4.5 Article

Relative Differences between Nonlinear and Equivalent-Linear 1-D Site Response Analyses

Journal

EARTHQUAKE SPECTRA
Volume 32, Issue 3, Pages 1845-1865

Publisher

EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH INST
DOI: 10.1193/051215EQS068M

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. Pacific Earthquake Engineering Research Center (PEER) as part of NGA-East
  2. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC)
  3. U.S. Department of Energy (DOE)
  4. Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI)
  5. U.S. Geological Survey (USGS)

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study investigates the conditions for which one-dimensional (1-D) nonlinear (NL) site response analysis results are distinct from equivalent-linear (EL) results and provides guidance for predicting when differences are large enough to be of practical significance. Relative differences in spectral accelerations and Fourier amplitudes computed from NL and EL analyses are assessed for a range of site conditions and for suites of input motions appropriate for active crustal and stable continental regions. Among several considered parameters, EL/NL differences are most clearly dependent on shear strain index (I-gamma), defined as the ratio of input motion peak velocity to time-averaged shear-wave velocity in the top 30 m of the soil profile. For small I-gamma (generally under 0.03%), EL and NL results are practically identical, whereas at larger strains, differences can be significant for frequencies >0.3 Hz. Frequency-dependent I-gamma, values are recommended for conditions above which NL analyses are preferred to EL.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Engineering, Civil

Site parameters applied in NGA-Sub database

Sean K. Ahdi, Dong Youp Kwak, Timothy D. Ancheta, Victor Contreras, Tadahiro Kishida, Annie O. Kwok, Silvia Mazzoni, Francisco Ruz, Jonathan P. Stewart

Summary: This passage introduces the organization of NGA-Sub data resources into a relational database and describes the Site table within that structure. It provides metadata for 6502 stations that have recorded earthquakes. The critical parameters for ground motion modeling, such as time-averaged shear-wave velocity (V-S(30)) and depths to various V-S horizons, are discussed. Proxy-based estimation frameworks are used when reliable data is not available, and uncertainties are provided for validation-free estimates.

EARTHQUAKE SPECTRA (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

NGA-Sub source and path database

Victor Contreras, Jonathan P. Stewart, Tadahiro Kishida, Robert B. Darragh, Brian S. J. Chiou, Silvia Mazzoni, Robert R. Youngs, Nicolas M. Kuehn, Sean K. Ahdi, Katie Wooddell, Ruben Boroschek, Fabian Rojas, Jennyfer Ordenes

Summary: We present the source and path attributes of the NGA-Sub project's relational database, which contains information on 991 earthquakes from 1937 to 2016. The curated data includes earthquakes with high magnitudes, with 73% having M > 5 and 13 events having M > 8. The attributes in the database cover moment tensor, finite-fault parameters, and categorizations based on event types and sequence classification.

EARTHQUAKE SPECTRA (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

Relational database used for ground-motion model development in the NGA-sub project

Silvia Mazzoni, Tadahiro Kishida, Jonathan P. Stewart, Victor Contreras, Robert B. Darragh, Timothy D. Ancheta, Brian S. J. Chiou, Walter J. Silva, Yousef Bozorgnia

Summary: The NGA-Sub project has developed a relational database containing data resources and ground motion models for global subduction zone regions. The database consists of 20 tables and contains 71,340 three-component records from 1880 earthquakes. The data can be accessed to obtain ground motion intensity measures for different oscillator periods.

