4.8 Review

Sex differences in medico-legal action against doctors: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Journal

BMC MEDICINE
Volume 13, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

BMC
DOI: 10.1186/s12916-015-0413-5

Keywords

Disciplinary action; Malpractice; Medical education; Medical regulatory boards; Meta-analysis; Systematic review

Funding

  1. UCL Impact studentship

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Background: The relationship between male sex and poor performance in doctors remains unclear, with high profile studies showing conflicting results. Nevertheless, it is an important first step towards understanding the causes of poor performance in doctors. This article aims to establish the robustness of the association between male sex and poor performance in doctors, internationally and over time. Methods: The electronic databases MEDLINE, EMBASE, and PsycINFO were searched from inception to January 2015. Backward and forward citation searching was performed. Journals that yielded the majority of the eligible articles and journals in the medical education field were electronically searched, along with the conference and poster abstracts from two of the largest international medical education conferences. Studies reporting original data, written in English or French, examining the association between sex and medico-legal action against doctors were included. Two reviewers independently extracted study characteristics and outcome data from the full texts of the studies meeting the eligibility criteria. Study quality was assessed using the Newcastle-Ottawa scale. A random effect meta-analysis model was used to summarize and assess the effect of doctors' sex on medico-legal action. Extracted outcomes included disciplinary action by a medical regulatory board, malpractice experience, referral to a medical regulatory body, complaints received by a healthcare complaints body, criminal cases, and medico-legal matter with a medical defence organisation. Results: Overall, 32 reports examining the association between doctors' sex and medico-legal action were included in the systematic review (n=4,054,551), of which 27 found that male doctors were more likely to have experienced medico-legal action. 19 reports were included in the meta-analysis (n=3,794,486, including 20,666 cases). Results showed male doctors had nearly two and a half times the odds of being subject to medico-legal action than female doctors. Heterogeneity was present in all meta-analyses. Conclusion: Male doctors are more likely to have had experienced medico-legal actions compared to female doctors. This finding is robust internationally, across outcomes of varying severity, and over time.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.8
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Computer Science, Information Systems

Benefits realization management in the context of a national digital transformation initiative in English provider organizations

Kathrin Cresswell, Aziz Sheikh, Bryony Dean Franklin, Susan Hinder, Hung The Nguyen, Marta Krasuska, Wendy Lane, Hajar Mozaffar, Kathy Mason, Sally Eason, Henry W. W. Potts, Robin Williams

Summary: The study explored how benefits realization management was practiced and conceptualized within the Global Digital Exemplar (GDE) Programme. Results revealed tensions between national and local reporting purposes, as well as challenges in attributing benefits to causes due to slow infrastructural changes. Efforts to simplify reporting requirements and support targeted collection of key outcome measures were suggested to enhance effectiveness.

JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL INFORMATICS ASSOCIATION (2022)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Access to personal protective equipment in healthcare workers during the COVID-19 pandemic in the United Kingdom: results from a nationwide cohort study (UK-REACH)

Christopher A. Martin, Daniel Pan, Joshua Nazareth, Avinash Aujayeb, Luke Bryant, Sue Carr, Laura J. Gray, Bindu Gregary, Amit Gupta, Anna L. Guyatt, Alan Gopal, Thomas Hine, Catherine John, I. Chris McManus, Carl Melbourne, Laura B. Nellums, Rubina Reza, Sandra Simpson, Martin D. Tobin, Katherine Woolf, Stephen Zingwe, Kamlesh Khunti, Manish Pareek

Summary: During the COVID-19 pandemic in the UK, a significant number of healthcare workers did not have consistent access to appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE). Older healthcare workers and those working in intensive care units were more likely to have consistent access to PPE, while Asian healthcare workers, those in allied health professional and dental roles, and those who saw a higher number of COVID-19 patients were less likely to have consistent access to PPE.

