4.7 Review

Mechano-chemical interactions in sedimentary rocks in the context of CO2 storage: Weak acid, weak effects?

Journal

EARTH-SCIENCE REVIEWS
Volume 157, Issue -, Pages 86-110

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.earscirev.2016.03.009

Keywords

CO2 sequestration; Rock deformation; Weakening; Acid attack; Short and long-term; Laboratory experiments

Funding

  1. French National Research Agency (ANR) through the SEED programme (project FISIC) [ANR-11-0003-01]
  2. Polish-Norwegian Research Programme [PL12-0109]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Due to the corrosive nature of dissolved CO2, the potential short or long term alteration of rock properties, represents a major issue in several sites where natural CO2 circulation is observed, as well as in reservoirs targeted for storage of anthropogenic CO2. To date, this has been primarily studied from a transport-chemical perspective, with laboratory evidence of microstructural modifications together with the consequences for flow properties. Compared to the transport-chemical aspects, the mechanical-chemical aspects have been less investigated, though it is to be expected that mechanical properties (e.g. elastic properties, failure parameters, and time-dependent mechanical behaviour) could potentially be affected in a similar manner to hydraulic parameters. Yet, since CO2 is a weak acid, the pH drop is expected to be moderate with a likely lower limit close to 4.0. The buffeting of pH by calcite minerals present in most reservoirs targeted for storage may further limit the pH drop, as well as confining it to a localized rock volume around the injection well. This leads to the question of the magnitude and time/spatial scales of chemically-mediated mechanical processes during CO2 sequestration. The authors propose to address this issue by reviewing recent laboratory-based studies restricted to sedimentary rocks, namely: reservoir rocks (carbonate or sandstone), intact or fractured caprocks and fault rocks. Key findings include the following: 1. the short-term impact on the elastic and inelastic behaviour of intact caprocks remains limited; 2. shear strength weakening is likely to be respectively low and low-to-moderate for shale/clay-rich and anhydrite-rich faults, but without modifying slip stability in either case; 3. the largest impact is located within carbonate reservoirs, but with a broad range of reported responses depending on hydrodynamic conditions (closed or open) and on dissolution regime (uniform or channelling); and 4. creep experiments confirm that CO2-induced dissolution may enhance long-term compaction of carbonate reservoirs, but the magnitude of acceleration (varying from non-significant to 50 times) depends to a large extent on site-specific conditions (grain size, pH, temperature, effective stress state, etc.), which renders any direct extrapolation from laboratory to reservoir scale difficult Finally, some directions for future research studies are discussed. (C) 2016 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Engineering, Civil

Coupled hydro-chemo-mechanical model for fault activation under reactive fluid injection

H. Tounsi, A. Pouya, J. Rohmer

Summary: This study presents a simplified set of equations to solve the coupled hydro-chemo-mechanical problem of reactive fluid flow inside a fault, and simulates the evolution of faults during CO(2) storage. The results show that under normal conditions, fault reactivation is unlikely. However, the proposed model has the potential to become a useful tool for assessing related risks.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL AND CIVIL ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Engineering, Geological

4D Synchrotron X-ray Imaging of Grain Scale Deformation Mechanisms in a Seismogenic Gas Reservoir Sandstone During Axial Compaction

J. F. Van Stappen, J. A. McBeck, B. Cordonnier, R. P. J. Pijnenburg, F. Renard, C. J. Spiers, S. J. T. Hangx

Summary: High-resolution time-lapse X-ray micro-tomography imaging allows visualization of grain-scale deformation mechanisms during triaxial deformation of reservoir rock, providing important input for developing microphysical models describing compaction of gas reservoirs.

ROCK MECHANICS AND ROCK ENGINEERING (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

A Machine Learning Framework to Automate the Classification of Surge-Type Glaciers in Svalbard

C. Bouchayer, J. M. Aiken, K. Thogersen, F. Renard, T. Schuler

Summary: This study aims to understand the transient behavior of surge-type glaciers. A machine learning framework is developed to classify these glaciers based on various features. The study focuses on the Svalbard archipelago and finds that the surface and bed slopes, ice thickness, glacier width, climatic mass balance, and runoff are significant factors in determining surge probability. The study also creates a probability map of surge-type glaciers in Svalbard.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-EARTH SURFACE (2022)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

The evolving representative elementary volume size in crystalline and granular rocks under triaxial compression approaching macroscopic failure

J. A. McBeck, B. Cordonnier, F. Renard

Summary: Determining the size of the representative elementary volume (REV) is crucial for upscaling properties from laboratory measurements to crustal systems. The REV size is expected to evolve as fracture networks propagate and coalesce. However, it may not systematically increase in all experiments due to the highly heterogeneous porosity distributions. In sandstone experiments, the REV size does increase systematically, suggesting that intact sandstone estimates may be applicable to damaged sandstone.

