4.6 Review

Mentorship of Underrepresented Physicians and Trainees in Academic Medicine: a Systematic Review

Journal

JOURNAL OF GENERAL INTERNAL MEDICINE
Volume 36, Issue 4, Pages 1023-1034

Publisher

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s11606-020-06478-7

Keywords

mentorship; underrepresented in medicine

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This review identified successful mentoring programs for URiM physicians and highlighted the importance of institutional support for diversity, tailored programs based on local needs and resources, mentor training, and the utilization of both URiM and non-URiM mentors for optimal outcomes.
Background Though the USA is becoming increasingly diverse, the physician workforce contains a disproportionately low number of physicians from racial and ethnic groups that are described as underrepresented in medicine (URiM). Mentorship has been proposed as one way to improve the retention and experiences of URiM physicians and trainees. The objective of this systematic review was to identify and describe mentoring programs for URiM physicians in academic medicine and to describe important themes from existing literature that can aid in the development of URiM mentorship programs. Methods The authors searched PubMed, PsycINFO, ERIC, and Cochrane databases, and included original publications that described a US mentorship program involving academic medical doctors at the faculty or trainee level and were created for physicians who are URiM or provided results stratified by race/ethnicity. Results Our search yielded 4,548 unique citations and 31 publications met our inclusion criteria. Frequently cited objectives of these programs were to improve research skills, to diversify representation in specific fields, and to recruit and retain URiM participants. Subjective outcomes were primarily participant satisfaction with the program and/or work climate. The dyad model of mentoring was the most common, though several novel models were also described. Program evaluations were primarily subjective and reported high satisfaction, although some reported objective outcomes including publications, retention, and promotion. All showed satisfactory outcomes for the mentorship programs. Discussion This review describes a range of successful mentoring programs for URiM physicians. Our recommendations based on our review include the importance of institutional support for diversity, tailoring programs to local needs and resources, training mentors, and utilizing URiM and non-URiM mentors.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Medicine, General & Internal

Health Outcomes Used to Determine Facets of Health-related Quality of Life for Post-9/11 Veterans Using Assistive Technology for A Combat-related Mobility Impairment: A Literature Review

Mark Greenhalgh, Hailee Kulich, Eline Blaauw, Rose Turner, Sara Peterson, Rory A. Cooper, Thomas Songer

Summary: This article reviews health outcomes of combat-injured service members after 9/11 and indicates that assistive technology can improve health states for those with mobility impairments. The study categorizes different domains and subdomains into six categories to determine overall HR-QoL, and suggests that further research is needed in this area.

MILITARY MEDICINE (2021)

Review Clinical Neurology

Does the evidence support brief (≤30-mins), moderate (31-60-mins), or long duration naps (61+mins) on the night shift? A systematic review

P. Daniel Patterson, Mary K. Liszka, Quentin S. Mcilvaine, Lily Nong, Matthew D. Weaver, Rose L. Turner, Thomas E. Platt, Samantha E. Opitz, Francis X. Guyette, Christian Martin-Gill, Leonard S. Weiss, Daniel J. Buysse, Clifton W. Callaway

Summary: This study conducted a systematic review of experimental research to investigate the impact of nap duration during night shifts on fatigue mitigation, health, safety, and performance. The findings showed mixed results on the effects of brief, moderate, and long duration naps, with all seven studies exhibiting serious risk of bias and low quality of evidence. It suggests that decisions regarding nap duration during night shifts should consider post-nap time and outcomes.

SLEEP MEDICINE REVIEWS (2021)

Article Cardiac & Cardiovascular Systems

Racial Diversity Among American Cardiologists Implications for the Past, Present, and Future

Amber E. Johnson, Mehret Birru Talabi, Eliana Bonifacino, Alison J. Culyba, Esa M. Davis, Paula K. Davis, Laura M. De Castro, Utibe R. Essien, Alda Maria Gonzaga, MaCalus Hogan, Alaina J. James, Charles R. Jonassaint, Naudia L. Jonassaint, Loreta Matheo, Melonie A. Nance, G. Sarah Napoe, Oladipupo Olafiranye, Sylvia Owusu-Ansah, Tomar N. Pierson-Brown, A. J. Conrad Smith, Tomeka L. Suber, Orquidia Torres, Rickquel Tripp, Eloho Ufomata, J. Deanna Wilson, Jeannette E. South-Paul

Summary: Race-based disparities in cardiovascular disease care are pervasive in the United States, with African American/Black, Hispanic/Latinx, and Native/Indigenous American individuals at increased risk and less likely to receive high-quality medical care. Diversity among healthcare providers is associated with better quality of care, and racial diversity among academic teams and research scientists is linked with research quality.

CIRCULATION (2021)

Review Gerontology

A Systematic Review of Tools Assessing the Perspective of Caregivers of Residents With Dementia

Alexandra E. Harper, Stephanie Rouch, Natalie E. Leland, Rose L. Turner, William E. Mansbach, Claire E. Day, Lauren Terhorst

Summary: A systematic review was conducted to assess self-report tools measuring the perspective of family caregivers of nursing home residents with dementia, revealing gaps in tools measuring specific domains important to stakeholders. Future research should focus on developing psychometrically sound tools aligned with the multidomain caregiver perspective.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED GERONTOLOGY (2022)

Review Neurosciences

Mini-review: Robotic wheelchair taxonomy and readiness

Sivashankar Sivakanthan, Jorge L. Candiotti, Andrea S. Sundaram, Jonathan A. Duvall, James Joseph Gunnery Sergeant, Rosemarie Cooper, Shantanu Satpute, Rose L. Turner, Rory A. Cooper

Summary: This article introduces a taxonomy and readiness model for robotic wheelchairs, and analyzes the slow progress of innovations in this field in translating into the marketplace.