EARTHQUAKE SPECTRA (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

NGA-Subduction research program

Yousef Bozorgnia, Norman A. Abrahamson, Sean K. Ahdi, Timothy D. Ancheta, Linda Al Atik, Ralph J. Archuleta, Gail M. Atkinson, David M. Boore, Kenneth W. Campbell, Brian S-J Chiou, Victor Contreras, Robert B. Darragh, Sahar Derakhshan, Jennifer L. Donahue, Nick Gregor, Zeynep Gulerce, I. M. Idriss, Chen Ji, Tadahiro Kishida, Albert R. Kottke, Nicolas Kuehn, DongYoup Kwak, Annie O-L Kwok, P. Lin, Jorge Macedo, Silvia Mazzoni, Saburoh Midorikawa, Sifat Muin, Grace A. Parker, Sanaz Rezaeian, Hongjun Si, Walter J. Silva, Jonathan P. Stewart, Melanie Walling, Katie Wooddell, Robert R. Youngs

Summary: This article summarizes the Next Generation Attenuation (NGA) Subduction (NGA-Sub) project, which aims to develop a database and ground motion models (GMMs) for subduction regions. The project has developed the largest global database of subduction earthquakes, with 214,020 individual records from 1,880 subduction events. Four GMMs have been developed, including three global subduction GMMs and one Japan-specific model. The GMMs provide median predictions and variability for various ground motion parameters, and account for epistemic uncertainty in regions with sparse data. A damping scaling model has also been developed for adjusting predicted results.

EARTHQUAKE SPECTRA (2022)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Relational Database for Horizontal-to-Vertical Spectral Ratios

Pengfei Wang, Paolo Zimmaro, Tristan E. Buckreis, Tatiana Gospe, Scott J. Brandenberg, Sean K. Ahdi, Alan Yong, Jonathan P. Stewart

Summary: Frequency-dependent horizontal-to-vertical spectral ratios (HVSRs) can provide useful information for site response modeling, but are not commonly included in ground-motion models. To facilitate the use of HVSR, we developed a publicly accessible relational database that contains microtremor-based HVSR data and supporting metadata. Users can interact with the data through a graphical user interface or use external tools for further analysis.

SEISMOLOGICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Development of a Generalized Cross-Building Structural Response Reconstruction Model Using Strong Motion Data

Han Sun, Henry Burton, Jonathan P. Stewart, John W. Wallace

Summary: Models for reconstructing seismic response demands across multiple buildings can aid in cluster-level rapid postearthquake damage assessment. Given the recorded responses for a subset of instrumented buildings in a cluster, the demands in the uninstrumented buildings can be reconstructed by combining the median values generated from the structural response prediction model (SRPM) and estimated within-event residuals obtained from the kriging model.

JOURNAL OF STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Soil liquefaction potential assessment using ambient noise: A case study in Pohang, Korea

Su Young Kang, Kwang-Hee Kim, Yong Sik Gihm, Byungmin Kim

Summary: The spatial distribution of the ground vulnerability index (K ( g )), estimated via ambient noise analysis, correlates well with the distribution of sand boils, making it an affordable supplement for earthquake screening and regional evaluations.

FRONTIERS IN EARTH SCIENCE (2022)

Article Engineering, Geological

Effects of pulse-like ground motions and wavelet asymmetry on responses of cantilever retaining wall

Seong Jun Ha, Hwanwoo Seo, Byungmin Kim

Summary: Fault-rupture processes generate pulse-like ground motions in near-fault regions, characterized by large-amplitude long-period pulsing that can cause severe structural damage. This study examines their impact on cantilever retaining wall responses using numerical simulations. The research shows that the relative wall movements induced by pulse-like and non-pulse-like motions are not significantly different, instead, they are highly influenced by the ground motion Arias intensity. The simulations also demonstrate that ground motion asymmetry can affect the wall response, with motion asymmetric to the wall movement direction generating larger wall displacements.

SOIL DYNAMICS AND EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Unmanned aerial vehicles for planning rooftop rainwater harvesting systems: a case study from Gurgaon, India

Harish Puppala, Pranav R. T. Peddinti, Byungmin Kim, Manoj Kumar Arora

Summary: Rooftop rainwater harvesting systems effectively provide water access by storing precipitated water. The use of satellite imagery has limitations on spatial resolution, thus UAVs with high-resolution spatial imagery have become popular. This study utilizes UAV-generated orthomosaics to estimate the harvestable quantity of rainwater and identifies a suitable site for constructing the storage unit using GIS.