GEOPHYSICAL JOURNAL INTERNATIONAL (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Coupled dissolution-precipitation and growth processes on calcite, aragonite, and Carrara marble exposed to cadmium-rich aqueous solutions

Maude Julia, Christine V. Putnis, Helen E. King, Francois Renard

Summary: The interactions between calcium carbonate and cadmium-rich fluid were studied at the nano and microscale under fluid flow and static fluid conditions. The study examined three forms of CaCO3: calcite in single crystals of Iceland Spar, calcite in polycrystalline Carrara marble, and aragonite single crystals. The experiments revealed the nanoscale effect of cadmium on CaCO3 dissolution and growth, as well as the precipitation of a Cd-rich phase on the samples' surfaces. Hydrothermal experiments showed that the reactivity of single calcite crystals was passivated by the epitaxial growth of a less soluble Cd-rich endmember on the sample surface. On the other hand, the presence of grain boundaries or structural changes in Carrara marble and aragonite allowed the replacement of samples by a porous (Ca,Cd)CO3 solid-solution phase.

CHEMICAL GEOLOGY (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Efficient removal of antibiotics from water via aqueous portlandite carbonation

G. Montes-Hernandez, L. Feugueur, C. Vernier, A. E. S. Van Driessche, F. Renard

Summary: Current wastewater treatment technologies struggle to remove antibiotics, leading to contamination of water sources. This study demonstrates that aqueous carbonation of portlandite can effectively remove commonly used antibiotics from water. Amoxicillin showed the highest removal efficiency (9.5 mg/g), followed by cefazoline (4.3 mg/g) and ceftriaxone (2.7 mg/g). Comparatively, nanomagnetite-interfacial Fenton reaction is more effective in removing amoxicillin (76.5 mg/g), but is slower and more complex chemically. Both methods show promise at the laboratory scale and can be implemented in wastewater treatment plants.

JOURNAL OF WATER PROCESS ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Pressure Solution Grain Boundary Sliding as a Large Strain Mechanism of Superplastic Flow in the Upper Crust

Jean-Pierre Gratier, Luca Menegon, Francois Renard

Summary: A mechanism involving grain boundary sliding is described for the deformation of fine-grained calcareous shales, which can accommodate large strains of 100%-300% in the Oisans massif in the Western Alps.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SOLID EARTH (2023)

Article Water Resources

Dissolution rate variability at carbonate surfaces: 4D X-ray micro-tomography and stochastic modeling investigations

Marthe Gronlie Guren, Francois Renard, Catherine Noiriel

Summary: Using time-lapse X-ray micro-tomography, this study provides a detailed 3D characterization of the geometry evolution and dissolution rate mapping of four carbonate samples at pH 4.0. The dissolution rates exhibit a large spatial variability, with crystal edges and convex topographies showing the highest rates and flat surfaces and concave areas showing slower retreat. Microcrystalline aragonite dissolves at a higher rate compared to calcite, and rough microcrystalline calcite surface dissolves more slowly than specific faces of calcite spar crystal. The presence of mineral impurities and the geometry of the crystals and fluid-mineral interface affect the global dissolution process of carbonate rocks.

FRONTIERS IN WATER (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Dynamic Fluid Connectivity Controls Solute Dispersion in Multiphase Porous Media Flow

Joachim Mathiesen, Gaute Linga, Marek Misztal, Francois Renard, Tanguy Le Borgne

Summary: Solute transport in multiphase flow through porous media plays a crucial role in natural systems and geoengineering applications. This study investigates dispersion in multiphase flows using highly resolved numerical simulations of immiscible two-phase flow. The results show that the activation and deactivation of different flow pathways under capillary forces accelerate solute spreading compared to single phase flow. The study establishes transport laws under dynamic multiphase flows and identifies the controlling factors for solute dispersion in porous media.

