4.7 Article

Social exclusion reliably engages the default network: A meta-analysis of Cyberball

Journal

NEUROIMAGE
Volume 227, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ACADEMIC PRESS INC ELSEVIER SCIENCE
DOI: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2020.117666

Keywords

Meta-analysis; Cyberball; Social exclusion; Default network; Meta-analytic connectivity modeling; Functional MRI

Funding

  1. Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada
  2. Canadian Institute of Health Research
  3. National Institute of Aging [AG068563]
  4. Canada First Research Excellence Fund
  5. Fonds de recherche du Quebec - Sante

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Social exclusion refers to the experience of being disregarded or rejected by others, with negative consequences for well-being and cognition. The neural correlates of social exclusion remain a topic of debate, particularly regarding the role of the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex (dACC).
Social exclusion refers to the experience of being disregarded or rejected by others and has wide-ranging negative consequences for well-being and cognition. Cyberball, a game where a ball is virtually tossed between players, then leads to the exclusion of the research participant, is a common method used to examine the experience of social exclusion. The neural correlates of social exclusion remain a topic of debate, particularly with regards to the role of the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex (dACC) and the concept of social pain. Here we conducted a quantitative meta-analysis using activation likelihood estimation (ALE) to identify brain activity reliably engaged by social exclusion during Cyberball task performance (Studies = 53; total N = 1,817 participants). Results revealed consistent recruitment in ventral anterior cingulate and posterior cingulate cortex, inferior and superior frontal gyri, posterior insula, and occipital pole. No reliable activity was observed in dACC. Using a probabilistic atlas to define dACC, fewer than 15% of studies reported peak coordinates in dACC. Meta-analytic connectivity mapping suggests patterns of co-activation are consistent with the topography of the default network. Reverse inference for cognition associated with reliable Cyberball activity computed in Neurosynth revealed social exclusion to be associated with cognitive terms Social, Autobiographical, Mental States, and Theory of Mind. Taken together, these findings highlight the role of the default network in social exclusion and warns against interpretations of the dACC as a key region involved in the experience of social exclusion in humans.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Neurosciences

Lacking social support is associated with structural divergences in hippocampus-default network covariation patterns

Chris Zajner, Nathan R. Spreng, Danilo Bzdok

Summary: Elaborate social interaction is an important asset for the human species, and the complexity of people's social lives plays a significant role in their environment. This study focuses on the relationship between the allocortical hippocampus (HC) and the neocortical default network (DN) in the context of social isolation. The findings suggest that the lack of social support is associated with specific subregions in the DN patterns, and these patterns are linked to HC subfields such as subiculum, presubiculum, CA2, CA3, and dentate gyrus.

SOCIAL COGNITIVE AND AFFECTIVE NEUROSCIENCE (2022)

Article Neurosciences

Temporal pole volume is associated with episodic autobiographical memory in healthy older adults

Roni Setton, Signy Sheldon, Gary R. Turner, R. Nathan Spreng

Summary: Recollection of personal past events differs across the lifespan, with older individuals recalling fewer episodic details and conveying more semantic information than young. This study examines the relationship between gray matter volumes in temporal lobe regions (hippocampus and temporal poles) and age differences in autobiographical recollection. The findings show that older adults have smaller gray matter volumes in the posterior hippocampus and display less episodic and more semantic autobiographical memory compared to younger adults. Age-related associations between temporal pole volumes and episodic autobiographical recall were also observed in older adults, while in younger adults, temporal pole volume was correlated with performance on standard laboratory measures of semantic memory. Exploratory analyses further revealed that the relationship between age-related episodic autobiographical memory and anterior hippocampal volumes was dependent on sex. These findings suggest that age differences in brain structures implicated in episodic and semantic memory may indicate neural circuit reorganization to support autobiographical memory in later life.

HIPPOCAMPUS (2022)

Article Geriatrics & Gerontology

White matter lesion load is associated with lower within- and greater between- network connectivity across older age

Karin Kantarovich, Laetitia Mwilambwe-Tshilobo, Sara Fernandez-Cabello, Roni Setton, Giulia Baracchini, Amber W. Lockrow, R. Nathan Spreng, Gary R. Turner

Summary: White matter hyperintensities (WMH) in older adults are associated with changes in the functional connectome and lower fluid intelligence.

NEUROBIOLOGY OF AGING (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Neurocognitive aging data release with behavioral, structural and multi-echo functional MRI measures

R. Nathan Spreng, Roni Setton, Udi Alter, Benjamin N. Cassidy, Bri Darboh, Elizabeth DuPre, Karin Kantarovich, Amber W. Lockrow, Laetitia Mwilambwe-Tshilobo, Wen-Ming Luh, Prantik Kundu, Gary R. Turner

Summary: This article provides two 10-minute multi-echo functional MRI (ME-fMRI) runs and structural MRI (T1-MPRAGE) data, as well as a large amount of behavioral assessment data, including cognition, personality, and socioemotional functioning. These data are valuable for scientists studying BOLD signal, brain-behavior associations, and aging effects in healthy adults.

SCIENTIFIC DATA (2022)

Article Biology

Time-resolved structure-function coupling in brain networks

Zhen-Qi Liu, Bertha Vazquez-Rodriguez, R. Nathan Spreng, Boris C. Bernhardt, Richard F. Betzel, Bratislav Misic

Summary: The study revealed that the coupling between structure and function in the human brain is regionally heterogeneous, with dynamic structure-function coupling patterns being region-specific. This provides a new perspective to study structure-function relationships and highlights the importance of considering regional differences in brain connectivity.

