4.8 Article

Fewer butterflies seen by community scientists across the warming and drying landscapes of the American West

Journal

SCIENCE
Volume 371, Issue 6533, Pages 1042-+

Publisher

AMER ASSOC ADVANCEMENT SCIENCE
DOI: 10.1126/science.abe5585

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. Trevor James McMinn professorship
  2. College of Agriculture and Life Science, Research Innovation and Impact
  3. University of Arizona Libraries

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Uncertainty remains regarding the role of anthropogenic climate change in declining insect populations, partly because our understanding of biotic response to climate is often complicated by habitat loss and degradation among other compounding stressors. We found a 1.6% annual reduction in the number of individual butterflies observed over the past four decades, associated in particular with warming during fall months. The pervasive declines that we report advance our understanding of climate change impacts and suggest that a new approach is needed for butterfly conservation in the region, focused on suites of species with shared habitat or host associations.
Uncertainty remains regarding the role of anthropogenic climate change in declining insect populations, partly because our understanding of biotic response to climate is often complicated by habitat loss and degradation among other compounding stressors. We addressed this challenge by integrating expert and community scientist datasets that include decades of monitoring across more than 70 locations spanning the western United States. We found a 1.6% annual reduction in the number of individual butterflies observed over the past four decades, associated in particular with warming during fall months. The pervasive declines that we report advance our understanding of climate change impacts and suggest that a new approach is needed for butterfly conservation in the region, focused on suites of species with shared habitat or host associations.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.8
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Insects and recent climate change

Christopher A. Halsch, Arthur M. Shapiro, James A. Fordyce, Chris C. Nice, James H. Thorne, David P. Waetjen, Matthew L. Forister

Summary: Insects have adapted to Earth's changing climate over millions of years, but recent climate change and anthropogenic pressures pose new challenges. Research shows that the impact of climate change on insects can be significant compared to changes in land use. A case study on butterflies in Northern California highlights the complexity of montane-adapted insects responding to changing abiotic conditions.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (2021)

Article Ecology

Restoring Palmer's agave in a Lehmann lovegrass dominated grassland in southeastern Arizona

Amy S. Gill, Jeffrey C. Oliver, Helen Fitting, Brooke K. Kubby, Elise S. Gornish

Summary: Dryland restoration is challenging in arid and semiarid regions due to land degradation, non-native species, and climate change. This study in southeastern Arizona found that protecting agaves from herbivory and providing shade resulted in the highest survival rate, while shade alone led to larger agaves. Dense Lehmann lovegrass cover was found to protect agaves from direct sunlight and predation. Land managers can mechanically reduce Lehmann lovegrass or plant agaves in existing vegetation to promote population recovery of Palmer's agave.

RESTORATION ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Genetics & Heredity

A continental-scale survey of Wolbachia infections in blue butterflies reveals evidence of interspecific transfer and invasion dynamics

Vivaswat Shastry, Katherine L. Bell, C. Alex Buerkle, James A. Fordyce, Matthew L. Forister, Zachariah Gompert, Sarah L. Lebeis, Lauren K. Lucas, Zach H. Marion, Chris C. Nice

Summary: In this study, the presence and genetic diversity of Wolbachia infections in North American butterflies of the genus Lycaeides were investigated using genotype-by-sequencing data. The results revealed high infection frequencies in most sampling localities, suggesting interspecific transfer between host lineages as the major mode of infection acquisition. Multiple Wolbachia strains were also observed, indicating complex dynamics between strains and hybridization between butterfly lineages.

G3-GENES GENOMES GENETICS (2022)

Article Ecology

Climatic history, constraints, and the plasticity of phytochemical traits under water stress

Aramee C. Diethelm, Michael Reichelt, Thomas E. Dilts, James P. Farlin, Audrey Marlar, Elizabeth G. Pringle

Summary: Environmental stress can lead to changes in organismal traits and intraspecific variation, influenced by trait plasticity and ecological constraints. Plants can adjust to abiotic stress like drought through chemical changes, but the ability to produce costly metabolites may be limited by local selection and ecological constraints. Climate at the seed source predicts plant chemical plasticity in response to water stress, influencing intraspecific variation in phytochemical traits, showing that local adaptation can shape phytochemical strategies for water limitation.

