4.7 Article

Modernizing risk assessment: A systematic integration of PRA and PHM techniques

Journal

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY
Volume 204, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.ress.2020.107194

Keywords

Complex systems; Prognostics and health management (PHM); Probabilistic risk assessment; Logic modeling; Deep learning

Funding

  1. U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission [31310018M0043]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Recent advances in sensing and computing technologies have resulted in an abundance of data in various formats and more processing power for using this data. Consequently, there has been an interest in using these advances to enhance modeling and assessment techniques for safety and reliability of a variety of systems. To date, this has occurred under two distinct aspects of reliability engineering. Prognostics and Health Management (PHM) has developed powerful new algorithms for understanding and predicting the mechanical and electrical devices' health. For complex systems, the techniques of Probabilistic Risk Assessment (PRA), which provide a system-level perspective, have become increasingly dynamic. Both PHM and PRA bring unique advantages and limitations. PHM excels at data handling and supports prediction, but the methods applicable at the component level are not suitable for modeling complex engineering systems (CES). PRA provides a comprehensive approach suitable for drawing together many types of data and assessing complex systems, but is limited in the ability to exploit advanced ML methods or enable prediction. In this paper, we explore how to systematically draw together the advances in PHM and PRA to provide a more forward-looking, model- and data-driven approach for assessing and predicting the risk and health of CES.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Exploiting the Capabilities of Bayesian Networks for Engineering Risk Assessment: Causal Reasoning through Interventions

Andres Ruiz-Tagle, Enrique Lopez Droguett, Katrina M. Groth

Summary: Bayesian networks have been widely used in engineering risk assessment for causal reasoning and intervention reasoning, helping identify risk-contributing factors and enabling scenario analysis. Expanding the scope of BN models in risk assessment can provide more robust decision support.

RISK ANALYSIS (2022)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Toward a hybrid causal framework for autonomous vehicle safety analysis

Stephen Thomas, Katrina M. Groth

Summary: This article analyzes the limitations of current safety standards and methodologies in the AV industry and proposes a new AV safety framework based on Hybrid Causal Logic. The framework combines Event Sequence Diagrams, Fault Tree Analysis, and Bayesian Networks, providing an integrated approach that has the potential to more completely satisfy fundamental requirements.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE INSTITUTION OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERS PART O-JOURNAL OF RISK AND RELIABILITY (2023)

Article Engineering, Industrial

A hybrid population-based degradation model for pipeline pitting corrosion

Roohollah Heidary, Katrina M. Groth

Summary: This paper presents a novel algorithm for developing a population-based corrosion degradation model for oil and gas pipelines. It eliminates the need for defect-matching procedures for non-critical pits and uses a hierarchical Bayesian model to combine uncertain in-line inspection data and physics of failure knowledge. The algorithm successfully predicts pipeline degradation levels with high accuracy.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2021)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Toward a framework for risk monitoring of complex engineering systems with online operational data: A deep learning-based solution

Ramin Moradi, Andres Ruiz-Tagle Palazuelos, Enrique Lopez Droguett, Katrina M. Groth

Summary: A mathematical architecture is developed for system-level condition monitoring using fault trees and deep learning. The architecture computes the operation health states of the system and its components based on streaming monitoring data. The applicability of this architecture is demonstrated on a real-world mining stone crusher system and it can be extended to dynamic risk assessment of complex engineering systems. However, caution should be taken when using deep learning models for safety-critical applications.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE INSTITUTION OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERS PART O-JOURNAL OF RISK AND RELIABILITY (2023)

Review Chemistry, Physical

Critical review and analysis of hydrogen safety data collection tools

Madison West, Ahmad Al-Douri, Kevin Hartmann, William Buttner, Katrina M. Groth

Summary: This article discusses the importance of quantitative risk assessment in the hydrogen energy sector and highlights the current limitations in hydrogen QRA due to the lack of reliability data. The article critically evaluates and analyzes four tools for collecting hydrogen system safety data and provides recommendations for improvement, serving as a reference for adequate reliability data collection for hydrogen systems.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HYDROGEN ENERGY (2022)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Integration of deep learning and Bayesian networks for condition and operation risk monitoring of complex engineering systems

Ramin Moradi, Sergio Cofre-Martel, Enrique Lopez Droguett, Mohammad Modarres, Katrina M. Groth

Summary: This paper presents a novel mathematical architecture for risk and reliability analysis of complex engineering systems, addressing both the complexity of operational data and system complexity using Bayesian networks and Bayesian deep learning models, providing system-level insights.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2022)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Dependency definitions for quantitative human reliability analysis

Vincent P. Paglioni, Katrina M. Groth

Summary: This paper explores the concept of dependency in human reliability analysis (HRA) and proposes a standardized library of key terms and mathematics to lay the foundation for the development of a dependency framework.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2022)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Metrics for evaluating the performance of complex engineering system health monitoring models

