4.8 Editorial Material

Community-led governance for gene-edited crops A post-market certification process could promote transparency and trust

Journal

SCIENCE
Volume 370, Issue 6519, Pages 916-918

Publisher

AMER ASSOC ADVANCEMENT SCIENCE
DOI: 10.1126/science.abd1512

Keywords

-

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.8
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Fostering Responsible Innovation through Stakeholder Engagement: Case Study of North Carolina Sweetpotato Stakeholders

Khara Grieger, Sebastian Zarate, Sarah Kathleen Barnhill-Dilling, Shelly Hunt, Daniela Jones, Jennifer Kuzma

Summary: Stakeholder and community engagement is critical for the successful development of new technologies in sustainable agriculture. This study demonstrates a simple and low-cost approach to understand the preferences and needs of sweetpotato stakeholders in North Carolina. The findings highlight the importance of detecting sweetpotato characteristics and using smartphones in the field, as well as the inclusion of environmental parameters and a Spanish language module. Most participants were willing to share data for the benefit of the industry but were concerned about sharing with competitors.

SUSTAINABILITY (2022)

Review Public Administration

Narrative policy framework at the macro level-cultural theory-based beliefs, science-based narrative strategies, and their uptake in the Canadian policy process for genetically modified salmon

Teshanee T. Williams, Jennifer Kuzma

Summary: This study utilizes the Narrative Policy Framework (NPF) and cultural theory to analyze the use of policy narratives by coalitions and the institutional uptake. The findings reveal significant relationships between policy-stance, the cultural disposition of a policy narrative, the narrative strategies being used, and policy uptake. Final government documents referred more to narratives that contained the scope to science-only and expressed hierarchical or individualistic dispositions.

PUBLIC POLICY AND ADMINISTRATION (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Assessing the impacts of urbanization on stream ecosystem functioning through investigating litter decomposition and nutrient uptake in a forest and a hyper-eutrophic urban stream

Jie Gao, Yuyue Huang, Yue Zhi, Jingmei Yao, Fang Wang, Wei Yang, Le Han, Dunmei Lin, Qiang He, Bing Wei, Khara Grieger

Summary: Rapid urbanization has significant impacts on freshwater systems, particularly in terms of litter decomposition and nutrient uptake. This study found that litter decomposition rates were lower in urban streams compared to forest streams, and macroinvertebrates played a lesser role in the decomposition process in urban streams. Additionally, nutrient uptake rates were higher in urban streams, with phosphorus uptake being significantly higher and nitrogen uptake being significantly lower.

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2022)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Should Gene Editing Be Used to Develop Crops for Continuous-Living-Cover Agriculture? A Multi-Sector Stakeholder Assessment Using a Cooperative Governance Approach

Nicholas R. Jordan, Jennifer Kuzma, Deepak K. Ray, Kirsten Foot, Madison Snider, Keith Miller, Ethan Wilensky-Lanford, Gifty Amarteifio

Summary: Continuous-living-cover (CLC) agriculture, which involves integrating multiple crops to continuously cover soils with living plants, has the potential to improve various ecosystem services. Gene editing (GE) could be a powerful tool for developing crops suitable for CLC agriculture, but there are risks and management issues that need to be addressed. Responsible innovation and scaling methods could help manage these issues and improve outcomes of GE crops for CLC agriculture.

FRONTIERS IN BIOENGINEERING AND BIOTECHNOLOGY (2022)

Article Social Issues

Governance of Gene-edited Plants: Insights from the History of Biotechnology Oversight and Policy Process Theory

Jennifer Kuzma

Summary: This article analyzes the history of US biotechnology oversight for genetically modified plants, using policy process theories to provide insights for contemporary governance of gene-edited plants. The Advocacy Coalition Framework explains how opposing coalitions with different policy beliefs struggled to influence oversight, while coalition disputes over the scope of issues in regulatory policy-making were also observed. The Multiple Streams Approach and Punctuated Equilibrium Theory highlight how focusing events from these struggles created opportunities for changes in oversight. Non-governmental organizations played a significant role in bringing legal challenges and raising awareness of risk issues, prompting advances in federal regulations and risk-mitigation practices. However, recent biotech regulations do not require public disclosure or tracking for gene-edited crops, which undermines transparency and public legitimacy, as well as inhibits adaptability to future biotech products and emerging risks.

SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY & HUMAN VALUES (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

How can we promote the responsible innovation of nano-agrifood research?

Ashton W. Merck, Khara D. Grieger, Jennifer Kuzma

Summary: The use of nanotechnology and engineered nanomaterials in food and agriculture (nano-agrifoods) can have benefits but also risks. Responsible innovation (RI) is an emerging best practice that helps align research with societal needs. This article discusses the need for RI in nano-agrifoods and how it can be institutionalized more effectively in the United States.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2022)

Letter Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Exploring the value of a global gene drive project registry

Riley I. Taitingfong, Cynthia Triplett, Valeri N. Vasquez, Ramya M. Rajagopalan, Robyn Raban, Aaron Roberts, Gerard Terradas, Bridget Baumgartner, Claudia Emerson, Fred Gould, Fredros Okumu, Cynthia E. Schairer, Herve C. Bossin, Leah Buchman, Karl J. Campbell, Anna Clark, Jason Delborne, Kevin Esvelt, Joshua Fisher, Robert M. Friedman, Gigi Gronvall, Nikos Gurfield, Elizabeth Heitman, Natalie Kofler, Todd Kuiken, Jennifer Kuzma, Pablo Manrique-Saide, John M. Marshall, Michael Montague, Amy C. Morrison, Chris C. Opesen, Ryan Phelan, Antoinette Piaggio, Hector Quemada, Larisa Rudenko, Natewinde Sawadogo, Robert Smith, Holly Tuten, Anika Ullah, Adam Vorsino, Nikolai Windbichler, Omar S. Akbari, Kanya Long, James V. Lavery, Sam Weiss Evans, Karen Tountas, Cinnamon S. Bloss

