.

ECOLOGY AND SOCIETY (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Defining successful climate services for adaptation with experts

Eva Boon, Jurian Vincent Meijering, Robbert Biesbroek, Fulco Ludwig

Summary: This article introduces a global Delphi study, which presents a widely supported definition for successful climate services. The definition emphasizes the importance of user satisfaction and highlights the need for climate service developers to consider climate change uncertainties, build trust and capacity with users, and tailor interactions based on user needs.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Common pool resource governance in strong-government context: A case study of caterpillar fungus (Ophiocordyceps sinensis) on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau

Zhiqi Zhang, Xiangyu Jia, Zeren Gongbu, Dingling He, Wenjun Li

Summary: This study conducted research in two villages on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau of China and found that the village with interactive and supportive government involvement achieved better outcomes compared to the village with forceful government intervention. This highlights the importance of congruence between government actions and community demands in developing self-governance institutions for natural resource management.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

The role of iconic places, collective efficacy, and negative emotions in climate change communication

Yolanda L. Waters, Kerrie A. Wilson, Angela J. Dean

Summary: This study found that climate messages centered around the Great Barrier Reef (GBR) are more effective in strengthening intentions to adopt energy reduction behaviors. However, they are limited in motivating more impactful civic and social behaviors, including those seeking to influence climate policy support. Messages emphasizing collective efficacy can enhance message effect and influence the uptake of a broader range of behaviors. Emotions related to distress played a significant role in this effect. This research offers an alternative for expanding beyond traditional climate communication strategies.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Investigating the barriers and pathways to implementing satellite data into air quality monitoring, regulation and policy design in the United Kingdom

Daniel A. Potts, Emma J. S. Ferranti, Joshua D. Vande Hey

Summary: This study investigates the barriers to integrating satellite data into air quality management and proposes the creation of a network of experts to facilitate collaboration and knowledge exchange between scientific research and air quality management.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Imagining reef futures after mass coral bleaching events

Amber W. Datta, Carina Wyborn, Brian C. Chaffin, Michele L. Barnes

Summary: Extreme climate events are changing social-ecological systems and challenging environmental governance paradigms. This study explores governance actors' perspectives on the future of reef management after a crisis and finds that multiple and conflicting visions are shaping the trajectory of coral reef governance.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Climate change resiliency response from and within cross-cultural children activities

Ranjan Datta, Prarthona Datta

Summary: This paper discusses the importance of learning climate change solutions from the activities of cross-cultural children, and introduces reflective learning, Indigenous Elders land-based teaching, music and arts learning, and positive interactions with cross-cultural children in a cross-cultural community garden.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Comparing biogenic blue mussel (Mytilus edulis) reef definitions in Northern Europe: Implications for management and conservation

Julie Lydia Stounberg, Karen Timmerman, Karsten Dahl, Maurizio Pinna, Jon C. Svendsen

Summary: To combat biodiversity loss, the European Union established the Natura 2000 network. However, some sites are still not mapped, and habitats remain undefined. This study compared the definitions of blue mussel reefs in different EU member states and identified significant variations in parameters and limits used for reef identification. The study also highlighted the need for compatible and justified habitat definitions to ensure a consistent level of protection.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Farmers perspectives on options for and barriers to implementing climate resilient agriculture and implications for climate adaptation policy

Shilpi Kundu, Edward A. Morgan, James C. R. Smart

Summary: Climate change impacts in low lying coastal areas, like Bangladesh, are negatively affecting food and livelihood security, necessitating adaptation measures to build resilience. However, the effective implementation of these measures is hindered by a lack of local-level knowledge.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Social equity and pluralism in Nature-based Solutions: Practitioners' perspectives on implementation

Theodore Tallent, Aiora Zabala

Summary: This study explores how pluralism and social equity are incorporated into the governance of Nature-based Solutions (NbS) in the field of conservation. Using a conceptual framework of social equity, the researchers analyze five exemplary cases to understand how practitioners assimilate these principles into their practices and governance processes. The findings highlight a strong commitment to participation and involvement of local communities, along with practices that aim to foster actor participation, build local capacity, and strengthen ownership. The study emphasizes the importance of considering diverse voices, perspectives, and forms of knowledge in conservation governance.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Lessons from a plain language analysis: US Clean Air Act Title V public notices as barriers to environmental justice

Natalie Sampson, Carmel Price, Melanie Sampson, Mary Bradshaw, Bianca Freeman

Summary: The Title V program of the Clean Air Act provides opportunities for public participation in permit-related decisionmaking, but there is a lack of substantive changes prioritizing environmental justice in overburdened communities. Increasing the use of plain language can improve public participation by enhancing access, transparency, and accountability. Analysis of public notices revealed poor writing quality and a lack of attention to writing strategies for improved understanding and addressing environmental health and justice. Suggestions for improving public notices are provided, emphasizing the need for plain language and environmental health literacy.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Building adaptive capacity to address coastal flooding: The case of a small Texas City

Karabi Bezboruah, Amruta Sakalker, Michelle Hummel, Oswald Jenewein, Kathryn Masten, Yonghe Liu

Summary: This study examines the role of a rural, community-based nonprofit organization in addressing coastal flooding. Through an analysis of the Ingleside on the Bay Coastal Watch Association (IOBCWA) in Texas, the study finds that the organization has improved the community's adaptive capacity through activities such as community organizing, advocacy, data collection, resident capacity building, and regional communication networks. However, more policies, partnerships, and inclusion of socially vulnerable groups are needed.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Knowledge co-production around the cormorant-fishing conflict using a joint fact-finding approach

Heli Saarikoski, Suvi Vikstrom, Lasse Peltonen

Summary: This paper examines the cormorant conflict in Finland, highlighting the frame conflict resulting from different scales of analysis. The study finds that knowledge co-production processes have the potential to address environmental conflicts and generate practical and contextually appropriate knowledge. Key factors include participants' control over information and third-party facilitation of dialogue.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Inviting a decolonial praxis for future imaginaries of nature: Introducing the Entangled Time Tree

Naomi Terry, Azucena Castro, Bwalya Chibwe, Geci Karuri-Sebina, Codruta Savu, Laura Pereira

Summary: The practice of envisioning the future has deep roots in African traditions, but is not widely used in conventional futuring methodologies. To achieve a decolonial approach to futuring, it is important to consider diverse pasts and storytelling forms. Stories can serve as mechanisms of power, healing, and diversification, leading to more just and ecologically sustainable futures.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Weather information, farm-level climate adaptation and farmers' adaptive capacity: Examining the role of information and communication technologies

Priya Chetri, Upasna Sharma, P. Vigneswara Ilavarasan

Summary: Previous studies have overlooked the role of information in farmers' capacity to adapt to weather and climate variability. This paper examines the relationship between farmers' access to weather information and the uptake of farm-level adaptation strategies, and highlights the potential of information in improving farmers' adaptive capacity. The paper also emphasizes the moderating effect of farmers' social ecosystem on this relationship.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Resource nexus perspectives in the Blue Economy of India: The case of sand mining in Kerala

Baker Matovu, Floor Brouwer, Raimund Bleischwitz, Firas Aljanabi, Meltem Alkoyak-Yildiz

Summary: This paper proposes a novel framework for sustainable sand mining based on Ecosystem Service Assessment. It analyzes the case of Kerala, India to demonstrate the impacts of sand mining on local ecosystems and livelihoods. The article also highlights seven key steps that can guide sustainable sand mining and promote integrated governance systems.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2024)