4.7 Review

Aquatic plants and ecotoxicological assessment in freshwater ecosystems: a review

Journal

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE AND POLLUTION RESEARCH
Volume 28, Issue 5, Pages 4975-4988

Publisher

SPRINGER HEIDELBERG
DOI: 10.1007/s11356-020-11496-3

Keywords

Freshwater plant organisms; Ecotoxicology; Plant-based ecotoxicological test; Toxicant; Water contamination; Aquatic ecosystem

Funding

  1. Universita degli Studi Roma Tre within the CRUI-CARE Agreement
  2. National Order of Biologists
  3. MIUR-Italy

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This paper reviews the current state-of-the-art, limitations, critical issues, and new directions in freshwater plant ecotoxicology. The main issues identified include narrow range of species and endpoints considered, lack of environmental relevance, excessively short exposure times, and potential reactions between toxicants and culture media.
This paper reviews the current state-of-the-art, limitations, critical issues, and new directions in freshwater plant ecotoxicology. We selected peer-reviewed studies using relevant databases and for each (1) publication year, (2) test plant species, (3) reference plant group (microalgae, macroalgae, bryophytes, pteridophytes, flowering plants), (4) toxicant tested (heavy metal, pharmaceutical product, hydrocarbon, pesticide, surfactant, plastic), (5) experiment site (laboratory, field), and (6) toxicant exposure duration. Although aquatic plant organisms play a key role in the functioning of freshwater ecosystems, mainly linked to their primary productivity, their use as biological models in ecotoxicological tests was limited if compared to animals. Also, toxicant effects on freshwater plants were scarcely investigated and limited to studies on microalgae (80%), or only to a certain number of recurrent species (Pseudokirchneriella subcapitata, Chlorella vulgaris, Lemna minor, Myriophyllum spicatum). The most widely tested toxicants on plants were heavy metals (74%), followed by pharmaceutical products and hydrocarbons (7%), while the most commonly utilized endpoints in tests were plant growth inhibition, variations in dry or fresh weight, morpho-structural alterations, chlorosis, and/or necrosis. The main critical issues emerged from plant-based ecotoxicological tests were the narrow range of species and endpoints considered, the lack of environmental relevance, the excessively short exposure times, and the culture media potentially reacting with toxicants. Proposals to overcome these issues are discussed.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Plant Sciences

Is the capture of invertebrate prey by the aquatic carnivorous plant Utricularia australis selective?

S. Ceschin, A. Bellini, A. Salituro, L. Traversetti, N. T. W. Ellwood

Summary: The feeding strategy of Utricularia australis is highly dependent on prey availability and size, with a preference for moderately motile prey that can trigger the trap but be small enough to be easily captured. The study also suggests that the digestion process is fast enough to keep up with seasonal changes in the outside community, and the trapped community of U. australis is influenced by factors such as prey availability and trap stimulation by epiphytes.

PLANT BIOSYSTEMS (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

The ultimate database to (re)set the evolutionary history of primate genital bones

Federica Spani, Maria Pia Morigi, Matteo Bettuzzi, Massimiliano Scalici, Gabriele Gentile, Monica Carosi

Summary: This article summarizes scientific literature on the genital bones of primates, utilizing thorough analysis and updated data to present new findings and interpretations, laying the groundwork for further comparative studies.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2021)

Review Ecology

Freshwater wild biota exposure to microplastics: A global perspective

Alessandra Cera, Massimiliano Scalici

Summary: Current understanding of the exposure of freshwater organisms to microplastics is largely based on laboratory experiments, but field data provide valuable information on the occurrence and quantification of microplastics in different animal taxa. The research focuses on fish, mollusks, and arthropods, with some attention also given to birds and amphibians. Future studies should explore the impact of microplastics on mammals, reptiles, and plants, which are currently under-examined despite being endangered.

ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Water Mixing Conditions Influence Sentinel-2 Monitoring of Chlorophyll Content in Monomictic Lakes

Michela Perrone, Massimiliano Scalici, Luisa Conti, David Moravec, Jan Kropacek, Maria Sighicelli, Francesca Lecce, Marco Malavasi

Summary: This study assessed the potential of neural network models and remote sensing technology for monitoring chlorophyll content in freshwater lakes, while analyzing the relationship between remote sensing and in situ data under different water circulation conditions.

REMOTE SENSING (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Riparian vegetation as a trap for plastic litter

Giulia Cesarini, Massimiliano Scalici

Summary: Plastic pollution poses a significant threat to aquatic habitats worldwide, especially riparian zones. Research shows that riparian vegetation plays a crucial role in trapping plastic litter, with shrubby vegetation having the highest plastic density.

ENVIRONMENTAL POLLUTION (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

An integrated approach for chemical water quality assessment of an urban river stretch through Effect-Based Methods and emerging pollutants analysis with a focus on genotoxicity

Mario Carere, Antonio Antoccia, Annamaria Buschini, Giada Frenzilli, Francesca Marcon, Cristina Andreoli, Gessica Gorbi, Antonio Suppa, Serena Montalbano, Valentina Prota, Francesca De Battistis, Patrizia Guidi, Margherita Bernardeschi, Mara Palumbo, Vittoria Scarcelli, Marco Colasanti, Veronica D'Ezio, Tiziana Persichini, Massimiliano Scalici, Antonella Sgura, Federica Spani, Ion Udroiu, Martina Valenzuela, Ines Lacchetti, Kevin di Domenico, Walter Cristiano, Valentina Marra, Anna Maria Ingelido, Nicola Iacovella, Elena De Felip, Riccardo Massei, Laura Mancini

