4.7 Article

Prospectivity modelling of Canadian magmatic Ni (±Cu ± Co ± PGE) sulphide mineral systems

Journal

ORE GEOLOGY REVIEWS
Volume 132, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.oregeorev.2021.103985

Keywords

Mineral potential; Mafic; Ultramafic; Exploration; Mineral system; Machine learning

Funding

  1. Targeted Geoscience Initiative (TGI) program [20200519]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

New mineral deposit discoveries are vital to meet the demand for critical raw materials, with governments investing in mineral systems research and making geoscience datasets freely available. Translating conceptual mineral system models into mappable geological proxies is challenging due to incomplete data of varying quality.
New mineral deposit discoveries are required to meet the forecasted demand for some critical raw materials. Governments are responding to that challenge by investing in mineral systems research and by by making government geoscience datasets freely available to the public and explorers. However, translating conceptual mineral system models to mappable geological, geochemical, and geophysical proxies is difficult with incomplete data of variable quality from modern and legacy surveys. Herein we address those knowledge gaps and propose a new open source workflow in R for prospectivity modelling using public geoscience datasets. We focus on the largest footprints of magmatic Ni (+/- Cu) sulphide mineral systems and their critical raw materials (+/- Co +/- PGE). Multiple prospectivity models are presented, including data-driven methods (e.g., weights of evidence, gradient boosting machines) that use the features of known mineral occurrences as a training set and a hybrid method that also incorporates conceptual mineral system criteria. All models are validated using data from northern Canada (i.e., north of 60 degrees latitude) as a test set. Statistical analysis of the prospectivity results suggests that rock types and geological ages are two of the most important predictive datasets, which correspond to the sources and drivers within the mineral system framework, respectively. Variable importance plots further suggest that geological boundaries (e.g., horizontal gradient magnitude of the gravity data and multi-scale edges) and the close spatial association between areas of high mineral potential and the edges of thick continental crust represent prospective ore-forming pathways. Model performance and the best combination of predictors and hyperparameters for each model are based on the receiver operating characteristics (ROC) plots, which yield a range of area under the curve (AUC) from 0.846 to 0.923 for the spatially independent test set. Most Canadian geological provinces, possibly with the exception of the Grenville orogen for the hybrid and weights of evidence methods (AUC = 0.716-0.726), yield comparable model performance, suggesting that the heterogeneous spatial distribution of different mineral system sub-types (e.g., komatiite-associated, rift-related, Alaskan-type, and hydrothermal awaruite) have a relatively minor impact on the prospectivity results. Monte Carlo-type simulations further suggest that the expert weightings used in the hybrid method (AUC = 0.843) are only slightly better than an average model constructed from random combinations of weightings (AUC = 0.809). The general agreement between different methods and multiple iterations of the same model demonstrate that public geoscience datasets can effectively reduce the search space to support mineral exploration targeting (i.e., less than 8% of map pixels contain more than 80% of the known Ni mineralization). However, vast segments of the Canadian landmass have not undergone systematic geological surveying or data acquisition. Prospectivity modelling can thus also be used by governments and academia to prioritize areas for future targeted geoscience research.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Interpretation of buried basement in the southwestern Athabasca Basin, Canada, from integrated geophysical and geological datasets

Victoria Tschirhart, Sally Pehrsson, Colin Card, Eric G. Potter, Jeremy Powell, Dinu Pana

Summary: Recent discoveries of basement-hosted uranium deposits in the Patterson Lake corridor in the southwestern Athabasca Basin of Canada have sparked strong interest in exploration in the region. New lithostratigraphic constraints, geochronology, and airborne geophysical surveys have greatly improved understanding of the host basement geology, leading to a re-examination of remote predictive mapping and geophysical responses of the buried basement rocks.

GEOCHEMISTRY-EXPLORATION ENVIRONMENT ANALYSIS (2021)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Fluid evolution along the Patterson Lake corridor in the southwestern Athabasca Basin: constraints from fluid inclusions and implications for unconformity-related uranium mineralization

M. Rabiei, G. Chi, E. G. Potter, V Tschirhart, C. MacKay, S. Frostad, R. McElroy, R. Ashley, B. McEwan

Summary: The study reveals that the uranium deposits in the Patterson Lake corridor exhibit similar ore fluid compositions and temperature-pressure conditions to typical URU deposits in the Athabasca Basin, suggesting that they were formed under comparable hydrothermal conditions. The episodic reactivation of basement faults played a significant role in drawing uraniferous fluids from the basin and reducing fluids from the basement to form deep basement-hosted deposits.