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2023)

Article Physics, Applied

Time-Resolved In Situ Imaging of Strain Localization in Draupne Shale under Triaxial Compression

Aldritt Scaria Madathiparambil, Kim Robert Tekseth, Fredrik K. Murer, Benoit Cordonnier, Nicolaine Agofack, Jessica McBeck, Pierre Cerasi, Francois Renard, Basab Chattopadhyay, Dag W. Breiby

Summary: Understanding the mechanical behavior of rocks is crucial for subsurface activities. This study combines 4D mu CT imaging with strain analysis to study the deformation process of Draupne shale. The study reveals intermittent deformation at different locations within the sample, which eventually evolves into a major fracture plane. This suggests that the previously reported macroscopic stress-strain relationship of Draupne shale samples may consist of irreversible processes.

PHYSICAL REVIEW APPLIED (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

The Influence of Confining Pressure and Preexisting Damage on Strain Localization in Fluid-Saturated Crystalline Rocks in the Upper Crust

Jessica McBeck, Benoit Cordonnier, Yehuda Ben-Zion, Francois Renard

Summary: The spatial organization of deformation can provide important information about the timing of catastrophic failure in the brittle regime. Recent analyses show that deformation experiences temporary phases of delocalization superposed on an overall trend of localization. X-ray tomography experiments reveal that larger confining pressure promotes more dilation and greater localization of high strain events, while greater amounts of preexisting damage promote delocalization. Importantly, dilative strain may provide more reliable information about the timing of catastrophic failure than shear strain.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SOLID EARTH (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

How Do Earthquakes Stop? Insights From a Minimal Model of Frictional Rupture

Fabian Barras, Kjetil Thogersen, Einat Aharonov, Francois Renard

Summary: The question of what arrests an earthquake rupture is crucial for predicting earthquake magnitude. Using a minimal model, researchers have identified the basic physical parameters that may control the arrest of large ruptures and derived closed-form expressions to predict rupture arrest under different conditions.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SOLID EARTH (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Dynamic Evolution of Porosity in Lower-Crustal Faults During the Earthquake Cycle

Stephen Paul Michalchuk, Sascha Zertani, Francois Renard, Florian Fusseis, Alireza Chogani, Oliver Plumper, Luca Menegon

Summary: This study analyzed pseudotachylytes and mylonitized pseudotachylytes from Lofoten, Norway to understand the evolution of fluid pathways and porosity. It was found that porosity is dispersed within the pseudotachylyte vein, but increased along garnet grain boundaries. The porosity is mainly formed due to metamorphic growth of garnet. In the mylonitized pseudotachylyte, porosity is dramatically reduced due to solution-precipitation processes. Porosity reduction may lead to shear zone hardening and new pseudotachylyte formation.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-SOLID EARTH (2023)

Article Engineering, Marine

Coastal Flood at Gavres (Brittany, France): A Simulated Dataset to Support Risk Management and Metamodels Development

Deborah Idier, Jeremy Rohmer, Rodrigo Pedreros, Sylvestre Le Roy, Jose Betancourt, Francois Bachoc, Sophie Lecacheux

Summary: With recent scientific advancements, complex coastal flooding events can now be modeled, but their high computational cost limits their use for forecasting. However, metamodelling techniques have shown promise in coastal hydrodynamics, and developing these techniques for predicting coastal flood information requires a large and detailed learning dataset, which is currently scarce. This paper introduces a publicly available dataset for the site of Gavres, France, which includes 250 scenarios and provides examples of use and recommendations for method developments, local knowledge, and risk management.

JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Deformation evolves from shear to extensile in rocks due to energy optimization

Jess Mcbeck, Benoit Cordonnier, Michele Cooke, Laura Fattaruso, Francois Renard

Summary: Determining how fracture network development leads to macroscopic failure in heterogeneous materials may help estimate the timing of failure in rocks in the upper crust as well as in engineered structures. The proportion of extensile and shear deformation produced by fracture development indicates the appropriate failure criteria to apply, and thus is a key constraint in such an effort. According to synchrotron observations and modeling of triaxial compression experiments on granite, fracture networks transition from shear to extensile immediately before macroscopic failure in order to optimize the total mechanical efficiency of the system.

COMMUNICATIONS EARTH & ENVIRONMENT (2023)

No Data Available