WATER SUPPLY (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Effectiveness of nanoparticles-based ultrahydrophobic coating for concrete materials

Saikat Sinha Ray, Pranav R. T. Peddinti, Ritesh Soni, Byungmin Kim, You-In Park, In-Chul Kim, Chang Young Lee, Young-Nam Kwon

Summary: This paper examines the performance of protective surface coatings applied to concrete, the most common building material. A novel synthesis method for producing ultrahydrophobic coatings is demonstrated, enhancing concrete impermeability. The modified concrete specimens showed superior hydrophobicity, which is crucial for maintaining the intended longevity and performance of various concrete materials.

JOURNAL OF BUILDING ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Engineering, Geological

Responses of a cantilever retaining wall under multiple earthquake sequences

Seong Jun Ha, Byungmin Kim

Summary: This study investigated the seismic responses of a cantilever retaining wall under earthquake sequences and found that the relative wall movements caused by mainshock-aftershock and foreshock-mainshock sequential ground motions can be larger than those caused by a single mainshock motion. The sequence itself had the effect of increasing the relative wall movements under strong sequential ground motions. However, the effects of the aftershock and foreshock motions on the wall responses were insignificant under weak sequential ground motions.

SOIL DYNAMICS AND EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Seismic analysis of waste packages stacked in radioactive waste disposal silos

Hyeongjin Byeon, Jaeyeong Park, Byungmin Kim

Summary: This study evaluated the seismic stability of the stacked radioactive waste disposal container columns at the silo-type Gyeongju repository in Korea. The within-rock motions, based on ground motions measured at the repository site in 2016, were smaller than the actual ground motions. The computational investigation showed that the container columns are unlikely to collide or be damaged during seismic loads.

TUNNELLING AND UNDERGROUND SPACE TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Review Engineering, Civil

Pavement Monitoring Using Unmanned Aerial Vehicles: An Overview

Pranav R. T. Peddinti, Harish Puppala, Byungmin Kim

Summary: The main objective of this study is to provide essential knowledge on the prevalent challenges of existing monitoring techniques and discuss the potential advantages of UAVs over conventional pavement monitoring practice. The study presents a state-of-the-art review emphasizing UAV technicalities in the context of image-based pavement monitoring, and provides a detailed workflow and checklist for drone deployment to ensure safe and high-quality data acquisition for novice users. Finally, the present challenges and future scope of UAV-based pavement monitoring are discussed.

JOURNAL OF TRANSPORTATION ENGINEERING PART B-PAVEMENTS (2023)

Article Social Issues

Barriers to the adoption of new technologies in rural areas: The case of unmanned aerial vehicles for precision agriculture in India

Harish Puppala, Pranav R. T. Peddinti, Jagannadha Pawan Tamvada, Jaya Ahuja, Byungmin Kim

Summary: Technological advances can transform agrarian rural areas by increasing productivity and efficiency, but there are barriers to the adoption of such technologies by rural farmers in emerging economies like India. This study identifies and classifies the barriers impacting adoption into technical, social, behavioural, operational, economic, and implementation categories. A hybrid multi-criteria framework is used to evaluate the relevance and importance of each barrier, and the paper suggests new avenues for accelerating technology adoption in rural areas of emerging economies.

TECHNOLOGY IN SOCIETY (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

Seismic fragility assessments of fill slopes in South Korea using finite element simulations

Dung T. P. Tran, Youngkyu Cho, Hwanwoo Seo, Byungmin Kim

Summary: This study evaluates the seismic fragilities of fill slopes in South Korea using parametric finite element analyses. Three slope geometries, three slope angles, and two soil types are considered. The results show that soil type, slope angle, and input ground motion influence the probabilities of exceeding different limit states, and the findings can assist regional authorities and engineers in assessing the seismic fragility of fill slopes in road systems in South Korea.

GEOMECHANICS AND ENGINEERING (2023)

No Data Available