GEOCHEMISTRY-EXPLORATION ENVIRONMENT ANALYSIS (2021)

Article Geology

The Colombian geochronological database (CGD)

Andres F. Rodriguez-Corcho, Yamirka Rojas-Agramonte, Johana A. Barrera-Gonzalez, Maria P. Marroquin-Gomez, Sarah Bonilla-Correa, David Izquierdo-Camacho, Sofia M. Delgado-Balaguera, David Cartwright-Buitrago, Maria D. Munoz-Granados, William G. Caranton-Mateus, Alejandro Corrales-Garcia, Andres F. Laverde-Martinez, Aura Cuervo-Gomez, Marco A. Rodriguez-Ruiz, Juan P. Marin-Jaramillo, Nicole Salazar-Cuellar, Laura C. Esquivel-Arenales, Maria E. Daroca, A. Sofia Carvajal, Ana M. Perea-Pescador, Juan D. Solano-Acosta, Sergio Diaz, Alejandro Guillen, German Bayona, Agustin Cardona-Molina, Bruce Eglington, Camilo Montes

Summary: Geochronological databases, such as the Colombian Geochronological Database (CGD) presented in this contribution, are powerful tools for understanding the crustal evolution and age spectra of a region. By comparing different databases, temporal constraints on the evolution of the South American continent can be obtained, revealing both global and local geological events.

INTERNATIONAL GEOLOGY REVIEW (2022)

Review Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

A geochronological review of magmatism along the external margin of Columbia and in the Grenville-age orogens forming the core of Rodinia

Ake Johansson, Bernard Bingen, Hannu Huhma, Tod Waight, Rikke Vestergaard, Alvar Soesoo, Grazina Skridlaite, Ewa Krzeminska, Leonid Shumlyanskyy, Mark E. Holland, Christopher Holm-Denoma, Wilson Teixeira, Frederico M. Faleiros, Bruno Ribeiro, Joachim Jacobs, Chengcheng Wang, Robert J. Thomas, Paul H. Macey, Christopher L. Kirkland, Michael I. H. Hartnady, Bruce M. Eglington, Stephen J. Puetz, Kent C. Condie

Summary: This research compiles a large amount of magmatic U-Pb ages data from different blocks, revealing the temporal relationships and geological events among various blocks during the formation of Columbia and Rodinia. There is a certain degree of correlation between various blocks, but there are also significant differences.

PRECAMBRIAN RESEARCH (2022)

Article Geology

Infaunalization and resource partitioning during the Mesozoic marine revolution

Luis A. Buatois, M. Gabriela Mangano, Bhawanisingh Desai, Noelia B. Carmona, Fiona Burns, Dean Meek, Bruce Eglington

Summary: This study compiles ichnological data from Middle Triassic to Late Jurassic shallow-marine siliciclastic units and finds that there was a significant increase in the utilization of infaunal ecospace during the Early Jurassic, followed by a plateau during the rest of the Jurassic. The study also reveals that the infaunal ecospace is partitioned into different tiers and multiple organisms were able to exploit the same resources. The increase in the number of ichnoguilds per community and per tier suggests that niche partitioning played a key role in the efficient use of infaunal ecospace and in driving alpha diversity.

GEOLOGY (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Deep Geological Controls on Formation of the Highest-Grade Uranium Deposits in the World: Magnetotelluric Imaging of Unconformity-Related Systems From the Athabasca Basin, Canada

V Tschirhart, E. G. Potter, J. W. Powell, E. A. Roots, J. A. Craven

Summary: Unconformity-related uranium deposits in the Athabasca Basin, Canada are the highest grade, large tonnage deposits in the world. Recent studies have shown that a deep heat source enhances hydrothermal fluid flow and the incursion of basinal brines along reactivated brittle shear zones. However, the spatial extent of the ore systems and the role of lower crustal features remain unresolved.