BMC HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCH (2022)

Article Immunology

Cross-Sectional Study of University Students' Attitudes to 'On Campus' Delivery of COVID-19, MenACWY and MMR Vaccines and Future-Proofing Vaccine Roll-Out Strategies

Adam Webb, Mayuri Gogoi, Sarah Weidman, Katherine Woolf, Maria Zavala, Shamez N. Ladhani, Manish Pareek, Lieve Gies, Christopher D. Bayliss

Summary: University students are a critical group for vaccination programmes, but vaccine hesitancy and uncertainty about vaccine status are concerns. This study found that COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy was associated with Black ethnicity and concerns about vaccine side-effects. Additionally, uncertainty about vaccine status was high for MMR and MenACWY vaccines.

VACCINES (2022)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Hesitancy for receiving regular SARS-CoV-2 vaccination in UK healthcare workers: a cross-sectional analysis from the UK-REACH study

Neyme Veli, Christopher A. Martin, Katherine Woolf, Joshua Nazareth, Daniel Pan, Amani Al-Oraibi, Rebecca F. Baggaley, Luke Bryant, Laura B. Nellums, Laura J. Gray, Kamlesh Khunti, Manish Pareek

Summary: This study found that nearly a quarter of UK HCWs were hesitant about receiving a regular SARS-CoV-2 vaccination. Black HCWs, those with previous COVID-19 episodes, and those who have not received influenza vaccination were more likely to be hesitant. On the other hand, HCWs who received influenza vaccination and trusted official vaccine information were less likely to hesitate.

BMC MEDICINE (2022)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Cohort Profile: The United Kingdom Research study into Ethnicity and COVID-19 outcomes in Healthcare workers (UK-REACH)

Luke Bryant, Robert C. Free, Katherine Woolf, Carl Melbourne, Anna L. Guyatt, Catherine John, Amit Gupta, Laura J. Gray, Laura Nellums, Christopher A. Martin, I. Chris McManus, Claire Garwood, Vishant Modhawdia, Sue Carr, Louise Wain, Martin D. Tobin, Kamlesh Khunti, Ibrahim Akubakar, Manish Pareek

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF EPIDEMIOLOGY (2022)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

How has the emergence of the Omicron SARS-CoV-2 variant of concern influenced worry, perceived risk and behaviour in the UK? A series of cross-sectional surveys

Louise E. Smith, Henry W. W. Potts, Richard Amlot, Nicola T. Fear, Susan Michie, G. James Rubin

Summary: This study investigated the changes in beliefs and behaviors following the news of the Omicron variant and changes in guidance understanding. The results showed fluctuations in worry and perceived risk of COVID-19, an increase in wearing face coverings and testing uptake, and a temporary decrease in social mixing with other households. Protective behaviors were associated with worry and perceived risk.

BMJ OPEN (2022)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Coverage, completion and outcomes of COVID-19 risk assessments in a multi-ethnic nationwide cohort of UK healthcare workers: a cross-sectional analysis from the UK-REACH Study

Christopher A. Martin, Katherine Woolf, Luke Bryant, Charles Goss, Mayuri Gogoi, Susie Lagrata, Padmasayee Papineni, Irtiza Qureshi, Fatimah Wobi, Laura Nellums, Kamlesh Khunti, Manish Pareek, UK-REACH Study Collaborative Grp

Summary: This study found limited data on the outcomes of COVID-19 risk assessment in healthcare workers and explored the association with ethnicity, sociodemographic, and occupational factors. The results showed that ethnic minority healthcare workers were more likely to be offered a risk assessment, but less likely to have their work practices adjusted as a result of the assessment. Previous SARS-CoV-2 infection was also associated with lower odds of being offered a risk assessment and having adjustments made to working practices.

OCCUPATIONAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL MEDICINE (2023)

Editorial Material Medicine, General & Internal

Retention of ethnic minority staff is critical to resolving the NHS workforce crisis

Katherine Woolf, Padmasayee Papineni, Susie Lagrata, Manish Pareek

BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

How Notifications Affect Engagement With a Behavior Change App: Results From a Micro-Randomized Trial

Lauren Bell, Claire Garnett, Yihan Bao, Zhaoxi Cheng, Tianchen Qian, Olga Perski, Henry W. W. Potts, Elizabeth Williamson

Summary: This study examined the effect of different types of notifications on engagement in a drinking reduction app through a micro-randomized trial. The results showed that receiving a notification increased the probability of opening the app in the next hour by 3.5-fold, and both types of notifications were similarly effective. However, the effect of the notification did not change significantly over time. This suggests that targeting notifications based on user states and interests can enhance their engagement in the app, but further optimization is needed to improve long-term engagement.

JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

The relationship between age and sex partner counts during the mpox outbreak in the UK, 2022

Julii Brainard, Louise E. Smith, Henry W. W. Potts, G. James Rubin

Summary: This study analyzed the relationship between age and partner counts during the 2022 mpox epidemic in the UK. The results showed a linear declining trend between age and partner counts for heterosexual partnership groups, but a peak in partner counts and concurrency for middle-aged MSMs (age 35-54), especially those in a highly sexually active subgroup.

PLOS ONE (2023)

Article Psychology, Clinical

Factors associated with wearing a facemask in shops in England following removal of a legal requirement to do so during the COVID-19 pandemic

Louise E. Smith, Robert West, Henry W. W. Potts, Richard Amlot, Nicola T. Fear, G. James Rubin, Susan Michie

Summary: This study found that worry about COVID-19, beliefs about risks and severity of COVID-19, and perceived effectiveness of facemasks were significantly associated with the use of facemasks. Removal of legal obligations to wear facemasks resulted in a 25% decrease in wearing facemasks and stronger correlations between psychological factors and facemask use.

BRITISH JOURNAL OF HEALTH PSYCHOLOGY (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

The role of accelerator programmes in supporting the adoption of digital health technologies: A qualitative study of the perspectives of small- and medium-sized enterprises

Chidi Njoku, Stuart Green Hofer, Ganesh Sathyamoorthy, Neelam Patel, Henry W. W. Potts

Summary: This study explores the perspectives of stakeholders using accelerator programmes (APs) in promoting the adoption of digital health technologies. The findings indicate that while APs are helpful, there are still challenges such as the emphasis on traditional research evidence, which is difficult for SMEs to generate, and system-level barriers to healthcare innovation. Therefore, there is a need to develop supporting processes and infrastructure to accelerate the efficient and timely adoption of new digital health technologies.

DIGITAL HEALTH (2023)

Correction Medicine, General & Internal

Who is engaging with lateral flow testing for COVID-19 in The UK? The COVID-19 Rapid Survey of Adherence to Interventions and Responses (CORSAIR) study (vol 12, e058060, 2022)

Louise E. Smith, Henry W. W. Potts, Richard Amlot, Nicola T. Fear, Susan Michie, G. James Rubin

BMJ OPEN (2022)

Meeting Abstract Oncology

Promoting physical activity via a smartphone application in people living with breast, prostate or colorectal cancer: study protocol for a randomised pilot trial (APPROACH)

Fiona Kennedy, Natalie Miller, Anna Roberts, Rebecca J. Beeken, Diana Greenfield, Henry W. W. Potts, Nicholas Counsell, Nicholas Latimer, Chloe Thomas, Lee Smith, Jacqui Gath, Charlene Martin, Lynda Wyld, Abi Fisher, Phillippa Lally

PSYCHO-ONCOLOGY (2022)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

An app with brief behavioural support to promote physical activity after a cancer diagnosis (APPROACH): study protocol for a pilot randomised controlled trial

P. Lally, N. Miller, A. Roberts, R. J. Beeken, D. M. Greenfield, H. W. W. Potts, N. Counsell, N. Latimer, C. Thomas, L. Smith, J. Gath, F. Kennedy, C. Martin, L. Wyld, A. Fisher

Summary: This trial aims to pilot a theory-driven, app-based intervention that promotes brisk walking among people living with and beyond cancer. The study will investigate the feasibility and acceptability of the intervention and collect data to inform a larger future study.

PILOT AND FEASIBILITY STUDIES (2022)

No Data Available