NATURE BIOTECHNOLOGY (2022)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Genes drive organisms and slippery slopes

David B. Resnik, Raul F. Medina, Fred Gould, George Church, Jennifer Kuzma

Summary: The bioethical debate on using gene drives to manipulate or eradicate wild populations has mainly focused on short-term risks, governance, and public engagement, rather than considering the bigger picture. This article examines a specific type of slippery slope argument against using gene drives and discusses its relevance in ethical and policy debates. While the argument does not strongly support a ban on gene drives in wild pest populations, it serves as a cautionary narrative to encourage clearer thinking on appropriate use, long-term risks, and risk management strategies, such as protecting wilderness areas from genetic engineering.

PATHOGENS AND GLOBAL HEALTH (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Development and application of screening-level risk analysis for emerging materials

Madison D. Horgan, H. Alex Hsain, Jacob L. Jones, Khara D. Grieger

Summary: Analysis of the environmental, health, and societal impacts of lead-free piezoelectrics is crucial for materials development. The screening-level EMRA approach proposed in this paper is used to compare mining and processing routes for hafnia, a potential replacement for PZT, and identify the more sustainable route.

SUSTAINABLE MATERIALS AND TECHNOLOGIES (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Phytoextraction of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) by weeds: Effect of PFAS physicochemical properties and plant physiological traits

Qiang He, Zheng Yan, Shenhua Qian, Tiantian Xiong, Khara D. Grieger, Xiaoming Wang, Caihong Liu, Yue Zhi

Summary: Phytoextraction is a promising technology for remediation of contaminated soil, but its potential and the influence of PFAS properties and plant traits on efficacy are still unclear. This study evaluated the potential of weeds for phytoextraction of PFAS and investigated the effects of PFAS properties and plant traits on uptake using correlation analyses and imaging techniques. The findings suggest that phytoextraction can remove PFAS from soil, with short-chain PFAS being preferentially extracted by weeds. PFAS molecular size and hydrophilicity determine plant uptake, while plant morphological traits, especially root protein and lipid content, influence accumulation and translocation. Furthermore, short-chain PFAS are transported quickly upwards in the plant, while uptake of long-chain PFOS is restricted.

JOURNAL OF HAZARDOUS MATERIALS (2023)

Article Agronomy

Views of RNAi approaches for weed management in turfgrass systems

Sandra R. Ethridge, Khara Grieger, Anna M. Locke, Wesley J. Everman, David L. Jordan, Ramon G. Leon

Summary: Public concern about herbicide use in urban areas is growing, leading to a need for safe and effective alternatives for weed control. Molecular tools like RNA interference (RNAi) have the potential to meet these requirements, but understanding stakeholder perceptions is crucial for adoption and regulation. A survey of turfgrass managers, such as golf course superintendents and lawn care providers, revealed that cost and time spent managing weeds are the main challenges they face. They are most concerned about cost, efficacy, and efficiency when considering new weed management tools. Despite some concerns, managers are optimistic about using RNAi for weed management and believe their clientele will accept it.

WEED SCIENCE (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Identifying sustainability assessment parameters for genetically engineered agrifoods

Wei Wei, Khara Grieger, Christopher L. Cummings, Nick Loschin, Jennifer Kuzma

Summary: This paper proposes a set of parameters to evaluate the sustainability of genetically engineered food and agriculture products and discusses mechanisms to improve their governance and oversight. By conducting comprehensive evaluations, genetic engineering applications that are beneficial to sustainable agriculture can be identified to promote sustainability. To achieve international sustainable development goals, food and agricultural production need to rely on sustainable and resilient practices.

PLANTS PEOPLE PLANET (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Using a Phosphorus Flow Diagram as a Boundary Object to Inform Stakeholder Engagement

Ashton W. Merck, Khara D. Grieger, Alison Deviney, Anna-Maria Marshall

Summary: Phosphorus is crucial for life on Earth but its current management is unsustainable. Stakeholder engagement is urgently needed to address the challenges, yet there is limited research on stakeholder views. In this opinion, the authors use a mass flow diagram to understand the complex challenges and incorporate human factors at a national scale. The approach can be generalized to other mass flows and areas, and the authors suggest ways for researchers to identify knowledge gaps and research needs in stakeholder engagement.

SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Bioaccumulation and Translocation of 6:2 Fluorotelomer Sulfonate, GenX, and Perfluoroalkyl Acids by Urban Spontaneous Plants

Yue Zhi, Hongying Lu, Khara D. Grieger, Gabriel Munoz, Wei Li, Xiaoming Wang, Qiang He, Shenhua Qian

Summary: Limited information is available on the bioaccumulation potential of polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) in urban vegetation. This study investigated the bioaccumulation and translocation of select PFAS in four common urban spontaneous plants using a controlled greenhouse exposure setting. The results show that different PFAS compounds have varying bioaccumulation factors in roots and shoots, and Phyllanthus urinaria has the highest bioaccumulation capacity among the four weed species. Leaf area and average root diameter were found to be the most correlated traits with PFAS bioaccumulation factors.

ACS ES&T ENGINEERING (2022)

No Data Available