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Plate tectonic modelling and the energy transition

Jean-Christophe Wrobel-Daveau, Graeme Nicoll, Michael G. Tetley, Benjamin Greselle, Lucia Perez-Diaz, Andrew Davies, Bruce M. Eglington

Summary: The formulation of plate tectonic theory and its application in simulating the motion of lithospheric units has significantly advanced geosciences, supporting industry funded research, geological understanding, and resource exploration, with a growing importance in the current energy transition.

EARTH-SCIENCE REVIEWS (2022)

Article Energy & Fuels

Modeling a fractured geothermal reservoir using 3-D AMT data inversion: Insights from Garibaldi Volcanic Belt, British Columbia, Canada

Fateme Hormozzade Ghalati, James A. Craven, Dariush Motazedian, Stephen E. Grasby, Victoria Tschirhart

Summary: An audio-magnetotelluric (AMT) survey was conducted to explore shallow geothermal resources in the Garibaldi Volcanic Belt in Canada. The survey revealed complex 3-D subsurface structure, with high conductivity features related to hydrothermal alteration in the south and north regions. Clay cap layers connect to the surface, and conductive zones are located near warm springs along Meager Creek. Integrating the AMT model, geology, and temperature data is crucial for building a conceptual model of the Mount Meager geothermal system.

GEOTHERMICS (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Geothermal Exploration in the Burwash Landing Region, Canada, Using Three-Dimensional Inversion of Passive Electromagnetic Data

Victoria Tschirhart, Maurice Colpron, James Craven, Fateme Hormozzade Ghalati, Randy J. Enkin, Stephen E. Grasby

Summary: Sustainable development in Canada's North requires a focus on renewable, zero-emission energy sources. The study in Burwash Landing suggests potential for geothermal energy based on high geothermal gradient and proximity to active fault lines. Electromagnetic data inversion reveals vertical conductive structures associated with fluid-deposited graphite and hydrothermal alteration, indicating a possible heat source for sustaining a geothermal system in the region.

REMOTE SENSING (2022)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Analysis of Fluid Flow Pathways in the Mount Meager Volcanic Complex, Southwestern Canada, Utilizing AMT and Petrophysical Data

F. Hormozzade Ghalati, J. A. Craven, D. Motazedian, S. E. Grasby, E. Roots, V. Tschirhart, Z. Chen, X. Liu

Summary: In this study, the relationship between electrical resistivity and fluid flow in a geothermal reservoir was investigated by combining 3-D resistivity models derived from AMT data with rock properties and fluid sample data. The results showed that 3-D inversion of AMT data can map the fluid pathways at the study site, which are correlated with loss circulation zones in boreholes and can account for a porosity of up to 8.5% and a permeability of approximately 0.249 mD.

GEOCHEMISTRY GEOPHYSICS GEOSYSTEMS (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Retrieval of Subsurface Resistivity from Magnetotelluric Data Using a Deep-Learning-Based Inversion Technique

Xiaojun Liu, James A. A. Craven, Victoria Tschirhart

Summary: A data-driven mathematical method with a deep neural network was developed to estimate subsurface resistivity in magnetotelluric (MT) data analysis. The method showed reasonable accuracy and reliability in predicting resistivity models, demonstrating its potential application for real-world MT data.

MINERALS (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

American Journal of Science

Dwight C. Bradley, David A. D. Evans, Paul O'sullivan, Cliff D. Taylor, Bruce M. Eglington

Summary: This study reports detrital zircon data from two tectonic domains in Mauritania, covering Mesoproterozoic to Ordovician strata. The analysis reveals four distinctive detrital zircon age distributions, named as barcodes, in the Taoudeni Basin. The results also suggest a correlation between the Mauritanide orogen and the West African Craton based on the similarity of detrital zircon age spectra. Additionally, the study implies the existence of a continent-scale fluvial system that transported detritus to various regions, including the West African Craton.

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF SCIENCE (2022)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

Structural evolution and related implications for uranium mineralization in the Patterson Lake corridor, southwestern Athabasca Basin, Saskatchewan, Canada

Dillon D. Johnstone, Kathryn M. Bethune, Colin D. Card, Victoria Tschirhart

Summary: The Patterson Lake corridor in the Athabasca Basin is characterized by multiple basement-hosted uranium deposits and prospects. The area has undergone multiple phases of deformation and folding, resulting in complex structural features.

GEOCHEMISTRY-EXPLORATION ENVIRONMENT ANALYSIS (2021)

No Data Available