ECOSPHERE (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Milkweed plants bought at nurseries may expose monarch caterpillars to harmful pesticide residues

Christopher A. Halsch, Sarah M. Hoyle, Aimee Code, James A. Fordyce, Matthew L. Forister

Summary: This study found widespread pesticide contamination in milkweed plants sold in nurseries across the US, with some pesticides known to have sub-lethal effects on monarch butterflies. There was only modest predictive ability of retailer size and milkweed species in determining pesticide levels.

BIOLOGICAL CONSERVATION (2022)

Article Entomology

Botanical Gardens Are Local Hotspots for Urban Butterflies in Arid Environments

Kathleen L. Prudic, Terese Maxine P. Cruz, Jazmyn I. B. Winzer, Jeffrey C. Oliver, Natalie A. Melkonoff, Hank Verbais, Andrew Hogan

Summary: Urban botanical gardens serve as habitats for local wildlife, particularly in the warm and dry climate of the southwest US. They exhibit higher numbers and diversity of butterfly species, acting as important green refugia for pollinators and other wildlife in the face of ongoing aridification due to climate change.

INSECTS (2022)

Article Ecology

Improved topographic ruggedness indices more accurately model fine-scale ecological patterns

Thomas E. Dilts, Marcus E. Blum, Kevin T. Shoemaker, Peter J. Weisberg, Kelley M. Stewart

Summary: This paper introduces a technique that removes the correlation of topographic ruggedness with curvature to accurately represent fine-scale surface ruggedness. The modified ruggedness metrics passed ideal ruggedness criteria and accurately captured surface ruggedness. The habitat selection relationship between desert bighorn sheep and ruggedness was scale-dependent.

LANDSCAPE ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Agricultural margins could enhance landscape connectivity for pollinating insects across the Central Valley of California, USA

Thomas J. Dilts, Scott A. Black, Sarah L. Hoyle, Sarina Jepsen, Emily L. May, Matthew L. Forister

Summary: One of the defining features of the Anthropocene is the decline in ecosystem services and biodiversity caused by the reduction of common organisms, including insects, which play important roles in natural communities and agricultural systems. Protecting insects cannot rely solely on legal protection of distant natural areas, but also requires intelligent management of intensively farmed landscapes, such as the Central Valley of California. A modeling tool for landscape connectivity in insects, considering pollinators in particular, shows that connectivity is possible through the restoration or improvement of agricultural margins, which exceed natural areas in total area. The modeling approach is flexible and can be applied to study changes in land cover and pesticide application rates.

PLOS ONE (2023)

Article Biology

Additive and interactive effects of anthropogenic stressors on an insect herbivore

Christopher A. Halsch, Dominic J. Zullo, Matthew L. Forister

Summary: The pressures of global change, including exposure to environmental toxins, introduction of non-native species, and climate change, have negative effects on the survival of caterpillars. High pesticide exposure and a non-native diet result in significant reductions in survival, while the interactive effects are weaker. This study suggests that the cumulative effects of stressors acting in isolation are sufficient to severely reduce survival and population persistence in the wild.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY B-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Thirty-six years of butterfly monitoring, snow cover, and plant productivity reveal negative impacts of warmer winters and increased productivity on montane species

Christopher A. Halsch, Arthur M. Shapiro, James H. Thorne, Kyle C. Rodman, Adriana Parra, Lee A. Dyer, Zachariah Gompert, Angela M. Smilanich, Matthew L. Forister

Summary: This study examines the effects of climate change on butterfly populations through changes in weather patterns and plant productivity. The results show that snow pack has a positive effect on butterfly occurrence, while low snow pack during droughts leads to reductions in butterfly populations. Additionally, plant primary productivity has consistently negative effects on butterfly occurrence.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY (2023)

No Data Available