COMMUNICATIONS BIOLOGY (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Hippocampus and temporal pole functional connectivity is associated with age and individual differences in autobiographical memory

Roni Setton, Laetitia Mwilambwe-Tshilobo, Signy Sheldon, Gary R. Turner, R. Nathan Spreng

Summary: Recollection of personal past, or autobiographical memory (AM), varies across individuals and the life span, and is associated with functional brain networks. Older adults showed lower connectivity within certain brain regions but greater connectivity with the default network compared to younger adults. The connectivity patterns were related to specific types of memories.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Le Petit Prince multilingual naturalistic fMRI corpus

Jixing Li, Shohini Bhattasali, Shulin Zhang, Berta Franzluebbers, Wen-Ming Luh, R. Nathan Spreng, Jonathan R. Brennan, Yiming Yang, Christophe Pallier, John Hale

Summary: This study presents the Le Petit Prince fMRI Corpus (LPPC-fMRI), a multilingual resource for cognitive neuroscience research on speech and language. The corpus includes fMRI data of English, Chinese, and French speakers listening to the same audiobook, as well as time-aligned speech annotations and word-by-word predictors. The dataset is of high quality and can facilitate cross-linguistic comparisons in language processing.

SCIENTIFIC DATA (2022)

Article Neurosciences

Age differences in functional brain networks associated with loneliness and empathy

Laetitia Mwilambwe-Tshilobo, Roni Setton, Danilo Bzdok, Gary R. R. Turner, R. Nathan Spreng

Summary: This study investigates the impact of age on the functional connectivity associated with loneliness and empathic responding using neuroimaging techniques. The results show that there are age-related differences in the functional connectivity of loneliness and empathic responding, suggesting that age may influence social and cognitive functions in the brain. The findings suggest that loneliness is associated with the integration of visual and association networks in younger adults, while empathic responding is associated with the integration of visual and association networks in both age groups. These results highlight the involvement of different neurocognitive processes in social experiences across the lifespan of humans.

NETWORK NEUROSCIENCE (2023)

Review Health Care Sciences & Services

Social Prescription Interventions Addressing Social Isolation and Loneliness in Older Adults: Meta-Review Integrating On-the-Ground Resources

Catherine Paquet, Jocelyne Whitehead, Rishabh Shah, Alayne Mary Adams, Damion Dooley, R. Nathan Spreng, Anna-Liisa Aunio, Laurette Dube

Summary: Social prescription programs aim to link primary care patients with community resources to improve their well-being. This study integrates scientific evidence with on-the-ground knowledge to develop an extensive list of intervention terms and keywords related to reducing social isolation and loneliness in older adults. The findings highlight effective intervention types and the need for efficient identification and structuring of resources to facilitate referrals for older adults.

JOURNAL OF MEDICAL INTERNET RESEARCH (2023)

Article Psychology, Clinical

Analyzing the Factor Structure of the Toronto Empathy Questionnaire: Dimensionality, Reliability, Validity, Measurement Invariance and One-Year Stability of the German Version

Tobias Janelt, Tobias Altmann, R. Nathan Spreng, Marcus Roth

Summary: The study aimed to validate the German version of the TEQ and contribute empirical evidence to the debate on its singular versus multidimensional factor structure. The results showed that TEQ has a unidimensional factor structure and demonstrated sufficient internal consistency, test-retest reliability, one-year stability, as well as convergent and discriminant validity with measures of empathy, emotion recognition, emotion regulation, altruism, social desirability, and the Big Five personality traits.

JOURNAL OF PERSONALITY ASSESSMENT (2023)

Article Clinical Neurology

Longitudinal changes in hippocampal texture from healthy aging to Alzheimer's disease

Alfie Wearn, Lars Lau Raket, D. Louis Collins, R. Nathan Spreng

Summary: Early detection of Alzheimer's disease is crucial for preventive treatment strategies. Texture analysis of the hippocampus can detect microstructural changes before cognitive impairment occurs, providing additional information beyond hippocampal volume for predicting future cognitive decline.

BRAIN COMMUNICATIONS (2023)

Article Psychology, Mathematical

Taking stock of the past: A psychometric evaluation of the Autobiographical Interview

Amber W. W. Lockrow, Roni Setton, Karen A. P. Spreng, Signy Sheldon, Gary R. R. Turner, R. Nathan Spreng

Summary: Autobiographical Interview (AI) is a performance-based assessment that quantifies the episodic and semantic features of recalled and verbally conveyed prior experiences. This study investigated the reliability, validity, association to individual differences measures, and factor structure of the AI in healthy younger and older adults. The AI demonstrated strong reliability, validity, and a two-factor structure, and showed correlations with standard measures of episodic memory.

BEHAVIOR RESEARCH METHODS (2023)

Article Psychology, Mathematical

Troubled past: A critical psychometric assessment of the self-report Survey of Autobiographical Memory (SAM)

Roni Setton, Amber W. Lockrow, Gary R. Turner, R. Nathan Spreng

Summary: The SAM showed reliability as a self-report measure of perceived recollective capacity, but weak associations with actual memory performance and age effects were observed. It was significantly associated with self-efficacy, suggesting confidence in general self-report abilities. Caution is advised in using and interpreting the SAM as a measure of autobiographical memory, pending further validation and revision.

BEHAVIOR RESEARCH METHODS (2022)

Article Neurosciences

Solving large-scale MEG/EEG source localisation and functional connectivity problems simultaneously using state-space models

Jose Sanchez-Bornot, Roberto C. Sotero, J. A. Scott Kelso, Ozguer Simsek, Damien Coyle

Summary: This study proposes a multi-penalized state-space model for analyzing unobserved dynamics, using a data-driven regularization method. Novel algorithms are developed to solve the model, and a cross-validation method is introduced to evaluate regularization parameters. The effectiveness of this method is validated through simulations and real data analysis, enabling a more accurate exploration of cognitive brain functions.

NEUROIMAGE (2024)