Summary: The study highlights the presence of a wide range of emerging contaminants in aquatic ecosystems, such as pharmaceuticals, pesticides, personal care products, and PFAS, which can have a significant impact on environmental health. The use of Effect-Based Methods (EBMs) revealed chemical pollution and ecotoxicological effects in the river, providing insights for future studies and measures to monitor, mitigate, or eliminate chemical contamination and its adverse effects on ecosystem health.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Is the weight of plastic litter correlated with vegetal wrack? A case study from a Central Italian beach

Giulia Cesarini, Alessandra Cera, Corrado Battisti, Davide Taurozzi, Massimiliano Scalici

Summary: This study examined the presence and distribution of plastic litter, as well as plastic entrapment by wrack on a natural reserve beach. Large microplastics, mainly white fragments, were the most common type found. Transparent fibers were the predominant plastics entangled by egagropiles. The study suggested a significant positive correlation between plastic and wrack weights near a breakwater, hinting at the potential influence of breakwaters on plastic deposition patterns.

MARINE POLLUTION BULLETIN (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Carpobrotus spp. patches as trap for litter: Evidence from a Mediterranean beach

L. Gallitelli, C. Battisti, Z. Olivieri, C. Marandola, A. T. R. Acosta, M. Scalici

Summary: The study evaluated Carpobrotus spp. patches as potential litter traps in coastal dune systems, finding a significant difference in the amount of litter trapped between Carpobrotus and control patches, with plastic fragments being the most commonly trapped items. The research also suggests that managing Carpobrotus patches can contribute to solving beach litter issues by acting as a filter for anthropogenic materials, particularly plastics.

MARINE POLLUTION BULLETIN (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Environmental management of waters and riparian areas to protect biodiversity through River Contracts: The experience of Tiber River (Rome, Italy)

Giulia Caneva, Simona Ceschin, Fernando Lucchese, Massimiliano Scalici, Corrado Battisti, Massimo Tufano, Maria Cristina Tullio, Emanuela Cicinelli

Summary: Urban rivers play vital ecological roles and provide ecosystem services, requiring management for biodiversity conservation and ecosystem sustainability. Data collection and assessment of anthropic impacts can enhance ecological resilience of urban river systems.

RIVER RESEARCH AND APPLICATIONS (2021)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Over and beyond the Primate baubellum Surface: A Jewel Bone Shielded in Museums

Federica Spani, Maria Pia Morigi, Matteo Bettuzzi, Massimiliano Scalici, Monica Carosi

Summary: Computed Tomography (CT) has been widely used in the medical field and is now being applied in Cultural Heritage studies. Micro-CT, combined with landmark-free shape analysis, allows for non-invasive exploration of the morphology and shape complexity of Cultural Heritage objects.

APPLIED SCIENCES-BASEL (2022)

Article Plant Sciences

Unusual underwater flowering of Utricularia australis populations: a botanical enigma?

S. Ceschin, E. Pelella, M. M. Azzella, A. Bellini, N. T. W. Ellwood

Summary: The discovery of large populations of Utricularia australis growing in deep water in Central Italian lakes is unprecedented. Quantitative-qualitative comparisons of subaerial and underwater flowers revealed some differences in morphological characters, such as the length of the floral scape and the size of the flowers. The possibility of stress-induced flowering due to underwater ecological conditions is also proposed.

AQUATIC BOTANY (2022)

Article Marine & Freshwater Biology

Differential phytotoxic effect of silver nitrate (AgNO3) and bifunctionalized silver nanoparticles (AgNPs-Cit-L-Cys) on Lemna plants (duckweeds)

M. A. Iannelli, A. Bellini, I. Venditti, B. Casentini, C. Battocchio, M. Scalici, S. Ceschin

Summary: This paper investigated the phytotoxic effects of silver nitrate and silver nanoparticles on duckweeds. The results showed that both substances had negative impacts on plant growth and chlorophyll levels, with nanoparticles having a smaller effect. Duckweeds were found to be potential phytoremediation agents for silver ion-polluted water.

AQUATIC TOXICOLOGY (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

The flax in the Flora's image in the Ariadne House (Pompeian area, Italy) as a symbol of feminine in a wedding sacred to the afterlife

G. Caneva, A. Bourmaud, A. Bellini, A. Melelli

Summary: This paper proposes an interpretation for the plant represented in the iconic painting in Pompeii called "Flora in Ariadne's house", suggesting it is flax. Flax was economically and culturally important and symbolized fertility and the afterlife, associated with the feminine sphere. This interpretation strengthens the proposed identification of the girl in yellow as Persephone, a wife transitioning to the afterlife.

RENDICONTI LINCEI-SCIENZE FISICHE E NATURALI (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

Habitat Fragmentation, Connectivity Conservation and Related Key-Concepts: Temporal Trends in Their Recurrences on Web of Science (1960-2020)

Corrado Battisti, Luca Gallitelli, Massimiliano Scalici, Francesco M. Angelici

Summary: This study analyzed the temporal trends of nine key terms in the habitat fragmentation field and found that the most commonly used terms have been increasing over the years, with landscape connectivity showing the highest increase in frequency. On the other hand, the term ecological network planning appeared less frequently in the research.
Review Fisheries

Hydra vulgaris assay as environmental assessment tool for ecotoxicology in freshwaters: a review

A. Cera, G. Cesarini, F. Spani, M. Scalici

Summary: Hydra vulgaris is commonly used for toxicological tests in freshwater ecosystems, showing potential as an early warning system for assessing the impact of emerging contaminants. Hydra assays have proven to be suitable monitoring tools for assessing freshwater ecotoxicity, offering a range of biomarkers and opportunities for innovative research.

MARINE AND FRESHWATER RESEARCH (2021)

No Data Available