Austin D. Lewis, Katrina M. Groth

Summary: This paper introduces a new taxonomy of metrics to assess and compare the performance of system-level health monitoring models. It also describes a verification process and provides an illustrative example for applying these metrics in model design decision. The comprehensive set of metrics enables both PRA and PHM communities to rigorously evaluate system-level health monitoring models.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2022)

Article Engineering, Industrial

BaNTERA: A Bayesian Network for Third-Party Excavation Risk Assessment

Andres Ruiz-Tagle, Austin D. Lewis, Colin A. Schell, Ernest Lever, Katrina M. Groth

Summary: This paper presents the development and results of BaNTERA, a probabilistic Bayesian network model for third-party excavation risk assessment in the U.S. The capabilities of BaNTERA for risk-informed decision support are demonstrated through model performance verification, damage rate prediction validation, and application in multiple case study scenarios.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2022)

Article Engineering, Chemical

Emergency shutdowns of propylene production plants: Root cause analysis and availability modeling

Ahmad Al-Douri, Mahmoud M. El-Halwagi, Katrina M. Groth

Summary: Unplanned shutdown events in chemical process plants lead to revenue losses, repair costs, and environmental and safety impacts. This study analyzes the causes of these events and models the failure probability of process plants, providing recommendations for reducing the occurrence and mitigating the consequences of shutdown events.

JOURNAL OF LOSS PREVENTION IN THE PROCESS INDUSTRIES (2022)

Article Chemistry, Physical

A quantitative risk assessment of hydrogen fuel cell forklifts

Ahmad Al-Douri, Andres Ruiz-Tagle, Katrina M. Groth

Summary: In this study, a quantitative risk assessment (QRA) was conducted to analyze the potential risks and reliability of hydrogen fuel cell forklifts. The results showed that the fatal accident rate of hydrogen forklifts is significantly higher than current rates for industrial truck operators. However, the individual risk for forklift drivers was found to be tolerable. Suggestions for improving design and reliability were also provided to mitigate these risks.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HYDROGEN ENERGY (2023)

Article Nuclear Science & Technology

Dependency Idioms for Quantitative Human Reliability Analysis

Vincent Philip Paglioni, Katrina M. Groth

Summary: This paper reviews the current conceptualization of dependency and demonstrates that current research is not addressing all the technical gaps in HRA. To address the technical gaps in HRA dependency, a set of fundamental dependency structures are proposed, which provide a robust logical structure emphasizing causality.

NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Identifying human failure events (HFEs) for external hazard probabilistic risk assessment

Ahmad Al-Douri, Camille S. Levine, Katrina M. Groth

Summary: In recent years, advancements in nuclear power plant (NPP) probabilistic risk assessment (PRA) have been made, driven by increased understanding of external hazards, plant response, and uncertainties. However, major sources of uncertainty associated with external hazard PRA remain, particularly in the area of risk-significant human actions and human-plant interactions. This study evaluates the applicability of an existing cognitive-based HRA method, Phoenix, to ex-control room actions and identifies sources of uncertainty to make this method suitable for XHPRA.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2023)

Proceedings Paper Engineering, Multidisciplinary

A Multi-Interval Method for Discretizing Continuous-Time Event Sequences

Austin D. Lewis, Katrina M. Groth

Summary: Prognostic and health management (PHM) techniques are being developed to support health assessments of increasingly diverse and complex systems. Causal models like Dynamic Bayesian Networks (DBNs) visualize dependencies between system components and update system health assessments. A new approach is proposed to convert continuous operational data feeds into discrete intervals for building DBNs in PHM.

67TH ANNUAL RELIABILITY & MAINTAINABILITY SYMPOSIUM (RAMS 2021) (2021)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Reliability analysis and redundancy optimization of k-out-of-n systems with random variable k using continuous time Markov chain and Monte Carlo simulation

Mateusz Oszczypala, Jakub Konwerski, Jaroslaw Ziolkowski, Jerzy Malachowski

Summary: This article discusses the issues related to the redundancy of k-out-of-n structures and proposes a probabilistic and simulation-based optimization method. The method was applied to real transport systems, demonstrating its effectiveness in reducing costs and improving system availability and performance.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Node importance identification of unweighted urban rail transit network: An Adjacency Information Entropy based approach

Wencheng Huang, Haoran Li, Yanhui Yin, Zhi Zhang, Anhao Xie, Yin Zhang, Guo Cheng

Summary: Inspired by the theory of degree entropy, this study proposes a new node identification approach called Adjacency Information Entropy (AIE) to identify the importance of nodes in urban rail transit networks (URTN). Through numerical and real-world case studies, it is found that AIE can effectively identify important nodes and facilitate connections among non-adjacent nodes.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Importance-based system cost management and failure risk analysis for different phases in life cycle

Hongyan Dui, Yaohui Lu, Liwei Chen

Summary: This paper discusses the four phases of the system life cycle and the different costs associated with each phase. It proposes an improvement importance method to optimize system reliability and analyzes the process of failure risk under limited resources.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Reliability analysis of multi-state balanced systems with standby components switching mechanism

