4.6 Article

Comparing coal phase-out pathways: The United Kingdom's and Germany's diverging transitions

Journal

ENVIRONMENTAL INNOVATION AND SOCIETAL TRANSITIONS
Volume 37, Issue -, Pages 238-253

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.eist.2020.09.001

Keywords

Coal phase-out; energy transition; Triple Embeddedness Framework; Germany; the United Kingdom; energy policy; climate policy

Funding

  1. German Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) by financing the research group CoalExit as part of the Global Change funding priority [01LN1704A]
  2. German Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) by project Future of Fossil Fuels in the Wake of Greenhouse Gas Neutrality being part of the Economics of Climate Change funding priority [01LA1810A]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Political decisions and trends regarding coal use for electricity generation developed differently in the UK and Germany, despite being subject to relatively similar climate protection targets and general political and economic conditions. The UK agreed on a coal phase-out by 2024. In Germany, a law schedules a coal phase-out by 2038 at the latest. This paper investigates reasons for the different developments and aims to identify main hurdles and drivers of coal phase-outs by using the Triple Embeddedness Framework. The comparative case study approach reveals that policy outcomes regarding coal consumption are deeply influenced by several actor groups, namely, coal companies, unions, environmental NGOs, and the government. The most discussed aspects of a coal phase-out in both countries are energy security concerns, whether coal is mined domestically, (regional) economic dependence, as well as the relative power of actors with vested interests in coal consumption.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Economic Resilience of German Lignite Regions in Transition

Nora Stognief, Paula Walk, Oliver Schoettker, Pao-Yu Oei

SUSTAINABILITY (2019)

Article Energy & Fuels

Strengthening Gender Justice in a Just Transition: A Research Agenda Based on a Systematic Map of Gender in Coal Transitions

Paula Walk, Isabell Braunger, Josephine Semb, Carolin Brodtmann, Pao-Yu Oei, Claudia Kemfert

Summary: The research shows that the phase-out of coal has both opportunities and burdens for women, with gender playing a significant role in agency within coal transitions. The study emphasizes the importance of gender-responsive policies in sustainability transitions and highlights the need for further research on the impact of such transitions on women's lives.

ENERGIES (2021)

Review Environmental Sciences

Coal transitions-part 1: a systematic map and review of case study learnings from regional, national, and local coal phase-out experiences

Francesca Diluiso, Paula Walk, Niccolo Manych, Nicola Cerutti, Vladislav Chipiga, Annabelle Workman, Ceren Ayas, Ryna Yiyun Cui, Diyang Cui, Kaihui Song, Lucy A. Banisch, Nikolaj Moretti, Max W. Callaghan, Leon Clarke, Felix Creutzig, Jerome Hilaire, Frank Jotzo, Matthias Kalkuhl, William F. Lamb, Andreas Loeschel, Finn Mueller-Hansen, Gregory F. Nemet, Pao-Yu Oei, Benjamin K. Sovacool, Jan C. Steckel, Sebastian Thomas, John Wiseman, Jan C. Minx

Summary: A rapid coal phase-out is crucial to meet the Paris Agreement goals, but faces challenges such as vested interests and social disruption risks. This paper provides a systematic review of historical coal transitions, highlighting the importance of targeting both demand and supply side transitions for successful coal phase-outs. Policymakers play a crucial role in facilitating coal transitions through regulatory instruments and investment plans.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2021)

Article Environmental Studies

Power in transitions: Gendered power asymmetries in the United Kingdom and the United States coal transitions

Isabell Braunger, Paula Walk

Summary: This article discusses the need for major sustainability transition processes in the coming decades to meet international climate protection targets, which will result in profound economic and social changes. By using historical coal transitions in the UK and the USA as examples, the authors demonstrate how women are differently affected by the transition and how they engage in shaping the processes. Through analysis and data extraction, a gendered analytical layer is added to the existing Power in Transitions (POINT) framework, providing a tool for systematic analysis of gender issues in transition research. Furthermore, the empirical results lead to suggestions for gender-just transition policies.

ENERGY RESEARCH & SOCIAL SCIENCE (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

From coal phase-out to net zero: Driving factors of UK climate policy

Paula Walk, Nora Stognief

Summary: In order to meet the targets of the Paris Agreement, global net greenhouse gas emissions must be reduced to zero by the middle of the century. The UK has taken a leading role by phasing out coal by 2024 and setting a net zero target for 2050. The decision to phase out coal was driven by policies and contextual factors that were not initially associated with the phase-out. The net zero decision was influenced by the recommendations of the Committee on Climate Change, a general political mood for more climate protection, and the Conservative Party's ambition for climate protection. Continuities in UK climate policy can be seen in the importance of scientific expertise, social movements, cost arguments, and political consensus among relevant parties.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Analysing transitions in-the-making: A case study of aviation in Sweden

Emily Christley, Emrah Karakaya, Frauke Urban

Summary: This paper analyzes the transitions in the aviation industry in Sweden and examines the role of narratives as coordinating mechanisms in sustainability transitions. The study finds that industry actors construct narratives about alternative fuels and technologies to maintain the societal function of aviation while mitigating its climate impact. Narratives not only initiate transitions but also play a vital role in coordinating actors' transition activities.

ENVIRONMENTAL INNOVATION AND SOCIETAL TRANSITIONS (2024)