NEUROSCIENCE LETTERS (2022)

Review Oncology

Impact of non-pharmacological interventions on activity limitations and participation restrictions in older breast cancer survivors: A scoping review

Rachelle Brick, Rose Turner, Catherine Bender, Madilyn Douglas, Rachel Eilers, Robert Ferguson, Natalie Leland, Kathleen D. Lyons, Pamela Toto, Elizabeth Skidmore

Summary: Cancer-related disability is a complex problem for older breast cancer survivors, with limited understanding of how interventions influence activity limitations and participation restrictions. Current research suggests that exercise and behavioral strategies can be effective nonpharmacological interventions. However, the study samples are not representative of the actual population, and future research should focus on clarifying and comprehensively measuring intervention measures.

JOURNAL OF GERIATRIC ONCOLOGY (2022)

Review Otorhinolaryngology

Non-Pharmacological and Non-Surgical Feeding Interventions for Hospitalized Infants with Pediatric Feeding Disorder: A Scoping Review

Amanda S. Mahoney, Molly O'Donnell, James L. Coyle, Rose Turner, Katherine E. White, Stacey A. Skoretz

Summary: The aim of this study was to review the literature on infant feeding and swallowing interventions and identify areas for further research. The researchers found that while the body of research in this area has grown, there is still a need for studies focused on infants with various medical complexities and interventions that lack supporting evidence.

DYSPHAGIA (2023)

Review Sport Sciences

Prevention of Lower Extremity Musculoskeletal Injuries in Tactical and First Responder Populations: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Trials From 1955 to 2020

Aaron M. Sinnott, Kellen T. Krajewski, Alice D. LaGoy, Meaghan E. Beckner, Felix Proessl, Maria C. Canino, Bradley C. Nindl, Rose L. Turner, Mita T. Lovalekar, Chris Connaboy, Shawn D. Flanagan

Summary: Lower extremity musculoskeletal injuries (LEMSIs) pose a significant burden on tactical and first responder populations. A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials from 1955 to 2020 was conducted to determine the effectiveness of LEMSI prevention strategies. The results indicate weak evidence to support current LEMSI prevention strategies.

JOURNAL OF STRENGTH AND CONDITIONING RESEARCH (2023)

Review Integrative & Complementary Medicine

Face-to-face telehealth interventions in the treatment of low back pain: A systematic review

Christopher G. Bise, Zachary Cupler, Sean Mathers, Rose Turner, Meenakshi Sundaram, Maria Beatriz Catelani, Sarah Dahler, Adam Popchak, Michael Schneider

COMPLEMENTARY THERAPIES IN CLINICAL PRACTICE (2023)

Review Rehabilitation

Prehabilitation for spine surgery: A scoping review

James E. Eubanks, Cristiane Carlesso, Meenakshi Sundaram, Geronimo Bejarano, Rob J. E. M. Smeets, Richard Skolasky, Maria Vanushkina, Rose Turner, Michael J. Schneider

Summary: This study aimed to identify and describe the interventions used in preoperative programs for spine surgery. The findings suggest that prehabilitation programs are feasible and have the potential to improve physical and psychological outcomes for patients undergoing spine surgery. More studies are needed to determine optimal patient characteristics and intervention strategies.
Meeting Abstract Rehabilitation

Goal-Oriented Interventions to Improve Disability & Functional Status in Adults With Multiple Chronic Conditions: A Systematic Review

Tara C. Klinedinst, Jennie Dorris, Rose Turner, Carrie Ciro, Juleen Rodakowski

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY (2023)

Review Health Care Sciences & Services

A Scoping Review of US Insurers Use of Patient-Reported Outcomes '

Janel Hanmer, Amy M. Cizik, Bernice G. Gulek, Polly McCracken, Elizabeth C. S. Swart, Rose Turner, Suzanne M. Kinsky

Summary: This scoping review examined the use of health-related quality of life patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) by US health insurers. The review found a wide range of articles across different insurance providers, health conditions, and uses of PROMs. However, there is a lack of data in pediatric populations and limited information on the use of data collected within health care settings that is transmitted to health insurers.

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MANAGED CARE (2022)

Review Gerontology

The experiences, priorities, and perceptions of informal caregivers of people with dementia in nursing homes: A scoping review

Alexandra E. Harper, Lauren Terhorst, Marybeth Moscirella, Rose L. Turner, Catherine Piersol, Natalie E. Leland

Summary: A total of 114 articles were reviewed, identifying nine key themes related to caregivers' perspectives of nursing home care for residents with dementia, including communication, transition to nursing home, quality of care, quality of life, informal caregiver role, knowledge of dementia, end-of-life preferences, medication use, and finances. Communication issues were the most frequently discussed, highlighting the need for improvement in this area. Researchers may view these themes separately, but caregivers perceive them to be interconnected in relation to person-centered care delivery.

DEMENTIA-INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SOCIAL RESEARCH AND PRACTICE (2021)

No Data Available