Xian Zhao, Chen Wang, Siqi Wang

Summary: This paper proposes a new rebalancing strategy for balanced systems by switching standby components. Different switching rules are provided based on different balance conditions. The system reliability is derived using the finite Markov chain imbedding approach, and numerical examples and sensitivity analysis are presented for validation.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Probabilistic-based burst failure mechanism analysis and risk assessment of pipelines with random non-uniform corrosion defects, considering the interacting effects

Fengyuan Jiang, Sheng Dong

Summary: Corrosion defects are the primary causes of pipeline burst failures. The traditional methodologies ignore the effects of random morphologies on failure behaviors, leading to deviations in remaining strength estimation and reliability analysis. To address this issue, an integrated methodology combining random field, non-linear finite element analysis, and Monte-Carlo Simulation was developed to describe the failure behaviors of pipelines with random defects.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Optimal mission abort policy for a multi-component system with failure interaction

Guoqing Cheng, Jiayi Shen, Fang Wang, Ling Li, Nan Yang

Summary: This paper investigates the optimal joint inspection and mission abort policies for a multi-component system with failure interaction. The proportional hazards model is used to characterize the effect of one component's deterioration on other components' hazard rates. The optimal policy is studied to minimize the expected total cost, and some structural properties of the optimal policy are obtained.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Competing risks-based resilience approach for multi-state systems under multiple shocks

Hongyan Dui, Yaohui Lu, Shaomin Wu

Summary: A new resilience model is proposed in this paper for systems under competing risks, and related indices are introduced for evaluating the system's resilience. The model takes into account the degradation process, external shocks, and maintenance interactions of the system, and its effectiveness is demonstrated through a case study.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Neural network-aided simulation of non-Gaussian stochastic processes

Yang Li, Jun Xu

Summary: This paper proposes a translation model based on neural network for simulating non-Gaussian stochastic processes. By converting the target non-Gaussian power spectrum to the underlying Gaussian power spectrum, non-Gaussian samples can be generated.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Quantification analysis of potential risk in railway accidents: A new random walk based approach

Yanyan Liu, Keping Li, Dongyang Yan

Summary: This paper proposes a new random walk method, CBDRWR, to analyze the potential risk of railway accidents. By combining accident causation network, we assign different restart probabilities to each node and improve the transition probabilities. In the case study, the proposed method effectively quantifies the potential risk and identifies key risk sources.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Target spectrum-based risk analysis model for utility tunnel O&M in multiple scenarios and its application

Nan Hai, Daqing Gong, Zixuan Dai

Summary: The current risk management of utility tunnel operation and maintenance is of low quality and efficiency. This study proposes a theoretical model and platform that offer effective decision support and improve the safety of utility tunnel operation and maintenance.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Methodology for probabilistic tsunami-triggered oil spill fire hazard assessment based on Natech cascading disaster modeling

Tomoaki Nishino, Takuya Miyashita, Nobuhito Mori

Summary: A novel modeling methodology is proposed to simulate cascading disasters triggered by tsunamis considering uncertainties. The methodology focuses on tsunami-triggered oil spills and subsequent fires and quantitatively measures the fire hazard. It can help assess and improve risk reduction plans.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Prediction of pipeline fatigue crack propagation under rockfall impact based on multilayer perceptron

Mingjiang Xie, Yifei Wang, Jianli Zhao, Xianjun Pei, Tairui Zhang

Summary: This study investigates the effect of rockfall impact on the health management of pipelines with fatigue cracks and proposes a crack propagation prediction algorithm based on rockfall impact. Dynamic SIF values are obtained through finite element modeling and a method combining multilayer perceptron with Paris' law is used for accurate crack growth prediction. The method is valuable for decision making in pipeline reliability assessment and integrity management.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Weaponized disinformation spread and its impact on multi-commodity critical infrastructure networks

Saeed Jamalzadeh, Lily Mettenbrink, Kash Barker, Andres D. Gonzalez, Sridhar Radhakrishnan, Jonas Johansson, Elena Bessarabova

Summary: This study proposes an integrated epidemiological-optimization model to quantify the impacts of weaponized disinformation on transportation infrastructure and supply chains. Results show that disinformation targeted at transportation infrastructure can have wide-ranging impacts across different commodities.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Maintenance scheduling at high-speed train depots: An optimization approach

Jiaxi Wang

Summary: This paper investigates the depot maintenance packet assignment and crew scheduling problem for high-speed trains. A mixed integer linear programming model is proposed, and computational experiments show the effectiveness and efficiency of the improved model compared to the baseline one.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2024)

Article Engineering, Industrial

An adaptive structural dominant failure modes searching method based on graph neural network

Yuxuan Tian, Xiaoshu Guan, Huabin Sun, Yuequan Bao

Summary: This paper proposes a DFMs searching algorithm based on the graph neural network (GNN) to improve computational efficiency and adaptively identify DFMs. The algorithm terminates prematurely when unable to identify new DFMs.

RELIABILITY ENGINEERING & SYSTEM SAFETY (2024)